← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3701/2013allowed

Diwan Singh v. Shankar Lal And ORS

2018-11-22Mr. Justice B.S. Walia8 pages



      

  





   



    

  ! "       # $% &"'" $#'( &% ) &

 $*  %!+&"'  $ &"'

 " "  $  $ &"'" $ %&"'  $ ,$( &"'

 " ---  



 

   .  "  %   %   

&/

01 "" .2  " $ " ) % 3.  & ." 4   "   5 3.  67      +   ".2

%' " 8





 3



"   , +  %" "  9

"  %"   %'% , +

3     .1 "". 2" .  :33.  .2,  %"+ 2   

5;862"'". " 

,%" ;&



-:2:-

%&"% ,

" . <&

%".2 

2% 

 586&.2,   %   % = <&

 %   /&

01& .2 " 

01   &

014 ;

9<%7"& ;

 "" &

01%" 9 & ;&

014 ;

9

%7  "

&

014



 :". 27"/<&

01    &""  %  

&/

01  >"    

 "   %   ""  "  %&

  ""

: .

"%  % " ?6.

 %)  $, '$$  "

<4

7))   @ )% 2>" ' #2"&

4<7!)!4)' 7

8 "%"

2& ""  ;8 2        / 4'7 "#264 7&""   9"  2 " .     ;

  /  2&

:    .

"% ""& 9% &.,   %   2.

#  8  "  $, 6  4 7 " / 4'7    "  #2 64 7 " " "1

83 &   

 ""  "& ".+ "  ) &" ,   %"      , 

01   % 2   %  %    +  "

-:3:-

.

 %  "  "     %  &?)   ","     % ."   

 " " .2  )        "    3 &  

  +  "  ,  1 % "  "  

 "   "    %1

 ";

: ""    

" " .2  )      '4 73 '  " " @  %B4 7&C " D "" ' 

 '

"%  %  2.

   ' '%"&"

"' '9 ".2) "

& "    %.  "  "  + "%  E# !3) ' 3 , )" 4 88/7 < ))/ &'D) %.F ! 2 )% 2>" 8;

)/

&''#



2 " )

 >" 8<  ) /

" %"  %   %  9   " .2  3.  "?) % "  .2 2 " +, %  ""

"&%  %" .  47""% @ %% 3%  )  "  % .2  2

:& 9%" 2.2 ;

:".DG. %" .2  % : @ '    % ".

 "

-:4:-

& '  "    %.&"" ;

:    2   2% """ & """ %+.".  <  2 4H     %    9.

&  " I    2I  " . "  I    2  9I7 3 ""  " .  2 :        ""  <   ;

 2 3  " .  ""&       ""  %  ;

 2 3   '" %2 "  "

    &   2""""'""

 2", . 

"  "

 %"    ." "H""

%

2"     9"  2 4  '

  %&7& 

  

2,  2  %% ""    % ".%" 2"9  ' '  % 3 &,.  & %  %  ""  " 

&/&

01J

019

K

9

9 ;

79

9 L

!"#$%&'( '" 4'7 @   ""  

1%

2"   

9"  2&  ""   < :    .

" % "."" .  < 2"" ;: "". < ;

2"

-:5:-

:"". ;

 / 2 ".""2%" 3.

"%%% % 9%  < &

;82 " %"<

% ,

" . &

: .

"% 

 9% 

.,   %   2.

 ; >"  " %    %"."""M  %  

01""% '.""=

%  %"  %&%"

2 "%"

2

  " "2'" %"%. ".23.  @ " 2 

M   ..

"" 2& "" =

 %<

01 % 

01"" .23.   / ",

 8



&" 

01 2'.""4 ;

9<%73%"" .2 " 

. "@ "% 

".2 " 

" 2&" "

%  %

01  &

01 "" .2  3.   >,   %    &;

01  .""   "" &% 

-:6:-

'. %% %  %" 2& ""   " &;

%  %

 &;

01"".23.  "%" 9 & %"2  %  ;&

01""   "

  % ;

01""    20 %    >"    "  ,   +  "" 2

 "&   "

 .

."@ " % 2 " 

  



"   , + %" "  9 

 "     %"       %'%   ,  +  

 3   

  .1  

 "'.

 " 

  ".

"   % 3 & ,    

      %& %    

01 ""      " 

0 20 %     "  ;

013

 

"". 2 .  :   ""   %   

01 >"    "   %    ' . "  

 : ". 2 

  <

01  '   "    )   !% * (2  '  . '  F& $  " 

 4 7 !)! 4)' 7

 >"   "'..

"  2

% %  %" ! ' 9    "    )   !% * (2 6  4 7  " " "1

-:7:-

< .' 2"& " C "   "2 "  %    2 .  2 "   2 "%     . "" "   " 

% ". 2 "  " 

& %" "

   % "  "  " 2  %   %      ". 2   F9#1   "&  "    2  "'.." % '"&    %  , %  '%    ?'&  %    . "" "%" % ". 2 "  . " " & "

" 'D   )   "  .'  

01  . "" : ". 2   + "    &       % ". 2   "" '" F9#   ;;:&  %    & "=

'2 :". 2  > 2 " 

" 

  2" ;: .

" % 

&% "'.""= :     ". 2 "  @ " %    .%   

"   &  &  %  "" = :   

: 

 .

."""%" ",  <

01K<

01N <<

01 4<<

N 01 " .2 

2 

-:8:-

% 

 686   ", 

98N8;

< 0 @ %&%    "

%/<&

018;& < 01  " 2&    %    

&/

"" .2  3.  &  

   "  "  "     & &< 01     = 8    " 

   % 

" 2%& %  2 "2

""

%&@ )% 2

%, 2% 

 %,""  9 . 2& 2&" &"" ?6.

 %) #264 7 8 " 2&

 

""""" 8



&

".23.  %" "9".'    ))**)+*, +,,  H ,0" O0 H .

 O0