High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCS-OS/36/2016allowed

M/S Laggar Industries Limited v. State Of Haryana & ORS.

2017-01-17Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath12 pages

!!"#$#%& '

'

($)**+%,-$ +#!$)#.# !, ! # #%!+ /$ 0 !+1%%, 2!+$ !$3%,!% $ & 4) 0 505

!"

####

505 67+89

$%

& %'( (( ')(*+, (-. /" 0 '/" /%/

/ 1 " 2 !"2"2 !" '3 () ')(- '4 (( ')(-

!" %% 5 6 + $ /. %/

!

"#$

"#$

% %&'&

! "()()*(

$

$

+ % %& , '&

! + ()()*( *"

*"

!" +/ /./ 7 / / /-8 "')(*

'))

// - "')(*

1 %/ %

4) ')(* / / / //" /%

/

/%90 ''(:; ')(* 7<%%1 < !" /" ':

() ')(* 0 '$ (4 () ')(*+, (( ./" % $%

%

" %

0 '

" % (= (( ')(*

% '( (( ')(* >% % " " $ ?

@ /$

/" !" / % % / "/% 0 (4)'

= '))= /"5>A

':

= ')(*

/

/ " & 7/$ " " " %% +:. 701 % (-)))-)))/()))) $

/$?

@> "= ')(*/ % "'= ')(* % /" A 1 / $?

/ "

'= ')(* (*;+'. ')(4 1

/

%/ /"5>A

1$ 7A / <?15 ?+15.? :% ? @ 1 / 0 '/%" /"

1 % / % <%%1 < $?

>

5? //" /"% "'3 ;

')(* "B < /(4) /""

<%%1 <$?

9 "

: $ ?

% " '= )* ')(* % C1 /

" / ,

"

""/ %$?

1

//>/" / / 0 +:. %/ % +:.B

/ /

%+:./% B6 /

7 / "D& 7/$ " " "%% +:. 701

1%

?!% 2%%2

%2%9 ')()+'3.5 +.-4(& / , /% /& %&

" / 1

/ "

% " (-)))-))) /()))) $ %/ /"0 1 < + E1.'3 ')(*/"

% /

% " (-)))

; -)))/()))) $ ! / "/ $ ?

%"

/ /

" / < /

"%/ % / // %%/" % %/ $/ E /%%%/

% " $ ?

% / - = ')(* %

/% / //$ 1 /

$?

/ "

'= ')(*

/ / // - = ')(*

'))

/"

/ 0 ' / %

% % 0 ('

= '))= @ "

1%

/" 6E

6?0 ((*- '( () ')(*0 ((==''

() ')(*

0 (4)'

= '))= /"

$?

@ / $?

/

0 :(-=3)-*':

')(* " " 0 0E-**=): % 1 /

"% +:. 701

%/ % /

"& 7/$ " " " +:. 701

6

%& % /" +.

9 "% /" " %

A (*;+'. ')(4F +.

90 (4)'

= '))=

"F +.

9 /> /" /%

%A " 2& 7A$ "

" " +:.

701 9 +:."&

'

/ //"

F +.

9

% "

(-)))-)))/()))) $

//F 1& /"/ 1 G 0 (

$?

"% A = ')(* !$?

%

'= ')(*

A % A '= ')(*

%% B5 A " /" %/"

"

'=7)*7')(* / "/ /" H 15 ('

5%

"

3 = ')(* 1

" /"0 1 < '3 ')(* / " / % '= ')(* 1

% $

< " /" / % (*; ')(4 = < !$#*% #%,#+!" + +(."%

/"%%% "

A $ "5% " /

/ % " %% %/" "

" %% % 5%"" % "/ /

+'. % $

/" " " /"

% / / %

%

+4.9 "%

(*=

/

>

& /

/" " % %

(*;+'.%" % $

%/" /" " /" 1 $?

% '= ')(* /" " %A

/ "

'= ')(*

% " % 1 "/ 7 "

% / % "

'= ')(* % &

%

(*;+'. ')(4 % //" "/" " $

%

1 & % /"

% / " /

, ('" %%

" %

'3 ;

')(* // /% "$?

/"/"

/ " / , $ ?

"% %% / /" $ ?

" %"

"

%"& % %/"

% / @ / / /" % /

%& % % % 0 +:. 701 / :

01 % B

/ / 1 %

/ %:):* " +:.

1 /> /" "% +:.

%

/ / % 0 +:.

% > %

/" 2%%2 +

.

& " & & %% "

(-))) -))) / ()))) $ / " /"

0 1 <+ 1. '= ')(*

% " (-)))-)))/()))) $ 1 '3 ')(*/

"

E

'= ')(* // % 5% 0 1 < %

$?

'3 ')(* "&

& %"

/ /& % "

% /"

"% /"& %

% / / / /

/" $/" "

1$/"/"

/

9/ /"

%-+1 '6

' 7 505 9 +!%- 9

$%7 I70 95 / I70