High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9726/2016allowed

Santosh Mehta And ANR v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2018-05-29Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath5 pages

!" "#$%$&'

(

) (

) *! &!%+,"+! &- &!+". "!$!$&".% /% +"! !" .0 & &-!+".% "%1&-"&!% ,' ,' ,' ,'2 3,44, 2 3,44, 2 3,44, 2 3,44, ."%"&!' ,.5%+ 0$&- 67-8# !"7

.!+"1"!$!$&".% ,. 9. :+,+9&! 7 7 .0 & 7

.."%1&-"&!%!; &- ,%9&&""!4 9.7-8# !"7 . ,% &< & %+ +$7-8# !"7

.."%1&-"&!( 44,7 44,7 44,7 44,7 = & !+ >%$&#" -"#" %"-?7 !+". !+" 1"!$!$&".%7 @ % 66!!"-!+"6 &- &-:9$6-$&=$&A9"%!$&:0!+""+ :$6$! !$& "1 .!*"&!7 8".&*"&! &-$ & ( @+$#+ @ % 66@"- :0 ."=96 . =.""*"&!"B"#9!"-& ) ( = & !+-$"-& ; "6"

! :"+$&- +$% @$-@ * 4 9.7 @+ -$"- &

7 &- !@ - 9=+!".% & *"607 &!%+,"+! >1"!$!$&".? &-9%+1 "8$>1"!$!$&". ? = & !+7-9.$&=+$%6$ "!$*"7."A9"%!"-!+""+%$6- .> 6"%?7 "1 .!*"&! "+ :$6$! !$& *: 6 ! $%%9" !+" #&8"0 &#" -""- $& ."%1"#! 1.1".!0$&A9"%!$&$&#"+$%."A9"%!@ %&! ##"1!"-7!+"." ."7+" $6"- #$8$6%9$! .* &- !.0$&<9&#!$&@+$#+@ %-$%*$%%"-:0!+".$ 69.! :9! !+" 11" 6 @ % 66@"- :0 !+" --$!$& 6 $%!.$#! 9-="7 *: 6 &

)

;@$!+ -$."#!$&!+ !C!+"."%1&-"&!%D-"

"&- &!% ."-$."#!"-! "B"#9!"!+"#&8"0 &#"-""-$&."%1"#! !+"%9$!1.1".!079%" ( E .7*: 6 &!!$& 89. !+" 11"66 &!%D16 $&!$

% %1".!+" 66!*"&!6"!!".&."#"$1! 66!+"1 0*"&! %1".6 @@$!+$& 1".$- &" *&!+ .* !+" - !" .-". +"."

!".7 !+" "1 .!*"&! "+ :$6$! !$& !+.9=+ "+%$6- . > 6"%?7 *: 6 "B"#9!"- !+" % 6" #".!$ $# !"& )

;+"1"!$!$&".%1."%"&!"-!+"% 6"#".!$ $# !":"

." !+" $&! 9: "=$%!. .7 *: 6 &!! . $!% ."=$%!. !$& @+ &"$!+". ."

9%"-!+"."=$%!. !$&&.."=$%!"."-!+"% 6"#".!$ $# !":9!$!!. &%1$."-!+ ! !+" +$"

B"#9!$8"

$#".7 &!&*"&! .-7 *: 6 &!! 8$-" +$% 6"!!".- !"- )

; 11.$%"-!+"$&!9:"=$%!. .7*: 6 &!!!+ ! !+""&!$."6 &-%$!9 !"-$& &!&*"&! .-7*: 6 &!!$%@&"-:0!+" ,$&$%!.0 "&#" &-!+9%!+"$&!9:"=$%!. .7*: 6 &!!@ % -$."#!"-&!!."=$%!".!+"% 6"#".!$ $# !" 3" .&"-#9&%"6 .!+"1"!$!$&".%+ %%9:*$!!"-!+ !!+"$&! 9: "=$%!. .7 *: 6 &!! # &&! ."

9%" ! ."=$%!". !+" % 6" #".!$ $# !" &-$&!+$%."= .-+"+ %."6$"-91& -"#$%$& !+" $8$%$& "&#+ !+$% 9.! ."&-"."- $& !+" # %" C .$ $&=+ .$ $&=+ .$ $&=+ .$ $&=+ /% 9: "=$%!. . .& 96 9: "=$%!. . .& 96 9: "=$%!. . .& 96 9: "=$%!. . .& 96FFFF >?>$8$6?G

&- -"#$%$& !+" $8$%$& "&#+-"#$%$& !+"&-+. . -"%+$=+9.!."&-"."-$&!+"# %" C . % $ +/% C . % $ +/% C . % $ +/% C . % $ +/% ! !" &-+. .

! !" &-+. .

! !" &-+. . -"%+7 "=$%!. !$& &- ! *1% "1 .!*"&!F -"%+7 "=$%!. !$& &- ! *1% "1 .!*"&!F -"%+7 "=$%!. !$& &- ! *1% "1 .!*"&!F -"%+7 "=$%!. !$& &- ! *1% "1 .!*"&!F

>)? >$8$6?) ) "%1&-"&! % ! ;7 ( &- + 8" $6"- !+"$. %"1 . !" ."16$"%

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

;$&@+$#+!+"."@ % #6" .-$."#!$&7!+ !!+": 6 &#"*&"0 D %@"66 %$&!"."%! ;D@ %-"1%$!"-:0!+"- 9=+!".% = & !+ &- %%9#+!+"#&8"0 &#"-""-@ %$%%9"-$&!+"$. 89. 3" .&"-#9&%"6 .."%1&-"&!%!;H + %%9:*$!!"- !+ !!+"."=$%!. !$&+ %:""&-"#6$&"-:"# 9%"!+"1.1".!0$&A9"%!$&-"% &!:"6&=!!+" "1 .!*"&! "+ :$6$! !$& 3" .&"- #9&%"6 . !+" 1"!$!$&".% + % %9:*$!!"- !+ ! !+" 9:"=$%!. .+ %!+"<9.$%-$#!$&!."

9%"!."=$%!". -#9*"&!$&!".*% "#!$& !+""=$%!. !$&#!7 )I .%+.!J!+"#!2K"#!$& !+"#!." - %9&-".' C " %&% . ."

9% 6 ! ."=$%!". ! :" ."#.-"->?8".09:"=$%!. .."

9%$&= !."=$%!". -#9*"&!7"B#"1!&!+"=.9&- !+ ! !+" 1.1".!0 ! @+$#+ $! ."6 !"% $% &! %$!9 !"@$!+$&+$%%9:-$%!.$#!7%+ 66* 5" &

; .-". ."

9% 6 &- ."#.- +$% ." %&% . %9#+ .-". $& +$% 5 7 &- "&-.%" !+" @.-% C."=$%!. !$& ."

9%"-F & !+" -#9*"&!L &-7& 116$# !$&* -":0 &0 1".%& "B"#9!$&= . #6 $*$&= 9&-". !+" -#9*"&!7 %+ 667 @$!+9! 1 0*"&! &- 9&&"#"%% .0 -"6 07 =$8" +$* #10 ." %&%%."#.-"- > ? ."=$%!".$&=

$#". %+ 66 ##"1! . ."=$%!. !$& -#9*"&! % "&-.%"- 9&6"%% &- 9&!$67 9&-". !+" 1.8$%$&% +"."$& !". #&! $&"-7 !+" -#9*"&! $% -$."#!"- ! :" ."=$%!"."-F !$% 9.!+".%9:*$!!"-!+ !!+9=+!+"1@".8"%!%@$!+!+"9: "=$%!. . ! ."

9%" !+" ."=$%!. !$& -#9*"&! :9! +" + % ! %%$=& ." %&$&!+$%."= .-@"8".7$!$%%9:*$!!"-!+ !!+"9:"=$%!. .# &&! ."

9%"!"&!".! $&!+"-#9*"&! .."=$%!. !$&&!+"-$."#!$& !+"! !" 9&#!$& .0 @+ + % &1@". . #&!.6 8".!+" 9: "=$%!. . !$%%9" %9#+ -$."#!$& +" .=9*"&! !+"1"!$!$&".%$%%911.!"-:0 -"#$%$& !+" $8$%$& "&#+ !+"&-+. . -"%+$=+9.!."&-"."-$&!+"# %" . % $ + >91. ?

. % $ + >91. ?

. % $ + >91. ? & !+" # %" .$ $&=+ >91. ?

.$ $&=+ >91. ?

.$ $&=+ >91. ?7 !+" $8$%$&

"&#+ !+$%9.!+ -+"6-!+ !$!$%&!!+"1@". !+"9:"=$%!. .! * 5"1.:"$&!!+"@&".%+$1 !+"1.1".!0%9=+!!:"!. &% ".."-$& &0* &&".

( & !+" 1."%"&! # %"7 !+" 1"!$!$&".% + 8" !+" % 6" #".!$ $# !" $%%9"-:0!+""+ :$6$! $& "1 .!*"&!&!+": %$% -"#.""1 %%"-$& !+"$. 89. :0 !+" #*1"!"&! $8$6 9.! ! $% &60 !+" * !!" ."=$%!. $& !+"% $-% 6"#".!$ $# !"!@+$#+ &:<"#!$&+ %:""&. $%"- :0 &!+". "1 .!*"&! !+"8".&*"&!$"!+" "1 .!*"&! "&#"& !+"=.9&-!+ !!+"6 &-$&A9"%!$&$%$&!+" &!&*"&! .- &-#96- &!+ 8":""& 66!!"-:0!+""+ :$6$! $& "1 .!*"&!! = & !++$% :<"#!$& # &&! :" . $%"- :0 ."%1&-"&! ( :" ." !+" $&! 9: "=$%!. 7 "1 .!*"&! "+ :$6$! $& :"# 9%" ."%1&-"&! ( + % & #&!.6 8". !+" $&! 9: "=$%!. ! $%%9" %9#+ -$."#!$& . &! "&!" $&$&= !+" % $- -#9*"&! . !+" 19.1%" $!% ."=$%!.

$& ."%1&-"&!($%#6 $*$&=!+"@&".%+$1 !+"1.1".!0$&A9"%!$&7!+"0 %+96- "%! :6$%+ !+"$. .$=+! 8". !+" % $- 1.1".!0 :" ." #*1"!"&! 9!+.$!0:"# 9%"$!@96-:" * !!" "8$-"&#" %!@+"!+".!+"6 &-$& A9"%!$&:"6&=%!!+""+ :$6$! $& "1 .!*"&!.!+" &!&*"&! .- +9%7 * !+"#&%$-"."-1$&$&!+ !!+"1."%"&!1"!$!$&+ % *".$!7 !+"."

."7 -$."#!$&$%$%%9"-!!+"$&!9:"=$%!. .7*: 6 &!!! ."=$%!". !+" % 6" #".!$ $# !" - !"- )

; "B"#9!"- $& 89. 1"!$!$&".%:0"+%$6- .> 6"%?7*: 6 .!+@$!+ $!+!+"%":%".8 !$&%7!+"1."%"&!1"!$!$&$%+".":0 66@"- >44,?

>44,?

(

) (

) +"!+".%1" 5$&=D." %&"- '

"%D +"!+"."1.! :6" '

"%D