Harbans Kaur And Another v. Chandigarh Administration And Others




  
    

 !"#$%

&"'( )*&'+$,#$% &-& (.&/& + 

 ( (/( +& 01&+02 (& & 0+( 

(3 (



  


    

( )* / & ,4 0'&5+ * 4/ 4+&2&,0'&,"+3 ( 6 



    7 &8 +3 (&((&+0(0&0!

$ #,

$ !, #

#9& 0:

$$ #$905+'+&2 "+&3/( # !, 4'# 6,+& 01&+5&('& '0& 0+(5&((/20 + 1/ 0  "  ('/ 1  +  &2   -;  5&;  "  " 1  &  "&(  &""0&

 (</ &0("' +&&(- 3&((0-;+'&( 5&(+33&/+;0 1+' "+3 ( / 0+ /-' 2((7' "

&/+=0 ''/3& (8',$ %$

>#?

+"&'(&@+(

>:?

1+630'((6 ("+3 (&330 "&2 "&+/(/ 0+4'+2@ 5 &(A2 "+&3 /((/&+& 01&+ B&(& 063/'+&(4'+2,$ !CA7" (+,  A+ 4'+2A8 
  (  &  &020 "&'  +&     " + 2& 0&;

1-;/ 0+4'+25&(+&+&33'& (+/0 5 & ;

(0 &3+/( +6';, ,+& 01&+, '+@/&&

  *+&, +(5 &2 + &2"03 "&2;22-( > ?

1+1&&"&(&""0&0&0#$ $ !C+ ""'+&+00 5 & ;"6+0&(6+0(0 &3 +/(D( +& 01&+,*+& '+@/& +&("&'"+2& 5&(+&"&2;"&04 1+5 0(0 &3 $: %,4'6$C,

'+@/&5+'+5&( + &2"+(5" >C?

1+5&((/''(("/ 0&5"(& 0+&3/(  # !,4'# 65&(&0+2 
(3 2  +&+ &2 "+&3+/(5&(2&0 ' '(( &-&((&(+4'+2 5&(2& +&-&+(5+00 5 & ;(0 &3 +/( +6';"+& 01&+, '+@/&& 0*+&

>9?

+ +(3 6&/+(0'0+&&2 5&( ('/0-;5&;""&(&""0&,&(+5'&/( '0&0%

$ 5&( ((/0

>%?

+30'((6 ("+3 ((&0;@+ 3&+&(0 &3 $: %,4'6$C, '+@/&+&0 "&'-

& ("0-;+(5" + &2"+(( 4& &24 1+-"+1& +&""0&0&0#$ $ !C 
(' '00-"/(+& +& ;(& 005&(E'/0 & ;+ (/2 "& (" "&/"+ &10& ("5&(E'/0 +(6'&0"&2;&& 12 5&(& 0(    F/(";  +  &""0&  0&0  #$ $ !C   +  &/+( ' (</ ;00 &''3+E3& & & 0'& '0+&2  000&0!

$ #D#

$ # &04 1+6&"0&33&  CC"$ #5+'+5&(&(0(2((0-;++"02 (&,

+& 01&+000&0

$ !

>!?

2&;&(-2  0++&+& 01&+02 (&

 &(1010&
 $#$0&0#

$ !&1& (&04 1+ / 04' ( #D$ :
, 5+'++5&(&'</0 #% #:" 5& "0 '"+'23& &(5&("++& 065 1E3 > ?

"&  1&'</& +'2 &'&(,&04 1+"0 4/" 2& 0&; F/ ' "(& "&2 "+ (/-F'+/( +("&/ +(&0(/5&(0(2((0-;+/ 0F/012 0&0$$ #% "0"(&33& 5+'+5&(&( 0(2((0-;& 0('/01,+& 01&+0F/012 & 00' 0&0  #:

#$   +  (  33&  /  / </'&;  +0  &( "5()6

4 '( 30 +"+&+5""

+3& ""(0+3&0+,+' ' 0 &/+(1+;'& '0+&2 "+/(5+'+ 5&(&0 "&/"3& ""0&2  E 


& 03& ""(  0"+2& 0&;

 F/ ' 3&;0"& 0&''0 1;," 0 1("+ & 05'/ 
((/ $&&""20

>$?

+  F/012   & 0  0'  3&((0  -;  +    & 0  ( 33&/(+&&& 0" &;&( "/+&33&5&("0-;+ &+((/''(((6 ( >$$?

&0  4 1+  2& 5+  00  (  (/''(((6 (,

&2;,+3( 3 (+&""0 (  -"+ 0(+02 (&, ,+& 01&+,&1& (+00&0

$ !"++"02 (&, ,+& 01&+ + ( & /+;+&( 0+23/1 000&0#

#$90(2((0+ ( 3  +1/ 0"0&;"$$;&( &(5&(

 2(  2(,+&(&@ '"+"&'+&+3 (+& &&0;(+'(/ +(&2'&/("&'

>$#?

+&+&0& 0'/ ("+3 (5+& +&+3 '+@/&+&0- & ("0 "&/"&A((

4& &24 1+5-"+&""0&5&("/ (+0 
("/+/10+& ++/( 0(3/(&(2&05 1/ & 0(&2 0(( -(0"</&-' (0&


(&('  00+&( '+ 3 '+@/&5&(&0-;&0"" &1 ';, &2;, ,+ (3 (+& ' ' 5+&(5+(/'+&2  >$:?

,+5,0 " ;2 +'   ( (&;

("+&( +&&020; +0&5+ &04 1+1&+( &""0&0&0#$ $ !C,  $: %,4'6$C, '+@/&5&(5 0 -;+(5" +3&+&+3+&0- & ("0 "&/" "

+ ( ( " &(  + +  +   22&- 33;

&/ 12+& ( $D6'/0 +&- & ("0&;

(& 00+1&  (/2 5&(E'/0 +&""0&"0-;

1+5&(+"

"&( & '& "&2 ,5+'+ 5&(('/0+/1+"&/0/ 2& (,(+/("/;F/("0 +&&3&, /+&(&(/ 0&" 0 1""&'&1& (+3 ( + (&0" 0 1+&(&& 0" &;

+3 '3(&@ (6F/0'&&& 0';&&'0& 0+53  +(&2'&/("&' '&

- & 0 /+,+ ( &/+;+&(E&2 0+'&2"

3 ( 2(&(5& 0"/ 0 2+

+3 ( +&&&0; F;0+33;('/0+/1+0/-/(2& (,"2 +& :;&(

 >$ ?

+&( (&"6(&0,50 " ;1/ 0  "5++23/1 00( >$C?

(2((0   ! "

   #  *&'+$,#$% !  "


























#