Suresh And ORS v. Rahish And ORS
!
!"#$%&'&
$ ()
*& *
+ )
!"#$" %
& '
()*
+
$ ' ,,,,
+ ),& )
'-
% .
' % ++
%
/
'
0
%
0
+
0
$
0 ' 0
2 /
'
' 3 0 /
4 "$" ( + -0
'
5
6
67
44 8## '
'
' 4 (#%491:!%;
< -
4 (#%491'
/
' 1 *.& "& /!
0"1#2 * =%""91 $
* $>=%""? %="""91 @ = -
* %="""91 A 5%";7 $!"""91
A
$!"""91 = # - A
$!"""> =? (!#"""91 8 . + " @ +
@ 0 $ "#%4 $ @ B> $%"""91 . B = - +
4 (#%491 $
0
=
%
$" 0$"" 3 0'
0 / C1(#.9( ( 5
6
67
//
'
/
- / '
' 0
$$"%$" @*0 / !#
%"%$"
$!8D((# *+'
/
/
0$ /
E *'
'
/
$""""91 /
/ .
9
/ ' / / '
' C 0
$$ / '
0
0 # C 0
0
'
=%""91'
' '
/ F
0'
%$""91 .
G >
0
E 0
/ ' National Insurance Co. Vs. Pranay Sethi, 2017 SCC 270 and Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Nanu Ram alias Chuhru Ram & Ors., 2018(4) RCR (Civil) 333. 4.
On the other hand, learned counsel appearing for respondent No.3 - Insurance Co., while opposing the submissions made by counsel opposite, submits that the two minor sisters of the deceased Bablu i.e. appellants No.3 & 4, were not entitled to any filial consortium. He further contends that 0
0/ 0
/ : =%""91
/ 0 / C
0- '
/
'
. '
' 0
0
/
1
'
' *
+ ' 0
0
0
' 0 # $$ / E '
/ 0 F
%$""91
' ' E0
/ @
'
' ' 0
-
E 0
'
/
+ 3 C 60 + Pranay Sethi's case (supra) C 60 + Pranay Sethi's case (supra)
E
%"""91 0
>
=""""91
0
' 0 0 ";
' 0 ";
0
C 60+ Rasmita Biswal and others Vs. Divisional Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. and another : 2022(1) RCR(Civil) 344 '
Pranay Sethi's case(supra). Hence, the amount of compensation under the conventional heads stands modified to Rs.16,500/- each, for loss of estate & funeral expenses. Besides this,
'
' =="""91 Since, the Tribunal did not award any compensation qua future prospects, the appellants-claimants are also entitled to future prospects to the extent of 40% keeping in mind the age of the deceased, who was 22 years old. 8.
Resultantly, the compensation is re-assessed as follows:-
*.& "& /!
0"1#2 * %$""91 $
* $>%$""? 4$=""91 @ 5=";7 4$="">=";? $=84"91 = -
* #!(4"91 A '
> 5H7 $ #="91
A
4%%$"91 # # - A
4%%$"> #? !8(4"91 8 @ +
@ ##"""915 =="""91 " 0 / ' ##"""915 =="""91 @ B> 4%""91 $ . B 4%""91 ( - +
(##(4"91
(##(4"91
/' :#;
< 0
I
0
+ )
/3%,