High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2009/2015allowed

Ritim Alias Rajan Sharma Minor Th Harbans Lal v. Gurvinder Singh And ORS

2019-05-16Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

!" ###$$ % & '( ( ###$(

!" ###$$ % & '( ( ###$( ) )*+,# # -+

#.( /('*

$$#

#'0(/('*

$(1#23. **$4# 64(/.($ 7##

(! $$3

!"(

( ! $$3 !"/7*' **(# 6 4(/ * *8##/* !" 7*(( -* 9

(7:4 ($*

((477(6$ (: !"( *(7( **( (*

7(-* 9 ( )97 67( 7 ! + $## 7 *9 1# ,; (

( '* ! ('!4$(1#3 & '( '4( 7 !7 4 * <* ((7 *

* * !"(: * !" (7 ( (( * (7((!*94

(

'*'! *: **(/$(1#74 $'

(

'*!(:* !"(

( / $ * ( * 97=

( $( ' 7!(4 * ( * 4! :! (79 <' $!440 $' '*: (7 '*(7 ( <' $> 1 7790 $/ ? (( ((:((($

####/77(: 9 7$(/7 ( * 7 (-&./ <( #**( ' * **(/ * !"!*$4(!(( !

2 79$$4: .1#2((##

(*@/22@(228.-<7 (7-* 6$ /)*> 1 ! * !"#.( !"7 (! ; 4(

! 79(7 #,/A$/7* 7 (! @4:! 7 $ (# - !"(!

*$!

<-1# $(##& '( 3 ('/1'37(*&. *<$4/ -

( '*/* *$ # ***

(!4 '***(# -

# !"!

((B ((!

*$! <-1# !' ($(/* *$ # * **

(!4'* **(# *!*$ **(/ 7( !4 **(<C!

/> 1 ? (# */ $( ( $$(# $(1#(( (7/7 $(1#2 ($7# .7 (! $(

; 1#(/4'*'(* $ ' !*7 (!4

*$:* ( * *$:

*'**( ( * C!

#/ *$(((**(($(( *(! ( $(1#''

( *9 $(1#(*( 4*$**7!4 97 '*( (' '*/ 4 '

( # **( 7 $( 7 * (* ! '*/7*( * (**(/4 4 (7 ** $(1#!4$* *9D # *$( $4( ( *$# .7 !(! $( 1#2/9' !*/*( ***(79$*7

( *9( *'* ! 4''(*:*(( 4 4 4 **( ''

( '*# E ( **(/7 $(*((( 9$*** */77* (7 *

* (47!4

97'*:

( '*(! 4''( * !4 * * 7 $( 1#: $(1#7 **(('7( 4'(

(

*'(' ** (**(/7*7 97( $(1#:((7

( *9##$(1#7$4 7 4 $A'( (

*' $ ( * */ 7* (7

' $' *(( *( *$*4#/ *$7*'(#.( *$($4(

( *$# $( $ 7 7 (+ # E ! " ( ( **(* (!4'*1# ,; ( ( (' $(#/ (F--# # C 7 *$ ( 4/ 7 *(F--# 2# E ( '( ( *(

*$*4 (/ /

*F-# ;# # C*('(* $$ $*'

*#E$((((4'(*#

/*$77( $4!4C!

'(7(((8##;#- ! "/ 7 ( ( < - 1# 7 7(( *$ #;,/A/$/7 ( (<-1# 77((*$

#8#,/A 7 @# G$

, ( $ H$4!!4$( 1#2# C7**$!$$( 7 '7(# < !"(=7 ( (7*$7(((4' ( $$$!

< 9 * *$# 1* $$7 ($(1#24/ 7*$ $$*

* # .'((* $!(

*(# 9 $

( !4 $$A* !"# !"

('IB#-E,A ( ( *'( / ' / $ * ( * 9**((79<' $/? ( 77 (<' $> 1 ( 790 $/? (( ((/7( ####( 7(/ 97$(: (! ;84 (7( ! 79#-E)#)0 9($( (

( !"0 $##* ( (**('

( 9(*( 7 ( (( ( 4 9# ( (

( * 9( * *(4 9:$7$$( 9(9 !7$$( 9:$7(* (

@ ###E$' ' (*(* /(( $(* (#,/,A#-E6 //)(

(*($'(!IB#-IB#-@ (*( $ !"# CC!

7(( #,/2 A7( (*B$* ( $ * (*'(' !#C C!

9'7 *4/*(

'4 $$ * (**#*!9$( !7((7(

(*B$#C / *$ ((*(#2/A# CC!

7(( # /A ( ** 79#0$ '7 $

( !4* ( * ( *$7$$( 9(9!7$$( 9/7 ( '!$! 79 *(!/

$( * $H */ 7(( # /A7((*(# /A# CC!

7(( #/A7($ (

7*. (!(D # 7'/ *( # /A 7 7(( 7($/$*(*#/7* (# 0$ '7$( $H(

(*7 (' $ 7 $ / #/A7((**

8 ($*(/$

(( $*( 4($$*'4#7( # /A

((# C*'

( ((D $ ( ( $( $H ( $ 7 $# # /A **( 4 7(($$A**# C***

(!47 ( !!79/ 7$**(#

# /A7((** (

B$* # C * #/2/A CC!

7((*$ #;,/A# .74/*( * #8;/A

/2/ ;,/ #C*7 (!( = @# G$ ( $$* H *( #8;/A#C(*(

' * $$4*( 7# 179 $

!" (!

$$A* = / ( ! , 4/ 7 ** * 4 ( (!$( $ !'9/ $ 7!(!79 $ 7!* 4 -E@ )##0#0/*- )$ $(*/-&./ <( ((* *(IB#-; (!4-&./<( #C

9 * /A $ / $$4

$ 8 (*$ #/@/A#C!4

( ( '(!(( *$$#C*9# /A$ / #/2A $ # E $ *4 ( **7 ('( 4*(# "(* * ( 4

!"#!"$%&'( !4 $B< 7$B< (((7$ 7( *$* $(!4 7+

$(!4 $G#"9#

)!4!'G( $2G29#

)!4 $,G;9#

)!4 $G 9#

)!4!'G,9# -E;)# /7#,# 7

! 6(((*4B(=/ (8 4(*((($(!4 G'( (!4 * * IB#-8# C / * = ( #,//A *$ * (!4 $G# CC!

7(( #2 /;A7( (*B$* ( $ * (*'(' !#C

9'7 *4/*(

'4 $$ * (**#*!9$( !7((7(

(*B$#C / *$ ((*(# /A# CC!

7(( #//A ( ($(

#.4'7*( !

(!4*/$( $H/'4(

* 4$(

( !4$

4 D $H/ ( 7 $#0$

'7 *(** * */.*( #//A# CC!

7(( #//A** ( B$* #. ( 7((7(#C***

(!47 (!!79/ 7$ **(#.*(#//A# CC!

7(( #//A** ( $ ! A (#/@/A ** *$*4#* #,//A! 7((*** (!4/(7 (!

9!*'(!4 7((($(

((! (# CC!

( #//A ( ( $$*#. ( 7(( 7(#**

(!4*/

(

* ! 9$ '7 $ (!4#.*( ((#//A# CC!

7((*$ #//A $A B *!#. ( (!

((D # C*$* #2/ /A# CC!

7((*$ #8/,/A# .74/*( * # /;;/A

2/ /8/,/ #C*7 (!( = @# G$ ( $$* H *( # /;;/A#C(*(

' * $$4*( 7# E *( */!$$7($4# ,# # "

6 #$%&$%''%()*+%,-).%(/0+1 %)-* #$%&$%''%.*'&(23% %)-*