High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/29381/2018allowed

Si Shri Bhagwan v. State Of Haryana And Others

2025-03-28Mr. Justice Jagmohan Bansal27 pages

!"#$#% # &## # #% #

%(%))* + + ' ,,-.)$-/0 1)). 2.3 ,( .4-. 1 5 )- ,.+ + + )).

5 + ''6

8-- , ( .4 -. +

:.,)/- , ( .4 -. 7+ 9'

,;).,)/- , ( .4 -. '+ 99

' ,3)<=38. , ( .4 -. 9+ 7

>).=- , ( .4 -. 6+ 9'

9 "-+ , ( .4 -. + 69

6 :-=38. , ( .4 -. + 76

9 / 8 , ( .4 -.

+ ' '

6 2)=38. , ( .4 -.

+ 76

2).. ,)/- -. , ( .4 -.

+ 6

.)-?) : , ( .4 -.

+ 9

9 %3<)- , ( .4 -.

7+ 9

$-)8,)/- , ( .4 -.

'+ 9

.-- , ( .4 -.

"# $ %& ' "( & ))) "#

#$#,#@A"

* "! +

" , ,

,& ,&

- # ,&

, .

/$ "..01..2 3 4 #$ $ +5 ++ .5+6 7 .8!,& , 73

'$ +8 .5+6 7 .:!,&3

"'$ , # "& 52 +5 .5+5 "& +.

++ .5+.

( #$ ,&"3

'$ , ( 3 ,"

:+ .550% '$ :

/ ( & ,

$ " '$ 3

/ 3

"# '$

$ %

"&'$ - ,

$ / ' .0 .55; %

% '$ "

"& % " "

%- , 5:

5+ .550 %'$ $ " 3

'$ 56 .552 % - ,

"$ "3

- , 5+ .559

$ 5+ .559 %

$ " "

* , % '$ - , % '$ - , " " " *

% '$ - ,

, ""&, % -

'$ - ,

$ % " "

" ( 3 ," 3 ,"

" "

% " " % , %< " 3 ,"1( 3 ," / " " , "# $= 4/

"# , % /" & 3

;4 ( /3

, % ' " " ( & >% ?! / 3

"& 52 +5 .5+5" """ 3

'$ - ,

$ / " 7 3

"# $ % # "# &$ '

(

)

* * # + ,- -.

/,- 0) # $ 1 &$ $ 1 *$$* $+ * # $

7 '

(

% #

% # "#

$ "# &$ $ &$ '

(

*** #

% # *

$ # "# &$ 2# 1-

% 3% $$* 4# $ &$'

(

$ $ $

( (

% 5 3 % * "# $

# $"# , 1-3% * $ '

(

- $

% % 6789*6$, #- 6 79 * $ "# &$-$

# '

)$ / !%:;# < $ - / $ -$ 5 # $ / !% '

- *#

.;:3<$$*4# $ / !% :;# < '- $

$ $ - $

.; * !% $

# $ !%/ , 1-3% *$

'-$

%% 6=8=- *6$, #- 79 * $ !% !%:;# < $ $

# :< - "#

$ 4# # "# $ % '

> -"# $ # * *#* !%-;$-&$?#-& ?# !%:;# < "# ; -$ $ #%2# 1!%;

?".:),05,0<$$*4# "# '

>-$

' "#

?". $ $ * !%-;$-&$-?# !%:;# <

>-$

$"# ; :6 !%; < # ?".:),05,0< 7/=7@9

%%;

# :< - !%

$ 4# # !% $ %

!%$ # ; *#* )$* %1 ,#; $32;$ ;$- &$ ?#- & ?# $ : !%- ;# < $ % $

)

?". :),05,0< $ $ * 4# !%

$ !%

?".$$* ;$-&$?#-& ?# $

$$* ,#; # ?".:),05,0< 7/= 7@9

%%; $

# :<3 -

:% ,0< * $ "# ;

$ %- %1

/ ; -$ A

/ %'

+8 .5+6 3

"'$

7" "& 52 +5 .5+5 3

" '$

$ +5 ++ .5+6 ""$

&, $ ",

9 ;

/& ,, # "& 52 +5 .5+5 7 +5!

"$ "" "& ""$ !

/ "&

,& %' &

"& & "

"@ !

/ $ "& & "& +.

++ .5+.@ !

/ ,

$13

/3"$ .5 ++ .5+6 & $ +5 ++ .5+6 7 .8!

4 .8 5;

.5.. $

" 3 & ' ( & ( % # 3 / .8 5;

.5..

* %# *$# % $* % 0 #* 1

% # * @ # $

@ # $ $ % ** % # # , 31 3$- " * 1 * 1@ # 6 # *$# $* $ % * # # - "

6 ** * 1

1 * 1 $ *** % , 31-

#$# %* 0 * 1 % ** % % /"$$# % **# # 6 , # + 1 # )4# . - *%

) , 1" 31- 3/*-%*## *% )* *1 %*

5+ .5.:A &$ %' $"&

$ "& .5+.

, $ ,& ( & ".552 ><)#?! A ,"

"+9:8 " ," ( & ! > ?!

"+.

+ +.

:+:

++:

2+:

6 $ $ &

, # / " ,

,& B$"

/ $"& ""&,

,& 3

# ,&%' C "&

,& %' , & "

, A

"& "

"& +.

++ .5+. , "

" "

$ B"& +.

++ .5++ ,"# $= + /

( 3 ," $ "& , "# % /

$ 4

" & &

#$ ,

"& /

"& C73" ""3 " / "& ""$, 3,& &

%= 3 +2 5;

.5+0 "&

$ 3

" 3 & ( % A $ #" "$ 3

"14 ' " "

$ 1 "

"& 4 # 3

"& C7 3" " " & 4 # A$ ,

"& 3 ,"1( 3 ," / $ "& ,

" ,"

" "

& 1"

, "&

/ , %'$

- , #

4 "

"& % / A " " & $ , & %' /" , "" %' & A " , & " &$ +5

"# $ %& ' " ( & , " " *

, % 4 %

$1 $

$ "*

% ," , %'$

- , % " %' # ;5 ! " 3

, "

, ""&, % /%' $"&7 ,& ;5 ! " / %' <

$ "& $ ""$"&$ ," D ,"& .5+5 .5+. " " , "& 52 +5 .5+5 $ , % , "

$ /

$ , "

% < "# " , % / '$

" "

$ / $"&"

&C73" "3 / C7 3" " 3 " " & % " *

C73" "3 " %

" " % '$

- , "& 4 3 "#$' " 58 .5+2 "& +.

++ .5+.$ $ 7 " & C73" "3

" ,"$ / "

$ 3 ,"1( 3 ,"

C7 3" " 3 " "& " ," C7 3" " 3 " ,

" ," 3 ,"1( 3 ," ++

4 $ " " ,

," ,3.4.?)) +.

- " $,&" "

/ '

( & " E '

F *

" .5+2 >

6 3<?!

.5+2 .5+2 " " ," ,

" " ,"

" B"3

," .5+2 " / A .5+2 "

B"3,"

" $,&

90 " "", ,

"" "

/ ' ""

"" ,A

9. " '

# " &$ / '

# & " &$ 9: '

" /

&, ,& & *

F 9.9: 90 " ,"

% & '

(: <,"1- %1 .

"B-+# 1 #*#* ) :< @1# #)

% - 1%- -% 3# , 6 #- $ 0 3# + 1 # 3# # # % - #

1 # %

1 %C - $- 1 # #

% $# *4# 1 1 *# 1##

% )

: <0 1

# 1

* ) - , "1-%1 .

"B-+ # *- 1 *

# 1 :<@1 ##

- 1% #-% % , 6 #

+, # ')-(: < ) - ' :) ' <- ** , 31- %1 * :<?$ # * -1 1 + 1 * # # ) * # #-

% %+##) :< )

1 1 * ) *

% # * ) :(<#4% ;# # ) - ' :) ' <- ** % , 31-

%% #)

$# #) G +:

: " ""," ,& 8 " "" , # $ F '

& , :! 8 & "" " " "", , : 8 " ,"

#'* )* (

% ,- #%1 , " # ) ?$ 1

1 $ 1 * ) -% *

% % * 1$,#,%1

*#11% ,-

# 1 * $ ./-0 *# '* )* (,#%4 * ) - : <*

# #% # + # B

, " 1- %1 * -

#% 0 ,

,C :< ## B B+*

%# ,6 ; #8/ 6 ; #8%1** -* $

% #) C :< *1-

$ - - # * *

%# 1% * % C :(< * *

#% $* $ # **

% # 1 A HC "I +8

9 " "

$ 4 '

& ,& "

$ C $ ""

" % +5 ' " %'

& "

& , " % /

" $ % "" " 9 +5 ," J #'* - (,"1-%1 .

"B- * ,* @ -

* $* -

%%1

+ 0* " $

#* * */ " '* * ( , "- # $ / " - 1 %1

7 .

"B-

1$,% * * # # #

,#* $1%%11) -) /*#1 ,#* - 1 A +;

" +.

+ ,

" +.

+ 8! 4 "" , , """

, 4 , 4 "",, $ "" ( 3 ," 3 ," % "" , ,%"" ""% ,"

& , " +.

+ ;! A , 3" " "" , " ," ' "3 &" A$ ""$ "" " 7 "+.

#% & ## ( : < :< DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD :(< 0*

%%*

* %# 1#% ,

% %**

* * %# 1#% ,#%* ) ,#%0*

% %

%# 1 #% 3% %

% %

%# 1#% :

< 0 # *1- *- - 4

$ - #% + , #4%

% %1#4% ,

' ;# - % - 1 $* # A HC "I +0

" +: " ,

# *

" +:

+ #

# "" ,

,& " ,& & - $"

$ """

7 " =3%C -"",

B=3% C "",

% B >C? "",

%4' "- "",

" 7 "+:

+ ," J &

(: <

+- +-

% %1 * %1 1 @

1 1

% ,* 2# - $ # # * * * -

% #

1 2# $

$2# -

%* #

$ :< E * # *

$ #% $

1 % # $ * # *

* # 0 1- -$

# % - %# 1 % *% #** #%+-#

* +1* # * % - % * + % %

9 :< ! *#* # *

* )-8--/-@! $

% 6 )- 8- - /

% * %# '- >- $

# * % + % #% * 6@

/*#1 0* " * % #%#

: < $

# *+ #%* 6!

0* " * %#%#

: <$

# * + * @1 )-8--/@

% %+

$%# ? #

% $# #

DDDDDDDD DDDD DDDDA HC "I +2

"+:

2, " 3 ," B>=? # ( 3 ," "+:

2 "+:

6 3 ," # ( 3 ,"

B>=? B"3 +6

B " & 3 ," $B"3 & # ( 3 ,"

, B"3 /&$ "+. ;!

6 .5+2 "

, - & " +. ;! .5+2 " ,"

! ''

#'*

* F : <:(< DDDD DDDD DDDD DDDD :

6$, #*%

% * %1 6$ #C$

% #

** #%2# # * + G "3))<. +9

/ "$ "& 52 +5 .5+5 $

, "

3 "$ (?," 3 / ", A " .5

(?," 3 $ A " "&

3 "= (?," 3 ) & ! 1 2

3) 3%"$" $< "$ "& F & ₹;551 ₹+5551 A " / (?," 3 A " " 3 A$

"& & "&," ' & .+

4 4 5- ? 1 " +6$ , 6 3 " , , & " " "

" " & , 4 & $,&" "

, " "& " % ,$,&" "

4 , , & $

37,!##?

8" 6.$. " "$"

3 & / 4 "+9;8" , "

&,# ,$"

" "

"+8 3 4

/" 7 A$

$ #

1%+#*

# $ # #

* #-

1#%

1* #% )

( '

)

' % # #

%2# 1 **#1

B * 1**1

# , # * # % # * * * # 2# 1 **#1*#% * 1$ %# #* $

1 #-)

' 1 **

* 2# 1)

( 0$-)

( #$ )

'* )

2# 1

*#% * 1 % * * $ - - %)

( ' 2# 1 % ?$- $ 2# * * G 0

# -#$ 8 H -I$1 I- # % #%4 $ * * ** # 1 * #

% * - $# % # @2# 11 *$1* % I %%- % I

$ !* * $- 2# 1 % 0 2# 1 %$C% # $ *#% $ - $ * % # %1- * #2# %

* # $ )

1 *#% * 1- )

)

( '+%, #

2# 1 1 2# , # % % * * ** % +

1 # # % # %1 1 # % #$# % 2# 1 * , - # # % - %### *%

-$# # *$ %1)

( '

& *$ %

F * 8 %%1)

( '

I ..

)

+".$ 6" "$ "& " :6 /

"E "3 "+9;9 3 +.7$ ""$, "$"

;# 1G

*#* # # 1 1 #% 6 %# #* $ +$ 0 $

#% %

# 1

$ #F < 6 + * + #%

%< J !# ; # # # 0

< J 1* # 0 < ! # ,##$ #1 %1 % ) < ;*# 1 $ --1

< & %5#% :$

# $

16 # #1+# ;# < '

# 1 #% 6 -$

#-%4 % ) - $ *$ % #) $#% 6 *,# ;# 1 $ 1 * ,#- -

#- + # * 1 8# $

1 1 ;# $ 1* * % ) -%# $ %4 ) - # # * $ #%

1 A 4 ''' /# *

?+ '

* , -' !

+$ 6 6 3 " "

$ $"

&& 4 +992 " " $ $"

"& , & ," !))/ .:

B " $"& ,

,& %' " 7$ ,& ;5 ! " - & ;5 " ," J , -' (

/ "

% * + # # - $ * ) # # :< * C :%< $C :

< # * * B $+* %1 *

C :< # # # #C :< $ # C :

< * % * % * C : < #- # 1 ?"

*#*

$ * $

* * C :< # - * 1-

* C :< #

+ - * %

#%4 $ -1

* * *$#C :4< #

%1* C :+< * % %#%#% %1

* #

C :

#1* C :< # * #C :< * #C :<

1- *#* ) *

- * %# *$ #%1C

:*<

1 * * $ # * ) # # A HC "I .8

- " ,< %'

# $"

$ $ & " ,& "

# $"

B ""

$ $ "&

&, >*?$ , "" > $"

/ "$ $ "&1 $ %' .;

":59 3 4 K ""

B$"

# "$"

"& ":59 "",

K '

#"$"

$ /

,&'" """

,& "$"

":59

, * * )* #

,#%4 * #-) ***6 #1 # #-

***-*#% * $

E 1 ,F

% * # *1 * $

E- " ,# *1

* $

,- + # # #-

***- # *# *%

%1# ) ***6 ##

- 1#

#%4 * 1# ) A /A ," "

" 3 4

":00 +5! 3 4 >7$"

":00 +5! ,"

$I 1 $-. --%1 $-# # * % #%116 #-#1* *$ +# $-. --%1 $-# # G .0

- " " .5+2 " "& " ,"! , >?

"3$ & , "

" / " " & $ "1 /< ""&"# &

* % " ""

,, "&

& < " $ " /

$,& " / " " $

7 % 9. " '

" &$ 9: '

" / 7 ;5 ! " /3 $"&",

;5 ! " ""$ !

":59 3 4 ,A 3 B$"

& $"

C& 8+ B 2" ".80 3 4 '

," ," 3

" :59

# "$"

- A $ C& 8+ B 2 "":59 '

$ ,"

L ""&"#& "

" $ &

$ " ' 3 4 $"

%'"

#"&$"

$ , *

' !

"" >7$ "

? "

,& " :00 +5! 3 4

3 B$"

7$"

,& & & & 7$ "

3=A$ &9& ) &"

+$+ 6 & , 7$ "

,& "

7$"

" "

" +: ""& # 3 ,"( 3 ," "+:

: "" %B=3 % "",

"""$"

" $ 3 ," # ( 3 ," , 4 4 # 3 ,"( 3 ,"$,&B=3% C / & "+:

$"&$$ # 3 ,"( 3 ," !

" +:

+ # 3 ," ( 3 ," "" ,

,& " ,& & /$ $ & , B"3 / ,& $ "& "# " , % "&

$ & 3 ,"1( 3 ," / &

"+:

+ !

/ $ "& ""& 3

%' 3

& $"

9 ;5 ! "

# $"

/ & $ "& $ " ,& ,

;5 ! " !

8 :! " & "" "" "",

& , , 8 , 7 ,& ' B ,$ "& "# &1 $ " & ,

,& & "

8 :! "",$,& 3" " /<$"

,& & ,&%' !

;5 %' ,A " "" "

- $

$ $ & " "" 3 4

! /$ $ $"& , "" > $"

,&%'

& , "" >*?

;5 ! " %' $ & " >" ? , " $ 69 +5 " "

" 3

$ " %

" ;5 ! $$ , #

! - "

;5 " %' "

$ $"

( $"

4 # , $3 $"&1 ,,&%' ,&A " 3<"& $ ! "&$ "&1 52 +5 .5+5 ,& "" $ "& "&1 52 +5 .5+5 ,& .6

"" , .9

= $ A$ 3"

A < "& "&1 +5 .5+5,&%'"& ' ," /

" , , "&1 :5

$ " ! & ""

#$#,#@ "%

+ + ' &K# D #$1 1E D ," 1E