← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4241/2013allowed

Narender Kumar v. Neelam

2019-03-28Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain,Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill9 pages

      

 ! "!#$%$&'(#) *+

, 

         

(-'

&./0!(1% $#!2!%)31-($& &4/0!(1% $#!(&(!%)5$&6)$00     

    !"     #"    !"  

  2!%)31-($&+ $"

 

  %

" #

%

 

&&'(&) *+" , 

 *+."

"  *+"

)!" /

 %   0''1" 

!   !  " 2 34!

 !"

 % *+

 " %

!  +"*

 * !

"  % !"   . 

""

 7&(008

 /

  

-  

 $" + .  *  "  "

 +  .".*

&'&9(&&& % :

 $"   " % ""  

  

%"

.

"  +"  !

 ; 

!     +!"

  "

"  

 "

( 2<"=  "

3

2 ;;3  " "  %

   "   "

! + *   !."

"

  *"   

%;" " !" 

"   * .

" *" * "  !  * " !"  

 " % "  !

  !

.   "

   

!

$"

%#*

>* ."

"  

!"  " !

" * " !"  

% "  " "    

 % ! 

! .+%

"



! + * " 

!  

  &7(&&?  @ ;"  %

%  

!

.+ "." .

 .

"

.

&&(&&8" "   

! 

%

". * "

"  . 2@

;

% 3 )(&&85  % ""  

  * !!          

 "+   % +    "      

 "

 A

"  ! ,5)?0 '&(&&9

?09 )()  "  )?5-  ;"

""

   "  % ! 

! .+%

"  

! +  * * " 

,5.   *+"  ! 

5 !

"  % "* ! "     "  !5

!>

#

$  " 

" <  

 

+  "

  "   " $"  

!



 

     (  !  "     !  =  ! @ 

    (&&'1" 

!  !  " 2 !(&&'34 ".

8&7(&& 5  % ""     * ! " -

- ,

1>4! ;

%

 !"

 % * " 

  .!

= ""   

% "  

) + !

 !"

 %  " %

!  + /.  

 "   +  !

 *+  "   

"  ! 

 % .  

*  ""   !!

%!"

 

" . 

%

" /

%: - +.

"" *" 

" $"      :$ "

"  

.

  !

:B  % "   !"

 %  $"

 % +.

:    "

$ "!"

: /

>

  +

%"

 

"  

 % +   "       "  "   % +  *  ".

  !  "

 

" *+" !" !"   ."

" ..+!"

$"   "   

%

!

%"  

"



!#*

>

 !" * "

 %.

"" 

 $"

" 

"" "  ,5)?0 '&(&&9 *  % "" 

  ""      ,5.

"  

%"   !"  

5  %

""   *+" 

(!"  !(&&'.

*+"  5- 

.

"  

%"    $"     " .   !

*+"  

"  +"    "    *+"

"   * 

"  %  *+"  

"   + "  

%!"  " , ! .

 &0&9(&

" . 

*

". *  *+"   A  ;

%" 

 :""     .     + 

 "    

?

  " .

*D=

=    +

 

 !"

  $" 

 ;!"

! ;

%" 

 ."  %  !! ,5  %

"



! + * $"  

,

%"  !! !"  %  !" ,5 " *  "" %"

"      . !

*   "    ."

.

"   

7--.   

*+"

 !" ! + * !"  

!" ! + * !

"  

."."  

$" - " !

""

  . * %""   !"  

E.

! ." "  %"" 

!

 %"5 !   (&&'1" 

!   !  " 2 34

   

""   + *      

 

%5.*  *+"

 

 , +  -   "  

 "            

%  ! #

"*      

"  ! . *    

""  %   

" ,5*+"  

.  ! 5 !"  % !"   ""  

  "

 "  

*+

%*#  *  " " %""  "" .

%.

" " .

>

 " "

 5  %

" , ""  "" .  * ! " %"" 

 " 

!"  

."" *  !*+"   ! !  5 !"

 % !    

"  

 - 

% .

"

"  

  +"   *+"

.



#

% %

."

""    "* 

' $"    . &0((&?



 8&'(&9   .      *  "        %  .

"  



(?!"  $" - " 

  " 

   *+* .

"  

  "  * ! " 

-

-  !"

- *  "    

" !

  "" 

" !

" - "   ""   *   " !   

 "   ! " 

%   !    !" 

  F 

 !"   "!



* 

%  -  (??0?E-55  !  (&8           "    

7&8(&' *+" @  ;" *+."

""   

*+"  

.

 $" 

 . *

"" 

  

 (&(&8*+"

- 

"*

%"    !% 

"  

!

"" 



"  %"* * %"   " %"

"

 % " !"   

  !" -  $"  !  "    * 

%  -  (??0?E-55  !  (&8    "  *+ .

"  !" @  ;" 7&8(&' ;

  

 E F 

 !"   " * ""  +!  ""  

 %   ! ,5%

"  

! + * * 

%,5)?0 '&(&&9

?09

)() '&7G)?5-  ;" ".   *+" 

* ."

""  

 - " 

"

"  

7  

   

 

%%

" 

      

  .    !

        ." "   "

 % 

" ,5.  ! 

. !" !  "" 

 % .   "    "  +*

7&8(&'



 E5 !

"  * *+"

"" 

 7&8(&'"

 + " *

" *+"  

, "   * ""  "   !" *  !"

 " 

 !"  

 ! "  

" !"  

."

"" 

   % +"   "    +!"

  ! ;

%

 5 !

"  * ""  

!

*+"  

(!"  !(&&'.

"  



  

" "  

. " %" " *   *+" , * "  !    +".""  

"   "!  % +  *

" "   ."

"   + 5  %

 

 !"   " 

 @

:

"#

% !"

- 

"   ! 1%)7$&"!( 31(8%)21( %%+,CEE?&7!(&)1CH4

&'&((&' /.    " "  "

  ! "   

 " *  "  "  , +  -   "  ;

  

  " 

 *+"  "  * 

!

"

*+"



  ,5)?0.+     

  !"  

" ! + * I"  

  (  ! "   ! (&&' . 

 "

 %

I"

8 "

 !.  * !  

%"  

" " %

> 

%" * "

 %.

"" 

 I"  % ""



  

 !"  .  "    ! 

* "  

I.   *+" 

!  !."

""  

  * 

"  !

     *+  "      "  !    /.        !  "

  

+""    G   

!

*+ "  

%

"    !" ,5"*

*+"

@  ;"

 7&8(&'

""* * %"

  

 E = " "   

 !"  

   *   ""

*       )  ! "   +  .

"  %

  "  "

 %   * 

 *+

      "  *+" "

*

" .

!   )141 4

%" %

!  +

  )141 *4 *   "" *  " !

  !.+  

 +

%"    !"

  $" . 2  +3  !

"  * "* !

*+" - *+  

*"2"+ 3

2 3   +  5  "       "      "  +  !  "

 !"

 %  %

%   + 5  %

" "  !

+ !  " ,51BD94 % %   *+"  

 +%

"   * %

"

! + * 

%!"



"    ! 

! .+

  "

  $" ,5.

 *+  "    *  

  !

  +   *  " 

9  

%+   *  "          "  

 5A %   $"  

  

  !"

*+" 

" 

   . 

   

*+" - ".*  *+"  

*+ 

%

$" , " " %" !  " ,5*  !

!;

% +

 +*   !"   ""

   . 

/.  

%" 

+!"     "    .

 7&8(&'

"

"* * %"   *+"   *+     

 E5  

  ""  

 " "  7&8(&'

"    * !  +- !

.

 "

" 

 " *  !

$"

"* " 

*+" - "" ,5.! + %  

" - " "

 !"  %  !! ,5!"   !

%." " 

   " %

!2  +3!"   !% !  !

  5  %

. *     ! " ! ""

 % ;  7&(008

"  

! .+. % "

"  %  !,5 '&(&&9$"  % ! 

! .+" *  !  D +!  ! " + !"  %  +"

" , "*  ""   "

. * !"   !"  " %"" 

  " 

!"  

."" *  !*+"   ! !  $"

;

!."

""  ;

"  "  !"

        " 

%

  !      +  !  ."

"  "

  

 

0 $"

;

%! + % !

  

"

 ! 

*+"

-   A

!"   ! 

%

" #

%

 !" , !% !

 "     

%+   "  *+.

"  

#

%

!" ,   

" %".

" +  

  %

! !"    12!%)31-($& 1"6!

(#) *+

, (&(!%)5$&6)$00 8$&"9 1"6! =" "  ;

%G 

 J G =" "  *  J G