Union Of India And Others v. Central Administrative Tribunal And Others
!
"#$$%&'&()*
(&((+&" ,'
$(#,"-+.&(&'#,"#&/$,&01("-23"(+&4",3$(%3 ,'
!
67 77 "-,"86&(43 ,'
$(#,"-+.&(&'#,"#&/$,&01("-23"(+&4",3$(%3 ,' )* 9: 666 9: 66 ;6
!
"#$ % #$
#$ &
' (
)))
6 ;62 * %+,, + $++ -.- .-(
*
% #+ *%
/* *% 0 1
2345( .-( % %6 7, 1
%8 -'-3- .-( % %
%889*$8 , + .4.3 .-! *5 +8 :;$ :8 :8$ : 8 $$ .- -& .-!-'< , -!. .-! *7 $ # :8 % +
8 -.- .-(
*
%**% %,8<8#
$
<# % !' %888 ,
$6<7 , $ $$
;8 8$8$ $ # :8 = > $$ $ %8> +12 -'-3- .-( * $ +; $ 2!'
$ <# ?
7
77 $" ,+8 + $ @ :8 7? @ :8 !' %888 ,
$8 $ %89* $8 , + # :8
+ !' # :8 %8
% A,,$ 8# :8
+ :;$ :8.4.3 .-! # '
:8 $ $ +8 % 88$+ !'* , %
-!. .-! #& $ # :8
+:;$ :8 ,% , , !' B 2 !
' <8#
$% *% $+88
; % %
8$6
$ # :8 %$ 8$+
+;8 :;$ :8 + * *% $ + +
8 -.- .-( - $+ % 8 $ C$
D
;8 $ # :8 -!. .-! *7 ,8
$
+ :;$ :8 .4.3 .-! *5 , -!. .-! * A$ , E$ 6 7 ,
%88 8 $++8
$ C$
D$%
, 4' #++ ..- ,%
$ C$
D , 87
%$*% ,8
@ 8+ %A0%
$ C "4,"8
"(+#3$,'=' (&((+&""(+#3$,'2
!6
E % %+AF%
$ C",("&- 6&(43"(+#3$,'=':"%33.&","&(1>#""(+#3$,'2
!6 7D $ "4,"8?'%"'$$8 # $$B % ,8%$>, * , % $ 7 , 0 @ 8+ 8 *% + %%, "4,"8?'%"'$ '1>,"
8 , <$$ 2 !'
$<# %888 %+ *% 8 $$?
8+ %AF%
+ "4,"8?'%"'$ '1>,"
,$$8$, $% + ;$ $ ;$ $ C$
D,%
$% $ ++
8 C$6 D ;8 , %88 8
$$ $ % B % B
9* % ,%% +8 $ %; A
%+ $8?
+%88 + 88 $++ 8$ 1 $
$$
" $8
, %
$ 8 AF%
$
"4,"89' '1>,"
!
"
#
!
#
$$%
#&
#
" '
%() "
" * '
+ &
#&
#
,
#
' - '
- . # / '
%()
!
"
"
"
1*
1 ,
# *
!
"
!
#
!
#&2#
0 *
!
#
" !
"
$$% , #
#
* '
%() *
#3
& # '#
44% & 5 '6
7((( &
5 '#
7(((
&
5 '6
7(( @ =+ $ ,%8 + :;$ :8 88% %88$+ !' , % $ $ @ :8 ,;8 % $ 6 % B + 2 !'%888$ # :8,% $% E # :8 % $ $
,$ %,8 2 !'*
$ $6
$ %8, 4' ++ $+ % +
$ $ 8% $ , % ,8
$ , "4,"89' '1>,"!*A0%
$ "4,"8?' '1>,"!,$
84' +++ $$ ; $ $+ 8 +8GB $ GG%$>, GG
$$G% +>8 + $ ?
8+ % "$ AF%
+ ",("&-6&(43?'%"'$'1>,"A0%
$ $ "4","89' '1>,"!; B +$$B % ,8B
$ $ *% $+
$$= > $$ 8 -5 @80 ?
8+ $ A8
9 3 # &
# *
'
'
: ;
$ $7
!
" " #$$% ***< =***,
9 3
3
*
'>
& , - & ? @- #
9
+ 7((87 #&& # (%
7
"
&" '
(
" !
"
:+
* 8 *% , $ $, $ AF%
* 8 + E 28?0 ?
8+
% H + $$8@80 $ $$ ?$ #+6 7$ + $ $ $ $,#$-( !# 8$$B % ,8B $
9* 8$+ % + $8
$ $6
* *% 8B >8$
+ , %88 ,$$$ 6<7
C$$
D ;8 $
# :8 + , + # :8 %88% H 2 !',, % $ $ @ :8 $ +#;
#-
@ :8 .5.! .-- 7 , % $ , %%+&'.&''$+8
$
+ 66!
6 ;6!
$0,1",C
2