Himanshu Chopra v. State Of Punjab



         



   

 

 !
"#

$# %#! &  $!'(

"     

 



$# # )"* ) + ,- #   "#

 .* )!# & !+ ,/+ $!'(



" #

1      " * !# & 2 
# $

# 3#  #3!*# (*    "#  45 6   7  + #3# !# &     6# #!3  $8 #" &!( , &     6$& ,  (  *#  +  $* & 9!#+ # $*



:# !* #   "#  !(     "#   !8  7      -3  "*   **  ( "#   # #  "#! ;+ !  ;  + *8 2 ; - ( <  8   !+   *!  #*  *=*8  =     * (* ""*    "# ;   ; #;    3  7    -  ##+   #*    8 "#3#+  !+ *3   "#  *   "# (* "  ="3  -;   !8   



"#+  #-     #3!*# (*+  8 !# # ## ;!* ( -*-    #3     "#  # !# ,#*    
!  5 :# !* #   "#  #* !" -#! ##    >(* &!"#
!#+ ; #+ **8    (    !8+     (*  ( 3# *  * ( "* !"  ##    ?(* - 9   
!# 


     *  @ 

 $ 



@



    # + *# & !*  ""   "# " # 3#  #3!*# (*    "#   !(     #-#8  #   "# ** ;    3#8  #* A!8   !+ (# !# & 7    6$& , ;!* ""*8    "#  5  !# # !(     "#  -*-   # +  !+    #-     #3!*# (*

:# !* #   "#+  #(!*+  !(     "#   (*        #* !"   '!3  >(* &!"#
!#   !

"

 #

$#!

&!'!

() #"#    *+ 

         #!    "#  #  (     (* ""*    "#  ( #' **8    3#!     "#  -*-   #  *- "#     '!3  #"#! #(*; B
 

   

    



       





  

 



  



 

 

    

  

  

  

  

1 
!#  # *# !* #   "#   3  #!3   ""#(=



?(*   &!"#
!# $ 

   ,!-! ##



.$

 *
!+  *#+! /   *  0# 11"

# 2#!

3

4#

 +  (#-  !#     !

  

     

  

 " #           

        

  $          %         



   !

   

 &  

  

   



  

   !

                !

   

   ' "(

)*+'
 ,

  

     

 

    

 

   

 

! -
    



     

 

)*+'
 

    

   

     

.  (  

    

!  

 

   

2

 & / '0+     

  1
                      

, "#!*     ;!*  ;      (- +   !8    ! ;  8#  2    ; * =3  #      -3  ( "*      *!  #* ;!* = +   ?(* &!"#
!# ; "*  3# #3!*# (*    "#  #

1  >(* &!"#
!#   *  5 "" "

0

 6 2#!

3

71 ) - ##   C  "  %&'()*

&)+& ,- %%&)* ".* #

- //0


; "*  (#-  !#  @#  

  

 

 

     &  .  

    

  

  &   

  

 

    

                       

 

  

'2 3  !      

  +  45      6

1  (-  ; *   !#   6$& ,    45  ( #3# !# & C  +        

, 1      "#!  # ;     #-#8 #    "#  # ;  #* A!8 1  >(* &!"#
!#  (#-       (* ; (3 3#    "#  # *8    3#!     " (! ; 8#  !8    *!  #* ;** =  



>(* &!"#
!# 
 "

  !,-/ *  @


 #8# # 9# 2# 3

4#

 5+ - ##  7  + ; "*  3#   (*    "#

 #    ; #   !8 ;   8#  7   ""#<*8 1  #*- "#     ##  7     !#  @0    

7    "8(98:8  

  

;<)-(/(98:1   

   

       '   $"1  +  &      

):$-98:/  

! +'

  '  9:=

) * + ' 
  :1/,
 

 

                   $-  

                       .

   9:8(98:/  





 :8        

  

   

 #

   

   



  

          

           #



    > 45 '   

;9 & 

& 

  

2  ' )*+'
 )  ? 



   45   '          

      

   

 

  #

   

    6 

5  #    +
 "

  ! :

 *  @7  ; # '  < #" 2#!

&

= )5) - ##  

C +   >(* &!"#
!# ; "*  (#-  !#  @0         

           9,8:9899    

      7  <

  +   +  '    2    <;  )::(39899  !

    :/8-9898   

       )@    )8939898         ' /989(=

9/ 

91

) * + ' 
  :1/,      &             

     #   <
 &?+  '
  

 <' 2
 ' A

   

    



  

 

7

  #

 

> 45     

! 

     45 !  

            

  !         45       

4 5
            

    

   

7      6 

, "#!*    (- ## ;!*  ;        *   !8 ;  ""#<*8  8#+    7 8     ; !#   6$& ,  "##*8+ #3   *3-8    !8 "#+   (* ; 3#    "#  #



1  >(* &!"#
!#  5  

.$

 *
!+  !-:

/ *  @

#  6> <  2# 3

4#

 5+ - ##   C + ; "*  (#-  !#  6


    918(9899 

        

 '  0  +     

'

 

'

# @      

'

     

   & B ;)-:9 9898   :(:89898  ' 9:45 "(

)*+'
    +'

@# @

C

*



  

     8:  8( 

818-9899!

         !

  

     !&        

         

  



   

    

 

    

              

  

!   '  0  +          

    +  45      6 2

, "#!*     ## ;!* *  ;       ; !#   6$& ,    "#-  & 7    6$& , ;# *         (* ; 3# "##*8 (8 #3   "#  #  !#3 !8 #  "#   8#  7    *8  ;  ( <

1  ?(* - 9   
!#   

?# # *#++ -  * '!3    +  * *    +   ! "#  (*  = !   ;    "##  ,#*    
!  5    (  *3 "#  !8+    #-     #3!*# (*+ -      #3#  & 7    6$& ,



,
# 9   
!# -    ,!,!



" 
 :: *  



 2#!

' 19  3#     #3!*# (*    -*-3 #-#8  #* A!8  """8 !=+ ; #   !8 ; #  "#   8#+      8+    3#!  *3 ##    ! "# (3  -*  #3     ! # "8 #*  # !# ,#*    
!  5

7

5   "# +   "#   !8  7      -3  "*   **  ( "#   # #  "#! ;+ !  ;  + *8 2 ; - ( <  8   !+   *!  #*  *=*8  =    !+ ="3   "#  !# # ## ;!* ( -*-   #3   # !# ,#*    
!  5

C

)"3  -;   (-   #!  ;**    *; * ;    (- '!3+   "# "  **;    "#  #  ( #*  #3!*# (*   !# 3 (*D!#8 (        # #*
!#D!8 3#  !('    (3 #A!#  8  #  1  "#  ** * ( (8   **;3  

1  "# ;**  "# ;   - !#3   #*

(

1  "# ;**  "#!#E D    "#! ; 



1  "# ;** ""# (#   #*
!#     <+ !* "#* "#  <"

1  "#  **     *#   



  ;    ! + # #   ;    !"



1  "#  **  #*8 # #*8 = 8 !+  # # "#  8 "# A! ;           !  # *3 !    
!# #  8 "* # # "# ;   -



5   (#  8    (- +   "#!  ** (  *(#8  -  ""* # **  (* (#  
!#



;-#+  3  (-  ** ( #!   * <"#  "    #        #*
!# ;!* "# "*8    (#-     "#  ;  # *8 #   "!#"  '!3   "# (* "



$3 ""*+  8+  "   -;    (-

',-1&.

/!


 "

 #  &  23&,3&.

$%&)4(567.&)$-5&80 &$7 - 23&,3&.

.&%-.,)1*&0 &$7 -