← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2216/2014dismissed

Cholamandalam Ms General Insurance Company Ltd v. Afsana & ORS

2025-12-23Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma13 pages

 



    

 

  

 !"#$%&'((

)*$+,- -$%&.((

)*$+/01$)#-%2&((

334 34

   3( ((((((0011)%* 5 ( 4

4( ((((((  0$%#%*

&  63 4( 4 4 4  

         



    ! "#

 4  ( '' 

"

$    %& '  "()*   

 )

 + ,  

-

'   ,    , .  / 



*

!  

 #

0  /+          

      ,       

  ,     .

&

1                      

 .       ,      

  . )

$

 )

 +,    

 

  

 "



+      ,   . ,  , ! "#  

-

$     , ,      +  .

 ""

"2 -2"* ,          $,   !

 3     4 $, 45.,   6! "#. .

    -(7)2226 +.8(9  

  .

 ,

  +    .

+

*

$    ,      ,     ,

! "#6, 6   +  .

  ""

"2 -2"*    %"))  "(::,      $, !

    +       -(7)2226 +.8(9  



      /     27 2* -2"-

#

           ;

        .

  ,      $,         ;

 ,   / ,

44 4



434

 4 & '         

, ' $,  .+ /     ":2226 .

 <     + +  =      .

,  $, +

$ 

   , .     ,    .

)

      6 ,     ,  $,  . ,  $ 

       ,   ,  .       ,      ,    .

         .  

4337  4 :

=>,%    



      

      . .             ?

 

    

      

                        



   

      

   

   

  



 

     



                   



 

    !"#$       

  %#  !"&$      

    &    '        !"($    

   

 



  )    

            

                       *       (+,         







      

-  

    

         

    

    $       

       .   /

    

   

          

                 *  

 

              



  

            

    

     

            (+,          

   (+,

                   



  

                                           

 

                )             

 

    &$  

          0

   1      $     

 !2    !(%+ %! %(

 $ 

     

 

3!4%'#+

 3!'#!#(

 3!( #'&+

 3!&&!&(

  3!# &'(+

   

     

  3!!(!((

 35(''+

 34'!'(

  3(''4+

 (

=>,  %             !  " #$%  &$

'( 89 4 ':    . %"))")* "):  "(:: .+  35 @          +  <     A

 3B5 %       +    +    A +  ,    + A 3@5

 , +             < . A 3C5     +     +.  ,A   <

"2

$  

+ 

 ?)  6       #*     

   



   

    7/

8  *      %(+++   

7 !+++++   

        7  !+++++   

        

    

     

   

     

        7/

 0  9 

 



        



             

  



  

     :       

       6

                    

     



 



    

   

  

  

     

; 

 



      

   

     

     

 

   



                 

    

*

    



      

 



 



        

  

!(+++7 &++++ 7 !(+++

            

   <     



   

  )          

    

 

 

   

   

     !+,   

 )

  

 



 

 



  = = = = )

)     

    (+,            

   

      

    

 /   

 &+

     

 #+,   



 

&+(+

 * 





 

 (+'+

  

 !(,6     

  

 ) * 









 $                 &+,    

 

  



    &+

 6  %(, 

  

 &+(+

  !+,



  

 (+'+



   





 

 

     ) ).      

       



        

#+    #%    0  > ?       



    )   



           

       0> @  &%/

 ) +   

  

     ) ,7   

       

   

  

   

         

 7 !(+++7 &++++    7   !(+++  

      

    

  !+,

 

 A ""

=>,%    -./ " #$%  ! 0  

0'

(  1 , ,

2 +   

&$

   .+ + 

         B 6  <

  C 

8       

      

;



   

  *   

  D  D        

  



 D     D

  D    D     D   D              

           

  

 

  

  



  )

 

 

   

 

%!! # 

 

   

            

   





D       

        /  D %!%&# 

       

   

 D     

   

    

 

   D %!#3 # 

  



  

 

    6 

     

 

      

    

  

    

    

               

 

                   

  

  

 

    

         3  /      

 

   E

  

   

   

    3 /     

      

      

 

        

     

 

  

        

       3  >  

 6       

     

     

  

 

  

*

                   

              C     

         

      

   

    6 6      

    

       



 

     

    

  

      

   

     

   

      D

 

 D   C  0 8* 





 

 

    

    &++++ 

  "-

$     . , 3D0BE ""- -2"&5   "*

         .

           

/.

 ,-#      .

 ,      $,  +  +   /

-#  

 "#

1    ,    .

 ,./+    .

  , + -&2226 $     6,  <   1 3F#5 +$ %

 / C   $ 

+ .     %

 /

C   $  +    

 +G   !

+  + / =       C< "- 1") C< #..  8 ":2226  ;

 ' $,  +      ":2226,  + C<  #3%    "- 1")5 "&

    .

.   $,            + +     .

      C    + 

     . $   .

;

 +  

 3 4 ")

.  . ., =>,% 

 , 

+, 

)11$;# %,   . 

 +   + #- <- # $ .

  ""

"2 -2"*      +

 $  

 , 6            4!($( )# $<0% )*-$%;)!## "

 

":2226 -  8#29

7-2263#29 ":2225 * @   .

   < "6#

)*2263"6# -&-225 # $ 

":(2263-&-22)*225 &

 ":

) 

@

#2:-#226 3":(22D"-D":5 ' C 

":"&26 :

 C<

":"&26 ( '    1 #:#22D- % #:#22D"

 #:#22D"

"(*)226 "2 $*)1 $<0% )*-$%

(.==.> ""

<$/%*;)!##?@*A !-?/%)1

(B=9=> "- %A)%,#)<$/%*

(.=.=.>.==. B=9=

"7

%                     ,

=>,%    .

4

56  $ .

   7

+  0  (    !    )   

+       8(9      +     H 

":

$                      +.3< +  

 2)

 +, 5.

 $, .  .      

+ $$, ,   , 6  , /            .

     ""

"2 -2"*  $   0, 6    , /    $,

"(

!    

           +     .  +  .

 ""

"2 -2"*

-2

+  35    

 4 4 

  .((



F /+6  I6! F , I6!