M/S Ravneet Agro Industries v. Punjab State Civil Supplies Corp Ltd & ORS












 

 

 




 !

!"#$#%&
'!()!*
+,


-$
'%!!
.*
%/0$ *#!$,
/1#*
/,
0$%*
#//!*)1 ,
#$ *#"

02 $* 33!44% 5!*$0$

0%6)
7  !
#'#4
70334#!$
*3* #%
8#(# !/,
1%/#.*1


 1!*$  !$3%/!% $   

   !"

#$

*!$!% &

*9579%.,
/'" !, *
1!
33!44% 

*(%
71*(,
/'" !, *
1!
*!$3%/!% $ :::::







































 !"

 %&' ;
1#$
*/!*,

#% !%/

/#$3$!

<
 $
%/ =


$
1!
"((%
>0!$ #%$

4<
%/
"
*!
#%'4'!/
#%
) 1 1!
33!4$ 1!
*!(!% #%!/
33!4$
*!

1!
#%$ %"!

1!
33!44% ?

#44!*
$!!2#%.
$! #%.?$#/!

1!
<*/$
/ !/
@
);
#%'2#%.
1! 3*'#$#%$

7!" #%
+A

1!
*)# * #%
%/
%"#4# #%
" ,
==
* $1*
B==
" C 
 1
1!
<*/$
1'!
)!!%
*!%/!*!/




/!$3# ! 1!
"
1
1!
33!44%
1/
'#4!/
1!
$!*'#"!$


4<;!*,
)0
/#/
% #4!
1!
*!34;

'!%
1!
)6!" #%$
1'!
)!!%
#4!/
<# 1
/!4;,
)0
;!
1! $(!
1'!
)!!%
/#$(#$$!/ 0*#%.
1!
"0*$!

*.0(!% $,
*9579%.,
4!*%!/ "0%$!4
*
1!
33!44% ,
%
#%$ *0" #%$
*(
1#$
"4#!% ,
.*!!/

$! 4!
1!

(0% 
*(%
71*(,
4!*%!/
"0%$!4
*
1!
7

1$
1%/!/ '!*


"3;

1!
4! !*
/ !/
@

$1<
1
1!
*!4#$)4!
'40!
 1!
3*3!* ;,
<1#"1
#$
)!#%.
!*!/
);
1!
33!44% ,
#$
4($

@
4"$, <1!*!$
1!
0 $ %/#%.
(0%
#$

,=,@,++-?
#%
) 1
1!
<*/$
$
% +A,
)0
""*/#%.

*9%.,
1!
3*#%"#34
(0%
$
3!*
) 1
1!

<*/$
#$

,@,,-?
*9%.
0* 1!*
$0)(# $
1
1!
1$
.#'!%
!*
 1!
7


$!44
4%/
(!$0*#%.
@
"*!$
*
1!
!D!"0 #%

1! <*/$,
)0
1!
7

#$
" #%.
$

$1;4"2
!
0* 1!*
$0)(# $
1

% /0) ,
1!
4<;!*
1/
%
)!!%
/#4#.!%
#%
30*$0#%.
1!
( !*
$
1! 33!44%
1/
"(34! !
# 1,
(0"1
4!$$
*!4 #%$1#3

4<;!*
%/
"4#!% <$
#/0"#*;
#%
% 0*!,
)0
;!
$0)(# $
1
<*/#%.

#% !*!$
E
F
#$ 
31!%(!%4
%
$033*

1#$
"% !% #%,
1!
1$
*!4#!/
03%
1!
* # /!"#/!%/#
"044!/
0
);
1!
%G)4!
703*!(!
0*
#%
(&)*&+%,-*.& /%0*1 23%-/- 4-  0)"

5   ,6,' 577

*(%
71*(
$0)(# $
1

1!
<*/#%.

#% !*!$
#$
#% "%$%%"!
<# 1
1!
!*($
%/
"%/# #%$

1!
.*!!(!% ,
#!,
40$!
 
1!
.*!!(!%
%/,
1!*!*!,
1!
<*/$
*!
3!*!" 4;
$
3!*
1! *!(!% #%!/
!*($

#% !*!*!%"!
#$
<% #%.
#%
'#!<

1!
"%/0"
 1!
33!44%  
1'!
1!*/
1!
4!*%!/
"0%$!4
*
1!
3* #!$,
33*#$!/
1! 33!*
)2
%/

1!
'#!<
1
1!
!D34% #%
.#'!%
*
#4#%.
1! )6!" #%$
/!4#)!* !4;
1$
%
)!!%
)"2!/
);
%;
".!%
*!$%$
$
1! .*!!(!%
!% !*!/
#% 
<$
 !*
1!
/!(#$!

1!
10$)%/

1!
33!44%  
<$
4$
1!
/0 ;

1!
33!44%

">0#*!
1!
2%<4!/.!
)0
1! 0 "(!

1!
*)# * #%
3*"!!/#%.$,
(0"1
4!$$
#%4
<*/$
*(
1! 4<;!*
#%$ !/

<# #%.
*
1!
%/
*(
1!
"0%$!4

1!
2%<4!/.!


)!
">0#*!/
#%
1!
 1!*
*)# * #%
3*"!!/#%.$
10.1
"%%
)!
$#/

)! 0%*!$%)4!,
)0
);
1
#(!,
1!
$  0 *;
3!*#/
3*!$"*#)!/
*
#4#%.
1! )6!" #%$
1/
!43$!/

1!
3*'#$#%$

8#(#  #%
"
/
%
334;

/ %
#% !%/

/#!*
<# 1
1!
#%/#%.$
*!%/!*!/
);
1!
)6!" #%.
0*
'#$?? '#$
/#$(#$$4

1!
)6!" #%$
%
""0%

1!
4#(#  #%,
)0
1!
" *!(#%$
1
1!

!4!(!%

#% !*!$
E
F
#$

31!%(!%4,
(0"1
4!$$ 1#.1
9!!3#%.
#%
'#!<
1!
"
1
1!
)0$#%!$$
#%
1!
!% #*!
"0% *;, (0"1
4!$$
#%
1!
7  !

0%6)
1$
"%$#/!*)4;
"(!
/<%
%/
1!*!
#$ 1*/4;
%;
3*.*!$$,
(0"1
4!$$
!'!%
1!
)%2
* !$
>0
1!
#% !*!$
1'! )!!%
"%$#/!*)4;
*!/0"!/,

/!!(
#
33*3*# !

*!/0"!
1!
* !
 #% !*!$
*(
F

F H# 1
1!
*!(!% #%!/
(/##" #%
#%
1!
<*/$,
1! 3*#%"#34
(0%
0 $ %/#%.
<04/
*!(#%
1!
$(!
1!
*!$3%/!% ?

7

$144
)!

4#)!* ;

$!!2
1!
!D!"0 #%

1!
<*/$
<# 1
1! #% !*!$
E
F
#%
""*/%"!
<# 1
4< 33!4$
$ %/
/#$3$!/

63893% 5"

  !  %&83-*

#$ !*30*3% -:3&+,.;4%3&-.3) <3-4 !*30*3% 3:%0&9'3 <3-4