High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1377/2015allowed

Sumitra v. Narender Singh And ANR

2019-05-14Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan10 pages

!" #" $ #

$% "

!" #" $ #

&#'&( # )* + , )

#-. /0 /#( '#"

120 /#( '# # # 3#"

, "0 /#( '# # #

$420 /#( '# # # 67" # 08 " # #'9# ' # 3"'#' ' 3"'#' :$% "09"(""/ ##'" ((

6'7 0'( #'"( "# * 3# ) ;) 0 ( < <# !9" /#"

9 / ==* /"("/ !! # #>$*6

" ' ' # " #'' ! ( !# ! '# "

/! , # > 9? " " /"( 9 3 ! / 37 # # !" /7 " !!

"!" @!@!

?"" ( #"

/ "/"(" A # #: /# / #73# #''(?"9" "/"(" (" - " #'

1% #- &"3# &"> 9$# 0 (% !

((7#0 7< < - # " " #?"# #B

" 3# 79 (# ( 2 ># 0&" ?" '# 8$ # C '# " #'' ( (#

+;;C;*; *8,49 ! !

# #:

!",#(# 1% 0> 9"

! (/ - ,# :#"#' ( < < " 3#!"(# 3 ! 4=4 ##' ; !

# !": /(#9 9

(4# 71

#'"#'' !( 0( (#

#" #'$ ( # #' "#'"

< < ##/"((( "/ # #'" ( 0 ( < <9 ! 3#+7 "9

-#7 !!## ""?""9 #'6 7

# ( 0 !$ 0 ;# " "9 #3 9

#'" '7 ,# " 3#!" ( # 3

4=4 ##' ; # $% "" #3#!" (# 3 ! 4=4 #C#' ; !

" 3#/ # 0( !(#

#" #'$ (

$ ( 0 (/7# #' - '' 37" " ##/"((( ("(#

# ##'" (( 0 "# 9 #!"37 ##(( 4 =3 0$9 '" !! 0"(#

9#9 737"=3 / 9 + *,# 0 9"# " ' 4= 4 # #' ; 9 9 (#

#'$ 0**0 ;0# 09"#" ' 4= 4 ##' ; 9 9 (#

#'$ 0C0 C; # $% "09"#" ' 4=4 #C#' ; 9 9 (#

#'$ 0 0;# !9" " #' D

'# " #' ' ! #' " #

' @# 73 37 # #="

( (# 79

3 #/ #' 37#7(#

#3 / !""#'' /"(9 !## /"( ( < <# !9"

- $% " 9 / ! !#

! 0"'# # #3 !#9 /#'" /"(9 3#7"(#

4 $% "9

' 9""

* (#

9 # " "7 "/ '

3'#" 4# % ! ( #'(#

#(#'" 9

#" # 09"# ("#!"(#

8"/" (#

'#" 3 !# "#!""(# '

' 37 ;( (# ( 0 3 ( #' 7 (#! (# / ( / ( 37 " ( # #//#(# (# #' " ( < < ! 37"0"=3 " % "# 3

% 3# " (#9

#3$ ; # "8 # #' 7" !9# !9" ("#("#'"=3 >#9/0 # # # #''# ( " 3

8 /9#'"##'"#7

!"## $"

% ("

/ 7* D#'"# #3 #9 '# ( &# !""# "7 (##'" ( % $

E F$ 0 ; #'"##'"#7

& '

(

% )"

## $"9"" ( 9 3("# "( " 0 (# #9 'B

#3% D8 "

( "=3 " (#(7 ( D#'"# #9 '

&# !"" (7#'( (# ##$ 0C ; # "0

(7(# ##$ 0C BF$ *0 ;

="=3 " #'C09"("%

/9"!#'" ( " 3 #7 &# !"" (#

73(# ##$ *0 BCFC00 ; /9 #' " # #' "#7

0"(

#!(#

(# / # " $ 0 ;#

((# #' #

#' $ 0 ; ' B

0 # $ 0 ;="#(#

(# ##$ C00 E 0 F C00 ; ="=3 " 9 (#

#'$ 0**0 ; " 970" ( # (# ##$ 00 ;

C00 0**0 ="( 9# 3 #! G D

'#" #'' !#'"(@#

" ( # #'$ 00 ; '

' # 3"' #'

;( $% "< (# ( 0"=3 9 (#

#' $ 0 0; # " ( $% " < '' " 09"(" )

#'B

'#! ! ( 9"(" ( "#

("! 0B

(" ! (

( $ 0 +0;

#' '' $ 0 ;

((# #' (

## ( $ 0 ;

/ #'D 37 $ 0 C0* ; 8' "(#

#" #'$ 0 C0* ;9

#'D 37 - # H" ! ! (#

#' $ 0 +0; #9

( 9"(" ( "# ("! 0B

(" ! ( (0"=3 " #% #/9"'( " 7 0"(# #'/# # # (" #'

( ( #% ## " 3 9 #9

' ( B

=" 0 " (#

" "

( #$ 0 0 ; ="=3 " 9 #'$ 0 ;# #'

'' ! 8 7 /9 (#

! " 3#' -

'' 37"( 0# #'"# @# 0 /7 ''(# A '7" '' ! !# 37 '' -7 A !# !"# @# 0 ! '##9 < /9 " '( (( ( #' " ( 0 8 ( # $ 0 ; "" =" =3 " 9 (#

# # #'

$ 0 ; "" (

## (>#9/0 "# / #39 '' " ! ( 0 '' - #

( '#7 #(#/789 #'$ 0 ; "" < /9"# #'"# @# #'

- "( 9# "/!# #""# '#'##9 #0 #'$ 0 ; 9 #"# #'

="( "/ ! '' - A"#'

! " # #' " "# @# " !# ! # "# '#'##9 #'$ 0 ; ((# !7 9 #" ;( # " (# ="( # #' - '' 37"9#

#33#9%0 # "9 ##"(( #'

$ 0 ; 9 #"# #'#

#' #

B(# #'' ="#(#

(# ##$ *00* ; ="=3 " 9 (#

#'$ 0 0; " 970" ( # (# ##$ 0 0+;

*00* 0 0="( 9# 3 #! G D

'#" #'' !#'"(@#

" ( # #'$ 0 0+; ' "37#7"# #'(#

3#""#

(# ( 0"=3 37 #'/ ( 9# # #'9" (##"(# ( # "

( (# 7 9 # 3 # 7 " (#

# H"

((# 7 "# "/3 ( # '7"9 0"#!"

! !!"#(#/"# 37'#"

(# #'" ## "( ( (#'9' ! # 89 ( 37", ##/ '#"

09"# '' - "##/"((( 9

#"! / #'"/( 09"# '# 7# " / (" " ( #'/ ( #( #

C (3" 1 (#

'#" ;( " ' # "#7* + ,

#- + .,

) 37"B4#9" 9" !9"(#

* #'" ## "( (0+CC9" " (( " 3 ( # !! (#' /#'"/"(09"("

9 (7 ! !#

!0 9 #3 / " 8

( 4# 7 #3#7(#

#/( #'(( 09"# 9!#

! 0"#!" ("

((# 79 ( #7(#

9 #/( (#/" '##9 #'/"( B(# #( "( 1 (#

'#" ;( " '"' #(#

# - ! / 37>!"4##'&" 4,,C#C*0C + #'

C '( #'" ( /

# !9" (/ !## 9/ "#'' !(%#3

# #2 !#0 I%" '#"/!6!" %0 0& ( 2!0 >7 ?"79(7 !!## '#" "# !#' ' %(" 37#'"?"# #' " !! / !#'

"(%37 /0"(( " % (0(#

A 7" (%# !9"!## " ' # ("0 7"#((

#' " (% ( ! / " ' - =" ! / #'" (

/ "(%" 3#!" (#

09"("9#9 37 4= (#

! #">#9/0"7" ' 3 !

' 9"

"# #'(#

! #" "# (

+ '#" !3'#&">!"4#="A # (# # 9""" ( 9!#

((# 9 3#7(#

$7 !# "- ! * + ,

#- + .,

37"B4# 9" 9 ( " ( #'!#

! 0 7#'

# '7"9 ' 09" /#% !" (#'J7 (#/K?" (9

((# 79

( #7"9 (#

#( "'0 (#/'#"#9 #'

/"( (" /#'" /"(" B # "/3 % #3 !# (# "

! / 1 (#

'#" " '" " (1/,# ' !

"- !

"&">!"

4#" (3

>" ' ## C 37"B4# "! " #" " 0 (#

'# " 8

( (# 7" ' #"#7

"#%137"B4# 9

1 0"!

)37"B4# >#9/08' ""# ' #37 (#

'#" ;( ' (# #"'( #'" ( 09" # #9" (#""# ' #37 (#

'#"

((# 7 H"! #"- !

" '' '( 9"

"#' / (##7" % ( 9

#3 / ""

!9 / (## !9"

" !##

((# 79 #38 " ( #0 "

((# 7 #3 ! 9" 7( 737 ="#!" A #7(#

# #( "

(#/ '# #9 #' "

/"( =" #" "#7

" #9" '' '( '#"'(

#'" ( /9#'"3#/ (

# 0"( "3 #(#/(#

9 3#""#

'## 7 #' " # >#9/0 (#/7 !" !/ # "

((# 7#(#/" '# # # H" ("# '(#

03#"" #9 7 * + "# 6- $%&'%&((&)*+,&-.*/&)01,2 &*.+ $%&'%&((&/+(')34& &*.+