Mohit Gupta v. Union Of India Through Narcotics Control Bureau, Chd
!
" #!$%&%"'( )*) "+% ,-
))))! % %"'!.
/!.&,&
'%"'
" '#% +.",0+ .$" %$& "' ."1 ,.! ,2 + '#%0 .+
)))))!&-"'#!'
( 34 ) 5 /65 4
7777 /65 42 )
4
!"
#
!!$%& '( &'&' )&%&&&" ('
* + , %")-
& .# / # 5.)") 5!08!' &
.
"&)
0!
"&)
%
0$ ! & ! & # 1 ! 1 !
#
) 1 )
#
#
" ) %%
- 2 %' %1 %% &1 345 3 56# %% %- %& %- , ,+ 3527 3 5 %( %( 3445 %1 %( &1 34445 %) &' &1 &) !
#.8 / # 0/# #/ 0 %'
'( &'&' #/ 0%& '( &'&'
9 7 # / / # # , : ; * * , 0 %& '( &'&' #.8 #.8 # 0 0 / # &'''' # 9, %'' # 3
# %'' :5//# #. 8 / #. 8 # # , 8# 3$ * 5#8# * 2< , %& '( &'&'
# /* * ; : 2< 8#
#
8# !1''' # 9,%'' # 3
# %'' :5 4 #.8 # # %& '( &'&'/ # :
08# / #/ 8# #.8 # # ; # :
0 8# / % '( &'&' / # = / :
08# # .8 / /
# / #,:
08# 9 . // #. :
08# ,
% '% &'&% :
&!&&' &'&'
8# # # # / '& ') &'&'
// ., 6 0 & %% &'&'
> # ,'& ') &'&'3&, %#5
# , &&//#, = # 0, 0# 4
# ,
> # / / ,/ ,, # ,
# :
08# , % '% &'&% - ? # , %& '% &'&& ,*
@
!
! "
&& ') &'&& , 9A #
"
# $ !
"
%"
&
'' B (( "(
)
*
+
, !
! *
-.
! '1 '& &'&' , 9A #
(
"
"
/'0 B !!
1 "
2
, !
! * 3!
"B '- ') &'&& ,9A # (
"
"
*
B- "
5
!
- "(
*
B '% ') &'&& ,9A #
"
# $ !
"
%"
&
'4 0 :
!
+ ;
, !
! * 3!
"B 4# ( ; # # , # / :
08# // / / #.8 #.8 8# #.8 8# / / 4 # :
08# / / / , ,
:
&!&&' &'&'% '% &'&% > # :
0 8# / / # #. 8 0 / / 4# = /
#.8 /:
08# # / /, / = /
#. 8 / :
0 8#
4 # # , # , / / #.8 :
0 8# 8# , # 4 #. # # / 8# / / #/ , 8# , #.8 /
# # # 4 # / ,# #
8# , #7 #
> .#9C # @, *
$
!
! * , ( "
< %/& .# ' , %1 '( &'&' @1
!
! * 6 .
2<
.#
= ".
!
!
! * ) ;
< #, # 4
C#D#
,# :
/ ,
2
/ , # 7# # # /0 &'%( #4 :C/ # ) >
# # / / , #. 8 2< / , # #/ #
. # 8# / # # 4# # # 4 = / # / # / / '% '% &'&' %& '( &'&' / # , 1&" = /
4 / / #// , #. 2< # / /
# # >
.# 9C #
@
!
! "
!
1 "E (
"
"
* %
!
* !
!
*
"
# $ !
"
% (
"&
4
* & %"
'1 &'&& 4 # ## 7 , !1 * / , 4
#, #. 8 # ,
% '% &'&% :
&)&'% &'&'
"
>
# ,
# // , #.8 # 8# / , # #
# # , # 4# # #, # # / , , #/ # , #/, 4#
, , # # /
# # C # 4 # / # ,
#.8 / / # # # #/ , # 8# /# 4 # / / # / # * * 2< 4 # , # / / # #
# # / # # 4 # / / # ## / #
,/ #, / = // # # # #, = / #, #.8 :
08# // / # 4#
, , = / 8# .#* 4' 4 @
!
! "
$
E
/ .# D.
9 @>
?
;2
( + "
!
! * -.
! !
@ "
-.
/ = / # # #
/ / , #, / , 4 , / / 0/ # # # # # / , # #,
> # # #.8 / , / , #
# , , # / #.8 / 0 / # # &'''' # 9, %'' #
3
# %'' :5 / # #!1''' # 9,%'' #3
# %'' :5/ # /# #. 8 # 4 # , # 4 # .# 9C # !
1 "A % &/
, # / / / # # /# # / # , # # , / # # , /
# / #6 / , , # . ,/ # , # 4 ,,
/ / % , ! # / , &, %# # , %'
0
%% 9A # (( "(
)
*
+B 3 5C B
! " "
# $ %
& / * %")- 24: )35&%35
&" / , # 35 / ## 7 , 9A # / 35, / , , / 0## %& 9A # !!
1 "
2 B
3 5/ 35 / , / % , 1 #
=# , '1 '& &'&' B'
" ( )*+,*-*
.
/01 2+3+ ,*-4 "
5)4# 1 -52 ,*-3
" # ,-6 1
7 #
8 -439 8
52
"
,-*+,*-3
:
-*
; $%
/ ,
17# 8 1 <
$% "
& %!
4- "
5
!
- "( B 3 5 9A # / B' " ,9*-,*,,
. ( 0 # # 0/ 1 --+!,*,, "
-3*2,*,*
1= 1 *,!,*,*
3,*,+688,3
,4 1
7 #
8 -439 "
08 <#
0
>
; $% "
"
$% " "
"
$% "
$ % 8 ( " & // ,/ =# ,&, %# %1 , / * %")- # , , / 35 % 9A # 4
!
+ ;
B 3 5 &8 ,4*+,*,,
' #
=
.
" ?:/ 1 2-, ,*,* -+-*,*,* ,-$% )+
17# 8
# =
= 7
*- *+ *4*2,*,,"
"
"
"
" " ' #
# $ %
& / / / * %")- !1 * %")-/ # # / # , , 35 , '%, '1# , / = # 35 ,# %- *
B
3 5 # 0 / # &%
4 /, !1 * %")-
%( '
+!
-.!&!'
$ &!2 +!
-! % %"'!.
+ & 9!!'
%'
$,& "#:
&%'$!
);)
:! .& '# 8"' + '# +!.!
.!
& 8 ':
&
-."&!$, %"'
<% '!&&!&2 ", " <+%$+2 "'1:
"'!
<% '!&& + & 9!!'
!= 8%'!# '# +,&2 +!
.% 1 %& 1%>!1:
"
>!
%8!) +!
-! % %"'!.
%&
& !# "
9!
'"
%'?"1?!# %'
':
" +!.
$ &!)
+!
9"?!& %#
@,#08!' & " +!
"'A91!
5,-.!8!
",.
+,& --1:
"'
",.&
"
+!
$ &!
" +!
-.!&!'
-! % %"'!.
'# +,&2 +!
-! % %"'!.
%&
!' % 1!# "
+!
0. '
" +!
$"'$!&&%"'
" .!0,1 .
9 %1 "'
+!
& %#
$",'
1"'!) %1 4 /
35 / :
0 8# / / # #.8 // # / ? # = / / # ## ,:
08# 9 . #.8 :
08# % '% &'&% :
08#
/ @9# 0 A
8
1
=
9+***
"
. -**$" 1
6-** /%
# <
= <
= " ? B :
1=
. # < :
2 0 A
:
( # < =
# #
+ : 8
3 "
B
# <
= < ? B 8
"
. -** $" 1
6-** /% "
-**2,*,* )+***
B -,*2,*,* # ,****
:
# <
/ <
= < ? B 8
4 8 7 = .
C , *
!
! * , ( "
% &
.
5(
1 "
*
%
& /
;
"
"
*
%& /
< A D : $ %
6
'="
'=
;6 @- @ 5,
17# 8 E !
@ 9) 17# 8 E @# ( E
,9 F 8 G ,
2+ 17# 8
5,
2+
E "'=
-9, @
5, 9)
17# 8
,9 F 8
8 -5 ,* $)% ,-
: HH :
5
;
"
"
% & .
5(
1 "
% &
"
;6 @$% "
9) 17# 8 @
E ,9 8
,9 F 8
17# 8 $%"
2+
17# 8
17# 8 E
-* :
1
=
6
2+ 17# 8 "
6 # <
? B"
8 6
, *
B
E 35 F 7 # 8# # (1 , , # , # $ #,#
, 35 #. 8 / / /
%& '( &'&' / # * * , 0 # # 2< # # / , 8# # # # # / , #. 8 / # #
, . #.8 # # / / 8# # , >
35 # /
8# / , # / , # / , 35 4 / # / 8# * * 7 # #/
; # # / # / # / # 35 ? = / / # *
!
! "
B
% &/ @ / <#
0
/ < # :
E 4 .# D.
9 >
?
;2
( +"
"
B % & @.
(
6
E .# / / / = /
# / # #
/ / #/ #, # 3= %5 / /
,/ 2<
= / #.8 :
08# ,
/ , # , / , 35 # #.8 ,
% '% &'&% :
&)&'% &'&' / #
# , " / #.8 / 0 # #/# # 0 / / * * # /&'''' # 9,3 %'' :5 / # , !1''' # 9, %'' # 3
#
%'' :5 # 2< : "
#.8 / @4 :
=
# " #
7"7 ,****
"
. $
6-** /%
)+***
= " ? B" E
4/ #.8 /
%& '( &'&' # % '% &'&% #.8 1 #,/ # &, %#, 4/ # #,:
08# :
08#
/ # / # /# , 35 ? .# , 9C
# !
1 "A
% & / /# .# / / / 3 5/ / # D 8# / / , 4 1 / %( .# / / # # /
# / # 6 / , , # . ,
## , / 4 , # ## , ) .# / / , ,
/ , #/ ,, / , # 3=5 4 ,9C #
* %'%- .# , 9C #
/ ## 7 , 0 9A # 4 %& %'
&'&' # (() &'&' @( !
$
) ( "
6 </ !0 )'' # @ E# , , / 0, 0 # 2 &- '& &'&% :
&'%11 &'&' // / , / !
) 0 @ E 3## 7 ,5 , % , 1 # / , 9A # & ') &'&% > 3 5
-)-&$&'&% B
!
! "
$
!<
2 * .# !% ') &'&% :
)&(& &'&% : !1&%
&'%- ) "
$
!
"
$!
!
;
! /, / ## 7 , 4 # * 0 /
$&% 4 / , 2 .# 9A
# !
! % , * " & $
# + G3&'&%5-
1& / 0 !1 * /
/ # , ,
/ 0, : / # * .# "
!
! * 6 .
2G &''1 3%5 :
:
3 # 5 !%( / 0* A 3 5/ / 4 .#/ / .# + 5( $
!
! * 6 .
2 &'%) 3 5:
:3 # 5) !1
* = / ## 7 , .# @
"
:
)+$-%$%$
%
=
)+$-%$%$%
C C
8
"
C C C 17# 8 C
.
.
0
6
:
"
'
!
E > 3 # 5* , &('" &'%) .#
/ #,9A # 4/ / , / , # ,
/ ,9C #
/ 0 ## , #,/ , /!1 %) 8 / , , %(.# / /,9C # / * %'%-.#
%1 .#/# / / , / $, $*,
. # 7 , , / % / #/
& / < $ # /35 !
/ = =#
## # / ## / - , , # 0 , # # , 7 / # # , #/ %"
4 , ,# &'
9/ 0 / # %- .# 9C #
!
! "
!
1 "
% &C
=# / , # / , .
/65 4
5!- !89!.
2
0 Whether reasoned/speaking?
Yes Whether reportable?
Yes