← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/29277/2018allowed

Jaswant Singh v. Haryana Warehousing Corporation Bay No. 15-18 Sector-2 Panchkula And ORS

2020-03-03Mr. Justice B.S. Walia4 pages

  



      

 !" #"$%&%'())  &* '!+%',- ."!%!%'"/ 0"/&1&

/2 '  /"-1&%', /3/ !%'4 '$-516  ."&3'#"'!&  

   /"&"'!( 7/ 5"&- ,3 64#8$ !" /!-"3"!%!%'"/ 7/ # 95 '!*%8"#%4#8$ !" //"&3'#"'!& !) :::     < / 2"/%'!-"3"!%!%'1'#"//!%$6"=> !-" '&!%!1!%'   '#%  %& / !-" %&&1 '$"    /%!  "/!%/ /% / ?1 &-%', /#"/4 ''"@1/">A# !"#  >)   33%'!%',/"&3'#"'! &

'?1%/2

%$"/!$'#1$!"'?1%/2%'$- /,"B&-""!# !"#  ;< /%"

$!& !-"$ &"6" #%',!!-" %6%', !-"*/%!3"!%!%' /"!- !' 43"!%!%'"/* &%&&1"#$- /,"B&-""!4''"@1/"> -%& - 8%', $ 1&"#  6&&   &=)4>B ! !-" /3/ !%'  -" "'?1%/2 /"&16!"#%'/#"/4''"@1/"> # !"# #%&9%&&%',!-"3"!%!%'"/

/9 &"/8%$"   !-" /3/ !%' *-"/" & !-" $B$- /,"# #"6%'?1"'!& *- *"/"&%9%6 /62&%!1 !"# &!-"3"!%!%'"/*"/"%93&"#31'%&-9"'! #*'B ,/ #%',    & & 6& *%!--6#%',   '" ''1 6 %'$/"9"'! *%!- $1916 !%8""

"$!/"&3"$!%8"62 -"3"!%!%'"/ %6"#$%8%6&1%! =# !"#

A  / #"$6 / !%' '# 9 '# !/2 %'C1'$!%' $- 66"',%', !-" 31'%&-9"'!/#"/ -"&1%!* &3 /!62#"$/""#%' 81/ !-"3"!%!%'"/

;< 8%#"C1#,9"'! '##"$/""4''"@1/"># !"#)

)3"/ !%8"3 /!  !-"& 9"%&/"3/#1$"# &1'#"/(B  



  

             

  



   

  

                     !  

 "#   $

             

       

       

       

          



        #  

           

                 

#   

    

 

     

      



            





                  % 

    &  '  (  '  ) 

 



               

 

         %

*      + ;)< -" /"9"'!%'"#C1#,9"'! '##"$/""# !"#)

)* & $- 66"',"# D2 !-" 3"!%!%'"/ & *"66 & !-" /"&3'#"'!&  *"8"/4 D!- 33" 6&*"/"#%&9%&&"# '#!-"C1#,9"'! '##"$/""# !"#''"@1/">4 # !"#)

)* &13-"6#D2!-"6" /'"###%!%' 6%&!/%$!1#,"4+%/&  & *"66 & D2 !-%& 1/! 8%#" C1#,9"'! '# #"$/"" ''"@1/" >) # !"#



 '#''"@1/"># !"#  ;< +-/! /,19"'! 6" /'"#$1'&"6 /!-"3"!%!%'"/%&!- !'$" !-"C1#,9"'! '##"$/""4''"@1/"># !"#)

)3"/9%!!"#$'#1$!  /"&-#"3 /!9"'! 6"'?1%/2!D"$'$61#"#*%!-%'!-/""9'!-& /9!-" # !" 3 &&%', !-"#"$/"" %6%',*-%$-!-"3"!%!%'"/*16#D""'!%!6"#! ,"! 66&"/8%$"&D"'"

%!&D2%93&%',!-"& 9"31'%&-9"'! & * /#"#!!-"

;)< $B"9362""& ' 9"62 - 66"  9 '# - /&%  9 '# !-" & %# 3"/%# - 8%', "@3%/"# '# "'?1%/2 '! - 8%', D""' $99"'$"#4 D"&%#"&4 !-" 3"!%!%'"/ - 8%', D""' /"6" &"# !-" &"/8%$" D"'" %!& !"/ %93&%', 31'%&-9"'! & * /#"# ! !-"/ $B"9362""& ' 9"62 - 66"  9 '#

- /&%  94 !-" 33%'!9"'!   "'?1%/2 

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

)3 &&"#D2!-"6" /'"###6 %8%61#,"+/%8+%/& * & 13-"6#D2!-%& 1/!*%!-1! '29#% %$ !%'*- !&"8"/ -"C1#,9"'! '# #"$/""4 ''"@1/" > # !"# )

) ,/ '!"# 6%D"/!2 ! !-" /"&3'#"'!& ! $'#1$!  /"&- #"3 /!9"'! 6 "'?1%/2 *%!-!-" /%#"/!- !%

/"&-#"3 /!9"'! 6"'?1%/2* &%'%!% !"#!-"'!-"& 9"* &!D"$'$61#"# *%!-%'!-/""9'!-& /9!-"# !" 3 &&%', !-"#"$/""4!-"/*%&"4!-" 3"!%!%'"/* &"'!%!6"#!,"! 66&"/8%$"D"'" %!&D2%93&%',31'%&-9"'! & * /#"# ! !-"/ $B"9362""& ' 9"62 - 66"  9 '# - /&%  9  ' !-"/ */#&4 #"$%&%' ! $'#1$!  /"&- "'?1%/2 & *"66 & $'#1$!  "'?1%/2* &!D"*%!-%'!-"!%9" / 9" !-/""9'!-& /9!-"# !"

;< 3 &&%', !-"#"$/"" -"& 9"* &'!#'"*%!-%'!-"&!%316 !"#3"/%# !%9"'&!" # $'#1$!%',"'?1%/2*%!-%'!-"&!%316 !"#3"/%# !%9"4!-" /"&3'#"'!&%93&"#31'%&-9"'!'!-"3"!%!%'"/ & * /#"#!!-"/$B "9362""& ' 9"62 - 66"  9 '# - /&%  9 & 3"/ !-" C1#,9"'! '# #"$/""4''"@1/"># !"#)

) '#/"6" &"# 66&"/8%$"D"'"

%!&! !-"3"!%!%'"/ &3"/-%&"'!%!6"9"'! ;< -" "'?1%/2 $16# '! - 8" D""' $'#1$!"#     !-" C1#,9"'! '# #"$/""4 ''"@1/" > # !"# )

) *-%$- - # !! %'"#

%' 6%!2 '# ! *-%$- C1#,9"'! '# #"$/""4 !-"/" * & ' 9#% %$ !%' '&!" # $'#1$!%',!-""'?1%/2*%!-%'!-"&!%316 !"#3"/%# !%9"4!-" 3"!%!%'"/* &%93&"#31'%&-9"'! &* & * /#"#!!-"/$B"9362""& ' 9"62- 66" 9 '# - /&% 9%' $$/# '$"*%!-!-"C1#,9"'! '# #"$/""4 ''"@1/" > # !"# )

) '# -" * & /"6" &"# 66 &"/8%$" D"'"

%!& &3"/"'!%!6"9"'!'!-"$%/$19&! '$"&4!-"36"  !-"/"&3'#"'!& !- ! ' '?1%/2

%$"/* & 33%'!"#*%!-%'!-/""9'!-& /9!-"# !" #%&9%&& 6 +%&*%!-1! '29"/%! <  ' 8%"*   !-" 3&%!%' & '!"# D8"4 !-" */%! 3"!%!%' %& 66*"# '#%931,'"#/#"/4''"@1/">A# !"#  >)  %& ?1 &-"# + 6%  1#," )) 9%! -"!-"/&3" 5%',>/" &'"#( "&> -"!-"//"3/! D6"( "&>