Aninda Sunder Nandi v. Union Of India & ORS
!"
#$
"%&'&#( )
*+, -.
)
/ 0 1 2
23
!
" # $%
"
&&'(&&% # "
)
* $+ % &,$'- . (/0 12
/ " 1 * *
&'
$& &,$'- . (%0 12
3" 12 12 . (/
1 * # $3 & &,$% - . ($,0 12 % "
1 * " $/2
&
* "
4 #
5 -
6453 $++$#1 7 " 12 # 5
8 $% 92 7* # 2 &,$$ 1 "*2 9
. 2 * :
* " * 1 * " : * * ;< #
# * &= ,& &,$/&& ,> &,$' 12
;< # . ($ (&
2
1 : " # 5 * 9 * * 9 *" * 2 " ?1 *? 9 9 " " *12 " 2
7" : 2" 12 9
" *
?&+ ,> &,$3 "" # 5 "" 1 * " : " ? " *1 "
9 " 2 "" 9
" 2 * 2"
" *2 2 1 * : " " 2 9 : *2 2 2 *1 7"
" : 12
#**
) " * 2 $> ,& &,$/- . (=0
#** * *
2 @ * * " *
9 "
2 *
"
2
9 " .
(3 =
: "
2" 2" " # 5
9 *
" * 9 ) 1 ) 2" * 1 2*
9 <) 2? 1* ,+ ,'
&,$'
2
* 7 " ) 2 * " 2 2 @ .* * " <) 2? * @ .* " " : "
12
? 1 ) ,+ ,'
&,$'
*
$+ ,% &,$' - . @/0 " " 12 " 1 * 2 *
* 1
" "1 2 =/A =/,,(@ "
9
* . @/ 1 2" 2 2 "
12 * * * &'
$& &,$'- . @%0 "
. @/ @%
=
*
*
"
* . 2 "
* * *
;< # * * ;< . ($ (& " * : "
*
" :2 " 7"
* * * "" 2 * 2" " 9
*
" "*
"
2 12 " ) " 9 " ) 1 " ) 2 " 2 2 @ .* " 9 <) 2? 1* )
,+ ,'
&,$'" "
"1 * 9 2" * * * * . (/ 2
B " *2
* ** 12 # 5 1
* **" 2 3 1 * -< C ? 0 $+%$ - D D0
2 2" $3 ,& &,$%- . $,0
1
/
B " * *@1 " #
* " . ($& *" "
" " 2 * *1
9 " 1 # 5 ": " *1 1 : * " 2 )
) 2
* 2 ) <) 2? 2
2 2 2 * "1
2 @ .* "
: "
@
9 ) "
1*
1 2
. (/ * 2 )
1* 12 <) 2 ?
9 2
* 1 "2
'
* ** " . ($,"
9 * 2 + . ($, 1 * "
*1 %
7 1** 12 #
" *2*
"
5
" *&/ ,+ &,$3 "1 " " 12 9 *
* * 2 " 5 "" * * 2 * $> & &,$/ - . (=0 2* "": 12 E 2 ; * " * "2 " * >
1 ) 2 "
"
1 ( * 2( "
1 1 ) " 1 * 2 *
$+ ,% &,$'- . (/0 9 "
) " 2 " )
+
B
* " 2 2 @ .* " ) 2 " 2 2 7"
) 212 # " 2 "1 <) 2?
) 1 E 2 22
2 "
( * * 12 <) ? 2 2 )
": 2 7 1 2 * ) 1 11 * 1 2" ) $,
9 : 2* 12 # * . 2" * ) 2 1 21 ) # 2 # : " )
" * "
" 1 1 1 1 1 21 <) 2 ? " * : 12 @
# * 2 1 # * . # " * ) 2" *
2" ) "" : 127F1 * # (&#( #$ (6& (6 #!7"8'
1 *( '": 8 (.
; 5 2 < ." 7F1 .# 1
4@ 6$=
E " @ 2 1 7 # 2 @ 1
) 2
9 #
" 12 2 2" 12 # * 9 1 7 # 9 7 # .
"
&&'(&&% # @
9 7 # 2 " 4@ ) 2 12 * 2G ) 2 1 1 G
G 1 * *
12* . * G
" * 1 12
. G
2 "2 1 1
G
2 2
2 * *1 * G 2 2
2 * *1 " G 1 &&'(&&% # 7 # 4 -0 @ G -0 " ) * 1 ""G -0 ) 2 G - 12 G -
1 * " 1 1 - 0
"
*2 1 G - 0 2* :
$$ 2! !"
#$
(678 8 6"'7 (6 8'1 =1 28""
> # ?<- 2 - 7F1 .# 1
4@ 6%
9 7 #
&&' #
* ) 2 1
4 * " ) 2 12 2 * 1 1 1 " I *
" 2 " 2 ) 2 " *2 12 ) 2
7 # "
&&'
"
9 7 # *21 2 "
* ) * " 1 * ) " 1 * * 12* . * 12 " * 1 12
"
2 "2 1 2
1
*
*
) " 2 1 * " 1 1 ) 2 12 * " 1 * 1 1 7 #
"
&&' # H $&
2 * "
" 1 1 1 "
1 2 * 1 12 @ * $+ % &,$' - . (/0 12
/ &'
$& &,$'- . (%0 12
3
$=
9 .
2 "
12
$3 & &,$% - . ($,0 " 12 "
) 12 # 5* * 1 * *
2
* ** 1
* " ) * ** 9 1 2 2
* ** * 21
$3
2 * "
* * ;23
5
*+,
-.
1 I : ( J 4 K I 1 J K