High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17880/2023allowed

Anshu v. State Of Haryana And Others

2026-03-16Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri35 pages

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT

CHANDIGARH

" #"! $%"& "

'( ) * +!,-"".

) * +!,-("! 16.03.2026

) * +!,-!(0 *1

/ "0&(".(" +!,- ("!"* " !00+!,- ("! 2!00 ) 0&4&4 ("!-!00 +!,-4" " 5((010 CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIKAS SURI " "

06!-"7 "*+4." (" "

-0484%"& "

(970&4.* "

#9& ! 4.""(5

3 ::::: VIKAS SURI, J.

) ("(!""0

! ; 1 0 1& (" !4 * . !" ("- 10&4 " , 1! &"4 "!0-,* 9#5*$04("

!2!

- 1& "( 5

"1! 04 -0& 9 %"&7+0#"5,-< """""=5,-> ) "!, (4 ("449 *"-( ! ""41 00,, "!?(0& 3

@ A!" A (""1!"-"-"(".,-(00," .- ! 1& 0"!40!, 0"4 A((0 (". B-(0&>-(4 @

" "4=@

> 0",0 &"C 0-(!, ""

A!" * "1& -( 4@ ? * !" !(" "!4 A 0!-(!" 09!!"("(404(!!"-0A(4 -0 "-4( &0(40-"",("(4A(" A0!."9"4

$!0&4 %, ) %)? %, #0, %#

.0 0" 0 *" ( " ! ("

$! %)?%# 0 " ! "1! (*" "- !1 004(0-!""-"4* ( .0,* "!-(1& -1! ) " (" "D! ! "!-1"- %, ) %) 9#0*&"- !4 *."4 *( "D! B. .", *"4*,* ",4*" -, ." (" - "D! ("- "(0 -1"&"!

!3!

( - 4 (" * (0&, "" ! $ "!4* 0!" " *" 10&C (""*" !>!"4 *", 10& ) "9#%)0"" ! ("40-! , ,"00 ! !"!0&4 ("-,"!("A-& , *""!,(""!0&0 10&!"." 1!" +!" ) ""4 (" * --0& 9 $ . %(04 5-"4 '+ 4 "- * "4 " 1, (". 0 "-4 * """ 8;B'4 ,"

*- -",&*"

"!3 ) !"+!"".1& ("*" ! !", " "- 8;B'4 " ", "- * "!0?-(! "- " ", !0" " * "!" " 0 > ", 00 ," '!00&4 !-(!4 ("!"@ E("-10&4 1, 0-" 10& ) 10& "

!1& 0! "&4 "," 4%"& 1(0""A!"/

) " (" " "- (00" ( 1" ."! ! " 0 0 "-0 -(0 , "(! "4* &0&--"!0""0 "-"-0 "("0&00*,!( -"42;'5

*","!"$

;0$04" ","

!4!

) ("0((" !" "!, "!"0 ,!"4 1& *& *" (4 1", 5

4 ("&,"-(!-'

"" ("

F( (4 0" !0 ((", 1 0 "( !""

(0&3

@1&%7#5<"0,-( .-0?0*" "0.- 4 . ("!1-, "0-1" -(! "&(" (0&4 - 001" A(! "- (0& 00 1 9 " ) ?"*(1 0 (" * ! ("+! " ", ",0&4 * (" * ! ("+! " "(. ", " --, !( -" 401"&*," (".""

4 ((" "( ! " " 9, 1!"- -( "- ((010(0& ; * !" "(!0 .0,! 0-?"(" 1& ("4 - 00 1 A(!0&4 (""10& * (" / - "- 0, ! 0-?"("4 " ", (("!& ", (""

/ ; " ""

A!" ( 1& !"

4 (" -. "(" @

A!" @4 "( ! "4 . ""

4 *" -(

!5!

' 4@ ? .!" ("4 "- (0& 3

@ ) (" ". " -! !" (" -! "0& ( . (" A (! 2'

) (" 00 0, ,,". 1& D!& -( *" 1& "( 5

5,-4 ((" !"1&*& ("*"( / <"!0" ("",! -! -( (&10 !" (0& 3

@ D! 0&" 010& !, 1!( ""4 5,- ) *"-!""- 1,+!"-(" -,!"1& (" ! ,0, -0 "( 5,- ; *!" "!1- "(5,-9"!,!" "! 3

@4 . " !"0 010& !" (!100* / <" !0 " (" !" " ",! (0&3

@0 !-"! "-,4* 1 "- (0&4 ! 4 "D!" - * ".!" ;*0 (0& 1 - !"-0& ((010 00 ," .- -("."&10!0(" (". @

40!,-(0& ("-"(".("4 *"9,"*"9,.!04 0"!009 ) " 00,10""(".,"--- 0!0,

!6!

-! -( " !0 0" !" &" , 09 ) "("."(0,"-0A("" "!-4-0,&( &0(!"1& 0 ) -! 1 0!0 0 9 "9, 0 -"", ("( " D! -( " ", ",."4 9(,.* !"+!"!" ) - 0!0, -( !" @

1 - ((010 0"*004", "-1 --!-(""11& 8."-* 0,", !!"-."1 ( ! " , "."4 , 1 *" !"!!"("(?0" /

'0 1 (0 , (1987) 1 SCC 395

, (2002) 2 SCC 162 "," D! -((&104"0 1(0!( +!,- "" 1& . 7 %- 0 " %, !"/3 @

4 ((".-1& %>10$!("-!"

, (2017) 3 SCC 115 ""40"!0" "(5,-",! D!0&0* 09 ("4 5,- 0"&9!(0&4* "0 "!3

@ ) (" 0"&1,"!00 0-(!" "! 4 ("

!7!

(0101- ,"!0 5!" "-! (&10 ("4" " .,( -!(&10 !" (0& ;!" "!1- " (" A 10& !4 ! "(5,-* & !0 " !"! 4 "!0, ("- 10& ("

. " 0" !0 " (" -!0!0&, "!, (("19* "10 ) ! """ ("" " (" - 0- " -( ! +!"& -, !"4 " ., 1 *" -( !" "!3

@ ;*" "-.4* *!01"+!-!C " "! 3

@ " D! -! 0! -( !" 09 !!" ("(4 04-0A( (!!"4( &0 ( !",4 -0 "-4 " ("( -"",4 A( " "9" (04C " "!3

@""1""& 010 1" * -! (""1 !"- "- ("., -( 00 ," .- 094 0!, -"4 A( (". B-(0&> -( 4 @

4 "- -( " 0"* ,0 &"C .

" ""

A!" *",-(!" !(""! 0101- -( 4

!8!

9(, .* 0 ("(0 -(!, -( ?+!"& ; *!0 1 (( 0 !" -( (0& "! 3

A!"4* "A" "!"""&"" 9 %"&7+0#"5,- "" 00 %7#5 ,, . * " G"! "9& !- 0 "0&4 %7#5 (& -( -(0& !" B-(0& -( @

$-0"0&4 (". (" " 0*"-((""-!0((010 ",!0" -(0& 5,- * ,0,

; 1 " " " "(*00D!& -( ("0& 1, ( " 0 *00 0 !- 1, ! 0"! F" ! "!-4 5,- !0-(" -, ! !- 0 ! 0"!4 ""(.&"0"!0("" ("-(0& 5,-

",0&4 ". "- " "1& (""1 " (&- -( "0 *00 0 !- 1, ! 0"! " *"9, 0"0 &- %7#5"* 0!&" %7#5 / ) -( 00* !" "! ." 1. 1 "* -10 ","(" "- -(0&-?"?((0100* ) -( 00* 1& %7#5 1. (!"0& !-" ,"! 00 "&10,* .""10&!" 0*

!9!

6. Туpe of Accidents (, !( ."& -( !- 1,4 ! 0"!"0!"

Fatal accident:! '!0, !-1, II.

Non!Fatal Accidents:! '!0, 10& !-1, (,!( 10&4 0"!" "0 !"

"!0,("-10&

1"!0,("010&

"!0,-(""&10& 7.

Category of the affected person ) .-."!" (0&" ,"G!"

;

',!0"-(0& 5,- ;;

"!0*"9" "")-2!00 )- ;;;

"!0 *"9" " )- 2!00 )- "!, "" ;# "."

1 0" # "9- ,, 1& "" 5,-H *"9 ) -( (&10 1. - ,"0!!"

Nigam Regular Employees.

(I) Fatal Accident

AAAA AAAAA (II) Non Fatal Accident ) 00*, -( 00 1 (&10 .- (A) Permanent Disablement

AAAA AAAAA

!10!

(B) Partial Disablement

1AAAA AAAAA (C) Temporarily Disablement

1AAAA AAAAA @ AAAA AAAA 11. Private Person for Fatal Accident & Non!Fatal Accidents %7#5,, G"!.& "9& " !- 0 ! %7#5 * " 010& " -( (". (" ",0&4 -( (".(" 001(&100 *00 0 ""(. ""! 0"&&- ( (!10 ) -( -! 001(&10("(". B-(0& -( 4 @

%*."4 -( 001((010" !"",* 0"0*"9 %7#5(".("- Private Person having age less than of 16 years for Fatal Accident & Non!Fatal Accidents ) -( " 0 *00 0 (".(" .,,0 &"4 001(&10(" (". B-(0& -( 4 @

$4 ,""(" .,,0 &" .010 B-(0& -( @

4 ",0&4 , " " &" 1, , , " 00 1 " " *"9, ! -! -( %*."4 -( 00 1((010" !"",* 0"0 *"9 %7#5 (".("-

!11!

12A. Workmen engaged by contractor on Nigam works (Part Time & Full time).

I. ; 20 " 5 20 *"9-,,1&""5,-*"94 -( -! 00 1 (&10 (" (". B-(0& -( 4 @

%*."4 -( 00 1 ((010" !"", %7#5*"9 (".("- II ; "" -, "*" ( -( * (" - "- !"" 4 5,- 1, "(0 B-(0&" 00 ( -!* <1!"--" "- B-(0& -( 4 @

!"- 0,0 " 00 - " ( -(-!4 001".""- & -! (&10 "" -!!,, ""4 -! 00 1 "." 1& *& 0, .0!, ""

III ;0?04 "" 00 "- 5,- * / !"4 0 0,* ("!0" *"9- +!"? A(" ? "!-1"4"4-0 - (""-1(""1 1& 5,- "( "-4 " " 5,- B," ; ",? 00 1 "(10 " 9, "& (" 1. "- ) B,"; ", 000"- 0 9 1& - " B," ""?

("4%7#54%"

!12!

The authority for sanction of the compensation under the above policy shall be as under:!

Sr.

No.

Sanctioning Authority Category of persons Type of Accidents Description Investigating Officer AAAA AAAA AAAA AAAA AAAA

". ("

5-" , &" 20 -( '(. $B

"!, B; '(. B

" 0 '(. $B

"!, B; '(. B

520 -( '(. IB5

"!, B; '(. B

AAAA AAAA AAAA AAAA AAAA @ ("! ", " -( (0& ".0 "0"4-(**"(".("04 (" "-!0 ((010 ",!0" -(0&4 5,- * ,0, 5, " "( D!& -(1,"0"("0*000 !-1,!0"!4 5,- 9! -( " -, ! !- 0 ! 0"!4""(.&"0"!0("" (" -(0& 5,- ; "*"4-(!" "!3

@1(!" ("(0 !0010& @ 0! "! (!0 (&- -("0*000 !-1,4! 0"!"- 0"0&- "1!0

!13!

0&4 ("!"."+!"-, 0("A-&?* 9#%)0(," " ! ( D!"& ! 1& B0"& ;(" B;4 "- $ B0"& 4

"" """ =

>4 "(" ",", !"(10&" - 4 0 5,-10"(10" ;10 , 1"".", !0( 9# 5*$0(," ! .-1!00,0& ("> "4-0&'+6!-"4 00,00&A 10& !*" %)0 %*."4-"0 1(0 ""!1 "00, 5 04.* , 0!"" D!"&"("1& B0"& ;("4 "(10& 1 ,"00& A "(5,- @

0! / !(" "!4 * A" "" "(40."-"&!1 -(*"!" "! 4."1. 1 "* -10 " ," .- (" "!0 10,?((010 0* ("!0 !-1,!!(".-9 &-(*" !" "! *!0 " & " !( --?(!100*"-&.010!" ((0100* J/ ) -( 00* !" "! ." 1. 1 "*

!14!

-10 ","(" "- -(0&-?"?((0100* K <" !0 " "( 5,- 0 ( "." 0- " *" !" " -(1& ("."!"0!/"* 0! "!3

@41& "( 5,- ) "1(! !-0*001, (" -"& "- ; (" " !" +!" 1& 0"!! -"0 "1! 04"(&--(*!0" $

4 "0. (". ; B0"& '!04 !"0& !& "1! 04 "( 5,- (" 4 9( !- 0., "! 14 "- & "- 1& !((0& (00& ,"! ",&4 (00& "!, , .0, "- 0 ) 5,- *!&1!00* &-!""D!"11"." !((0&?"- 0"& B0"& ,"! --& !"&!& "1!04 5,- ("4(!(000(".-!"11& !"& (". "," ; (" 4 5,- 9("!00 "&&.4 !0 .1. ) 5,- .,0(" 0 ("("& (!100",,"0 ("("!0"4 ("00* -1"010&

!15!

) !0((! (" ) "(5,- 0"1!0 "* " 9(0*-,(", %)0 "- %, #0, 0"&4 * (, " ("> ! !""! 0 ;.* -4* " ("(0

*!0((0&* !00",

2!" "4* "," 010&(&-(1& ""4 ,".0& +!" 04 ( "1!"& ,0, 1 - ((010 ) " 1 &, 0 ! ", * ", 00, "1.4 " -"0 1"!, "" * ("*&!0 B.* "," 00,D! " (" .,A 10&4 1&-"0.010"" !- "(5,- (,0,010&4 (" 1 0 010 " "1!"& ,0, B. "*4 -" * !""

4 * " 5,- 10 ""& D!"&"(" "*,0, (" $ %)0""&, , .0,0"&*(, ."& 0 "- ("> !4 "1!, ,0, 1 "1! ,"0 , 1! &" . 7 &" %, !" !

#$ 4"("AIR 1997 MP 2484 0!"

!16!

J 2"- " ! "0, "1!"& ,0, (" 0 " , " !1 ( "1!"& ,0,1-((010 0 0 ! ", * ", 00, <,0& "0& " A( "- 0 0", !! 9,(",."1& -(!04 ." . 04 *!0 .1*" ("04*!0."-- * ,"! " G"! " -L ) *" 1 ,"0 H5H4 1!

0H 009 "00& 10& " "4 1 M) 9" $" $4 1- 0" "-LM 0"- 0(00", " & , ("90 ,0"& * -9 -" "9* !0((" (& ; .* !" " 0&4 * 0! 0 '&G4 0!"4*010" "1!

; 4 !-010&(! ) "(5,- 0"&,!(D!"&4 "!, B0"& ;("4 * "," ! "(10&4 "". 0! "( 5,- 0 "(10 ) ""4 (, ,4 5,-*.0 (--( ("(" 01"0G-((0&"0 "!3

@ ) "(5,- ""(,(0, *"(""& 00,

!17!

,"" D!"&"("" !1D!91& (0,"0!( 0! / ; 0, 1.4 ., ,. !" !, !0 " - !0 ( (". "!3

@4*" " ( (".0, ""-&0- -,"- ""4*!011""! ., 1*"-(!" "! .""

A!" 3 ) !4 A ( *!0 " " " * "," D! -( (" 04 "!- 4* "1& (" !" @ E ("- 10&4 (" 10& " A!"/

; 0 ("(0 0* (" +!" 1& ,0, "0,"0-,"(!"& 0! (4!",0-4 " (!"&041 (!!" ) %>10$!("-!" .0((05 @@ @@

@@34 0% &

' ( ) * "("(1995) 1 SCC 5514 0* 00*,("(0 "--("10& "9.7"0& (9, * 0 A, -! -( (&10 .- 4 -, . 1 ("0& (!"& -, (0 -, !"& -, " * .- !00& !"" *

!18!

" (10 1, 0!0 "- -&C * " (!"& -, " * " (101,1&" -00!0 ; "" ((" * ( (!"& -, -& 0! A( !"" 1& 0- -0C 0",("!( "0C "-"00 $"(!"& -,""4 &-&0! -," -0 ( &0 94 ( !",4 0"& !""090&1!"!!"C -, -( " 0 - 0 * -& 0!."&-" !+!"& 0--&110*094"!"C -, " 0A(04 4!+!"

& "-0 0,.& (" " "C .4 " (4 -"4 ((-4"!"-0"0 K ) " <" ( %>10 $!("- !"

" ) "(" (2013) 8 SCC 3894 ."" 00*,("(0",", -("("0+!"& "40. ; *000 ("(0 ,", -( " ("0 +!"&4 +!" 1 -( " ( !",C " 0 -C " A( 04 &C 0 ", " 0 ", (& " - " 1 C -0 "- " (0 -, ; ("0 +!"& * - 0- " ("0 0 (!"& 0 91!"4 N O.

!4 @ <) 5$

P7Q 4 ,! 1.*( !

!19!

J; , -( +!"& !0 9 ! * ,4 "4 (!"& 0 (0 ! 1& C 0&4 +!"& ! ("4" ( &0(&+&, 0 & - " (!"&0 & .9! 0& ("041! (&" !!"-(".- K 41.

"#$ %&$ / B "34 """, -, ("0 +!"& 4!"

J) (" ( &00& +!" -& "."1 " (!"&0 (!"& 0 (!"& 0 -0. -(" * (" - .G 0 ", " , * (0*!0 .- 1+!" -0 "A(* (!"!0 +!"&4 !" . !1. (!"& 0 " ," .G ( !",4 0 -00A(0 74 !" *00 . "--1" -!" -, 00 = !0 1 ! 10 . ""& -(0&" -.!" >'

( %

& ( &

) & $ $

( $*

+ &

$ &

-( !((0 42.

; ! -+ .

.! /O

6 <N/Q %, !"6"9* 00,* ("0 +!"& * " 0- ! ""! ,+!"!* 00*"0-1 *-(!4 0 "-!010&4 10&!1& 0-0 E !, 0& 0-H00*"0-1*-(! ;("@ +!,-4 !" 0!" 6 <N( /3

!20!

J0! "!0 -(!4 0- 1"""((0 %"D!" 0( "! . " *09, % 1-!"&9-!0*"9 * "0" 0" , -!0 *"94 -(! 0 0, 10* 94 "" -!"&9-!0*"9 % ! ; ! 4 *00 0 -!010& *00 .1" 04. !, ( &010& E K 3.<" ' 1+ .

$ O1+ .

$ 4 @ / @ <' 3

@ @ 00 B' 3 %<Q ( /@ JR - -( " ( &0 +!"& -( " 0 * !""!0 +!"& %0 .,0, 10& 0 !00 04 10& +& -* ("--.- 10& " -! ! ""!0 ." RK 44. ) "("(00*1& !"4 ((0 4 %! <" 0, ! " A(" """ !("4 * ( . 1 A" 1.4 00 !"4 " ((010 !"*",+!"10-( .!" ((00 !,".! +!"

" "(" 1&* E ("- 10- 1& -( " K ; ("4 (" 1"((0" " "0 %"", "- 1-(!"- !0"1 .,!"-, ," "0 2" +!" !"1& "4 *!01100+& -" -04* ("--.

!21!

@ ) !" "0& " -(! -("(!"&0<5

0 " -$ 4 "("Law Finder Doc Id #2853602 ; 4-( * *" " E !0?("- 10& ! ! ,0,-,!."&1!0,4* 00( .-4!","!! !."& ; 4 00*, %>10 $!("- !" ; .0 ((05

/ @

/0# $ ,

4 *00.0((05

/ /

40 ) $ "(" 2023 ACJ 16534 0 .0 ((0 5 @@@

3 0

" ) , "(" (2025) 10 SCC 2634 0 - 0&- 0-* 01'

43 ?* / E*"!!"("( 5!*"("0A( *-"- -!-(4.* 0*0* . " $ )/ , '

(

& & "

, "(" (2023) 13 SCC 3344 * ( 1& !".." * +!" "!0, ("-10& 4* " 0--1& ( ) !49(,.* " " 0

!(" 4 0-*

&", (" 4 (" * A &" , -

!22!

4 0- ("0&191 '

4 ?("- ) "0.(" +!,- " !("4" ! J / ; 0, " 0 ("(0 0*4""-,0-!* !" E !0 10&4 * " " .* - ((00 "D!" 1 "9 '

43 ? (" - 7 1.4 !!" ("( S / E " 1 *" 9(, .*

% & *

" ) "(" (2023) 3 SCC 439

" ) 4 "(" (2017)16 SCC 680

/ ) ,"0("(0"0,-( +!"&-!!"0",! ("- 10&4 A(! 1& %>10 $!("- !" - #- "("(2011) 1 SCC 343* ((0 00*

0 !(" ;*!" " 0 "&!&!-"&. (". 0 - .- !" *" -.1&!-"&. ) ("(0 *", 0 - * ((".4 * " -+!"!- ) "0. (" +!,-

!("" ! J59.) !4 * " .*4 -"("!0"0&9(,- !- !" 2O2.

3 4 ! !4

Q "& ! & !-"& . (". 0 - .- !"*" -. 1 & !-"& . ;2O2.

3 4 ! !4

Q* !" !0!"* 0 , - A, 0- -+!

!23!

"!- ("!0" 4 " , -( "..0&4"01"00& K

0&4 1" ((00 @@ ! 4 *1!

&",

4 * !"! !"" ;.* " 1

% !

) !4 "(" (2009) 6 SCC 1214-!0(0"1((0 ) ("(0" "- +! -( -(0 !" " # 0 4 @ *" "" .0 ((0 5 3

0 - ,& ̧"("(2020) 4 SCC 413 ; 4 * !" " 0 -!0(0" &- 1 00* 0& " "-, -( ! 0 - 1! 0 " "-, ",4 ) "0.(" " ! J5.) ("(0 * "," "- +! -( -(0 !" " *00 0 ) +!" ! (". 1& * 0 0-0--, ) -, -& ."& ", ,".& +!" ! 1& 0- ! +!"4 0--&!"D!0 0!

0",C

A( "- * -& 0!-0A(4"("4 (04 ",4 4

0"-! (0!"0 1&0("!0"(" 1&4

0!!"",(&

!24!

-, 1 (!"& *00 (!"&41!00 .1"!( ( 6.; -(10 D! !- !",("0(".* -& %*."4 * +!( !" ) !" -9+!! -(*"-,4-( 0-" 0!"1& .-

4 -( !0 1 ."& "..0&4 1! " 4 -( !0 0 1 01"0 -9 1!& 0- ) !" * 0, -( !0 . "," ,"(". 0 ! 1& ! (". $! -( * "- +! -( ) -( " -, " ("0 +!" !0 1 !10 -( +!" " (".!"1& +!" "!, ! ? " 0 ) & !0 1 +! 9 -,

# & 22.) ", . 1 *" 1& %, !" S ' 3 (" - " // &"4 * *"9 ! ' F"!0&4 &- ("(" &- !0(0" &- ! 10 ! ."! " -(*"0!-(!-4."! " " 9 " -((0!-(!-4 !" 0*&00* -!0(0"&- )

!25!

-!0(0"&- !0100*0& " "-, -( ! 0-1!0""-, ",4 ) &- * ", 1& !" # "

/ !.

!"!2! -

&O;' @

$ Q ) -!0(0" &- " 0"4 ""(&10 0!-(!-*"4 0,.& 0-4 0 "!! !" 0 ! 00 ."! 0". - 4 -!0(0" - 1 ", -"0"10 - ; !" 1" +! 1* (" ! "!0 *" J+! -(K* -, K

;

4.0((05

4"("(2017) 3 SCC 1154 (A!"*",+!"10 -( .-41& &"* - * , 0. *" !" +!" 7 "- .- 1-(! -9, - E10("-0& ; 4 -(*"-' @ <9 0,*

E " 9 " .-> !(1",, "" " 0

) .0 ((0 5 / @

/40$+.

4"("2024(3) PLR 707, 00* " -0 !(" ; *!" " 0 " 0-* *, 1! &" * !" ,".! +!" ! " 4 !" 10& A3E4 *."4-(0.".*

!26!

!4 09 (" 4 " 00 ("0 (!"(4 10& * " 1 E ) -( ' 09 *" !" H( !",H * ' 3 09 9, " 0-*00"-( "("" " "0*000- ! 9, (" . * *!0 . "-00& 4 - * !"!

6(,.* ("(00*0* -0 $ + .

0 !(" *!01+!"*" ",4"* ((0& -!0(0" &- "4 *00 ) ((00 *!0 0 1 0 " !!" -0 A( ' 3 09 4 1, 9 "..49(,.* !"+!" ("- 10& !" ; 0 1 1"- * .--04 *""- "( 001-.010 !!"4* !"*!0-("-!-& (!",409 ((004*!0("9 - 04 0 !"& 1 10 "! "-!!"4090&".- 0 ((00

@ ", -! !, 1 *" !" =(!",>4*!01,!0 "" 0*0*.0((05 @@

/40 $$+ 4 "(" 2024 SCC Online SC 3385 ) "<" ( (A!" 9*0,, H( !",H ( ( 4 """ " ! "4 0"0& 0 +!04 * " -( . 1 -* !" " $- "( ( !", * " 10& !" E *" 0 " ("!

!27!

01"4-!' 309 **"!" H( !",H4 * 00*, 1". J15.6(,.* 1.""" +!,-4 +!"!"4 =

(($> !4 00, !" 10& 0 !( 0- ((004 - " "("! 1.4 * "D! 0-((001+!! 4 *" ' 34 4 ? !" = (($>4!00&! ("&" 0-((00 " --(*1&!- ' 4 4 ?4 * -( 1 +!4 " "10 -! *" K

0, ((00 &!,*-* *!0!"00& ."- 0, -"-& ., 0" " *4 * "- ."0& -( 1& !"! ;*00",G -"",? -( (,"0(" !"00 !-1, 6(,.* !" +!" !" 1& ((00 " E !0 10&4"-(10" """ 0" +& -(0 (0!" -"0 0 6(, .* -( (!"&0!"1& ((004*" ".* ((00 10,"-(' 309 !" =0-"",("(>400*, " $+.

0 !("

) ((004 .,1"" "-.-! ("-10& !"1& "4*!01"D!"(A"-&

!28!

""(" 50& 4 ((00*!00 "D!" (0 4 9(, .* !" " +!"4 * 0- " -.- ,0,10 ",0&4 -! ' 09 ". 1 *"!" *00 K

; ("4 10&" A!"/ (","00&"" 10&!" J $ <-"10& ) , " ! ", !0""!0* "!"0", 00","

$ @ E ,!"5&)*(" *""-10&"0 "", (" ,!0 8!0 " (!"( , A ( 10& (" 0!!"'*4 1&8."- ;.$

B /

("!0 " 10& "" " A!"/ * - 1@ E "0 ", "- ) (","0 0",4 * * 00 "*!0 .0"+! ."- "10& ) ( ,"( ("(, +!"!"1& " .1(0""A!"

,0 ( ,"( *!0 * (""- -, *," 0 4"" 10&"4 " "!" A,"*00 5(",10& 1(! "("-10& 0 %*."4 9(, .* 10& "

A!" / !(! !-4 *

!29!

101& "40&1 (" !" E!010&* "," * 01&

; 0 1 ("(0 " -(!, -,?-("*", "- ("(0 $& "-0-!"4 ("01(! -(* *!0 .1 !" *", ; ("4 ("4,"0 0*,1! &"4 ", 0 0 &4 ((& , 0 !" "0 ! ; *, 0 !" -,* , *"4* *(0&, " * -4 * 0. * "!- 00 "- ( &00& 00, "!, ! 0 ) (" +!" " 0 * " 0 1, "! "-0 !

&- !", " ,"*,!( &"4 *!0 .!00& -(" "0* " 0" ",1,( &00& (""&* 00 . 101 04 , "!, .4-"4"!"-0 "" " "0 $ *!0"D!"!00- ,! 0( " "!, * -(0 94 * "D!" * "-? -(0 2" "4 ("00 -(0& " A! -(0 9 -(*" " ."- " ( &0 (& 0" 1 0 !0"0 B. -0&--1""(".

," 94 ("0*"-,"* 0 -4"."&& 6(,.

!30!

- ,& ̧"("(2020) 4 SCC 413 $+.

4"(" 2024(3) PLR 7074*!01+!"*" ", ((0& -!0(0"&- "4*00

) %>10 $!("- !" ; .0 ((0 5 /

/ 0 -1 & ) *"("(2014) 15 SCC 14 ((".."-00*, -!0(0"- "" *" , "-(41,+!"10 4 .,"," !"&,0, (" "( ("., &-!"",",0.0"&*"

/ ;" 10& (""4 ("> ", "- ., 1 -(! "- !0"4 *!0 "D!" . (" "-4 * *!0 10 " "0&.&""&* 0 ;019 (" *!0 "D!" "., "(0- " (" 0-1("00& ; 1. ",", D!!-A(!" ","4 !"0 "..0& ( -! *" 1& %>10 $!("- !" ; .0 ((0 5 @ @@

/ / @

3 0 #

" 2 3

" ) 4"("AIR 2025 SC 4099 ; 4 1&.",", "D!& ," "., (" 0-1" D!!-A(!"4 " <" ( (A!"*" ( -!'

!31!

09 *!0!!" !!"A(!! (" 0-1-0A(", "," ) -!0"D!"1*" (" ("

(! " !4 !" "(4 "4+!("("-(1*" ("1!0 "!"

Sr.

No.

Heads Compensation Judgments relied upon /!"

&& 5++& ! 4

& ! (2025) 10 SCC 263 2 & ! 2023 ACJ 1653

# / ! 6&"7 (2023) 13 SCC 334

50;- 0&'

4 ? !00& '

4 A T '

4/ 4 ? / & !8 4 4 & ! (2023) 3 SCC 439 2!!""( S/ E '

4/ 4 U@ 4 T'

4 ? /-& !%'

(2009) 6 SCC 121 ;-" ((0&,-!0(0" , &" '

4 AT '

4/4 ? /

2!00* ","* 0 1& E '

4/4 ? A E T' /

? 2, !7$

(2020) 4 SCC 413 1 /+ # ! ",

9& /& 2024 3 PLR 707

", " * 0- ' 4 A A T'

4 4 ? ' 34 4 ? 2, !7$

!(" 1 /+ # ! ",

9& /& !(" 2!!"-0 A(

!", ' 34 4 ? 2!/!" ! ! / + & 2024 SCC Online SC 3385

<- ' 34 4 ? 1 /+ # !

!32!

Sr.

No.

Heads Compensation Judgments relied upon 0-"", ",

9& /& !(" @

)"(" (0 ' 4 4 ? ' 4 4 ? 9

" ! 34

& ! AIR 2025 SC 4099 .(" 0-14"., "(0- (" )0-( Rs.99,93,600/!

"," 00," "! 3

@4*!0! -(,"!" "! !"(!"0& !-" ,"!4 1 ("(0 !0 010&4 * 1 ,"00& ( 1 ." 1. 1 "* -10 ("

) !" -4 & (4 1 00, ,"! D!& D!!- ,"! " !""-"* - 1 ((04 *!0 "- - ! "& ,", ! 4 -" * * . ",".0&.", (" ("!0 "! *!0 * & !"0 & ", (" "!"--0*"(!100*"(".0* ""&4 0! / "! (00& (". -(00*!" "!."1. 1 "* -10 " ,"4 (" ((0100* ) *!00! 0("(00*0* ! 9 ) +!,- . 0"& 1 """ "1"4* 0 ("D!-(1

!33!

!( (", +!"& !" 0- *" -( !" ."! 0 (" 3 "1"4 * *00 1 ." 1. -( *" !" "!3

@4 !-","! ; 0, "4! "*"",0&

"," 00, ""

A!" 4 (" 0-""- "" " 1", & (". !" 4 ! 00, 0&4 -(*"!" -(0& "0& " * (". "! 3

@4* .0"&1 01 !" 6(, .* (" 0"& 1 0 0 -( ." 1. * 0"& 1 *"!" "!3

@4, ""

A!" .04 *!0 (" "!-1-A" !"0 .&!" "" ("(

'!00&4 (" *" ( ("0& 00* ) -! -( *" "1" 00 " " S 3E (" !-4 "- ! *" ( 00 "0G " -! -" 1! !4 -0" !1-"- 0-( *"4"&-!(004("!0"0&* "" -(0"&,"!" "!3

!34!

@ ) 0 -( *" 00 1 ( *" ("* (" "- "-& 5&(" -!*001(2A(4", , " "4 - ("4!"+,!" ( " ("4&50G7904" ","

%"& ) 2A ( *00 1 ("00& "*4 00 (" , -+"& ) " "! *00 1 """ (" $., !4 1 ( - 7" - ("41("+0&1& "(" ) ," 50G794* " -(-! 001(4*!0"0!-' 4 ?("- ! "( .,! ("4 "!, ",!"4- "0&A( 10-! D!""1,9(("2A(4"1, !0G* "D!" ) - 0&-!,. (" *!0 9 " " (0 4 09 !"! 4 4!0A(4

@ ) ("*!0101"&((0& !"" "0 !" " !-4 * & " " !!" -0 "- " . (" "- " & !" ,&

; .* %>10 $!("- !"

& .

*"("AIR 2025 SC 17134 " -! 0!, " *" "1. *00 1 """1&"(5

9 %"&7+0#"5,-<

!35!

19 ! (" * (!0 - ) ("!0" 19! 0,* "D!!- !((" " 00 1 !" 1& (" "( 5,- * (" !" *9 "- "" !0 0011& 5,-

"(( ""-

,((0 4&400 (HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI) (VIKAS SURI) JUDGE JUDGE

&!+ "(9,?" V 5 "'("10 V 5