High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3985/2017allowed

Employees Provident Fund Organisation & ANR v. Punjab State Cooperative Supply And Marketing Federation Ltd. (Markfed) & ANR

2025-03-17Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi7 pages

! "

#$% $&

$!'$$ $ $& $!

()*+ & , --

*/'

!1& " & !

$0$ ) $!

!0 0 #$% 0$

!$1

0 /'

$& *$!2

& !$ /& $& $

3 3

()*+

*/'

!1& " & !

$0$ ) $!

!0 0 #$% 0$

!$1

0 /'

$& *$!2

& !$ /& $& $

()*+

*/'

!1& " & !

$0$ ) $!

!0 0 #$% 0$

!$1

0 /'

$& *$!2

& !$ /& $& $

()*+

*/'

!1& " & !

$0$ ) $!

!0 0 #$% 0$

!$1

0 /'

$& *$!2

& !$ /& $& $

()*+

*/'

!1& " & !

$0$ ) $!

!0 0 #$% 0$

!$1

0 /'

$& *$!2

& !$ /& $& $

()*+

*/'

!1& " & !

$0$ ) $!

!0 0 #$% 0$

!$1

0 /'

$& *$!2

& !$ /& $& $

!$*

5%/

*!.

# 0

$!0*!$ 0

!"#$#%%&$#'( )

-7 0-8 0-9 #.

(:+ # + ** ,- .

/ / ..

. *0 .- *. & ....

1* . 2

.. /.)-3.

/- ./.

0 * / , .

* 2 4 $5$6&$#% , 5(- !"7685 &$#' 4 9$: .

* - .. !"7685!"9#69!"9755!"#$#%%&$#' 5$: &5:.

- .. !"#$7$$&$#'

!"6&9$&$#'

. 7 ; .

/ .

- .- /*

1* . < 2 = #65&

>#65&?(/ .

.. /.* . ./.*

* *

/ 9$: ../.

; . /* * @</. * ! A

! " #

$ "

.. /. ./.*

- .

/. 9 ; . /*

/ / ! +

3 ! - .

####$#% & '

()*& $ $ #$+ / ..* . / / . ./. /.

* 'B #9+#65& 5 ; . * . /

.. /.- .

./.

%, -*

- *& & . / 0 "

1' 2 ' "34 54#$ 5..6#3

. / / @</. *! A - .

&277 8+##$ / 0 % , - *

- *& & . # $# #$ - * $5$6&$#% , 5( ././ % ; .

/ .

2!A

/* ,

.. /.

* .. .. /* 9$:../.*

/ .. / 3.

@ !

/ * - * *4 ./ *

' A . . - /.

8 A*/ . ..- . /@</. *! A 4 75" - ./. * #65& .

/.2 * @</. *! A , 0. ! "4#5 * #+8. /.* / / . * *./. #65& .

/ .. C

/* .. .

./.. / ./.*

.. /. *

/. - *

/. 6 2 - .

/ ! +

####$#0% & '

() *& $ $ #$+ / .. ..- ! .

/ ./. 'B #9+ #65& .

#$ >

/ /* /

* / #5 , * - * . / .. /* /. *

- *

/. . * .

. .

- .

4 / / .

* * ./. 'B #9+ A *! @

* ; <

(- . 8 7-:

;- <.

- , - 9

( + 0!

> * ..-

. / ** D #9+

. * .

..- . .

/ E .

2 !**

..4 */ . . 0 . *

. E . * . / . - . /.* . /

. .D * 0 / /. * . ./.?

#$ ; .

//. / . ..-* / -

4 - / *

.. /.

## 2

.. /. ,

/ * !7

= 0;-= 0<- <.

(;>+9 - * . / / @</. * ! A %, -*

-*& & .

(; .

//.

#& "

. .

.. *

.. #65&/ 3.

@ ! */

. / * - *

* /0 .- #7

- / * $5$6&$#% , 5(

.. /. * /4

.. /.

* . ..-

/ #65&* ./. /

/ /. #9$9&$&5 #9

.- ..

/ * #5

. .

. #% / . . ( $!0*!$ 0

+ # &

4F G

/. )