M/S Punjab Agro Rice Bran Extractions Ltd v. M/S Banwari Lal Suresh Kumar & ORS
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH Date of decision: 08.05.2015 M/s Punjab Agro Rice Bran Extractions Ltd.
/.. Appellant versus M/s Banwari Lal Suresh Kumar and others //Respondents
CORAM:
Hon'ble Mr.Justice Kuldip Singh
!" #
$
$%
!
Kuldip Singh, J.
#
"#
&'%&(
+
"# , # - )
(. ) , //0 1 2#
) - (&%&&(-
3 )
*
- )*
4 "
) # 5
8 1 5682-- &&9 ") * - "
)#:
"
, 8 1:,!
- *
- 5 -8 " ;"#
<
% $ /'/=%
" *- #
)* =/=( :, - #"
"
"
"
) 568- )*:,
) 7 > !""? +
@ A " 3 #
- # ) -
$B
-- +
:, 3 >" -C
" *-
*
)*(/=. :,- -
"
* - "
" D
*:,
$%#
*
" C
$ "
) - :,
<
$
$%:,
" =(/=( C #
$
$# )
%E/=.# - )
:
- "
) #:
"
" "
///='- ; - #+
- )* >" * # 568- ; - #+
///=' *
* *-
)
%&E/='
) "
:,D %
* *
) C #
)
)
(
$%B :, +"
* )
:,
E=///
- ) 3
- )* %%%&&&
$%B:,-
3 -
# ?#," , $E/0 %&&&
"
) ) /.&-
# )*,
$E/' %&&& F %.%&&)
,
-
#
?#," )
#
# - 3 ) "# - (&%&&(- *
)
) * " .0'((&4B #-
G %9
"3
- " 568
///=' ) * "
:, -
-
568 - -
- " *"
% #
///=' ) * "
-@"
#
$%<:, %%%&&&
#
) )
: "
*# "#
.
@
," >" 7 -
:,- #
*- *
%%%&&&
," ,
$E/0 %&&& # - , $E/' %&&&
7" B# - #
:, * ) "# $ % # &
$
'#$ '
'
#$
$ ( )
)* #
+
(
, - :
-*
%%%&&&
:,-
# - 3
* - :,
* * #
/'/=%-
$<
-
///=' >" ) 7 3 "
67,B.. /'/=%
- #
- 7 "
) - 568
$B
" *
'
3 #
# +
:
568- -
*-
") * :, -:,&&9 :,--
*- !
*"
>" * ; - # +
#
///=' $- C #
///='
7" 4. - - % #
- " "#
.+/01
# ' 2 '
% '
- :
# - 568-
)
///='-
"
:,3 - #
"
) ) )* -
" -
*
" * - - "
)
* /=.
#
" -C - # " # *
$%
"
=(/=(
7" % C ) C
F
7" ( %E/=.
3 "
- * 7
568-
) :,- 568
; - #+
///=' #
7" .3 : - %%%&&&
:, *
#
) )
:, - * "
* -
*
-
% #
///='
7" . " %%%&&&
)
:, *
)*
3 +
"# , #
(.
) :
) --
(&%&&(3
)
%%&&( ? ;" )
F 568 $- >"
-"
-
* "
( ")B '
" 314# $
' -
3
- *6 *
)
*
* * (.(-
#
# )
-
)"
- * C
) - 3
C
* *
*" ) 3 - >"
"
* # * )
-
3
:
)
)
"
(. ) 3 +
"# , #
" $% :
- # # "
- 3 "# "#
&'%&(
+
"# , # -
) - (&%&&(
)C
3 )
"
-
568
-
C # - )
)* ,"
- #)"
-
) * "
;
# -
=
) ) "
-"
(0 )
*
08.05.2015 (Kuldip Singh) % Judge