Sandeep Verma v. Bachan Singh And ORS
!"#$ %&'( )!(''$ ! "
!"#$ "%& '&# ( ) * +,-& +%./0+ ***** )!(''$+% ++% + &0 +#+& +
+ , && +% 1&/&% -"# & '&/&& . ++& #+ .2 , !0& , +%%+ 2+ &$&+ +
+, && +%'&&0-"#. $+%+ /& 2 &0 ++% , +%%+ +#+& +
+ , 40"& # 1" + &$&.
&$& # #0, 40"& #1" 5+0 + & # 6 &%+"& & , 2+, 0& &0 0 +#$ %%+
0 %+ $+"& #*+ +% $+%+.+&%& +6 %+&
4"6+#+& 7+!8"$+.$&9+% $+ + . +& 8"$+ +*"
%++ 5+%/& # 5+,+$& # "& 2+ 0 /& !"#$ + 0 +
%/+ 4+0 $ +$++ %%2)6
:
;
/&2 $, # +/ +& &". 0&+%%, &"
+ "& %+& &
"00 + +$ & , 4 + 02& 0 & ,2+, 0& &0 0 #$ %%+
#+& # %+ $+"& #8< +& # * 2+=* ++"
& >?>=
* ++ > == >==3 $+"& #8<?2 %+ * 2+=* ++"
&> =
* ++ > == 3== 6 . >== .+% .+%%+ $+"& #86 + !+$++ & ,+
?6 &"+ + /&%%+# ++& #+ @5 ++& #+ .$+%+ +,$ +%+ 0 +% 0 &+& 7.>>.
=6 " +% +% 0 &+& 7 .>>.
=6 + 0%++& + +% + >
40" , + & +/" 3 & 0 %+ $+"& #*+ +%<36= +%+& # = +" 86?+& #* 2+=* ++"
&>?>=
* ++ > == >==3& 2 #. &%%#+% "%% + /&. &
0&/ + & & # " &# %+& &
+ & , +& + +& $+%& +& #.0 "0& #+ 0+& #+ ,0 +#/ %+ A"& + ,$+
'0 ++00& #%, &%0 &# 0$+ "0$%&+ 0B 5+0 + & # &% + +%&0+& 40"& +&02 & +%%+ &% &+,!0& 1" + +/& # + 0"
+&. &$& !0& + + , 40"& # 1" +
&$& ++% 1"
+%%+ + ++&% # 1" %2 &$+&%, 0"
; & +#" + "# & & +$& + +%%+ & + + + "0 + ,/&+%+
3+ ?
> " +$& &, /&& 0& > + (,0. & C 0D !"#$ + 0+
+ +& , 0 %& 0
&/+ 02& -' , 0 0+%& # " + $+&+% +0 + %+,& # +" " !0 "+ &+ & 0 . & & +#" + 5+%/ & #
3& ++& 0++ +& 8"$+ + + &%& # 2& +$ ;& " +#" ++ !0 ++&+%+ 2 0 %+ -' + 0%%"& & # + A"& +0. & 2+ & 0"$ " 40"& #1" +$&"+ $& +&+"0/& 0. . +, 1"%2+%&+%+& $+ "% $& 40"& # 1" 0&& + %%2& #"0& +00+ 02& %+2;
" &0 . + !"#$ &1"5 +#2+ 5+&/ 1 &+ !&9+%+ + .
>7171&/&%? ? ; +/ +0"
+ " +6 * ; & + "
&" && 0+ + +%%+ & + + + "0 + , & &" $ +& 8"$+ + 5+%/ & # 3 /& #& +% +
3 +
?
> 0& 0 /, +& , +%%+ . & &
0+, 0& > 0+ +%/+ 4+0 $ ++ %%2)6
!"# $" % "#
'"& # 0,& + ,0" +/& #+" &,2& & %&$& ;
&+ 40%"& # + -+$$" + 8+ $& E/ $ +%& , "0 %&$&, 1 +%E/ $ + ,"& 0& #2 &0 & 0%%"&/+ 2 &0 + ,&# &$$/+% ,&&0%,+ 0& &0+%%,& A"& . ,0+
+ 2&+%2& ,+ ,+, "&0& # ++
0 &# + , +, "
+ ,0 2 &0 $+,$+ & .40"
+" &, 0" "0 $+&$+,&$B
%+& +& # 0& > 2"%$+*&/& +"% +%% +%,2 "&0& #+0%%"&/ A"& ++& 0 &+& &2 $
+0 + +%%+ + +& + %+ + 0 +
+ +& , 0 %& 0
&/+ 02& -',0 0+%& # "+ $+&+% +0+ ,%+,& # +"" !0.&"
&0& +00 &0 + !0& 2+ A"& 0& + +$& # &" + +& /& 0;0+
& +/,!0& & A"& 0&, +$& # &"+"0& # /& 0, +& A"+%%,"& +& " +0+ 0&0"$+ 0 +0 &/&"+% 0+ + 2 &" +& , !0 A"& +!"&0+& +& /& 0 0+ 0& +& %+& # +& ;
0+ + + . &% & +&%2& +$ &0%+&$ %+& &
=0 % 0& &0 0 +#$ 5,2+, %&$& +,!0& ++ .& + 0+#&0+%%,+/ + , +/% %+ A"& + +"0 "& %+& &
/&$&+%#+& ++ >.& + %+ + + +% & + 3 /+%"+%0 &+& +%&& #" %+& &
' 3 + +% % & + & 0 %+& &
+&% $ &+ +#$ "0 ."& %+& &
& %&+%&$&2& 0 +/0%+%,%+ 2& +$ + "& , +%+, %. 2 2+ A"& && #& 2& %+& &
=0 %
> &++.++& 8"$++ 5+%/& # +/% ,& +/" +%%+ &%& # 2& +$ , . 2% 2& &# & & %& # + & + 0 %+& &
=0 % 65+0 + & # ;
0&0"$+ 0.&&&
&0"%+000 +%%+ + /&2 %++&& !0& . %+ 0
&/+ 0 +"2+A"&0& +& &"=/& 0 !"#$ & 5 +#2+ 5+&D0+"+%&" , 0"
& &%,&
+0+ 0. &1" +00%+ +%%+ =!0 +A"& %+ ,5 +#2+ 5+&&A"&0& +& /& 0 +"0, +&+ +$& # &";
+&0+. =-' & + +#$ 2& !0=+%%+ +% %+ &"+ + 7 .
=6+0+ 40"+#$ +% +
+ 0&/ + "$ 7> .
=6 2+ + $ , '+ 40"& +% 2+ &4 +
"+0"+%& %+ &"2+%&/ +%%+
3
& + 0 +#$ +% & 0 +%0"% #&
. .&$
#&+& +% 2+ 4 2& $""+% +#$ "
?
+%& 0 %+ &"2+40"& +/"
0& &+%+ 0 +%0 &+& "7#&++ ,$%&0& 2+%&/ ; 2++%%#, +%%+ =!0 + $+ &$ 0%%"2& 0 %= + 40"+ &0&&" +#$ +% & 0 %+ & &" & & +/"
& +/& # +%+, 40" +#$ +% +
& +/" +%%+ + +% &0 2+ &0&&"%, %+ + 7.> .
=6+0. + 40"& +% 2+ &4 +
@2/. +& + 2+ $""+%%, 4
. 2 &0 +. 2++ +/ +
&0 " 7#&+. 7+ &+. " +%%# +/ +&% 0$ + + . &" + &0 0+%%& #" &$ 40" +%
7 2++ +/#
&0 " 7#&+
" 2+ +%%# +/ " "+ 0 A" %, &%+"&
& %+ &", 2+, 0& &0 0 +#$ +%+
>
+#+& +%%+ 2+ %&+%,$+++, "& ;
/&2 0"%&+ +0+ 0&0"$+ 0+& #& 0+ +" &,. 1" +&/ + + 0 0%"& + %+ 2 -'+ 0 %+&, !0 "0 +& & "&%+ 2+A"&0& +& /& 0 0 +,.& 0++ + . -' & &%&+&%&,40" +%2& +0& &0%+ +"&, ++%+, %, &++.+ 0 % ++%+, &%+"& +& +#$ %% !0 0+$ & &0" +& +% $+ & & +/" /& 2 +% 40""& # 0, 0& #. !00+
+ +, + 0 % + 0%%" 2& -' & & +& # + +#$ %% &%& # + "& 0& &0 0
?
;
/&2 +/.; + ,$&& 0 +&,0"
& + +& F #& #+ . ++% +&%+ &+00& #%, &$&& '()*+(, - .'/0 C'E"%+&D