Major Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&,
- - #.&/ 0*,12 &$2%/+ ------ %$*$*&,%/+
3%/+4+ 0$#$% 4,.#5 &$2%/+ ------
%+6&,(%,$+
7 8 -
0 0
/%+%,$ /- ,94+2 46$#:
(;&)#$% '&/ 6%$*$*&,%/+-
/- #;,%%$ 0*,12:
0%,*&/ ! 4,.#5-
/- *$%+2 0*,1<#:
(;&)#$%
'&/ /%+6&,(%,$+ &- = - - - 0 :
-
8
- %$*$*&,%/+
#.&/ 0*,12 &$2%/+ 2#;% '*<%( *,+$#,$ )*;*< >/*$ 6%$*$*&, 4,(%/ /$*)<%+ = &,+$*$4$*&, ,(*#:
*,$%/ #<*#:
+%%9*,1 # >/*$ ,#$4/% )%/$*&/#/* '&/ +%$$*,1 #+*(% &/(%/ (#$%( --
,,%?4/% =:
6#++%( !*;*+*&,#< #,#<
''*)%/:
8%2#< !*;*+*&,
//*1#$*&, /#,)2:
#$*#<#
+2&/$ 7! 7:
>2%/%5@ #, #66<*)#$*&, '*<%( 6/*;#$% /%+6&,(%,$+ &- = :
+%%9*,1 /%+$&/#$*&, )&4/+%:
#<<&>%(-
-
'4/$2%/ 6/#@%/ 2#+ 5%%, A#(% '&/ +%$$*,1 #+*(% &/(%/ (#$%( --
,,%?4/% :
6#++%( 046%/*,$%,(*,1 #,#<
''*)%/:
#$*#<#
+2&/$ 70 7:
>2%/%5@ #66%#< '*<%( #1#*,+$ &/(%/ (#$%( --
,,%?4/% =:
(*+A*++%(-
- /*%'<@:
6/*;#$% /%+6&,(%,$+ &- = '*<%( #, #66<*)#$*&, 5%'&/% ! :
+%%9*,1 /%+$&/#$*&, )&4/+% &4$<%$ &- :
4(2<#(# /#,)2:
>2*)2 )<#*A%( $& 5% (%A&<*+2%( '&/ #5&4$ 9#/#A+ &, +&4$2%/, +*(% 6%$*$*&,%/+7 9*<<# &- -
6&, /%)%*6$ +#*( #66<*)#$*&,:
/%6&/$ '/&A B*<%(#/:
%%/&9%:
)#<<%(C >2& #'$%/ *,+6%)$*,1 +6&$ +45A*$$%( 2*+ /%6&/$ $& !*;*+*&,#<
''*)%/:
#,#< !*;*+*&,:
4(2<#(#:
>2%/%*, *$ +$#$%( $2#$ $2%/% *+ # 64))# )&4/+% &, 5&$2 +*(%+ #66/&?*A#$%<@ 9#/#A+ )&4/+% *+ (%A&<*+2%( +&4$2%/, +*(% 92#+/# &- :
#))&/(*,1<@:
/%+$&/#$*&, +#*( )&4/+% /%)&AA%,(%(-
2% !*;*+*&,#<
''*)%/ '4/$2%/ '&/>#/(%( )#+% $& ! - - 2% !
46&, %?#A*,#$*&, A#$$%/ #'$%/ #''&/(*,1 &66&/$4,*$@ 2%#/*,1 $& )&,)%/,%( 6#/$*%+:
&/(%/%( /%+$&/#$*&, (%A&<*+2%( )&4/+%:
;*(% 2*+ &/(%/ (#$%( --
,,%?4/% = 2&<(*,1 #+ 4,(%/
!" #
$%
& '
($ ) &
*
%
& '
() &
+ ,+),)!+-
. / . !0,+),)!+- $
1
'
'
"2
$
+!
$
$ +3,) ()2,) $ 3+
$
. !"44 (
5
'
3 +60 / 7 $ ) +6-#8 - %*,1 #11/*%;%( #1#*,+$ #'&/%+#*( &/(%/ (#$%( --
,,%?4/% =:
6/%'%//%( #, #66%#< 5%'&/% 0 :
>2*)2 #<+& (*+A*++%(:
;*(% &/(%/ (#$%( --
,,%?4/% 2&<(*,1 #+ 4,(%/
$
$ $
-3 5 $ +! $
$$
$ +3,) )2,) $ 3+ +!
$
!4492:'
, !4492:
$ $ $
)!!2)!+3
$
'
;
<
5 /
'
;
<
5
/
'
$
$
!0!))!+3
8 - , #'&/%A%,$*&,%( )*/)4A+$#,)%+:
2#;% '*<%( 6/%+%,$ >/*$ 6%$*$*&, 5%'&/% $2*+ &4/$:
+%%9*,1 /%<*%'
+:
#+ ,&$*)%( #5&;%-
- 8%#/,%( )&4,+%< '&/ +45A*$+ $2#$ )#,#< #4$2&/*$*%+ 5%<&> 2#;% %//%( <#> '#)$ &/(%/*,1 /%+$&/#$*&, (%A&<*+2%( )&4/+% >*$2&4$ #+)%/$#*,*,1 )&//%)$ 6&+*$*&, %?*+$*,1 #$ +6&$-
2*<% /%'%//*,1 $& +*$% 6<#,
,,%?4/% :
)&4,+%< '&/ 6%$*$*&,%/ +45A*$$%( $2#$ <#,( *+ )&A6/*+%(
%)$- &- :
D*<<# &- :
=:
:
+2&>, 6*,9 )&<&4/:
>2%/%#+ <#,( 6/*;#$% /%+6&,(%,$+ $2%*/ /%<#$*;%+ *+ )&A6/*+%(
%)$- &- :
D*<<# &- :
C
%)$- &- =:
D*<<# &- :
:
=:
%$)-
+2&>, 1/%%, &/#,1% )&<&4/-
$ *+ '4/$2%/ +45A*$$%( $2#$ &, +&4$2%/, +*(% D*<<# &- :
:
$2%/% *+ # )&4/+% +2&>, 5<4% )&<&4/:
>2*)2 *+ )&A6/*+%( D2#+/# &- ,%?$ $& )&4/+%
&, +&4$2%/, +*(% $2%/%&':
$2%/% *+ # /&#( +2&>, /%( )&<&4/ $2%, <#,( 6/*;#$% /%+6&,(%,$+ *+ $2%/% #+ +2&>, 1/%%, &/#,1% )&<&4/-
$ *+ +45A*$$%( $2#$ )&4/+% D2#+/# &- #, &<( &,%:
>2*)2 (*+A#,$<%( 4,.#5 #$%/
%+&4/)%+ #,#1%A%,$ !%;%<&6A%,$ &/6&/#$*&,
/%+6&,(%,$ &- '&/ *$+ /%)&,+$/4)$*&, %,$*/% *++4% #/&+% $2%/% >2%, /%)&,+$/4)$*&, +#*( )&4/+% +$#/$%(-
$ *+ +45A*$$%( $2#$ 6/*;#$% /%+6&,(%,$+ 2#( *,'#)$ %,)/&#)2%( 46&, #/%# /&#( '#<<*,1 #(.&*,*,1 $& $2%*/ <#,(+ D*<<# &- :
&, #))&4,$
+#*( %,)/&#)2A%,$:
/&#( #+ >%<< #+ )&4/+% >%/% +2*'$%( $&>#/(+ <#,( 6%$*$*&,%/+-
$ *+ ,%?$ +45A*$$%( $2#$ 2#( ,& &5.%)$*&, *'
)&4/+% *+ )&,+$/4)$%( >*$2*, #/%# )&4/+% )&A6/*+%( D2#+/# &- #'$%/ *$+ (4% 6/&6%/ (%A#/)#$*&, +& $2#$ #/%# )&A6/*+%( D*<<# &- :
=:
:
*+ ,&$ (*A*,*+2%(-
&>%;%/:
*$ *+ )&,$%,(%( $2#$ #,#< 4$2&/*$*%+ (*( ,&$ 1%$ (%A#/)#$*&, #/%# )&,(4)$%( !
>/&,1<@ 6#++%( *A641,%( &/(%/ (#$%( --
,,%?4/% =:
>2*)2 &/(%/ '4/$2%/ 462%<( 0 :
;*(% *$+ &/(%/ (#$%( --
,,%?4/% -
$ *+ '4/$2%/ )&,$%,(%( $2#$ ;*/$4#<<@ /%+$&/#$*&, )&4/+% 2#+ 5%%, &/(%/%(
*<<%1#<<@ <#,( >2%, ,& +4)2 )&4/+% %;%/ %?*+$%( $2%*/ <#,( ,&/ 2#( %;%/ (%A&<*+2%( +#*( )&4/+%-
$ *+ #<+& +45A*$$%( $2#$ &, #))&4,$ *,.4+$*)% 5%*,1 (&,% /%+6&,(%,$ &- &/6&/#$*&,:
2#( $& '*<% # +4*$ '&/ 6%/A#,%,$ *,.4,)$*&, >2%/%*, #, *,$%/*A *,.4,)$*&, /%+$/#*,*,1 <#@*,1 #,@ )&4/+% #/%# 6#++%(:
2&>%;%/:
+45+%E4%,$<@:
&, #))&4,$ 6#++*,1 *A641,%( &/(%/+
,,%?4/% = ,,%?4/% :
+#*( +4*$ )#A% $& 5% (*+A*++%(:
;*(% .4(1A%,$ (%)/%% (#$%( --
,,%?4/% :
6#++%( *;*<
4(1%
4,*&/ !*;*+*&,:
4(2<#(#- $ *+:
$2%/%'&/%:
+45A*$$%( $2#$ *A641,%( &/(%/+ #/% 6#$%,$<@ *<<%1#< 6%/;%/+%:
#))&/(*,1<@:
+#A% 5% +%$ #+*(%-
- %/ )&,$/#:
)&4,+%< #66%#/*,1 '&/ 0$#$% 4,.#5 *,'&/A+ &4/$ $2#$ )&4/+% 2#+ 5%%, /%+$&/%( #$ +*$% >2%/% *$ %#/<*%/ /4,,*,1 '&/ <#+$ A&/% $2#, @%#/+-
$ *+ '4/$2%/ +45A*$$%( $2#$ 2#( (%A&<*+2%( )&4/+% &, #))&4,$
>2*)2 %;%, # )#+%
/%1*+$%/%( )&,+*(%/*,1 %,$*/% A#$$%/:
#,#< 4$2&/*$*%+ 2#( /*12$<@ &/(%/%( /%+$&/#$*&, (%A&<*+2%( )&4/+% #$ +*$%-
8%#/,%( 0$#$% )&4,+%< '4/$2%/ *,'&/A+ $2#$ #<$2&412:
6/*;#$% /%+6&,(%,$+ >%/% '&4,( 6&++%++*&, +&A% #/%# /&#(:
2&>%;%/:
6/%+%,$<@:
$2*,1+ #/% 6<#)% ,& *,$%/'%/%,)% *+ /%E4*/%( $& 5% A#(% *A641,%( &/(%/+-
+ /%1#/(+ #<<%1#$*&,+ $2#$ (%A&<*+2%( )&4/+% 2#+ 5%%, /%+$&/%( <#,( 6%$*$*&,%/+:
*$ *+ +45A*$$%( $2#$ +#*( +45A*++*&, A#(% 6%$*$*&,%/ 5%'&/% *;*< &4/$ #+ >%<<:
2&>%;%/:
2#( '#*<%( $& <%#( #,@ %;*(%,)% $2#$ /%1#/(:
#))&/(*,1<@:
$2%*/ )<#*A /%.%)$%(-
*$2 #'&/%+#*( +45A*++*&,+:
6/#@%/ '&/ (*+A*++#< *,+$#,$ >/*$ 6%$*$*&, A#(%-
- 2#;% 2%#/( )&4,+%< '&/ /%+6%)$*;% 6#/$*%+ 2#;% #<+& 6%/4+%( 6#6%/5&&9 >*$2 $2%*/ #5<% #++*+$#,)%-
=- , 6/%+%,$ )#+%:
#,#< 4$2&/*$*%+ 5%<&> >%/% &,<@ )&,)%/,%( /%1#/(*,1 /%+$&/#$*&, (%A&<*+2%( )&4/+% 4,(%/ 0%)$*&,
&/$2%/, ,(*# #,#< !/#*,#1% )$:
=-
'*,(*,1 '#)$ /%$4/,%( #,#< 4$2&/*$*%+ $2#$ )&4/+% E4%+$*&, *+ /4,,*,1 '/&A <#+$ @%#/+ +#*( )&4/+% A#(% 64))# #$%/
%+&4/)%+ #,#1%A%,$ !%;%<&6A%,$ &/6&/#$*&,:
!*;*+*&, &- :
#,+# #<+& $2#$ $2*+ )&4/+% 2#+ # 6%/A#,%,$ >#/#5#,(* 4,(%/ 0%)$*&, = )$-
$ 2#+ '4/$2%/ )&A% &, /%)&/( $2#$ %?*+$%,)% )&4/+% #$ +*$% 2#( 5%%, #(A*$$%( 6%$*$*&,%/+- =-
4/$2%/:
*$ *+ +$#,( $2#$ )&4/+% /4,,*,1 #$ +*$% 92#+/# &- :
>2*)2 #54$+ <#,( &, +&4$2%/, +*(% 9*<<# &- :
=:
:
-
=
%$*$*&,%/+ )<#*A $2#$ +*,)% +#*( )&4/+% 92#+/# &- &<( &,%:
+#A% (*+A#,$<%( /%+6&,(%,$ &- &/6&/#$*&, '&/ *$+ /%)&,+$/4)$*&, #$ $2#$ $*A% >2*<% /%)&,+$/4)$*,1 +#*( )&4/+%:
+#A% +&412$ $& 5% +2*'$%( $&>#/(+ <#,( #$ $2#$ $*A%:
&5.%)$%( $& +#A% $2%@ #<+& '*<%( # )*;*< +4*$ '&/ 6%/A#,%,$ *,.4,)$*&,- %$*$*&,%/+ +$#$% $2#$ $2%@ 2#;% ,& &5.%)$*&, *'
)&4/+% *+ )&,+$/4)$%( *$+ 6<#)% >2%/% *$ /4,,*,1 %#/<*%/ 92#+/# &- :
2&>%;%/:
*$ )#,,&$ 5% /%+$&/%( <#,( 6%$*$*&,%/+-
%$*$*&,%/+ )<#*A $2#$ )#+% )&4/+% *+ $& 5% )&,+$/4)$%( $2%*/ <#,( $2%, <#,( 2#+ $& 5% #)E4*/%( 6#@*,1 )&A6%,+#$*&, $& $2%A-
, &$2%/ 2#,(:
*$ *+ +$#,( 0$#$% $2#$ )&4/+% 2#+ 5%%, &/(%/%( $& 5% /%+$&/%( #$ +*$% D*<<# &- *$+%<'
+#A% 2#+ ,&$ 5%%, /%+$&/%( <#,( 6%$*$*&,%/+-
=- , ;*%> #'&/%+#*( +$#,(+ $#9%, /%+6%)$*;% 6#/$*%+:
*$ *+ $& 5% +%%, #+ $& >2%$2%/ )&4/+% 2#+ 5%%, A#(% <#,( &/ ,&$- =- , A@ )&,+*(%/%( ;*%>:
#'&/%+#*( *++4% #+ /%1#/(+ )<#*A $2#$ )&4/+% 2#+ 5%%, A#(% $2%*/ <#,(:
+$#,(+ #,+>%/%( '*,(*,1+ /%$4/,%( )*;*< )&4/$ >2%/% 2#( '#*<%( $& <%#( #,@ %;*(%,)% $2#$ )&4/+% 5%*,1 A#(% $2%*/ <#,(-
2% /%<%;#,$ '*,(*,1+ *;*< &4/$:
/%#( #+ 4,(%/
++
$ )!+ "+#*1/+
+
"
6 = ++ &
=
3+,,+3,) 9#"0:
)2,) 92"2:
>
) &
.
9
:
0 "
)! = 6 &
=
3+,,+ 93"!:
+093"!:
+3,+92"6:
&
4
$
/%+ /%2
&
*1 /0 *1 /3
$ ?
=
!)
7
=
3+,,+3,+ )2,)
$ +)
1
!" #
4
5
1
*1 + *1
1
/%+/% @
$
$
*1 + *1
$
$
$
$
$
7
@
$
$
+ 4
5
1
& 7 .
/%+ /%)
.
/% ?
.
*1 +*1
*1 + *1 ,
=
*1 + *1 $
$
$ $
=
/%+
1
= $
$
/%)
.
/% ?
.
1
= $
$
*1 +*1
$
1
+ ;
= =
=
3+,,+3,+ )2,)
/%+
1
1
!" #
.
/%)
.
=
1
+!
/% ?
.
1
1
#
A 1 =
*1 +*1
1
$
1
*1 +*1 +! #
$
1
$ (
/%+
1
7
/%)
.
/% ?
.
7
=
$
7
@
@
$
/%+/%
$
*1 +*1
=
*1 +*1
!" #
@ 1
+2 4
45 6- !+++)!+0&
45 $
+ ) 2
=
@ +!! 45 $
# ,+3-, 06,2)0 5/'
45 $ & $
/%+ & 7 .
45 6- !+++)!+0
$
)!! )!+6
$. = ?
/.*"5 .
'
;
/ '
5
/ *1 2
$
+ ) 2
)!!2)!+3 $
=
@
$
@
$
@
7
+#
1
%+ %
1
$
!" #
$
1
%+
B 5 *1
$ / =
$ $ $
)#" !
5
8 ($
*1
$
$
$
$
$
$ $
1
!" #
+-
$ $
A
5
$
$
;
7
1
!" #
4
$
!" #
$
$
7
!" #
+0
8 =-
/&A # 6%/4+#< #5&;% %?$/#)$%( .4(1A%,$:
*$ *+ %;*(%,$ $2#$ )&4/+% *+ /4,,*,1 '/&A <#+$ @%#/+ #$ +#A% 6<#)% !%6#/$A%,$ /%)&,+$/4)$*,1 )&4/+% E4%+$*&, &, +#A% 6<#)% >2%/% *$ %?*+$+-
2%/%'&/%:
&,)% 2#;% '#*<%( $& +2&> $2#$ )&4/+% 2#+ 5%%, /%+$&/%()&,+$/4)$%( $2%*/ <#,(:
$2%/% *+ ,& +)&6% '&/ #,@ *,$%/'%/%,)% $2*+ &4/$ '*,(*,1
/%$4/,%( #,#< 4$2&/*$*%+-
#$2%/:
*;*< &4/$ 2#+ 1&,% $& %?$%,$ +#@*,1 $2#$ *'
)&4/+% *+ #/%# +4*$ 6/&6%/$@ &>,%( 6<#*,$*''+
2%/%*, #+ *$ *+ /4,,*,1 '/&A <#+$ @%#/+:
$2%, 6<#*,$*''+
2%/%*, 2#;% #66/&6/*#$% /%A%(@ 4,(%/ <#> $& +%%9 6&++%++*&, +#A% #'$%/ #(&6$*,1 (4% 6/&)%++ <#>-
& +4)2 +$%6+ #66%#/ $& 2#;% 5%%, $#9%, 6%$*$*&,%/+- - D%%6*,1 ;*%> #'&/%A%,$*&,%( '#)$+ )*/)4A+$#,)%+:
(& ,&$ '*,( #,@ A%/*$ *,+$#,$ >/*$ 6%$*$*&, +#A% *+ #))&/(*,1<@ (*+A*++%(-
- %,(*,1 #66<*)#$*&,
+:
*'
#,@:
+2#<< #<+& +$#,( )<&+%(-
0
!
- -
+.9+ 2%$2%/ +6%#9*,1/%#+&,%(
"%+
& 2%$2%/ /%6&/$#5<% "%+
&