← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2155/2014allowed

Sunil Kumar v. M/S Bhullar Oxygen Pvt Ltd & ORS

2015-12-15Mrs. Justice Raj Rahul Garg13 pages

         



   

   



 

!"#$%& '() "

  *

  !

"# #   ' +,"

 ( "

  *! " ( 

 -    



 

   



   

 

  

  

 $  ."     

  "       %  

   

 /    0

& "   

 

 1%"

2  .    3"

  4".  56( 1-7-    

,    (  %  "

 

      1"

"  0     

8 ## ! % "  "  ""   / 

 

 " + 

9 '



 &- 7% " 10

& 1 "

 !"  #$%&  '(  )     &

&  * 7 /  

*  /  "   %1 # 8   / 

   1      !"  #$%&  '(  )  9   '



  &1 " (:(

&"



 0+'!//;/ <8  .

&2  % 0

 ;



      (  $%&  %

    :(  

&"   (  1

 

& "

&(" %

 "   /

  "

& &   

  %



   "

 "    "     

& 

 

&  

&  

 & (

,    "   &"  "   1          

&

  ""

& ."   /

 1

0 ) )

;

:.*  1""

  8<<   

   #   

, %"



"    /

 

         

88" "

 <==3"

 4"

%

56."1

&

 1%".   / ! "# $



# #% 

     &  % 

'   ( )  *+, 

 -      .

  '    /  $

%-      



 

  ' 123) 3034(),  



     /5  2  67  1&      8&# %

      & 611 ! "   5     &    %

%  

! "  

     8&  #      & &  &    

 %

%  

 61 3 ! &"    

  

   &    

     % 

%  

 61 3 !&"        61 3 .".   

&

 

( "   /

  &

"

."



&1

&"%  "

"   /

 1"&"

   2>/;  "

 ( ?$2>

1"

"" " "



1"

"""

 

,    +  (   1    %  "  

   ;  2

  ;

 

&"    '     4!5  (

     &"  "   %   %  &

    "   '    

&*+7778  "

 

%@!,

&"  %"

&?$ *>/    '>/    +   "  * 

  )   )

;

:.*   ( 

  -< * -<8 / " "

1  

" "

 /8/ 1 

"& -/</ '>/- "

&" # 2 ( ;

   " A"" %$



 

& "



 %"1   ""

   ?$  '>/-    ;    "  1       

    1    "

"



 %"$  B

 

 '>/7!"



&"' !"





)  2 7: 'C02*  

("   * 8 /%"

  

( 

 ?$*>/7  ."D  

 1 

  % ".    







  

       

  

    ! " # 

 $

 



%  & '()& '   $* " 

 + '$* & ', " -  ' ! "    "     $ #.# /.0%- #1.- 2)) 34 

  9

&



1 ""  & 1"

,   /

  

"



 @  "(  "  "     

   "    

 "    ."  

   (   ",& ; 5" 2@ 

"      



  !

"





  #$%&'%(  ' ( )*+1"" (  1 &7%  1 (&( @1 "" (&( 

 %  

&* 8 /   "  1 "  B 

  

 "    

    

 

    =  1  

     

&  "      

  * "

&   ,& ; 5" 2@ 

  ,     - .



/    0!

#$%% '&(  ' ( 1%) 1"

       1"  1  10

&      "     1 "  

  "

&1   

&

AB 

 %

"   ("

%"

%1 0

& * -  " "

 



   * -8 /     

   

&          AB  

 % *  / 

 

=1



9"* ) 1 11   *  1 

  

&  " * ) 1 



@ A=<  ",&  "   (   /       

     

     

      

  

     

         

  !      "  " 

        #      # 

     

            "  "    

              

      

   

 $       

% !      &   

      '  (        )

     )  

   #    * !

     

      

'

             +         "     

)#       #     

        , ! "   

           #     "         )     #                         

 $          

,- !           

    .        

*%* !   " 



               "   

#    ) #        #   / '

 0  #1  "  )  2*34-'))*5

*       /     )   

        # 

     *         

           6  7 

                   

   

    

   %,- !

( 6  "            "   

   

  8          9  5  :



 #  ;  '2*,4  *  '))  *     )

               

                             

 8    #      /  <(   

(2    4='

  #57 

/   = 366  )(  66  2=4   /   1#7    > 

)0   <> # 

  

   < 33 )( 2>  4) # ?

@5#     #      

             

 8      9     #      

   #    

            #               #    5    

   

   

     #    

      9      #      

)                   8         6        )  

     A    

      #            

       )  

                 

        

                                   

@    

  / 

 #      

  8               



  

               "    /               

* !     

        5     8      

 

               8   "             "    

  

     

             5              

         

   #    5  

   "   )          

    

   

      

 B# 

 # 

       

    

     

 

               "           

    "   )  

        8

             

  

  

  *  A      

     

  "   

         /         

   % !  



  

          *  "             "             5 

           

    

   # #      

  " 

 

  8

 

  #    % 1

    #          /   "  

     #

    "     /         % !     

 /   @ ,& %; 5" 2@ 

"   2 3/4 

- 3/4 

- #$%&'%(  ' ( 1)+1"

"   1"1 

&)7 / 

AB  

 %

  1 "" 9



 9                                   &     : '    

&      ,);

         @  ",& %; 5" 2 @ 

"  2



 6



- !

#$%+'7(  ' ( 8*#! 1"

"( 1  

 (" .  

"

 

) / :       

:  &

     '            &  /    78 & : ',))53 

 '    <   

();     % 

));       

    -    ,);

 

 %       

               ! ,))53=>,)53"7 7>?)%>%)))53 @ "  3 

95 

- !

#$%# '&(  ' ( #)7

 B  

 %" "   %"

&  

&

0

&  

"

&

     ."  (   D                

  "%

" %  

  1  -  %    &  

& *  / 

A1 

"1  1 *   "    "& % 

1

1 

 * -7-=A7A / @ "  "    "   /

  1"1  -/7 % & "   1

10

&  %1& 1 &

&* 7E3  % 1 6  ";

  0   %1& *  /     "   

& 

 ( 1  "  "    B

 % "1 ("10 "&""

  



&B "  



    "  

     "  " :0 

;

;//   

 / 

;

9 4  6 <

"%    

%

& 

  =  * E$$=F* 8 /



&"   5   $   %        %   1      

     1    "& " *%

+,  " ." 

 %

"%

   /

 %  







  

   

 !  

  & '

$ "   

!

  

 

' " (4$",

  

    !(  5' , 5$"56$3 # 

 " % 

!

5     5    #.# /.0%- #1.- 2))  -7-/)  0.8-#  .9 /.0%- #1.- (,(34, 65"" ."   "        

   * - / " %1 "

  1 "

 " 

    %"

." "    

 " %

 G<B 

 "

&"       C 

( 1" ,& ; 5" 2

  3/4  3 

- /- - ;-    

 22

 - 

- !

#$%+'%(  +78*

& 



   " 

 



&%  "  1         "  ( $  "  



%1         /