Sohan Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab

 IN TH HE HIGH COURT FOR THE E STATES OF PUNJAB AND HANDIGARH HARYANA AT CH
,-,,.

/ /0   

-3'', ,-,

 



      '''

 1 
               '''

  
 
!

"#$%& '() *
& " !$*
/
(4
5"
&-  /
/
5"
&-  /
/
5"
&-  

"



/
( 4
'"

, ,&6"
3

" !

$*+('


0





2


 


 




 






4 4 
 

 !



"
 




 

   "



$*4+*+"

"
)"

"
#
 
$$


% 
& #7





   
 
'
(
)*!+


% 
( "
#)





  

"


 




,-
.

. 
/ "
0'

"
, 
1 

'



 




"
 


 
"
 2
  
 



1
 



- 


 

 
 







 



2




 3
 
% 
% 
 


 

, 
 
 


$ "
;3

"
&  ,- 
8 "
/"
 

% 
% 
2
-


6-
  "

 




/<
/
13
1"
/ /
/
 
 "




  "
'




 

8
 "
!


  !
!

!:

4 



 


2"
' 
'
'





2
/<
%


"
/"
' 

4 




 
 
&



'
  

 

%
'
  
2

% 
%  0






'
4 

4
 


 =

>>

>>%
' 



-




/<
/
13
1"
' 
 


&
 "
 


'

'



"
'
2
4

-
 
$

  
0
 
'
 
8



'
 
-

 
 
0


 
'
 
'

 
&  
8 "
1

 
 



2

 



'

'



&2"
%


0
9 2"
1 


%
'
 








 "

 "



 2"
'



 





 
%

  


 -
 





1 ?
'
 

7$:


!:

 2

 2
 
'
-
 







'

 '

 



 2"

'

 
 
'
2
 
'
 

  




2 0
"
4


  

 



-
 
8


 



 
"
 
  
'



%  

4 
9 2 2"
= "
' 

'





 "
-
 
)

) !


 -
  

'



 2
!

!):"
'  




%



   

  


'

'
 
2
/<
54
8 
%
 "
3


@"
= 4


2
/<
/
1 13
1"
' 
'

 

  

'
 

 4




 





"
 "




 

 

"

 



   


 
 



 8








,-
. 
/ "
0' 
"



 

 "
 2
 
 

"
'

  "



  


 2


 "
 - 2



/<
/
1 13
1 %

 
2

 




2
 -


 2
  




0


 

' 

 


2 

'



'
 


&

 "

 

 
'
' 

"
'

 
&2
( 

)


'
 -







& 
8 "

1

$

;' -"




'




"




 
$
2"

 


2


 

 

2
 
"
"

'

2
 
%


 




  


-




 

 
4
' 


&


 
 
'
 '

  

  
'
'

$




'



 &2
 

"




 
$
2"
' 
'

- 

- 


& #7
/
"

 
'

4 
 2

 2


& 
8  
-



'

'

'

 

%

 
 


2
 

)


'
 

 




"
'  
'

- 


2
- 


& #7"


'

"

'
 2



-
'



2
2 0



A 

3 
' 
 


 







'
  2

3  


, ,./"
0'

C-
 '"








2
   4
"
' 




'


  

3 
 
B


  "


 





 -


'


 

'

 




 


  


 

 


0
2

 "


 





 





!

-   .   


   

 !

"

#$%
 " &
+ ( $

 !

"

, ,,%

'

' (  
  

% % / /##$/0% *    $) ) 
 
  

% / /0)#/ )% * 

,

!

 !

"








  

2
 



 
2
 


 "





  


"

  

3 "

  2


"
'
 2
   







 2 2



2

 
 
02
-
 




 


 
 


& #7

&

 
 


 




2 2


 
 

2"


 


 
'
4




"
  

 4


'




 

2
% 


 

 
 




 
'
 
& "


7"

2

$
2

 



2
 

 
3 


 



"
 2

-'
 

 

 

"

 
' 


 2

 

  






 

2


  




 
B
  


-

 


 




  


 "


 
 



 


 
0
2

  "

 



 

3 

2

 
1 

 




'  


"

/ / 0/ "
 

    %
-



 



 
  

-
 

 


  

  ) &




  "

% 
% 

-
 
 

/<
/
1 3
1"
/
/"
1 

$ 


'

 
 
1 ?
!:
"
-
A 2


& "

0
 

 
'





 
/<
% 
 "
/

  

/<
5 54
8 
% 
 "
=4 
0
 
'
-


 






!

 

'
  
'
 
'  

 
& 
8 "
1 



2
0 "


"

  
'

 

&2"
% 
0  9 2 2"
1

2"
' 
'



 "
- -
2
 

)

0
 
'
 -


 


& 
8 

$

0"



 



 
"
 
  
'



%  
9 2 2"
= 

 2"
'  

 



  "
-


) ) !


 -
 

'

 
2
!

!) :"
' 



 
%

  
; "
 
  2
 




2"



'


0


 





 

'
 
 
'
 
'


' 




$
2D
 &


#*+*+

 
& #7"


"
'

'


 
 
 

 -


& "
 


'

'
 



'

' 
2
A

'
2 "

'

' 





 

 

' 
 2
A

 2

 "

'
  







3 
 
'

'
 
'
A
 

'
2"
  "


 
7

   "


 




2 %

'
'
  
  


 





 

&

#7






 


2


 ( 
 

 

 
  
!

E

*  +
%
 
"


2
 
'
 -


 

 

5 '
&  
8 "
1

$




   
; "



7#* +

  





'

'


'

!

E

*  +"







$

;'-"

 
'

'



 2
 


 
"
4

 



%  
9 2 2"
= "
' 

  



 

 
-
0 "
 2
 


 
'
 
2

 
&  
8 


.
,  
& 

$ 7"
'  
'
 
2


2
 


)



 '
 




0






 




 



$





'
 
2



"
"


'

2



'





$
2"

 


2


 

4' 




0 
 


 

 









) *$+

   - -

' 
 

 


 


-"

' "

2
'





 "


-


  


6- 

2

2
 





2

  


 "
"






"

"




  
 
"



2
"




    
 

 


A  "
' 






 

 


 
 


6-

2

 2"



' 



 
'


 




 
 












6- 


 2"



A 
;

; "




$ 7

6 2



)

A 


 

$
2"

"

 *






+"



' 
'
4
2

  



  

 



 2




2"



7 7
2
0"



 



'

2





$
2
 


'
- -2
 
'
 0
A
 
-


2








'
2


$
2



  

2
 
9 2

1



'
'

$ 


'
 

2


"
'

' 
'


-
 


-


*7+


&

#7"


' "

%  
% 
 
'


 
2
; "



"



-


 
%

 "


 
 
 

 
'E

* +"
'

'


2


1 


 




2
 
7
2

 

 

2
;'-"


  2
 
'

-'
4
2



1 




 & "


*7+


& #7 
 



 '

2"
'-"

 
2

$
2"
' 

'

'
A 

2

 "




2



 
 


& "


- 
 



 


"











 
'
 
 
'

 


2



'

'
4

3 






%


  


 "

 

 
2
 

-



 






 


  

 

 -2




4
 


 "






2 2


 "
 2
'

 
'

'
2
"
"
  

 4

'




 
2


   (







'E 

* +"
'

 
1 

 


4

-'

'


 

2
 



 







2



 
2 

9






 

2
 

)


'
 











7$
2
 



  "
' 
'

- 


2
-


& #7



'

 
 
'

 

$
2
;'-"

 


 
-

2
 
 
)


'
 -
 

 

 
& 
8 
2
 
$





'
 

 "

'
 

 



"
' 
 

'
  


'

 

$
2


 
 

2
 
; "

 








%



 
2
 





 
2
'




1 "

/ 
 



 


 

'
'

 2

-


 

  
0
  





 

'
  



  


 

   "

"






-'"
4 


 





- -
'

 



  
 

 
2
0
  


- "


' 


 

 -



 '

 -




- 




  
8

3 




2
<
- 
 
4 ? "


' 


 



3  

 
/ "
 


 
 



  2
12
-

- 





   "

/ "
'
4 ? "



 

 

- "
'



 

  

 
2
( 


 

 
 

 !

 E

* +"
'
 
 -
-

 ;E 






 
 
2





'
 

 



 

  






- 
 




 "

 


 
 





 




   






 
2
2


 

-

  

 
 

 
 




B


 
 
'


3 

 

2

 "



 




 


 
'E


* +
' 



 

'
 
2

 






1  ;'-"

 


 

'


 
 

 "
 

'

 



2

 

 

 2 2

2"
 




 


'

 
 

 

 






 
0
 

- 


 


 "   
 


 




    

 "
 




 


%
-'


 
 

 -"








2



 


  

 

; "

 




2

 


 
 


"
2
-

 


 "

- 
0
 

2


 


 
'
'

!

;'-"




 

 -



-

2
 

 

 






 


 


A 

 
 




 -3'',-,    (MANISHA BATRA) JUDGE


 Whet ther speaking/reasoned Yes/No Yes/No Whet ther reportable