← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1979/2015dismissed

M/S Equipment Conductors & Cables Ltd. v. Chief Engineer Transmission Corporation Of Andhra Pradesh Ltd. And ANR.

2015-09-304 pages

 

     

 

 !""#$%$&'(")!"*+",-.

/%01$)*"&!&21#!,%  +3"%4!2.1,5 & ))"33 &!

6",%1% 7$"&5$&"",. /%, &%*$%%$&,), !$&&27,  , 2"%74!2.

82", + 2  &!7",  "%)&2"&!%  



 !

!

"#

$%

 97"!7", "),!",%3# 3) )",%* 8+" 33:"2!%""!7";125*"&!<  +","",,"2!!7" "),!",%,&!< - 97"!7",!7";125*"&!%7132+","),!"2$&!7"$5"%!<

,"%"&!'

, , % &"88 3.2=# !".

,!7" ))"33 &! >>>>> !

"#

  ?@A

,  !7"  ," %&%  *"&!$&"2  $&  !7"  ))3$# !$&.  :7$#7  $% %1)),!"2+8 & $2 =$!.2"3 82 8%$&$3$&5!7" ))" 3$%#&2&"2  %! &2%2$%)%"2

 

7" ))"33 &!7 %#7 33"&5"2!7",2",2 !"2@@B) %%"2 +8!7"22$!$& 3$%!,$#!125".7 &2$5 ,7.:7","+8!7" )"!$!$&$3"2 1&2",("#!$&-B!7",+$!, !$& &2&#$3$ !$&#!.? ,%7,!

C?  #!D  ,  %"!!$&5A %$2"  !7"  : ,2  2 !"2  ?.  7 %  +""& 2$%*$%%"2

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

& .B.?@.-?/A  1)!  -@  &  ##1&!    $&!","%!  &  !7"  2"3 8"2 ) 8*"&!    !7"  ),$#"    !7"  52%.  $".  B  F*%    ?/  ** 31*$&$1*:$,"=",G**(:$,"( #&21#!,#2"& *"

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

1' $,.2) $,3,.45,6+ -+20)+7 

 &  8 *6/ *3/*7* *''

6+,0+*)65,6+ +/ 1'

  59)6,'



   :; &!7" ,"*"&!$&"2;125*"&!%.!7"&I+3"(1),"*"1,!7 2 #133"21!!7", !$2"#$2"&2$+8732$&5!7 !1&!$3 &21&3"%%!7","$%",,, )) ,"&!&!7" #","#,2,!7" ,+$!, !,7 %&!33:"2%! !1!,8 3"5 3  )%$!$&.  $!  $%  &38  $&  !7"%"  #$,#1*%! &#"%  $!  :132  +"  ;1%!$$"2 $&!",",$&5:$!7!7" : ,27"$571,!%7132&! #! % 1,! ))" 3 &2," )), $%"!7"* !",$ 3/"=$2"&#" &2"*+ ,E"2& ) !7+8

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

  $,  &2 ," %& +3"!$%&: %"!!3"23 :!7 !!7",+$!, !,$%!7"%3";125" 01 3$!8 &201 &!$!8!7""=$2"&#"+","7$* &22"#$2"&!7"+ %$% !7" = $3 +3""=$2"&#" 2&!$&2 &8$33"5 3$!8 &2)",=",%$!8$&!7"$*)15&"2,2", &2 %:"33 %!7" : ,2.+8:7$#7!7"#3 $** 2"+8!7" ))"33 &!: % 1&2!+".

 !$*"+ ,,"2 &2!7",2",%# &&!+"% $2!7 ="+""& ) %%"2:$!71!;1,$%2$#!$& ##,2$&538.!7" ))" 3$%2$%*$%%"2 ,4+,59,0 & #

 !

"  0*5,'2

$%