High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1880/2024dismissed

Punjab State Warehousing Corporation v. P.K. Kalia

2026-04-21Mr. Justice Vikas Suri,Mr. Justice Suvir Sehgal7 pages

! " #""$ %&'( )*)+*)*, * " #""$ %&' - *!)+*)*, . " #""$ %&' " #/' **)+*)*, +

""0'(1"$ %&' - #"""1 $ %&' - 3 " 04'1041" -&11 $ %&4 "1 ! " # $$ % $ " # $%&$$

6 78"&4' (-#'" 7"'('"&4 (-41"9: '/"- 7;"0'4 (-41" '/"- <<<<< $ % $ '# ! " "( / 1' -"%'% $ %& # # /0" '% %' (

) )*+,(

- )4#"/0##'''1 /0

" =#' '' # # 4 ##) '&''%"'&1&('--'(0#'"11-1&##-4' " 1"''&4#> " 4 "='# '- =' /1' '- '% ' " &''/ * " ( 1-4 ' /'14 " " 4 #"' ('% "

7%4#- %' &0 %'1"%1-;-"%="#' ##

2 !. ##.#%' -' -'

*+, #'"-',*+,/0123 4353+16/+ /0/447816/+91'-

' "%1 ' ' ##-4"

%""'& - "" &# /$-" -&1 '% '-''0- "14 "#-' (''' #-('- /0" -'&' (' $ %& ##4%'#"'-"-'&' #1 4#"'-"' '% $ '-'/1"' ' #-#4-(01 :#'

;

-&/'& ' " &- '% /> 04/0" ##)4 " =' '&' " 1& ('- -'(0#'"11-1&" 1'& .

%?&'

#<*+,9 1" $/'('('-

4 &4 -&"-- '" 1 '&4 '-''0 & - / "( '0

-> -4/ - "(/ '&' 1&('- -'(0 %" "" 1 '&' #('' '#1 0"1- &1-('-'4#'"

-' '1"- -#"'-" -"-('-'4> ' ' # %1 "1 "'"/-10-'1'- "'@'%-' '1 '-''0- '%'& -" '"&1'&4& '-''0 "'0# / ' + ''%"' $ %&4 - 1" /&'"-" -('- -"%'(('% - ' -'&'/-"1 4'#1 0$ '1' ' '%" 1 '&''% "&'&- "' %' " -> - 1 %( &'- -4 '- 0#""-'&'- --&&' '%('- '1 "- "" '% %1''" '% " '&'- / 1'& '%'%1 '/1' 3 -4 - '% 1 " " $ %& /&' " " -'( '&' #?

**9/:0/#'"" '%1' -(01&' '&'1&('-1 ' '1 "% ""'& % ##) ' -

0'1-'% '%"- -1"&0 '%-('-' #4"14 '/'('#1" ''1# "' " " 1' '1-(010 & 4#"'-""/ '&' /0"' *A!)*)*3-0 1"$ %&"/- - /0"- ,

"(" - 1"' "(% " %""- #'""'/'- A 2- ''' ' ' 1& ('-#'"11-1& ##- " 1 '&'-&/ & -""1##)4 "#'"-'(11- 1&" 1'&'1-"$ '"'1&0 &0 " - -- 1 '4 0 -' "1" -'0/-/-'1'- 0(''

%"'%"0?&' "&'"-?1

#<1" $/'('('-

4 &' '%1" ' "#"#"'( "(&'"'%"1 =6122/>,6+? /4 =612,4*=6+? 83+:6/+4 #"0 04 '%" 1 439/534@04/A83+:6/+1- '0- "(&4'1' &$ '-'- '%"''1 % '01%( &'- -%'%- '%('- " (' 1 '&'1&('-1'& B "14"-- ' #/0" '% % " 0 '0 -> - - 1#4 - / ' /

4"''1'&0/ 1&"?1

**9/: 4 #"'-"" '% %" - 0@ &0/ '- " ##)1%1('''

**9/: 9-:4#"'-"'1' '-""%('%1' 1'&#'0% '4&( '&'1& ('- C

1' 1 #'""1 "'%1" '% %"" '&' #%0 '/1#1 -' '1" D- - '%-('-' ##)4'- /0" '% %4# &0 "% " " /-('- ''"-('-'/0 '1 &'-0# '&' " '-''0 "'0' > ' 0'&' " 1- -#"'-" -('-' - " '% %--0' " # - ' +6/+/0+,6*5#7>:6 *A *13>'- .$- '" " & 0 ?-' 1 -' '% " - - 1 " '> &0#&''% !)

%'- "#"" #&' '4"'& - ""'&# /$-" -&1 '%,6:968>6+*4@9*:3: ' &;" '& /$- " -& 1 " -'&' - "' # ''-'- &-'- /0" '% %#"''% "%'01" '&' "'('# 111&

)

('0'%'0 !!

> 0'%&#'"" '% %" & '%"&# ( 1 % " 0 ##- " '% %1 "" 4 0'% 2*?64*126 3+* 5# /*4, /0 64391/4:' #$# ## 2*+,4*$6+?25#$1*13/0 *B*:12*+4 $)- ' "'" /- 1 -'1'- ('' &''% -' ' 1 '-''0 - '%1" 1'1'-'% -" '"&1'&4 -"?-'- #/('( "//'

0 4 ''-1&

**9/:4 "'@'%"'%1 1 '&'1&('-%'' &0-"'4 " '-' &''/='/1'-/1 #'" !* / '- " " '% % " 1- -''-0&''/'# "('

""/' '- '"-'( '&'1&('-1 '& /0 #"'-"4 ' 0 -4 ' '10 " % > '& " $ %& 4 "14 '; -- /-/#"'%"1"' " "'01"&0

"'-/ 0%'& !. ' " 4'1-' # 0 #" " $ %& -"% ' "# / &'10 %0 / 1' -"'1'&'0'"

'& % $ %& "('#; /0 " '% %' '/ --('#/"1- # !+ > 04 /" " ,6:A6::3, %& # # /0" '% %' 11'& !3 '%&'- '-'9:4'104" ' 1 $ % $ %&$$

846>') "";'%E FE ""/ FE