Harsimranjit Singh Toor Etc. v. Gaganpreet Kaur Toor


 

       


   

   



    



!

"     #



   

 !   

 ""  $%&'%&('%&)*+,&-&.'!%/*0+1&(&2/('&+3.'%&+3,&!'4 &!

  

   
"

 







"   "

 

  

 ! # 

%&25(&.'!/65(!3-(5.)3'3.,%//(!3.7&+&7&5!&+ 8%/ 85!'%&%*!15.+/6(&!2/.+&.' 5,5.2(&&'#5*(//(%59&7%500&.,&+'%& 522/3.'-&.'/6(&!2/.+&.'5!,*5(+35.6/('%&-3./(7%30+5.+'%&7*!'/+: /6'%&-3./(7%30+,(5.'&+'/'%&(&!2/.+&.'%&(&3.3.'%&!*3'630&+1:'%& (&!2/.+&.'6/('%&,*5(+35.!%325.+7*!'/+:7053-&+*.+&(&7'3/./6'%& 3.+*3./(3':5.+ *5(+35.!%327';





&(3/*!  500&,5'3/.  %5+  1&&.  0&9&00&+  1:  '%&  (&!2/.+&.'  5! 5,53.!'%&(%*!15.+8%/85!5039&5''%&'3-&8%&.'%&2&'3'3/.7053-3., '%&51/9&(&03&6!85!630&+5!5,53.!'%3- !%3!25(&.'!%59&63,*(&+5!

+&6&.+5.'!3.'%&!*3'(&!3!'3.,'%&51/9&7053-/6'%&(&!2/.+&.'56'&(%3! +&-3!&8&5(&/6'%&93&8'%5''%&500&,5'3/.!-5+&1:'%&(&!2/.+&.'


5,53.!'%&(%*!15.++/./'85((5.'+&'530&+&051/(5'3/.

<

.1(3&6'%&(&!2/.+&.'%&(&3.3.%&(!*3'*.+&(&7'3/./6'%& 3.+*3./(3':5.+ *5(+35.!%327';

%5!!'5'&+'%5'!%&-5((3&+ 5(!3-(5.)3'3.,%//(/.  = %&(&56'&('%&7/*20&2(/7&&+&+'/ &01/*(.&*!'(5035/.  >  %&:8&(&10&!!&+83'%5+5*,%'&( .5-&0:%*1%5.3//(/.

 >  %&(&!2/.+&.'500&,&+'%5'%&( %*!15.+85!5+(*,5++37'

&6530&+'/7/-20&'&6*00'&.*(&/6+(*,5.+ 507/%/02(/,(5--&3.*!'(5035 &*!&+'/!2&.'-/.&:/.507/%/05.+ +(*,!2*''3.,'%&(&!2/.+&.'%&(&3.3.52(&75(3/*!2/!3'3/. %&(&6/(&'%& 7%30+85!!&.''/'%&25(&.'!/6'%&%*!15.+6/(503''0&8%30&'/(&+*7&'%& 2(&!!*(&/.'%&(&!2/.+&.'%&(&3.

?

'  85!  6*('%&(  500&,&+  1:  '%&  (&!2/.+&.'  %&(&3.  '%5'  /.   !%&/1'53.&+5..'&(9&.'3/. (+&(6(/-'%&5,3!'(5'& /*('5'

"37'/(355'(/5+-&5+/8!5,53.!'%&(%*!15.+  %&3!&@2&7'3.,'/,&'

2&(-5.&.'(&!3+&.7:3.'%&.&5(6*'*(& %&3!752510&5.+7/-2&'&.''/1& '%&.5'*(50,*5(+35./6'%&7%30+  %&2053.'3663!!*3'510:&-20/:&+3.

&01/*(.& *!'(5035   %& (&7&39&+  5.  5..*50 85,&  /6 522(/@3-5'&0:  A B
 8%37%  3!  !*66373&.'  '/  2(/93+&  7/-6/('510&  !/7350  5.+ &7/./-37  5'-/!2%&(&  %&  3!  50!/  5  +&,(&&  %/0+&(  3.  57%&0/(  /6 3/'&7%./0/,:3..+35 %&%5!50!/,/'320/-53. /--*.3':$&065(&3.

*!'(5035 %&(&6/(&!%&%5!!*1-3''&+'%5'!%&3!&.'3'0&+'/1&+&705(&+5! 5,*5(+35.5.+'%5'!%&3!50!/&.'3'0&+'/%59&'%&7*!'/+:/6'%&7%30+

%&  %*!15.+  /6  '%&  (&!2/.+&.'  %&(&3.  (&!3!'&+  %&(  7053500&,3., '%5' '%&(&!2/.+&.' %&(&3. +&9&0/2&+  300373' (&05'3/.! 83'% /.&

<
/11:5)853.'%&:&5(;8%/!'*+3&+83'%'%&(&!2/.+&.'3.'%& 7/00&,& 3!836&*!&+'/7/-&5'/++'3-&!

/-&'3-&!!%&(&'*(.&+%/-& 3.+(*.C&.7/.+3'3/.

 5(!3-(5.)3'3.,%//(75-&'/C./86(/-'%& /6637&/6'%&(&!2/.+&.'%&(&3.'%5''%&(&!2/.+&.'85!(&!3+3.,83'%/11: 5)85  (5*+*0&.'0:5.&@
25('&+&7(&&/6+39/(7&85!/1'53.&+1:'%& (&!2/.+&.'/.<  <  &+&.3&+'%5'%&85!5.507/%/0375.++(*, 5++37'

%&(&!2/.+&.'*!&+'/!2&.+-/!'/6%&('3-&/*'/6%&(%/*!&

%&3!(&!3+3.,3.5+*0'&(:83'%/11:5)85 %&7%30+3!!'*+:3.,3.

57%25.7%//05'%3.+58%37%%5!5,//+(&2*'5'3/.3..+35   .+&( !*7%73(7*-!'5.7&!36'%&7*!'/+:/6'%&7%30+3!,39&.'/'%&(&!2/.+&.' %&(&3.'%&6*'*(&/6'%&7%30+83001&+&!'(/:&+3'3!7/.'&.+&+



%&'(350 /*('%593.,'%/(/*,%0:5+9&('3.,'/'%&&93+&.7&/. (&7/(+75-&'/'%&7/.70*!3/.'%5''%&(&!2/.+&.'%&(&3.85!&.'3'0&+'/1& 522/3.'&+5!5,*5(+35./6-3./(%*1%5.3//(5.+85!50!/&.'3'0&+'/'%& 7*!'/+:/6'%&-3./(7%30+

=

%&  657'  (&-53.!  '%5'  -3./(  %*1%5.3  //(  85!  1/(.  /. 

 >/*'/6'%&8&+0/7C/6'%&(&!2/.+&.'83'%5(!3-(5.)3'3.,% //('%5''//C2057&/.  = %&(&!2/.+&.'%5!630&+'%&!*3'*.+&( &7'3/./6'%&3.+*3./(3':5.+ *5(+35.!%327'; 1&6/(&9&('%& 7%30+5''53.&+ :&5(!/65,&  !2&(&7'3/.5 /6'%&!53+7''%& 7*!'/+:/6'%&-3./(8%/%5!./'7/-20&'&+'%&5,&/6 :&5(!!%500 /(+3.5(30:1&83'%'%&-/'%&(

>

'3!5.5+-3''&+657''%5''%&%*!15.+5.+836&%5+'%/*,%'3' 63''/!&.+'%&7%30+'/.+356/(*21(3.,3.,1:'%&25(&.'!/65(!3-(5.)3'

?
3.,%//( %&(&3!50!/./+3!2*'&'/'%&657''%5'(&!2/.+&.' 5,5.2(&&' #5*(%5!/1'53.&+5+&7(&&/6+39/(7&6(/-%&(%*!15.+/.< < <6(/- &+&(505,3!'(5'& /*('/6*!'(5035  .6/('*.5'&0:5(!3-(5.)3'3.,% //(%5!25!!&+585:

;

'3!58&00!&''0&+2/!3'3/./6058'%5'63.5.73502/!3'3/./6'%& (395025('3&!75../'1&5+&'&(-3.3.,657'/('/+&73+&'%&7053-/67*!'/+:/6 '%&-3./(7%30+  %&8&065(&/6'%&-3./(7%30+!%5001&'%&25(5-/*.' 7/.!3+&(5'3/.

%& /*('8300%59&'/+&73+&8%&'%&('%&(&!2/.+&.'/('%& 522&005.'%&(&3.8/*0+1&'%&63'2&(!/.'/%59&7*!'/+:/6'%&7%30+ 

%&!'522&005.'5(//23.,%//(%5!(&'3(&+6(/-!&(937&

%&.+522&005.'8%/3!'%&836&/6!'522&005.'3!50!/5.5,&+8/-5.

%&&93+&.7&/.(&7/(+8/*0+,/'/&!'5103!%'%5''%&:%59&5+5*,%'&(8%/ 3!:&''/1&-5((3&+  67/*(!&'%&3(63.5.73502/!3'3/.3!9&(:!/*.+5!2&( '%&(&7/(+!2(/+*7&+1:'%&-1*''%5'75../'1&5657'/(8%37%8/*0+ *0'3-5'&0:+&73+&'%&(39507053-/67*!'/+:/6'%&-3./(7%30+  &!2/.+&.'

5,5.2(&&'#5*(50!/%5!&!'5103!%&+'%5'!%&%5!,/'2&(-5.&.')/13. &01/*(.&*!'(5035+(583.,5..*50!505(:/6 A B
8%37%8/*0+ +&63.3'&0:1&!*66373&.'6/('%&7/-6/('510&036&/6-/'%&(5.+'%&7%30+



'3!'(*&'%5''%&7%30+85!0&6'3.'%&7*!'/+:/6'%&522&005.'! %&(&3.5!2&('%&)/3.'+&73!3/.'5C&.1:(&!2/.+&.' 5,5.2(&&'#5*(5.+ %&(  05'&  %*!15.+  5(!3-(5.)3'  3.,%  //(  %&  73(7*-!'5.7&!  8%37% 2(&9530&+'%&.85((5.'&+'%&7/*20&'/'5C&!*7%5%5(++&73!3/.'/!&.+'%& 7%30+'/5'%3.+56/(%&(*21(3.,3., %&(&%5+1&&.563.5.7350!'(&!!/.

'%&7/*20&8%/85!0393.,3.*!'(5035 '3!/.0:./8'%5''%&(&!2/.+&.'

5,5.2(&&'#5*(//(%5!!&7*(&+52&(-5.&.')/13.&01/*(.&*!'(5035

%&&-/'3/.505''57%-&.'/6'%&-/'%&(83'%%&(D:&5(!/0+151:,3(0 8/*0++&63.3'&0:C&&2'%&7%30+3.,//+-&.'505.+!23(3'*50%&50'% %&(&3!

./'%3.,/.(&7/(+'/!%/8'%5' 5,5.2(&&'#5*(8%/3!'%&-/'%&(/6'%& 7%30+8/*0+57'5+9&(!&0:'/'%&3.'&(&!'/6'%&-3./(7%30+ 9&(:7%30+ 8/*0+0/.,'/%59&'%&0/9&5.+566&7'3/./6%&(-/'%&( %&6*06300-&.'/6 !*7%50/.,3.,8/*0++&63.3'&0:!%52&'%&500(/*.+2&(!/.503':/6'%&7%30+ 

&5(.&+7/*.!&0522&5(3.,6/('%&522&005.'!8/*0+!*1-3''%5' '%&7%30+3!!'*+:3.,3.59&(:(&2*'&+!7%//03.5'%3.+5 %&522&005.'!

%59&5.&./(-/*!8%&(&83'%50'/'5C&75(&/6'%&.&&+!/6'%&7%30+3'3! 6*('%&(!*1-3''&+  <

%&  63.5.7350  !/*.+.&!!  /6  /.&  /6  '%&  25('3&!  8%/  70537*!'/+:-5:%59&5!5:8%&.'%&2//(63.5.73502/!3'3/./6'%&/22/.&.'3. '%&03'3,5'3/.8/*0++&2(39&'%&1(3,%'&+*75'3/.502(/!2&7'/6'%&7%30+ .

'%&3.!'5.'75!&'%&(&!2/.+&.'%5!&!'5103!%&+'%5'!%&1&3.,52&(-5.&.' &-20/:&&  3.  &01/*(.&  *!'(5035  3!  +(583.,  5.  5..*50  !505(:  /6 522(/@3-5'&0: A B
./'%&(8/(+!'%&(&!2/.+&.'%5!!*66373&.' 3.7/-&'/-&&''%&&+*75'3/.50&@2&.!&!/6'%&7%30+525('6(/-2(/93+3., /'%&(7/-6/('!'/%&( %&(&6/(&'%&!/*.+63.5.73502/!3'3/.2(/)&7'&+1: '%&522&005.'!75../'1&7/.!3+&(&+5!5+&'&(-3.3.,657'/(8%37%%5!'%& 75251303':'//9&(
!%5+/8'%&7053-/6'%&(&!2/.+&.'  ?

%&(&85!5830+500&,5'3/.-5+&5!5,53.!''%&(&!2/.+&.''%5' !%&50!/+&9&0/2&++(3.C3.,%513'!

*'*.6/('*.5'&0:'%&(&3!./2(//6'/ &!'5103!%!*7%5.*.6/*.+&+500&,5'3/.

./'%&(830+500&,5'3/.%5!1&&.


-5+&1:2(/+*73.,@

'%5''%&(&!2/.+&.'!'5('&+0393.,3.5+*0'&(:83'% /.&/11:5)85 ./*(7/.!3+&(&+93&8'%&'(350 /*('%5!'%/(/*,%0:

,/.&3.'/'%&+/7*-&.'@

5.+(3,%'0:7/-&'/57/.70*!3/.'%5'!53+ +/7*-&.'
+/&!./'&!'5103!%'%5''%&(&!2/.+&.'%5!1&&.0393.,3. 5+*0'&(:83'%/11:5)85 25('6(/-'%&51/9&830+500&,5'3/.8%37% 85!./'&!'5103!%&+8&63.+'%5''%&(&3!.//'%&(8&3,%':,(/*.+'/*2!&' '%&7053-/6,*5(+35.!%325.+7*!'/+:-5+&1:'%&(&!2/.+&.'  

%&(&!2/.+&.'3!)*!'>:&5(!/0+ %&3!*.+/*1'&+0:%50& 5.+%&5(':

%&-3,%'%59&7/-&%&(%/*!&3.&01/*(.&05'&+*(3.,.3,%' 5!!%&85!9&@&+83'%'%&5''3'*+&/6%&(%*!15.+8%/%5+1&&.2*.3!%&+ 6/(+(*.C&.+(393.,5!2&('%&+/7*-&.'!2(/+*7&+1:'%&(&!2/.+&.' *'

8%&.'%&+5*,%'&(!'5('!!'5:3.,83'%'%&-/'%&('%&-/'%&(8300(*!%'/'%& %/*!&  '%&  -/-&.'  %&(  /6637350  +*':  3!  /9&(  5!  !%&  %5!  '%&  /.&(/*! (&!2/.!31303':/6,(//-3.,%&(+5*,%'&( %&-*'*500/.,3.,/6'%&-/'%&( 5.++5*,%'&(8/*0+1&!5'3!63&+/.0:36'%&7%30+3!83'%'%&-/'%&(-/(& !2&73500:3.'%&51!&.7&/6'%&65'%&(  

.93&8/6'%&51/9&657'!5.+73(7*-!'5.7&!8&63.+'%5''%& '(350 /*('%5!(3,%'0:'5C&.5+&73!3/.'/522/3.''%&(&!2/.+&.'5!,*5(+35. 6/(-3./(%*1%5.3//(5.+'/,39&7*!'/+:/6'%&-3./(7%30+'/'%& (&!2/.+&.'

%&(&6/(&'%&)*+,&-&.'25!!&+1:'%&'(350 /*('3!7/.63(-&+ 5.+'%&522&503!+3!-3!!&+83'%5+3(&7'3/.'/'%&522&005.'!'/%5.+/9&( -3./(7%30+%*1%5.3//('/(&!2/.+&.' 5,5.2(&&'#5*(//(83'%3./.& -/.'%6(/-'%&+5'&/62(/./*.7&-&.'/6'%3!)*+,&-&.'

=
$ $

=

.93&8/6'%&657''%&-53.522&50%5!1&&.+3!2/!&+/6'/+5: '%&5220375'3/.1&7/-&!3.6(*7'*/*!5.+'%&(&6/(&3'!'5.+!+3!-3!!&+5! !*7%



 !    %"   5:

  "" *05'3  %"