Nishu v. Haryana Power Generation Corporation & ORS




    
  

  

 



  ! 
 " #$  %"       !" # $%!%    & '
()*+ " &
+' ,)*+ " #$%!% &    " * (

-.

 
 /     &,  "0  "    "

, "  $"   1    2 , !

 1// 3!

"
4 5( 
,,6 "  7( 

  (0 (0 "   !+ ,7 ( 0" 6 ,(   9 ((0: )   0()*; . + ,,   .

.

 1      <.

- =(

  0+0 ,"(,(*""( ,"(,  +

, (( (   (  > 7   "  6 ,(   ( 6 "  ( ""(   , >>,0  ""(

,   

 6 "
,,     <

 ""(  (     (     >      (   ,  6 ,    " ? ,( (  ,   ,($ (  ""() ""(  (0>( >"" ( ""((0"    0   (+  /  ,     "( , 

@ A ,"(, ""

+>
 &  *; .      0+""," , 6 "      0  0+    + *; .

 (> ,"(,  00   6" ,,9   "(, 5( 
,,50 0

 6" 0   

 0; +*; .<  "",(,"(  "(, / "  " +*; .-   

 0  ;      0  "(,  "   0    *; .  / ( *, 
 ( ', 6 " ( "

+  , "(  0   "   B   ( 2,( C=(

   *; .

 6" ""  (, ;,  "(, 5( 
,,50 0>

'856  &

  

 :("
 ( /  50 0  6(0
E        + *;  .F  "  ""    ( ;,      "(,  5(  
,, 50 0      "   ,  " + *;  .   -

(0 ""(0"  *; .).

 .F,"(  "(,5( 
,, 50 0(0 ( >( 

@ A < 6 "  "

" " 

 7 "E   "(,    ( "

+0 ,"(, + 7 ( *; . - 6 ( "  G "(,5(  
,, 50 0  (   <

    -H, E6" > 0((, E

,:("
 (/*; . 

>, , "" ,6 "E"  >, ((  0(       ( 7(    " ,     "  ,"(   

" + *;  .  

 "  "   "  6 " 9"  7*; .+ ( *; .

0 " "  0+  "    >  0   ( 7(     (

6" ,+ ( "

 " 00   " > E0      7(       "(,5( 
,,50 0  + 7 " *; .<



  9+*; .-<

>0  >(0"  "      "  7(      "",

@A F I (   "     "  ,(+0 ;" ,"(   "(, >  "

+  , "(  0  B   ( 2,( C)"  > 0
 
 ---F 

  " > E0    7(   '(:, "0"

,"I
 " 7( IE "  (0 
 



<  " + (,  ()
 ( 0  "

, "  I
)  F  

, , (  7 0" ,("  "(= () =99    , (  ,> "/6/?  ",( "  (    ""  !

"
 "  (+    ,"( /6/ ) >"   ,"+ 0  ;"+ (,"

,  ") 0

,  "","  >0 "

,0 
," $"  ,
( E   >0"( ")"  7(  (0>(>""$"  1 2 ,!

D//>   ,9") "      +0""  "(,  ( ,>0 )   "  "(   !+ ,    %>(  %(, I  1I*7$1*; D     " >0 ,  0  E " ,"(,  ,"( )(,"(, " ,>

  "" < 

@<A  I( "    0+"   >0 0+ (  *;  %D 

   ( > "

+ >( ,"(,>  (7( " ( 3+4   ,, , ""

+ >  0+ ,) *;  %1  

   ,   00           ((  ;      90 , ( ,E0  (   

  ; (>0+>"  )"   >, "

  +0 ,"(   "(,   >    "", (   " + ,, , 

      "  "",   " )   "

+( *; .

>

 ;"  ;,0+"   (,  > 0( 9    0+ "",  " 7( "> ) '(:,

(">"  0>( (0>( " I
" 77(  "", "  /+ >, I( 0 0+  , +  "(>(>((  *,( + ;  . 

  "   0+      ( > "

+ >( ,"(,   >  ( 7(   0  0       $ 7 + ;  .< (;  90          +0  ((      5(  
,, 50 0>02(G  "(, 

@-A ,"("(,> 90 !
I) "?+ ;  .-   

    7  

  > 0;90,  "

 "  ;  >0

, " 0 0   

     (> ,"(,"  , ,, ,

*; D *(0"   ;" 

"+0  ;      90 ,"(,   7        (     "(,  ) 

" >  ;"      "", (  

 (0 0 ((    (,    "",    0  + > 

     " ,0" >, (   "(,5(  
,,50 0" ( ( " "(*; D   %>(  %(,   I   1 I *7 $  >  !+ ,     %+   &0, " , I     ((       ( ,"(,  " , E","(, ,"( . "" <G %(+;  , "

 1 B +4 (  (     ;"  >,   (, ""( 9> " -, ,   ) ,>,(   , >, E","(,( ,"( .    6   ( (   ( > ((     (,"(,"" < 

,

@A       /  )  (,      ( (   ""( ( > "

   (  (, ( > > " ,C 8F (   , ( ( 7

0"  ,("  "(= () =99 )  , >  "  /6/? 0 ,( "   +

, *;  D     ""

+ > 
  &  +  



(  ""!

"
" (+ ,"( /6/   "   7        "(,  5(  
," 50 0       E0  "      0+D ;>  "

; D<$   0+" 0+0 "",,,     7(     0  0           

7      (     "(,    5(  
,"  50 0 "   0+ D  ;  90 ,   ,> "  "  +  " (, "",> 7(  "> 

>E0 (     "(,  5(  
,"  50 0 "

+(( (   

    +  " "

"  + 0  ;            7  >(    ,"(      "(,   & +  '!"( %)  *+  >  (    0+ ,0

" ," ,

0 E0" ,"(,   "    <  

,        / 

@ A  ,   "  ((  %"       (, " "",>((///" ,,  7( "> "(, 5(  
,"  50 0   

     "", (   >( ( /// "    ( (  7(  , "  ,

, "  "   (((>(

 " " "(///>"  "("  ,,>+ (0 , (>">((0    J -H "  ,       (, ((   ",

  38'(4 #' =0 
 "E0.

  G.


 " >(  G.