Punjab State Cooperative Supply & Marketing Federa v. M/S Ravinder Kumar & Sons & ORS

!" #$%!
$&'(%) !* #%  





* ++
,-,./  







('
 $ 
) *
) "

$
 * !
"
+  






('
-$
.

'+ 
$$ /
/
 '
"
+ 0

0





('
, "
.*
"
' '
"
+ 







('
+

,*
1'

 '
"
+ 2

2





('
1
.

 $ 
"
1
"
+

 3

3





('

) " '
) *
 4+'
"
+ 5

5





('
"
/
 '
"
+ 6

6





('
1'
) *


!
 * !
"
+  






('
!
7
8$  '
"
+  






('
9#*
+"
) "

$
 * !
"
+  





('
'+ '+
:"'

'
"
+  






('
+*
%
"
 '
"
+ 0 0





('
; $
 
:"'

'
"
+  





('
1


"
/
 '
"
+ 2 2





('
. 
) " '
"
+

3 3





('
1 
8

''
"
+

5
6




2


('
'+ '+
) "

$
 * !
"
+ 6
6 


2


('
#'+
"
 * !
"
+ %- 0'1"-%&$2! "3""2& #  '< 

& #'
 $+=
" 4

+




"
- "
"




"
7 $=
" 4'

+

>>>> 3""2& #/&4,5

)+
 ?* "


 '
 
 $
"4 ""
!

4 ** 

'

'
 

"


+
+
4'
"
'''
 "
 
'

*

9 / =

+
'#

4  4=
+
4'
 
 $
#  *





 

)+
 
4'
 
+




!

"
 $
" 
%"

+  

"

'
@ #"A

"
"



6

'

!

/ "
4 '

' $

 "

$ '

.+


' ?

6?

)+
:)

""

"


' 

+ $+
 
)+
"?4 4 
+  

"

'
B+

"B
/'
 "
"

)+

4
 C"
/'
,'


4 

)+
 4+'

/'
4"

2

)+
*
/'


"


 

+
'4

 #"
"
+

4"

$'
4 * "
/ "
""


)+
4  *

+
 #"
/'
4"
"

"

4 '
/ 
''"

+
"
 "

'4

!
 $
/ +

 '
D
 E

*
)+
4 '
 "
!
+
 #"
/ "

'* ''"

2





)+
4  *
'"
!
+
 #"
/'
'"
 
+
4 "

 F "
 /<
 

    

 

   

  

 

  

      

   !    "

#     

$ 

 

  ! % & 

   '   !

( )  $ !   

  

 

  

&  *+,- 

.*- 





     !)      )  

$!  '

 "/01    

    

  

 



 ! 



    

 ) & ) & !) 

   

  

2 3 , 4
/'
4"
 

 4+'
''"
!

G7,:

2

  4+'

4 '

D
,'

0(?

4 
)+ 
4 '

$
+

4 "
/'

"4"
+

4 '
/ '

"

 '4

+
 4+'

""
2

"
 '
+

 4+'
 "

,
' 

? =
4"
+
4  *

+  #"

% "
4 '

+
 #"
4 "'
+
'

+ 4 "

 


4'
+ 
/'
 4+'

4 '



/
+
+ F "
!
+
"=
+
+
 #"
'+
!
+
'*


+

"
:
'
 +
 $"
+
+
  

$
"
 '4

!
 $
/ +
 '

/
! "
+
4  *
*"

% "
4 '

+
"
""'
+
/ "
"
+

* $"

9 "
 "
4 '

+
 '
"
'"
+
 

4 "

"4"
!
+*

 *

'

+
4 "

 
/ +
$ "

'=

* $ '
+

/'
 !

4'
+
/ "
4 '


/ '
 44 "
!
$  *
$4!

.+



6?

)+
4 "

 
4 

 "

+
+
.+


' 
"'

0

)+
 4+'
"
 
,
' 

?
/'
 
 

4

 "4



$
+ 4  *

 #"
/ + 
+
4 "

 

!

$
/ '

:
/  "




 
+
+ 
/'

 "4
+
/ "
4 '
 '4


 4+'


/ 
'

"

G7,:
 'F !=

4'


  4
"
4 
05

+
4
'
*"


& '??

'
+
'4 "
4  
+
+
 
/
! "

+
4  *


$
"

'4

!
 $
/ +
 '=
 "
4 ' 
+
"
'* '
+
+
/ "
4  "
 

C4"
'
+ C4 

4"

$'
/ 
'!"
!
+ '
  
"

""




 +

' 4 '=

'
'* "
+
+
"
'+

 

4  * $
"

'4

!

+
'

'

+
/ "

F' 
 '#'
 !

 *"

'

44 "4
/ +
/ 

:
/

+
'*
*"
!
 "
4 '

+

"
"
+
+


'
4  
*"
!
 "
4 '


 
+'

4"

*

'=
+ 
'

44'



+ '
4  
 '
'

"
+
/ "

+
* $"

)+


 '
 
44 "

$ !
"

'"

/ +
 !
' $+
!

"

0

)+ 
'

" 
+

 !

+


$
*"

'=
+
4  
4 4 "
/  "
"
/ +
+
'*
44 "4
/ +
/
4 '

$

+
4*

"4!




"





*

"

$
"4!





+  4 !

+ '


4"

+
 '

+
4 4"

 '

3""2& # &$*#"

,-,./  *#
H++
'

# $(
' "

< I'
(


H++

  < I'
(