Bachan Lal v. State Of Haryana & ORS
!"#$% &!'()'*+"#,"#$
&'-&.&
/(0( 1&!&2&&3-(
(45(
!"# $%&'(# )*%
(''
!"# $%&'(#
(' +++
() 6 &517-,5'&, !-4
6 1&546057,55 &2&&, !-1&
88888
(' ",$
-4,'&*7-*(!+&40+'(454( &75 %2&(&5-&75!*5&&2,-&(!5-4( 94'&*7-!97!): ;
! " # $ !
$ %
$ !
&!
' ! ($% &!
' ! $
*+ , ! " $ $ !
$ !
!
!
% ! ! !
&!
' !
-%
.
/
1 21 /0/30
!
$
! !
%
+ , !
!
! !
' ! ! !
!
+
+ 4 5
!
" ! ! $ ! 5
!
$ %
!
4 2 - + , " 6
7%
$
$
$ % !
+8
6 &517-,&5'0(&44&7+-&!!- 4 (0+*5 -& - 4( 4 4&( - '72, '*2&5-9:+7!-(5(!/&71&7&,*+&& &57,9-'-(77+(2!!'5&''0!-: *4*&<:!'* ! - 4(( ! - 0=&+ .&5
(&',$ ##>!(-;
.
?@&5-&5&9( /&7 1&7&((0&5&-+&A!B C &5&5=7-(- 1-&*&&5*&(07$ ##<$%##A&&(!-&7,9-'--&(+ !5&(;
(.&5?051' !- .
-(&5,- &0*+!A-&(-&795-!$D! 0-*7- &(9&(-!(&5,-&7(&!&'74+*( &44&'--&7'00&&5
9&(F&705-&-.91-&A(!&7-
- ('(! &'-A0&,*+&&&5&*0&&7&&*&25&5+2 0*+!4&(&*( 12(*F-+(55(0+:55 4&&5&(*4&'(0+:4&&&5&5&&( -&* &'-&2& !/&71&7&+24&((7(05&5$G "#$#-&5&A& 5'(-&-*74&(/&71&7&&5&5=&' +4-+597-5&7--&+&( -(4&((&7 &44&'--&7'00&&5,9-'-((0&5&'((-&550 -(&(,-&5-&5+'*+& -(0(0+*5- ,&&7&-9&(!9&55-67 !!':(45 E$ "#$$ 6&24(&(&7&(-7&*7&57& ('7 4&( -& + (0+*5, +0 &' -&5 + &A - .&5'0(!-4!0-'55-&- &* &'-&2&&5-(!/&71&7&9&-402 **((,*+&&(&7-&-(4'&+(!-/&7*-* $G "#$$&5"
"#$$,+0-H0(9&(&''55 9&( !9&55-26&7(&!'((&2&',+0255(0
.!9-*52,&7((&5&5"
"#$E>F0 : @ -6(! &'&57&,&2&& -'(45' +9-F'07,&1'((,*+&&&5- 402**((,*+&&'05,+0-79&(5&5&! -&7(-4!&2&'-4&,-4-&(&44&'-5 -(0!5'&!-7&' -!*&(07-05 - 7-!*&''&25'&5-&7&*7-&5 +4*5 /55&5$
$"
"#$ >F0 :$"@,- &7
( !!', (4&*,&&7&-9&-10+
(& !!',&&7&-(&7-&-*74&-&5(&5 !*$
$"
"#$ &=07-6&A&5&&5 (,+06<( -& 4( .5 &!5*&'&-&5&A-(4& - *74&-&&(77,5&2&57-'&'9- '&&5*(&,4'&5'54(&,4&29&(*&5 -(0!7&7-!,%+ (4( - ' ! *, 9 (&* +2 1&54I0*&,F'07,&1'((*+&& +-&!!(45( ",$$&5$"-&(+!5 &'-&(+ 4&'5 04 (0 5&5
"#$% 4&((5 +2 -&* &'-&2&, 1&7&-!!'-&-*7&-&5H0(-&5+ &445+2-*-07-4&0'!&0!6<(-&
4( .5 ,&&7&-&5-&7(-&5+='*7 &(-9&(5&7!!5(50-(&5*7 -&( '-&75 ( 5' ! !9 ! 9& &5 - 4&' ! *7 ( & (0!!'5(&'!*/&71&7& *(,9&((&5-&( &40+'(7&,+0&''0!4(&(,!,- &5H0(-&5+ 0(5+2-((!-4!*7 404((,9--&5+'&70'((&2-5&'-*79A &((75+2- *(-(4(&(' !'-&5 +*&5-&(55>F0 :$@F'05+26&5&.&&5 * &A&(-I0*&((!&'-&.&&(9&('45&5"
"##G (!27-&&(0*!",$#,###<:9&(&A!-*7404(+2 77-&5&+17-&5&=17-
-9(&*!5+2(45
+-&!
!(45( E, &5G&5-&&=(4'9&('50'5
$% "#$% +2 6 I -&0-& >67 (4'@, 75 17-
&&7&-, 10, 0 7, >3 @, &&7&-, 6&= &&
, &&7&- /&7( A&, 1&7&, &, &*540,62&40, &6&=&,1-&-40,&4&9-!05&-(4 -&&05E ('74&(94&&'5&59 9--4-+5*!"##*(!*-!( !'-&(&( +*&5F0 :!'&,9-+2&05$ ('7 4&(9(J5&54&25!5(*((&!-94
-&-&5-&5'0(!-4&(&5&44&(5 -4&4+A
5&44'&-'(!-&5'0(! -4&(,905+&4450'-&(55>F0 :$@&5 -'4F'05+2-'-5!-477-&5 *&(07$%A&&((0&5/&71&7&!*7404(( &+17-&5&=17-&7&(&&*0!",$#,###): ;F0 :$ # 9,$ 5:
$
'+;
9
'+' <$
!
' ! = > !($%+= "
!$
!
$ ! 5 !
' ! 6%> +1 = > !($% : "
+2 # :
+:
+4/1* 0 2/1* 0: $ !5 5 3#
! ?$%
* 4
5 9 <+
*/<+,
0 $ 2+ +
1
++
#+;% ' ! ;- ' !
' !
#
= > ! ( $% ! ;- 35 $
% + $
<+
*/="
0
% $9
;%' ! ;-' !+ =
$
%
"
+> "
" ;- 35 $ % % ++
"
%-
$
$
"
%-
%
+= %
" % %
%
" % +> "
!
%
+
!
! ;- 35 $ %
% $
+ '*# 9 '*,$ 5 '*<-:
$.)
9
@* '*'+A5<$
<$
6$ = > !+ ;%' !;-' !
@*'+ < ! $
<+
*/<+="
0 $'+;-' !;%' !
' ! $ !5 2+ +
1 ++
%
% $
+ ( @2+ +
1+ '*# 9 '*,$ 5 '*<-:
$.)
9
@*8
&&7&4-"$!-9(&*!5+2(45
+-&!!(45( E, &5G9-'-(&(&&5(-0():
;+ =
+ %$ -
"
* 4*
@4 #% '+:+ # ! $%' ?
! ' ! <+A+,+ > ! ' '
?
.
!
(/;B<0> !'#
- <, > ! !
= 5 ' ! ( 6$ #
< #-' = +
42
!
" !
"
5 !
"
% $
$ $A +
'+,+ ++ 1 '+
! ""
5
)
$
$ A !
' !
! ""
5 !"
$ $ A
+2
! "
C
<*+8 $#
-(&*(-&5+'5+2-4 &2*& -&(&(55-!&'-&-&5-&5+7+2 -(((!*7404(( '-(4'9&('50'5+2- !!'(,&(5'&5&+,9--&5!05-&&-*74*(( &9--4&&*(!- .
&5-(&024((!&9 9-0&2&,04,-4(4905!& 9--5*&!6&&&+2! 0+'(.7& 0(, "#$#
!
"#$$
%& '(%)%* +( )) ()*%&(
( %),,*%-.( *(
. #%
'( *
((/(%' '( *('
.(
/ (*. '
( , ((%'
* , ). %
* '( ' * (%*'* (, * %'&%(-
%*'( *
('-%- '(
") '.". +.%) '
))-( 0 - *.
'( *
( (/(%'
,*( .
'
& * '( /%*1 2(
'( *
((/(%'
( )%* 3- %' ' .( %* * %)( )4
( %)(
5/ *( 6 ' "+ * - *(,, * %
* "&. ( , ((%'
*(% ,% (',,*%,*( &% '(+( (
/ (*. (% , %&, '
(%'8% ( (% (
, * %'8'
(( (%' + % &. )%* (% %'(
( (
(/(%'" + (&( . )% ' (% - 9(%
)*-%%
%*&) :*'*."( &. '( *('
%''.
;
( %)-(, &,%*(' "
< %' % *&(( * / ( * '
((%'
)*%&*%(-(&
((%'
%&,''/ %) *
& '( %* (%*( * %) , * %'
%'/'/ (
" *
' %( * 7+*
. ( %( * %* . (
,%
((%'
* , *(''/ (% '-*%'& '( ,% (%'"
( *' %) %%/' ")%*
('+) )
((%'
* %&,''/-%(%'%) &'*/ ( =
/ (*. '(( (%- *).( '( '(
%) , * %'" % (.%*'
%(%'+ %'-%7
(
;
* (%' %) ( 5/ *( %' (
%) , '( *
( > * (
/ (*. '. % ( %'
'( '( "'%)) '%( (%( )) ( , ( ,"
9 ,(%'( , ((%'
+ * * - .,% ( ?
'( *
(
((%'
* - ( *% / ,% ( '%( '( *('
9 ,('( )%%+'/
<@
((%'
'(.,* %'
* ' ( '
((%'
%&,''/-%(%'%) &'*/ (
((%'
7'/+*('( '( * %) %*,
-
((%'
+(
%)
'( * ( ( ( &.
* *
%@&%( ,*%
'/ . ( *( ' C
'( *
(DA -
((%'
.)''.%*, .
. , * %'
&'%* '8%* %,,*
(%'
%) % (.
, ((%'
)'/ ' ( ( /%*. &.
'( (% (
& * * (*.%) ( (( / *-
( %*(.
%' *'
"+ %"%' ( )(%'* /*'// '
'
'
%) ( , ((%'
*"&.,*%- ( /' '/ % '
(%( -(&
+
*$
% 6!
%
% ?
! $ %
;
"
+8 $$
(&04(-!0!57(,-((+''0(- +&((!-4&57(&5-5'0*(+07-'5,'&+ (&5-&&27&*7(+7'&50&(&75 -4( +&(5&44-((9-0&2(0447*&&,(&(+7 9--&*!;=05'&9?&( 0+'(.7&F'( !9=0(5' (0&2,-(&*(&5(5(*((5
> )*%
(''
"/ 0
(' "/ $%12# $%12# , 64 8 8 79 6: ;<
= 7<
8 8 65
7<