← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3960/2017dismissed

M/S Krishna Cable Tv Network & ORS. v. Union Of India & ORS.

2018-03-28Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Lok Adalat Bench - 310 pages



    

   

 

!""#$%&%'( )*+ '

"

"!,"!' %

- &%

.

/!! !,""!,' %

- -0 1234-5/5&6-*15/ 1234-5/&1517  %!'  ., "$ '

"*,89"'%*

' %:%''!%

 .

"# 7%$*,89"'%*

' % :!,%!'

 ;;;

   :%''!  "

 #%%!  $%,   <."

!=  "!    ,"'%,

>?!!%@.

%0A*"::!'!=",B.,9"'!=".'  '% ',%9,% ' % (9".

%!'9%

.%,'9"#$%:% "'

%="

,!=' % $"#$'C' :"C 89%'"@"!,"! ,"'%, 

?!!%@.

%0DA

 %:%''!%

"

%9"#$%:% "'

9"

C!=!#.

!%

9"#$% 89% "'+ '

"

 % :!,%!'

"

%' %/!! !,"*%!'

"$ 3"

, @9 %"!,.

'+ "!,'(

9"$ ' %%!'

%E % 89%"@,%:"

'+%!'   %  :%''!%

 (% %  !'  %= %,  ('  ' %  % 89%  "@ ,%:"

'+%!',.

!=' %:% ,

+ 

'

 %C(%

:

8,!=9"#$% 89% '8"

.

9!

.+%

.

!=' %".,' 

"

'("C "!

+

!8'4',*4., "!"?

'*F "

'("C2A*' %

:!,%!'

.!,' "' "

'("C("

"9'!="

.$'0 '%+:% "'

"!, %9%8!='

"

% .# :'!"+.!'

+' %9"#$%:% "'

(  (% %:

8,!=9"#$% 89% '' %9!

.+%

 (9".

%!'9% (%

.%,'' %:%''!%

"$$%=!=' "'' %C(% %:

8,!='"@"#$% 89%

#.'(% %!%' % %= %,(' ' %,%:"

'+%!'!  ",:",' % 89%'"@ !  :.

."!9%  '  ' %  (  9".

%  !'9% *  ' %    ,"'%,  

?!!%@.

%0DA("

:"

%,#C :!,%!'D*%%:.'C++

!% * %!'

%E% 89%"@++

!% "'%* "!,="

,%+"!,("

"

%,( 9 !9$.,%, 89%'"@*!'% '"!,:%!"$'C D  %:

%!'( ':%''! "

#%%! $%, "

!='(

.% G ?A' "'' % ,"'%,

>?!!%@.

%A "::!'!=  :!,%!'  D  "

 "!  ",B.,9"'!= ".'  'C   #",*  "

 #C  !'

9"'!  ,"'%,   D

*  !$C  ++

!%

   %!'

"$ @9 %(% %=8%!' %:(%

%!'



9%

    "  .$'    ,"'%,  

?!!%@.

%  0DA   (' .'  B.

,9'!*  "8!= #%%!:"

%,#C' %%:.'C++

!% G"!, ?A' "'' % ,"'%,

>?!!%@.

%A

9!'

",9' C'' %3 9.$"

,"'%, 

    ,"'%,  

> ?!!%@.

%  0A  "::!'

 8"

.

 

9%

",B.,9"'!=  +$"

 !'9%

.%,  '  8"

.

!'9%% *( % %"

"

:% ' % 9.$"

*' .$,#%

00 ,%9,%, #C!%",B.,9"'!= ".'  'C(  ", 9+:%'%!9%  '  ,%9,%  ' %  9"

%  !8$8!=  ' % = % '"+.!' ,.'C >  .= ' %+:.=!%, ,"'%, 

?!!%@.

%0DA

"::%"$"#$%*(%%!'% '"!%,'

:%''!"

"<.% '! B.

,9'!

"

%,

 %:%''!%

2 %$"!9%!"!'

9"'!,"'%,  D

' 9!'%!,' "'!$C++

!%

%!'

% "8%#%%!9!

%, :(% .!,% %9'! ' %!"!9%9'* D?

'*F' %9'2A

!'(%$$ .!,%,  %9'! ' %9'*-.$% ' %% 89%"@-.$% * D ?

'*  F' %  -.$% 2A*  !'

9"'!     

>0% 89%  "@  ,"'%, 

>"!,!'

9"'! 

0% 89%"@,"'%,  D



%","

.!,% 0 ?A 

   

     

           



                  

     

  

       

   

  

        !"#$%&'

!"#$(  

  

 ) *   +               

 ,     

 

0D0

         

 

  -  

      .   

  

 

  

              

       

  



  + ?3A   

!"#$ %

/  

           

 0$  1   !""'%$2 !""'(           

  

             

     %2( ,    

  

     %$(  

  ,         



     . 

 1       + ,  

&'$(



    "  $   &') #           



?A ?

A ?A ?A 

'"!'  ++

!%  

%!'

"$  @9 %    %:.'C ++

!%    %!'

"$ @9 '%@9%%,!=- >$")

?

A 5!'++

!% %!'

"$ @9 #8%  -   >  $")  #.'  !'

%@9%%,!=- 

$")

?A ,,'!"$  ++

!%  

%!'

#8%  -  

 $")  #.'  !'

%@9%%,!=- > $")

?DA ++

!%    %!'

"$ @9 ' .'$+'

0>0 3              

 

           



  .  

  1               

      -    

   

 



       

 



 

 + 2+ ,

 

      



  

 ) * + 1+4+$'!5$!5266&7,   89   ) /

?A   %*

+!"#$ %,

-

+ )+9+ +%(7/

      0$  1   !""'%$2 !""'(   

 $    9  , 

 !""'      

 

             

     %2( ,     

    

  

      %$(  

,  



  

   

  

    %'(    %&(     

  ,    +

,  

&'$ (

 &'$ (

  . $ /  ?A ?

A ?A ?DA ?>A  $$ ' % ++

!%

%!'

 %  ++

!%

%!'

 .= .'

' %  '%

' !,"

!8% '="'!

"!, ",B.,9"'!

.9 9"

*"

+"C #%  "

=!%, #C' %3"

,

 % ++

!%

%!'

?,B.,9"'!A  %  ++

!%

%!'

 .= .'

' %  '%

' !,"

!8% '="'!

"!, ",B.,9"'!

.9 9"

*"

+"C #%  "

=!%, #C' %3"

, :1+4+!$;5#65266;7 <+'= 

( 89   ) /

  %:(%

",B.,9"'! "8%#%%!=8%!.!,% %9'! ' %9''' %%!'

%

9%

 %:(% 9!

%,#C' % %!'

"$3"

, @9 %"!,.

'+ #C"!'

9"'! :% -.$%' % 3"

,+"C"::!'' %%!'

%

9%

"!,"$ "

=!' %$9"$ $+'

"!, :%9 C' %'"@"#$% 89% !%@% % :(% 9!

%,.!,%

%9'! ' %9'*' %3"

,

.%,' %!'

9"'!,"'%, 

> 

'"!'  ++

!% *  %:.'C  ++

!% *  5!'  ++

!% * ,,'!"$  ++

!%  "!,  ++

!%    %!'

"$  @9 %  (% "::!'%,"

%!'

%

9%

"!,' % +!%'"

C$+'

:.

: ",B.,9"'!(% % @%,!9$.+!?A ' %!'

9"'!   %"

=.+%!' ' %:%''!%

 $%$C %$C!=!!'

9"'!

00 ,"'%,    D

   + :$"9%,   %  !'

9"'!  

   !'  !

.:%

! ' %%"

$% !'

9"'! %'(!'

9"'!

:% "'%

,

%!':.

:  %!'

9"'!

>"::!'

8"

.

9%

"

%!'

"$ @9 %

9%

"!, :%9 ' %+!%'"

CB.

,9'!  ' % :.

: %    ",B.,9"'!*  ( % %"

 .!,%  ' % 

  !'

9"'!*  ' % ++

!%

%!'

% "8%#%%!"::!'%,"

' %%!'



9%

 =8!=  ' %+  B.

,9'!  '

.= .'  !,"*  !$C   9"

 

!8% '="'!"!,",B.,9"'!( 9 "

%"

=!%,#C' %3"

, :% ' %

>!'

9"'!*"$$' %

9%

 "8!=,% =!"'!

+%!'!%,' % %!

"8%#%%!"::!'%,"

%!'

%

9%

 %9!'%!'! "

%,#C$%"

!%,9.!

%$ ' %:%''!%

' "'

' % ,"'%, 

?!!%@.

%0DA:"

%,#C :!,%!'D

(' .'B.

,9'!"

:!,%!'D("

!'"%!'

%

9% *

%B%9'%,*!8%( ' %

>!'

9"'!  % %9!,$+# ' %"

=.+%!' #"

%,.:!9$".

%

' %"

 9.$"

3% %,%"$!=(' ' %9!'%!'!*(%+"C<.'% 9$".

 "!,> ' %"

 9.$"

0 %% ( 0

        







    

  -     

 9   +  9  

       !6 > -       ? 



5







  

  !6> -

    &6 -+

00

+

  %   ( 

  ?  

5

  

 

     

+ /

        

 





     

  

9

  4      

 



     



              

      + %%

/

        

 



 

 % (

     

  

 9

 4     





           



       

       +   %9!'%!'! ' "'"9++!

.% !8$8%,!"$$' %

( 9".

% !'9%

.%,  ' 8"

.

 !'9%% * %!9%* ' % %9"!!' #% ,

%!'",B.,9"'!=".'  '% $$' % (9".

%!'9% .$,#% ",B.,9"'%,#C"9+:%'%!'",B.,9"'!=".'  'C(  "

B.

,9'!' ,%9,%' %9"

%!8$8!=' % = % '"+.!' ,.'C  % % " "$$"9C!' %"

=.+%!'$".

% ?A ' % "

 9.$"

,% !'+%"!' "' (9".

%!'9%

.%,',

%!'

!'9%% !' % "+%

.% "$$#%",B.,9"'%,#C!%".'  'C'(.$,

%$"'%!$C'9"

( % %!" +$"

.%,

%!' (9".

%!'9%

"8%#%%!

.%,'' % "+%!'9%%

0 0   %9 9.$"

($$ "8%' %!'9%% .!!!=

+:$$"

': '

#% %8"

.

",B.,9"'!=".'  '% "!,,% %!,!= +$"

!'9% "'

,

%!'$%8%$  %8%( '

%,#C" %",!= 9$".

 "!,> ' %"

 9.$"

$".

%>9$"

' %: '! ,

%!' ( 9".

%!'9%  "8%#%%!

.%,!' % "+%

.%'' % "+%!'9%% "!

(% "#$%',

%!'",B.,9"'!=".'  '% *' %!"$$' % (9".

!'9% (.$,#%,%9,%,#C' %",B.,9"'!=".'  'C!"9"

%!8$8!= ' % = % '"+.!' ,.'C D  %!'% :

%'"'! 9$".

% ' %"

 9.$"

"

"

=.%,#C' % :%''!%

* .: %$,*(.$, "8%9"'"

'

: 9%

%9'



8"

.

(  9".

%  !'9%

.%,  '  8"

.

 !'9%%  '

.= .'  ' % 9.!'

C"

%'#%,%"$'(' #C!%",B.,9"'!=".'  'C*'(.$,#% +:

#$%'9!

$,"'% +$"

!'9% '

.= .'' %9.!'

C"'!% :$"9% %:.

: % ' %9$".

%' "8%!'9%%

+ "

"

+%!'(.$,#% %"'%,! "9'' % :

%,9"+%!'(.$,#% "

(

% %:%''!%

9!'%!'! "99%:'%,(.$, %<.

%!'9%

+"$$8% ' %9.!'

C' '

"8%$'"!' % :$"9%'9!'% '' %!'9% .

' % * "$$ +$"

!'9%

"

%'#%,%9,%,#C!%%!'

%

9% *' %",B.,9"'!=:

9%

+"C!%8% 9!9$.,%")%"9"

%( % %' %",B.,9"'!=".'  'C,%"$!= ('  %8% "$!'9% " +$"

!"'.

% 8"

.

!'9%%  "

9++%!9%, "!, "#.''9!9$.,%' %:

9%%,!= "!,"'' "' '"=%*"!' % +$"

!'9%

.%,'' % !'9%%*!(  %9"

%' %"+.!'!8$8%,

= %  ' %:%''!%

29!'%!'! "99%:'%,*"$$' %!'9% ($$ "8%' #%'

"!

%,'' %",B.,9"'!=".'  'C "8!=B.

,9'! ' "'

0 "+.!' %:

9%%,!= ($$ '"

'"

"!,'

:

9%

(.$, "8%'#%

%:%"'%,"="!"!,"="! > +" %",!= ' %9$".

 "!,> ' %"

9.$"

*' %: '!%+% =% ' "'!$C +$"

(9".

%!'9% "

.%,'' % "+% !'9%%#C,

%!'",B.,9"'!=".'  '% *"$$ .9 !'9% (.$,#%",B.,9"'%,#C!%",B.,9"'!=".'  'C*%' %

9%

9+:%'%!'',%9,%' %9"

%!8$8!=' % = % '"+.!' ,.'C % 9 "$$%!=%'' % ,"'%,

>?!!%@.

%0A"$  "$  %( ':%''! , +

%,1(%8% * !9%(% "8%!'

",B.,9"'%,.:!' %+% '

' %9"

%*' %:%''!%

(.$,#%"'$#% 'C' "8"$' % %+%,C " '"'.' C"::%"$"="!

'' %+:.=!%, ,"'%,



!"  #    $%&'( )

)  !# !,B