Rampal And ANR v. Ambuj Bajaj And ORS
!" #"$%&%'( )
) *+ , '# '!-". ++",, '!& /".&0& *102 2 2 '#!-".& "&+'#"'!&
."&"'!( .&-%&- ''03#4$ !" .!-" ++",, '!& .5 0. 1-6 +.3#4$ !" . .&-%! ,%73#4$ !" .."&+'#"'!& ./%'#0+! 3#4$ !" .."&+'#"'!89'&0. '$" *+ ':
-%& ++" , - & 1""' %,"# 1: !-" $, %* '!& &""7%'; "'- '$"*"'! !-" $*+"'& !%' < .#"# ! !-"* 1: !-" ," .'"# !. $$%#"'! , %*& .%10' ,3 5'"+ ! =.%10' ,> . &-.! 4%#" < .# # !"# ?
@ ' $$0'! #" !- !-"%.&' 260* .%' *!. 4"-%$," $$%#"'!'
8 -" $, %* '!&3 <- ." !-" + ."'!& !-" #"$" &"#3 %,"# +"!%!%'0'#".5"$!%'
!-"!./"-%$,"&$!&""7%';$*+"'& !%' ' $$0'! #" !- !-"%.&' 260* .#0"!%'20.%"&."$"%4"#%' *!. 4"-%$," $$%#"'! <-%$- !7 +, $" '
8 8
# !"#
8 < & .";%&!"."# 0'#". 5"$!%'& ? '# 8 @A ! ,%$" 5! !%'60'#,% ; %'&!."&+'#"'!!< &+," #"#!- !!-"#"$" &"# ! !-"!%*" -%&#" !-< & ' ;.%$0,!0.%&!31"&%#"&.0''%'; # %.: .*%&
!! ,*'!-,:%'$*"< &&! !"#!1"&)3
9A"< & :" .&,# ! !-"!%*" $$%#"'!*+"'& !%'< &!-0&+. :"# . -"," .'"#.%10' ,'$'&%#". !%' !-" $!& '#"4%#"'$" '."$.#-",#!- !!-" $$%#"'!%'B0"&!%'!7+, $"#0"!!-". &- '# '";,%;"'! #.%4%';
"'#%'; 4"-%$," 1: %!& #.%4". -"." %& ' #%&+0!" ."; .#%';!-" 14"& %# %'#%'; !-"," .'"#.%10' ,'!-%&%&&0"3<-%$- - & !! %'"# %' ,%!: C" .'"# .%10' , 0.!-". &&"&&"# !-" ;" !-" #"$" &"# & :" .& !!-"!%*" -%&#" !- '#%'$*" !-"#"$" &"# < & &&"&&"# & &
9A +". *'!- "#0$!%' D < & "
"$!"# !< .#& !-" +".&' , "E+"'&"& & -" < & 1 $-",. !". ++,:%'; *0,!%+,%". @3 !! , #"+"'#"'$: < & &&"&&"# ! &3 @3
9A '!-". &0* &
9A< & < .#"#!< .#& 0'". ,"E+"'&"&-0&3 ++",, '! < & -",# "'!%!,"# . !! , $*+"'& !%' &3 ?3
9A ,'; <%!- %'!"."&! F D +". ''0* .* !-" # !" %,%'; $, %* +"!%!%' !%,, ." ,%& !%', %* ++",, '!< &#"$,%'"# C" .'"# $0'&", . !-" ++",, '!& .;0"& !- ! %'$." &" %' %'$*"' $$0'! 0!0."+.&+"$!&&-0,#1"
.#"#F@ D%'4%"< !%' ,'&0. '$"*+ ':C!#/&. ' :5"!-% '#!-".&3
@ %4%,
? "#0$!%' D - & .%;-!,: 1""' "
"$!"# ' $$0'! +".&' ,"E+"'&"&0,!%+,%". )%'&!" # @&-0,#1" ++,%"#*0'! < .#"# 0'#". !-" $'4"'!%' , -" #& '""#& ! 1" "'- '$"# & +". !-" 20#;*"'! !-" '>1," 50+."*" 0.! %' ;* "'". , '&0. '$" *+ ':C!#/& '0 * ,% &-0-.0 * '#!-".&3%'%4%,++" , ?)
)#"$%#"#') ?
)!%&!-0&+. :"#!- !!-%& ++" ,1" ,,<"# '#$*+"'& !%' < .#"#1""'- '$"#
8 C" .'"# $0'&", . !-" '&0. '$" *+ ': - & ."
0!"# !-" 14" & %# .;0*"'!& <-%," &01*%!!%'; !- ! !-" %*+0;'"# < .# - & $.."$!,:1""'+ &&"# '#';.0'# . ':"'- '$"*"'!%&* #"0! - 4" -" .# ," .'"# $0'&", . !-" + .!%"& '# - 4" ;'" !-.0;-!-"."$.#<%!-!-"%. 1," &&%&! '$" !%&'!%'#%&+0!"!- !#"$" &"##%"##0"!%'20.%"&."$"%4"#%' *!.4"-%$," $$%#"'!<-%$-!7+, $"'
8#0"!!-". &- '# '";,%;"'!#.%4%'; !-"
"'#%';4"-%$,"1:."&+'#"'!'$*" !-" #"$" &"#%&'!%'#%&+0!"'4%"< !-";0%#",%'"&, %##<'1:!-"'>1," 50+."*" 0.! %' !%' , '&0. '$" *+ ': C!# /& . ' : 5"!-% '# !-".&3
@ %4%,
?3 @ D %'$." &" %' %'$*" - & ! 1"
.#"#' $$0'! 0!0."+.&+"$!& "#0$!%' D- &.%;-!,:1""' "
"$!"#' $$0'! +".&' ,"E+"'&"& &!-"#"$" &"#< &0'* ..%"# '4%"<20#;*"'! !-"'>1,"50+."*"0.!%' ;* "'". ,'&0. '$" *+ ':C!#/& '0 * ,% &-0-.0 * '#!-".&3%'%4%,++" , ?)
) #"$%#"# ' ) ?
)3 &@
9A " $- - & ! 1"
.#"#!!-"$, %* '!&!< .#& %,% ,$'&.!%0*-"$, %* '!& .""'!%!,"# ! &3
9A " $- . ,&& "&! !" '# 0'". , "E+"'&"& %'&!" # & 3
9A
.#"#!< .#& 0'". ,"E+"'&"& *+"'& !%'!1" < .#"#%&!-0&."A<.7"# &0'#".(A
'$*"
+* %"3
9A+". ''0*
! ,%'$*" !". ##%!%' ! !-". !" @ D' $$0'!
0!0."+.&+"$!&
)3)
E@ D H3
3)
9A
@ 8 '$*" !".#"#0$!%' D ' $$0'! +".&' , "E+"'&"& 3
3)
I 3@
3
3)
H 3@
9A @ ! ,#"+"'#"'$: !". ++,:%'; *0,!%+,%". ) 3@
)H?3
9A C&& "&! !" 3
9A
C&& 0'". , 3
9A C&& %,% ,$'&.!%0*!!-" $, %* '!&F&@
9A" $- )
9A" $- 3 3
9A -" *0'! $*+"'& !%' ,." #: < .#"#!!-" ++",, '!&3 '""#,"&&!& :3&- ,,&! '##"#0$!"# .*!-" *0'!$ ,$0, !"# & 14" ++",, '!&&- ,,1""'!%!,"#!%'!"."&! !!-". !" D+". ''0*'!-" "'- '$"# *0'! .*!-"# !" %,%'; !-"+"!%!%'!%,,." ,%J !%'
%."$!%'& !-".%10' ,%'."&+"$!!* ''". #%&10.&"*"'! !-"$*+"'& !%' *0'!!!-"$, %* '!&&- ,,"'0." K%!-!-" 14"& %#*#% %$ !%'%'!-" < .## !"#?
@3 +."&"'! ++" ,%&#%&+&"#
$!1". )3
) &-< . K-"!-".&+" 7%';9." &'"#(A "&9 K-"!-".."+.! 1,"(A "&9