M/S Mahesh Wood Products Pvt Ltd v. State Of Haryana And ORS

1









 !


   

"#$

$%&'&() *

+'
",$',
-
.-/%#'
0#
1#- 2$#&#&($.

3$.'/'

4#"#$

".5"("
"(-
#,$.'
2$'6(-$(#'

 )

71

4
 3
4 8
 9
 4 :1

4

 119
 







 



 


 

 



 
 
!




 "

 


  

 #$
 


" 

 
 
 
 

 

" 
 

 
% &  3
4 8
 9
 4
 1 '

$

 





 
 



"



 
()#(&

* 

+ 
% 

$

,
-


*"

 

* 

(.'/






! 

!

 
''

$
,
-



'01)
!
 

.( ./ (..2



 

 







(.'/

.' .'

(.')



"

 

 



-  
!


"




 

 

"
 
"

 

2

(

$
  

 
 

 ()#(&



(.'/
!
 


"

% 
3


4"

 
% 

5 





  

         



"

!
   

  

-





"


 
()#(&



(.'/
$
6
% 

  









 

 
 
()#(&



(.'/
!


 

  










 



7 
!


"
  



 
 
" !

     ! "

  # $#$  "  %   

 !"

"  ! "

! &'   ! "(

 

)     !"

! & 
 "  %  )  %   %% !! *"

(  " )   ! " '  "(

" 

 "

 # $#)$! "

! & "

! +

!  )   & , % -.   "

  #$ ) %

  "

    )   -.   -.,   ! "/  "( "

  #$ !  "

 !  & 0

" %   "

 !    ! !       "

"  ! "

'  !  ) 0"

 ) 
 %' " ) 0'"

  ) 

      '!"

 ) '

 ) 0    

 ,* 1 1    !"

  #$ !  "

 !  &    "

     ! "

   "  , "/" ! 2   

      "

  #$  "      )    %   "

 3  !   (  

)!" # %$      !  !"  !

 "/   "

  !  "

 ! +

 

 )

3

    "

   """ %     !

"

! &
" ) ( "

& !  4 "/  "

 ! +

    ) ! !

'   "

& ! "

")( 52  ! "

  # " $    

     !  "/  "(
"!2  %  "



 3 ! ( ! !    ' "

   "

! & )   6 %6

 ! !" ! "/ "

 !

"

! +

 7
 "    )   "

      "

 & # $ !  "

 !

+

'     "

  "/     "

  #$   2     2   ! "

   "  , ) (     "

  )

(      "

 & # $ 4 % % ! ""

"

 %( !"! ( "

 ' "  "

   "/ 

"(  "

 #$! "

! &  ,   "

 #$! "

! &

 )      ! "

  #$    ! "

  # $#)$ 8 ,  ! 0(    "

 !

+

" 

 "

 #$)%(! /   9   :"%) 

0( "

 ! "

! +

'         (  "

 #$ ! "

! &'" ) 0 

 "

 #$ + ,   ! "

  #$  ( !     ! "(

") "     !     "

  0    "

  ! !     )!  "

 !  & "    !"'  "( ! "/  ( %  ""       

 ,  ! ) "!   )"  )*"

  "

 !! 

 "

 #$! "

! & ( 

 % " ! "

  /   (   ! ""



"( !  "/  "

   

  

"( (     ! !"   !  "

 !  &' '  


            2) "

        ""

 "(  

%

% /   (  ! ! 0( 

  "( !  !"

  

 !"    "/ .

4

/

$
 

 "


7 

"
  :




!





  


   

!
"

% 
3 #$ 5




! 

-




"

 
"



!


"
 

 
''




'01)









(.'/

.'

.'

(.')





 



!

  
!
!



 


 


"
 


 



(.'/




! 

!

 
''




'01)

"
 
 






(.'/

 




(.'/
!




" 



 


 
!

  









'01)


"
  #)$ $
!
84


"!

"

  

 
()#(&




(.'/


"


-.


-.
! 




 


-


 
"

  
 
"


  
" 



 

"

"



 
!

 

!


"


 

 

 

"

"



 


"


!


"

 
#!"  

&&#$! 3(  $

5

#"$






 



-





4"


 
% 

5 

 

"


6 
 


 


 
()#(&




(.'/






 

 
 
;

-



"




  
!

! 

"
6 

&


 


 
!





 




"




!


!


"

 


"

 



 




 



"


:






 

 
;

 

 
/'#'&
/'#(&
/)




'01)

 

!




 
 

 
<'

0.




(.'/

4"


6
% 

  



- 

  

 



 




 
/)




'01) =

4"


%

 
  



 

 

"
>

 
/'#'&

-

 
  

"


:

  


 

 
 
 

 


"


!
$
  

 

4"


%

 
"



!







 
 


 


!

 

  #$ ;


 

 

 
"


 
()#(&




(.'/

4"


 
% 

  




6




 

"

"



 

"




 
 
!



 " 



 

7 

  

 



 



(.'/


"
 


!





  


-


 
)




'01)
* 

 


"
  

 


7 



 
 



!







"
 
!



,
-

%





 



% 
!




7 


  
 
"


!
 






!




7 

  

 
 
!




!
"




 
/)




'01)
!


"

-  #$ 




 
 

4"


 
% 

  

!



- 
>
 
!




  
 

"

$
!
!




 




 
"
 

 



 

"


 
'2




'01)









"

  

  #!$ ;


 


 

 

"!



!






(.'/

 

"  


"
6


! 



6

 


7

 


 -



 

?





 

 
()#(&

"
 #($ $
4"


% 

 
  



-









"





-


!
 
! 


 





"


 

 
()#(&




(.'/

"






 
 

 
"
  #$ 5

//<

4"


% 



 


 
 
()#(&




(.'/



"

"

"   

!
!
!




 


 

  
 
)




'01)

"- 
 
@
 

!





 

 
()#(&




(.'/

)





 

"

 


!


 

A

(2>>'?>(
#( <&
'2
#( .&
(?>'
#. '<&
(<>>''>'
#' 1&
(.>'
#) .&
('>'>'
#' '(&
(<>>''>(
#. 0&
'1>(
#' 2&
(.>'
#) .&
('>'>(
#' .&
((>'>'
#' (&
((>(>'
#. )&
/.>>(>'
#. <&
(<>>'0>(
#. <&
(>>'>(
#? 0&
/.>>(>(
#2 '.&
(2>>(?>/>(
#. )&
(?>(
#. '(&
(<>>('>(
#/ '?&
(2#. <&
/.>>'>(
#2 2&
(>>/
#' /&
()>>('>(
(<>>'2>'
#. '2&
(0>>(.
#' 1&
('
#0 .&
 



3
A 
$

* 
B  

$
 

!
-


"



 
 
  

'< ''

(..?

.< .( (..2
 


 
)

 
2


,
-



'01)


!
"
!

.( ./ (..2


 "


 
 
 


: 




2?

20
#*7 

=  
%  &
B 

8

 
-




-  







 









 



  
 




-  
5

 



 


-



"
 





 
$ 
 
 

 




"



 

"
 


-


 



 
()#(&



(.'/ ?




 

 
,
 

  
 




 
 " 


 


 

" 


 



-  
"

 

  


 



!

!
"



(..2
"
 
*
*:

?22

.( ./ (..2



"




"  


 
  


 
 


 
"




 

'/11

/.

.) (..0

 
+ 




 


-  
!




!



"



 



!
3
  





7 


5
B 
  
# &

 " 


  

 

 

 
()#(&



(.'/



 
   


 

"

"




"
 
"

!

!


"
 




 
!
 



 


 


  

 
 







 

 
 

 
  $



  
 

 
()
#(&




9


(.'/





 









"

 






 

 
!





 



 
 
  


 
 

  

"

 
 

 
 
 
!


  










- 

"

   

!
"

4"

 
% 

5 




5
B 
  
# &




!


 & $ 

 




    



-  
 
!



 
!

 



 
 "

 !


 

  
 

"

4"

6
% 

5
B 
  
# &
! 

4"


% 

 

 


!
 




'01)


 



  
 

 
()
#(&



(.'/
;



-





!
 

 
 
! 





"
 
*
*:

?22

.( ./ (..2

 

 

  
 






 



"


 





$



!
 

 








 
 


 

 
" 


" 


!



10

$

"
"

 



-  
!

"
 
*
*:

?22

.( .( (..2


 

















 "
$
!


  

 


  
 



-  



 





"




 








 



-  

  



  
  

 
()#(&

(.'/



"&






 


 

"



! 

 
"






 



-  


 

 
$
4"


6
 
!

 

!
8 4
  

 ()#(&


!
8 4


 


()
#(&

(.'/



 

"

 



"
"
  


!
8 4





 




 

"


"

 





;
!


 


C


 D

"
6 


(./




 
>!



"




!


!


"

 


"

 



 
5
 !

!


  

 







 !



"



 







11

 
 

 



 
 

"

 



 

 


 
 

 
()
#(&

(.'/

 










& + 


 

 


-


 




!
"



(..2


 
 
"

,
% 
 




 



-  

"
 




  

/.






- 
'..


" 



 
! 
,5
 






 





 
 





  

 "


 

! 


!
-




"
 


-




!

 





 <



-


"
   


 !

!
 :


/2/

5
B 
  
# &
 


 








    



-  
 
"


"

 

 

 

 

 
  




-  

 


 

 "


 
!


  

 










 

"

 
- 
"

  
  

 
()
#(&

(.'/


12


" 



 
 
  




 
  

 
  

 
! 
 


 


 


 




$
! 
 
    
- 





#* 5
EA=*
F&















%5=+
FG$5%=
#*GE
,,5&





FGB =
./ .( (.((








Manoj Bhutani
;
 >
H>E
;
"

H>E