The Hoshiarpur Distt. Cooperative Labour Construction Union Ltd v. State Of Punjab & Others
!"
$#! # %& '" ( ()( (&#* + , "
# # "(- ' (*#
+
./!" 0!& '" 1( #2&#* + , "
# # "(- ' (*#
+ +30 45&3+6)678)3+3&
45&3+6)+3+6 (# 3 "(5 ( .9*%$ #9
3 + - (* :2 .9**.:9"(- ' 3 ,
(;. 9*%$ #9
!(*(#< ===
52> 2 #
$//( * 9
*#>> ' (;*
! * 9 $//(?" $# (%.%*# (
3"( ! . ! # (9 !" @ !(*(#<A
"* 0#(* (# $&:3+B
0B< * #*
@((C" 0A> #$ # (# / (*$(* @((C" 0 A9 (;'
DD
> E !# > (# #* (> E >( # . # < #(# $9 ; * (>#"'>.. 0' (; / #*$ # > E >
9
B0 $ #> E9> $
.
# (# !". #* /"(#
B0 ! (#
$ # (* #*
@((C" 0<A
"*'2 !(*(# 9"( ..*> E
(2 /"(# (* ..*> E $ (;"!#
B0> #';
%( ##& '" (*! # %$ ($ 9#$ >".*' "( '.#;
%#(* #*> E "(* # (; # 9 (# # %(#" .
#29 ;## (; # > E *(9 !( #(* / # (# $# (*$ *#'$ ..*#> " # /(# (* (!
#
(#
$ # (# # (##(* ..*> E $ (;"!#
B09> $> ..'
"*% *0(* (;2 #/9#$/!#
.. (.2 ' / * '#>( #& '" (* ! # % ( $ < #
#$ #!# # ##2> "..2.
'. (* ?" .
* ..#/(# > E >( # . #< #(# $9 '"#( $$"(# $(* (@>A *'2# "# % ((C" 0 9#2$".*(# !!.2 ##(* ! #
(9
#> / *$/!".
2'2# "# # ## ;($2 !!.2 #(* /"
# % # ..*/ /"/#>#"'>..> (.
#(2
$(* (> '
# 2 (* ..; .'$ "
$## #*"
(;#.
'"# 9(( #*! #/(# ## # "(- ' * ..##* (2 "$> E ( 0' #"'>..# (2 #& '"
(*! #
$# !" "$9 > (#!
'. #;
( (2C! ($ # ..
(;
0<0 /"/#>#"'>..> (.
#(2 $$ * (;##!# #
(> *-"
##* ## ;# (*.
'
#!# (* "$.
E# $ %(# >
9#
$(* ( @>A > *
( # 29 '$ "
3"( ! . ! # (9 6 . (* 9> .
"
(;0#(* (# $* #*
D9 /(**% $ ;(*"/* #*
D @((C" 0 A9 (;#(*
. > E9* *(# (2 "$$(* % # ..*#> #"'>.. (#! % "
($9 #> (#"(* # (* '. #>2
"$$(* (> *'2 !(*(#< ($9$(* (@>A
..; . (* '
# 29# 9
.
'.#' # "$E*>(+ !(*(# < * .
.
#*#(* (#2
D9
(;$(* @>A9 ;
#> $#!# * ! (#*## "#
> # # ?" # (# # "$ $(* ( "!( # & '" (* ! # 9'"#(*> !
*## /'2 !(*(#<9( (2 !.2> ;
%(
52> 2 #! (#> 9#!# % ";#
" ($ > $ # ?"
(;$(* (@>A (((C" 0
$ $". #* .(;> #0#(* (# $* #*
@((C" 0A " # ! 2 '(/ *#
" > / (* /"
* $# (;# !(*(# #! / ##//' ## ( )( # !!.2 (* $(
* #'
#> E . # (;#' #"'>.."(* > E
. #< D )!((# $9 !(*(#< ( !.2 "'/ ##*# ## > .# " (*$ 2 /(;#!"'.
$ #"'>.. (*
"!!.2 > # (#$ #2"
9#;##> E*( /#C! ($*
(* 9 $(* ( @>A # # # ;($2 !!.2 (; '
* /"
# %
# ..* / /"/ #> #"' >..
> ( .
# ( 2 9 > / * $/!".
2 ($#!# *(C! ($ # ..
(;#"'>..9 > $> E
#$( $ . (( #" ?"
... '" 9# 9 # > E $".*(# %'( ..##*##/ 5 ! $* " # 9$(* ( @EA (*@>A> $ .% (# (*($
2#'! "
*9> $ * "(* 0
!
"### $
"###
% &'
&( &
"###
(
%
) &
) & % ( & (
( &( * &+
,
'
$ ,
&%
-
% % $
& %
.
& (*$"( . $(#(**# #
($# :% (/(# "(- ' (2 "'
2* *(# ..# (2> E
( ' #"'>..*"
(;#.
# '"# # (2
#& '" (*! #
$# !" 9 # 9 ( C! ($ $ #
$ # $".* % '( " (
* '2 # !# ($/!.
($> #$(* (@>A " # $(#(**# #
0D0 #
(@>A> ..; . (* '
# 29 (% > $# # #3"( ! . ! # (96 . (* 9% *0#(* * #*
D9
/(**% *$ ;(*"/* #*
D@((C" 0 A9 * #* #(* #
. > E9 > #"#
(; (2 "$ $(* ( 3"( ! . ! # (9 !" @ !(*(# <A (* 3"( ! .
! # (9 6 . (* 9 # # # ; ( "
9 #2 $ ((# $# '
.2 (* %# $# ($( ( ($> # $# & (*$"( .
"'/ ##*# # # #!# >
F#< F.
# (# # #> $#> E '( ..##*##!
% #$(# $# "
!(*(# '* $#*#$ ($.# ..#/(# #> E ##!
% # $(# $# (*# 0 ###(* '2*.# (;# '
# 2$(* @>A ( # # (*9 . (* $"( . # !(*(#
"'/ ##*# #
($#!# *(C! ($ ..#
# ..B 0' #"'>..9> $
#$( $ .> E9# 9#2> (# .
'. ..#/(# "$> E # ;
% (; " #";# ". $(
* # ( # # % .
$(#(# . (*$"( . #! # 9>*(#
(* (2/ '## !# 9'$ "
#/ ## (*
!"#
$(# $#" . (( #" !C" # (
.*# #> . (%E (;!> -"* . % > / ## ##(* > * $(# $# 9$ # ( #" ".* '' ( (/ (*# #% ." # #(* (* > * $(# $#
(# ..2$// $ "($# (*!
($ !. ?"
#2 (*( #" .-"
$
# 2 # *
# ($ ( "$/ ## > -"* . % >> ..(#'
00
(%E*#! #$#!
% # (# # ##$ !"'.
$ (# #9 #*$ $(# $#" .*
!"# (* $(# $# > # ;
% ($$ ( .> 2
E* / ; ( $ % .$" #$" # ".*C $
-"* . (# "(.
..; .
#2 '
(
(#! # #:% (/(# (# / ##
!! (#%(# >
9
($#> E (B 0' (;
#"'>.. ?"
..9# 9 (" !
(9 ..#/(#
"$> E# ( (C! ($ ;($2>".*$ "
($(%( ($## ;( . !"'.
$# (; '(' ";#( $ *'2#!#
> (;# ## # ;
%('2#/> .
# (# # #> $# > E % '( ..##* # # !
% # $(# $# 9 #
;"/(#9 % (;( $9
#" (**>( (% >
* ##.*! !
. >9 (* $ ** '%9(; "(* (# ($'2#
" #"(* # $.
B
#( #"# (*
/ *"#( ?"(#.29
(* (;(/ (# > 9# / '2*
* !
$#' 9
" #!
(*- # ! E (;B (* 7 B # +! # '. 7 B