M/S Supreme Infrastructure India Ltd v. Hscc India Ltd And ORS












 

 

 



!"#

#$%&%'(
)#*"#+,#-
./


0&
)1*-#+#
'-!&"-1$"1-#
'2%!
3"2
-4#$"
%$#
!"
5!6*!'!
7!86!

#2%$!6
66#9#/
5!-'!6 **#66!'"

:#-&1& 0&
)
'2%!
3"2/
-4#$"
%$#
!"
5!6*!'!
7!86!/
#2%$!6
66#9#/ 5!-'!6

"7#-&  #&*'2#'"&  

  !"

"!

# $

%&

 ;7#"7#-
#*-"#-&

6$!6
*!*#-&
+!<
,#
!668#2
"
&##
"7#
4129+#'"=  
,#
-##--#2
"
"7#
#*-"#-&
-
'"= > ;7#"7#-
"7#
4129+#'"
&7162
,#
-#*-"#2
%'
"7#
%9#&"=

-#&#'"( -)5!-9
!-8!'!/
)#'%-
2?$!"#
8%"7
- 5!-"%@#<!/
2?$!"#/ -
"7#
!**#66!'" -)!1-!,7
%&7-!/
2?$!"#
8%"7
-:%?#@
<!9%/
2?$!"#

-&7%!-
)%'97/
2?$!"#
- -)!'4##?
)7!-+!/
2?$!"#/ -
-#&*'2#'"
&

 AAAAA







































"!

# $

 '() 7#
$7!66#'9#
%'
"7#
*-#&#'"
!**#!6
%&
"
"7#
%+*19'#2
-2#- 2!"#2

*!&&#2
,<
"7#
22%"%'!6
%&"-%$"
129#/
5!-'!6/
87#-#,< "7#
*#"%"%'
%6#2
1'2#-
)#$"%'
.

"7#
-,%"-!"%'
!'2
'$%6%!"%'
$"/ ..B
-
&7-"
C..B
$"D
7!&
,##'
2%&+%&&#2 -)5!-9
!-8!'!/
6#!-'#2
)#'%-
2?$!"#
!&&%&"#2
,< - 5!-"%@#<!
2?$!"#/
!**#!-%'9
'
,#7!6

"7#
!**#66!'"
&1,+%"&
"7!"

"7#
!**#66!'"E$'"-!$"-
8!&
!66""#2
"7#
8-@
-
$'&"-1$"%'

5!6*!' 7!86!
&*%"!6
!"
5!-'!6

2%&*1"#
7!2
!-%&#'
8%"7
-#9!-2
"
"7# *#--+!'$#

"7#
$'"-!$"/
87%$7
#'"!%6#2
-
&##@%'9
%'"#-%+
+#!&1-#&
,< %6%'9
!
*#"%"%'
1'2#-
)#$"%'
.

"7#
..B
$"
'
6%#1

"7#
$'"-!$"/ *#--+!'$#
,!'@
91!-!'"##
8!&
9%?#'
,<
"7#
$'"-!$"-
)%'$#
"7# 2#*!-"+#'"
8!&
"7-#!"#'%'9
"
#'$!&7
"7#
,!'@
91!-!'"##/
%"
'#$#&&%"!"#2
"7# $'"-!$"-
"
@'$@
"7#
2-

"7#
1-"
&##@%'9
%'"#-%+
+#!&1-#&
!'2
!& 8#66
!&
-
&"!<

"7#
"#-+%'!"%'

"7#
8-@
1'2#-
)#$"%'
.

..B
$" !&
"7#
$'"-!$"
#'?%&!9#2
"7#
!-,%"-!"%'
2%&*1"#
#
1-"7#-
&1,+%"&
"7!" #?#'
,#-#
"7#
*#"%"%'
$162
,#
%6#2/
"7#
*#--+!'$#
,!'@
91!-!'"##
7!& ,##'
#'$!&7#2
-)!1-!,7
%&7-!
2?$!"#
!&&%&"#2
,<
-:%?

#@
<!9%/ 2?$!"#
!**#!-%'9
'
,#7!6

-#&*'2#'"
&
!'2

&1,+%"&
"7!"
"7# $'"-!$"
7!&
!6-#!2<
,##'
$!'$#66#2
!'2
7!&
,##'
!66""#2
"
'#8
$'"-!$"- 
"7#
$'"-!$"-
7!&
!'<
9-%#?!'$#/
7#
$!'
&##@
!**%'"+#'"

"7# !-,%"-!"-
-
!2412%$!"%'

"7#
2%&*1"#
!'2
'"
%'
"7#
+!''#-
!'2
+2#
%" %&
,#%'9

*1-&1#2
!'2/
"7#-#-#/
'
$!1&#

!$"%'
&1-?%?#&
%'
"7#
*-#&#'" *#"%"%'

"7#
*#"%"%'#- 
7!?#
7#!-2
"7#
6#!-'#2
$1'&#6
-
"7#
*!-"%#&
!'2
!**-!%&#2 "7#
*!*#-
,@ "
%&
&"%66
!
+<&"#-<
87#"7#-
"7#
$'"-!$"-
7!&
&197"
"7# !**%'"+#'"

!-,%"-!"-
,<
&#'2%'9
!
'"%$#
!&
*#-
"7#
!-,%"-!"%'
$6!1&# &
*#-
"7#
*-?%&%'&

)#$"%'
.

"7#
..B
$"/
%'"#-%+
+#!&1-#&
7!?#
" ,#
668#2
'6<
,<
&##@%'9
!
-##-#'$#

2%&*1"#/
%
!'</
"
"7#
!-,%"-!"- 7#
*!-"%#&
$!''

* +#!&1-#&
8%"71"
-#&-"%'9
"
"7#
!-#+#'"%'#2
*-?%&%'&
)%'$#
"7#
*#--+!'$#
,!'@
91!-!'"##/
87%$7
8!&
&197"
"
,# &#$1-#2
,<
8!<

%'"#-%+
+#!&1-#&/
7!&
!6-#!2<
,##'
#'$!&7#2/
'
$!1&#
 !$"%'
&1,&%&"#2
%'
!?1-

"7#
$'"-!$"-
'
+<
?%#8/
"7#
%'2%'9& -#'2#-#2
,<
"7#
1-"
,#68
2
'"
&1#-
-+
!'<
%66#9!6%"<
!'2
*#-?#-&%"< 
2
'"
%'2
!'<
41&"%%$!"%'

"
%'"#-#-#
%'
"7#
%'2%'9&

"7#
1-" ,#68 '
87!"

87!"
7!&
,##'
,&#-?#2
!,?#/
"7#
!**#!6
%& 2%&+%&&#2 +,-+./+'

0$

 "!

#

 '(.+12

%&