← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9780/2016allowed

Naresh Yadav @ Naresh Kumar v. Future Generali India Ins.Co.Ltd.& ORS.

2023-02-20Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj15 pages



 

       

  

 !"# !$%&%"'())* 

+

,-

+.

 

 /  0 + )  )   

( 1 0

) +, +)

 )             

       !" #$ 2222 , +)

 3 ) %     & "      #     

    ''()*('+,$  -&  .",  $  /0" "

 1  $ " 2                   "  , " " 3! 4+( 3# '4(   #  4+ 5  %   ,    6'*(789(4  #  6(:'*4+'*(9*  

   -;  "

"   !   

  3  0" "

 5 $          

4)((((< 6(*  # (7(9*('9=  $      "       &  !"   $      !"  #$  #  6  (7(9*(*9     $  '+(9*('9 " $   " 

8+4+)7<  !           "  &   "

"   >"        >"   "    "   " 

 ?

 ?

" " %  @ "&

  6   3  0"

  &   !      (+(4*('9       >"  ,  &      "  "  &%     "   "        ;   (8(4*('9          ;            $  $ "

      

$ ",      

 " @!

 6'()  ()(4*('9         @ "& 6  "   "

$",,$ !   $'+(+*('9 !  "                 1   =     !"  #$    ,"   $        !"  #$ "          ;  "

 $,  $      @!

%         1  =       @!

         ,$    !"  #$  (:(4*('9 %  ,      "  ;   ,  ,        9:        ':77 .

       A   ':77B/         $           ,"

$",,$   ;" $ "$ $!"        ,  9:  ':77   & "   

    , "     " 

**.#/ -   "  $':7) ,  

 ,   -& .",  $  /0" "

   "   !" #$

 $  ", ,$    !"  #$

            @!

       >"  ,  & 

(4(4*('9   @!

>"     ()(4*('9      $    $  "        !" #$(7(4*('9  $ $     "   $!"         $   ",          *:(:*('**7'(*('*     " (4(4*('9        $      >" 5    "  9:   ':77      , 

$ " #   ,     $   $,  #>" $C" ""  ** #.7/ -   "  $':7) " &,$  -& .",  $  /0" "

          ",  

     ,$          -&   .",   $  / 0" "

            "     9:   ':775   ,  -  "                       ,$     -&  .",  $  /0" "

,$    

 

  

 



          

  

        

 

     

         

   

          !  " #$ %          

 

        &  

         '         !  "

!   # $ %' " !  "

      

 

(           

 

     !  

                  

       

 ( 

) ( 

(            

   !   *        + (  

     ,

   

    (   ( ! 

 

          -          

.    

 ( 

  /  ( 

 ! #  0 , %  )    "" 



 

   

                  !

                ,      '    



.  (

     

 

   (   

  

 

       ( -   

       

 !           !  " #$ %   (  



    

    '1





           

      (    (  

2

 5         ", ,$        "     %  $

  #           $  *:(:*('*  *7'(*('* "  9:  ':77%     ""

 , C     ,     !"  #  6   ;"   4 5   !6(*>"    ," (7(9*('9@"     !" # 6.;"  4/ $  ""  %  >",*('9%   >"  "

$  ,$         !"  #$       " >"   $     ""             ! 6(*  

     #   (7(9*('9 1  " ,       $   ""        A*('9B %       $ $              $ *('*  "   !  "              

      %  $   #     ,  C""$" ,$   5"

 , 

,  $ ""    "

 ,*('*   ,           ,  ""

 $  =   ,  "  ""   $ ,"  %  $  # ",$ 3  <   "  $      "

    , , !"  $

$   

 $ ",$     $$"!"    " 

9:  ':77"

, ,  

   ,   , "  %  , &    

     %                  !    $  $  "   @!

   5     !" #$  ,"& ",        @!

5 "",    , $    ",  5      !

3 # "

  ,    6!

3<5-%5<6!

#<#!

<*'8<(:< *(''   ",,$" , $  " $",  "        C"   



 !

"#$ %&'

( '

) *  &

+!       %,          "

   "    C" 5B, "  #"   -+"!&!

( '

.!&

&



 !

'

,  / 0##! ' 1  '

    "        ",,   5B, " #"   "

  !" #$"

,  " "            ; $     %  $   # 5    C"  5B, " #"    .!&

&



 !

'

%&'

( '

+ ) " 3& ''  / 0##! ' 1     "

 ) 3 

!

*! +'  

 ,

 

'



   '              ,     4     

     ('

(  5



 % (    !   "            

 (     

 

      ( 

  

 

     %

 7' 

  !  '           

        

          8 )          (  '   ( 

     ,

    !   

          ( ,

       (   

    

             

    (     (   

     

  8 (

  

           (



   ( 

   (

    

)

 ('        

  

.  '  ,  



    

 8              3

  (  (     (        (   

'                ,  '   '                   

 !   "    %          ,             

        )    '  ' 

    (            



 (

!  "

 # $  % (   

   (     



      6



 ) 3  9 * +'34:;4 

   '

( '

  5"&    

('     



5 * + )      

     (  <     (          

  (  



      

 

   (



           5 *

+ )      

     <     (    '     



   (  

 

      

              

 !

 %( ,       '(      

(  6 *   +2 @"      ,  C"  #"   ,4!! 25+ ( '

!"! %6 0& & +!

 

 

%,



       C  "  ,      9:  ':77%   ;   C"   "   ,   )  ( '           # 

  = # 

  !      

 ( 

        37;"">#< -

     

   

 

     ( 

 3            (      





 

< - 

        &);3

-   

'

!  -")>4 

    %   '         37;?

><-   (



 

08%  

            

  !  * + 

 #$ %' " *

   %2+'          

        

   ('

(    (

     ( 

        

 

  !   "    %'       

(  

      

 

      %

         !  "  %   

  (  



   

   <    08 %      

 (   

  

 1  

   5?

 @    

'        

     

   (( 



        

  ( 7 A( !4

/ 0##! '

 1   !& 

!



 !

"#$ %&'

( '

/!

+ +&

+&+ &! &!& 

''   & / 0#!# '

1   &! &!& 

''   !& 

%6!

+ ) "

(!

5!8 7+ 3!!



 !

"#$ %&'

& / 0##! '  1   !& 

!&!

25+ ( '

!*

&

 !

'

%&'

&

+!

&! &!&  ''   0       

       1      ( 7 A( 3    4  :

 ;   4   ' 3 :

:: ;6$ 3!!



 !

'

%&'& +!

( '

# 7+5* 8

  < 

 & !



 !

'

%&'

( '

(&$ 78

  <  BBBB BBBB BBBB

 ) &!

25+=

 !

#8 

       # 

 > 8?/!?)) C: 

 

  ; ''-<?     

 

               

   ,  

 7'     

   

   

  

 (

    D ; ''

<?(

   

  

            ,            

      :

  & 

  4  >   %' "   &

 )  4 





  ,    -E   ; ''-<?    

 D "E 

 

   

 

  (  

 ! 4   ! 4          

    (   ' 

    

  

 



 

  %   

         !  4   '          ( 

  (   3   4   '   

 

 ' !0>     (   ! 4 % 

   

  (!4 

  

  



1  

  

5? C  3    4    

  



                     

  

        (

         

     

          

    !  "

!   # $ %22

         C"   ,! !

3!!



 !

'

%&'

( '

,6!

+ ) " & +!   



%,

%   ;  C"   "   ,     

3   / '    

        ?     

 "" - "    

&'   

              & 1

   '               !  " %   '

  8       

 

   )  

  

   

(

            %        (         

3  

  

 

 ; ''<?      (   08 %  '      (          '  (1  

3    

 

      2         ",  ,$    "    ",,$  "     !"  #$     C"        ,! !

3!!



 !

"#$

# "

  ,  ,        "

$,"          ':77 "

$               64      ",,$     ! ,"  "       ",     C"  ,$   !" #$  , % C"     5E, "  #"        .!&

&



 !

"#$

#             ,  "   ",   "$   ! " ,    % "  &   "  ,""   $00"5"

     ,   D        C"        '4!!  +%'56 +789  ",      ; $        $  %  $   #  %  

         (7(9*(*9    &    (+(4*('9   9($    !       "         

  "

 "   ,   

   C"    " ,$           ,  % >"  "         , 

$ "     9:  ':77!"

 ",      

9:  ':77 "  >2!   1 ;+!

 (!+ !

0 8



'

! !

$ 1 !5 'F3       

           (  

 (    

        

 

  4 

  

                 ( 

   

             8

 

 ( 

5>

  



       

    

  (1   

      (  (  (  4  G  2  "        

9: ':77"

         "    ,    ; $ %  $  #  %      

     $ "   "

 ,   $ ,$ 9:  ':77  ">"

 ,$% 5B, " #"     D ,

      , ,  !      #   >" "(7(9*('9!6(*   >"     

(4<(+(4*('95  >"   &      $$     -  "       !"  #$        %  $   #       *((:*('*  *7'(*('*   "       >"  , "<     9:  ':77

  "

      >"                     "

     #  !(7(9*(*9""       , @"    !" # 6   ,, "

  

$ $ ""    >"*('95 %  $  #        *:(:*('*  *7'(*('*  ,  " 

     !"  #  6      $   ""    *('9  !"  #$           !"  #  6     $   ""   ,   *('9     ",        >"$ ,  $  *('*@"    %  $  # ""     "  ,$ ! ,  ,$       "        $            = 

     $   ,"          

 "   ,  ,    , "  "   C" $ 5 $

 , "   3  <    "  $$    %  $  #  "    

**.3/ -   "  $':7) 

"    -& .",   $  / 

,  ,$  >"$,C$      "   C"        C" 5     "

     ,$ ,C  "    $      ,      -&            "

"  

# "

 C"   ,  = ;  ,$"  ,,  ,   ,   ,,$  -&  !           , ,   ""

$          >"  , "   ,$   (7(9*('9  ,     9($  "  "      $              9( $%    "        9($ ,     $  ,9($B $ $,;    =       $        $    ,      "

  ,      "   "

    " " $ % C"   ,$ "     !"  #$  " ,   "  

      " ,  =          , "    $  (7(9*('9             9( $  "   9:  ':77 "

   "   9($  $    !      ,$

 #>" $      ''()*('+  ,$    -&   .",   $  / 0" "

    %    4)((((<    !6(*

  # (7(9*('9 "          8F "      "  **.#/ -   "  $ ':7),   -& .",  $  /0" "



" ," ;    " 

94 #  " #':(7 , +)



))*)    4!&!

C 8

<  5H<3 C ( 5H<3