High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/29242/2018dismissed

Jagdeep Mittal v. Punjab & Haryana High Court

2018-12-17Mr. Justice Raj Shekhar Attri13 pages

VIMAL KUMAR 2018.12.19 10:29

!"#"$% &

'% ()'*+

!" #

+, $ %#"% % " #

& " %# " % # " # ' # () * " " # #" %" +

# " ##" % +

,# ! # % " % + #" # #

" " "%#"% !

# #% " % #% %%# "% - ## "

+ "% % # + + "+"%! # () # " # .

$- $ "

. $ /0+# 1234 0/.0$01$$ 22$ % "

3"+

4 # % 0$ .005 3 4% % + .006 7 # "% &

+ " ! # % "%+

89,"%#% #( % % % : "% #" + # 05 0;

.006 3 + "% "% # "% ! #% #( %%%

% 3 #

.00; "

9 " "# # "% "% + "% + "

! 3 + ## % - ! 9" % 0$ 0< .00; + " 9 "% %

3 9 %

! 4# 0$ .005 # "% + % .006 # " " "%+ "+"%05 0;

.006 # 9 + # "

+ ( "% = > " # # # #% "% + #" # +

" # "% 3 % #

+ 8;

, + +

"#"

> (" " "! " #% !

! 7

" "

" 3

# % + ! " "

% % % (" +#

"" %( %

"% #% # " ! # " " 3"

%# # " "% #% % # " % %

+ ! " "% "% " % # "% #" # '+ + , #

+ # + "% "% +

" ( ! 3%#"

+%+ "%+ #"+

#" #!# "

< ?%

" 7 % "

% "% # / 1 #% %% # " % @ / 1 # #

" " "% # @/ 1!

# # % "

,#"%! # % " " # #% %% # % + # # 7 % " "%" #!# #% %%# # # % ,"! "% #" %# + > # "% ! # % # #% %%

% % # + !"" ( + # #

" "%" #!# " % "% + #" %+ # + # +

9 " "% #"

$$ ?% "% " % #% %% "

" # #

7 % "

# !""#%

A%"%

" " # " # 7 ! ## #

" @ "

% # % ! % ! "% "

% 7 # ! ,

"% ! #

" # " # " ""

# #% 3 # " + 7#!"" # "

"%%

"% ! # % # " #

% %#% !"" $.

>! # " %% % " % ! " "% " !

# " " #" %! ""

# " "% ! "% #" + "

" "% + #" + +%+

" $= B + "% + "% + " " " # "

" %# + "% + "% +

% %+ "%% # "% % " # " ""

# :

C%4" % ' 0 4"$ $- +# / -0 " *"$6/ /.0$51 $= 6;= # % )## % ! "

## "% % "

% 7 % # "

$5 $2 #

(" # ! % % "% "! %! # " " #

!#% + " ) 3% % # !% %

#% "

% % %

3 "% (% # " " # #% # "% # # + ! % % #% +

% " " ## %% # #% 3"

% % 7

3" ! + % "% % % " "

3% ! " ! % % % " #! %% % #% , % " " # 3#"

! # % " + # # + + + ,,, + 9 $< .002 + 3 # "% $.

.002 - " # + "% $.

.002"% #"+ # 02 .002 $5 #!

#"%%"% # "%

" # #( % #% #

+ + + ## + "+" + "

9 " " "

9 % 3 # 9 + % + +#

# % ""

" "% " " " "

% " " "%( "#"

# "% ! " B

+ " % " " + "% " % + " ## ! + " #"

# " "

># % " $ $-. $ /0+# ' '

/#/ 234 0 /.0$61 D 5$. + "%

9 + 8- "%:" " ? $65#$<<=+ # 0;

$<<= 3"

% 4# $0 $<<;+ ! 9

3 "

% % # "% $<<="% 3"

%+"

$<<< 4 #% 4 # " + " "% " + ! % % #" # # " + " "

#C E % 3

+ "

%7 %E(

)5 "

" "

%# # """+

+ 3 9 + ) + % + " 9 %

39 " # + # "" + " " ! #!# "

3"%+) "%+ " " ! #!# "

% #" + # %% % # + ! %% "" "% 4 " # % 3 + # "

9 " "

% # "%

39 " A%C%?

#/$<<515$=;@ ,F -/.00;1$6 620@ A # , 9 C /.0$$1 $= $=$@ # ?C%9 /$<<51555;@9, C /.00D1<6D$ "/1 > " # " + ! " "

% G A # , /$<;<1 5 52; " /1 +

" " % % " #"

# "# 9 " $<<= "% + "% # .006 + "

# "% 4"" " " +"%

( % #"%

;

37 + "#

#" " $. # % +@+ "% .006! #(

% +## " " "% ! $<<= ! # "% "

39 "/1 , " % "

.000" " #"% + "%"# ! "

% # "% "%# " " "

# 7 "% "% #"%"# "

% 3 " + % 9+ A #, /.0$$15.0< 3 + % " "

%" " .006 "% ! # ( %

3 " " $5 0.

.006 % !(" !" ! "

!##"

+ "" " # $<<= 3% " .006"%! #( % #"%

9 .0$5 "% % + " ! ! "% ! # "%

3 % " "% #" ! "%

, + " " "% " % 9 # " # " " ! +## % < > + 4#% " # #% % # # " % ! +# % # " "7" " #"%

3 % # = . # $<<= "% + " " # "% ## % 9 % ###

# % "" # #% % # % # "

#! % % " , + " "% " 9 4 + % + "

" " # # "% "% + " + ! %# # % "" > % + # B

9" " #

20"#/$ 234 0"+#*

$ . /0#.0$./.1 5D= 3% #

#" # B

9" +# "% " # !

9"! + " " H % " , % + # + % 3"! #

% + $$ , %% " C%4"+ ! B

9" "+ ! "/1 7 " " " # %" "#"% +! ! 9 .0$5 + "

! "

# " " % % + " " #%$<<= .0$5 9 " " # G!%

.D $.

.0$2+

+ + G!% 7 "

.< 0= .0$D , +

" "

! ""!

3# %"

# ! + " #"

3 #"

# " % # " + # #" ! 3 # #

" " % # =0 .0$2 #6;

% # ( ! " G!% # " =0 .0$6+ "+ # % + ( ! "6; # #

=0 .0$D ==# E % / #! "1 $<D= 3G!% # - #B "" " " ) "

.D $.

.0$2 " ## "'## " + ( #%6; 20/G 9120 2. /G -1 # ( # "% +

% ( " 3

4 # + ! ( # 6<

=0 .0$;

3 G!% "

.D $.

.0$2 0D 0= .0$D %! # #"% "# #% %% A#

4 # # ( 0D 0= .0$D# ! #=. ! + # +" 3+ #

" 9 ## # 0D 0= .0$D +

G!% "

.D $.

.0$2+

$= > # #

# $2 0= .0$D# # #% +#" # " " # + + # % % # =0 #% 9 + " & " +

0$ 0< .0$D# # 4 # "%

/ % 1 $.

0< .0$D 3 / % 1# " %

? %

# 4 - % " %%

#" 3 %

+ %%

.< $$ .0$D" # "#

"%%

" ! "% " "% +( "

.D $.

.0$2+ + .< 0= .0$D >" # #

4 # " 0< 0$ .0$; + %7

&+" ! % #

0= .0$; + " + % 4 # " - % %%

#" "" %

+ #

/ % 1 # ? + "

"% # + # 4 %%

0= 0;

.0$;

3%%

(% ""%%

" ! "% #% .< "" # G G B G, F! E"% #% + # $5

7 "

" +#

# "

..2#

#, B

9""

" # " "! % 3 "" 0D 0= .0$2 + 4 # " " .D $.

.0$2# % #

4 "+"! " "

!# #"

+ + + + G!% # " +

$6 ,! " #

# "

! + + " % ! "

%""

,%! + + "+ % # # " %# # !

7 # 9

FF #% A ! @- % F+#%G!% F+

% " # F+ FF #% C A ! "% "" 3

# + # " %

% % % 3# " # "

# " " % % " % " " ! " %

$2 3- % " %%

7 #"%

+ + + " " % ! #( #% 3 # +#" %% !

#" "

$D 7

% $;

+! 7 + " # #" " " "% "#+ #

8+9 % ! " # $" #