← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4212/2013allowed

Indian Oil Corp Ltd v. Union Of India

2016-12-02Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan6 pages

  

       

 !!"#$#%&'

%(#% #) *+* #%,#-# !( ++!))% $

.!*$/$

%#%%(#  !$+%(!% $

& 0,

 1 2 ,1  



     

,1 

,

34'5 

 "

#$ "

 %   

"

#$ "



   

 

 &'

 (



)   *+ +$ ,$+,  . '"

   

/ 



&'



-   1

   

    2  334 24  ..

5 *6$7$*6 +8 $, ,$$8  9

- ! 

: 5 :.

#;77<< :



55 :  

- ! 

  -  '  ' -  2 4 '  =  >     

'

 8+$7     . ***6+ ,+  ? . '"



 

 "

    %   '

 ' 

+ :

- "

@ , :

 

  +$7 . '"



- 

  '"@ * :

 

 

@  A @ < . 

. '"

   

/ 



 5 + 

  9'



 5 , *

  8+$7       "





   

  "

 



 

  )   *+ +$ ,$+, - . '"

   

/ 

55 ,$ $, ,$+*  



   

@

(

 '?

&'





5'

>



? &'



  "

  '

 2 4



 

' ?



A "



"

% A   "

1

 9'



 

1

 (



 "

'?

&'



 



"



  A   '



'?

&'



 A   

-  

"

   9 &'

  



?

 

3 &'

  &'

  "

0 

    

"



 -

B -



C "

 '



55 -



 "

 - 

5' '  

    

   

D 

    

 +;;7 .

<6#

-?

 - 

-





   



   

 









  



 

    !   



"



  



   #  $  



 %    %& !  % 

  #  



  #  '

 

    & " 





 

 



 "

    ()



       

   

 

  * + , (-

 %& !  %  

"

 .

"



  



  '    #  

&   

 

" 

"



   * / , (

 %& !  %  



&   

" 

  0

1

 !  *



 %



  







  " "  &



   ,"

* + , (- "

 * / , (

 %& ! 

% 

 

  &   

 

 

  &"

 2 

  

, (

* / 

&





   "  &



"





 







 

*

/

,

(

 & !  %      #     



" 





 





 



"  

 

 

& 

* + , (-

 %& !  % 

 

2   

" 

"





2 

  

1 

"

  







 

"

2

& 

&

  

 



" &

 "





 

  

  



  ""



" 0   

2 

  $ %  





 &

      "

  

 





"

 

  

   

     

""



"



 -  -

    '

     

0

"

'  "



C      

5'5  

 5 +     

  

'

 "

. +6$*;* <$  8+$7   

  ;E     

,+ $7 ,$$8  " 2 ,1 

   !"!-6!*7'

 :

?

C FC5 :

- FC5