High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/957/2010disposed of

Chander v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-12-10Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain3 pages

"#$ %$&'(')* $&$+,$- .

* /0 11 0 -$($)#* 1213-'13"'4$)%-""').1$)'-%5&"#$6'#3 "7-"588"-6"4.1")%$$913"-+". "%"5")% (13$$)717-".%5&"#$( -#3$4")%6)$-( -13'5$)%-"16"-9.(('(#")#%5&"#$$)$-"4."-:")" ";$(3')%"4 3'(-%$-6'44%'(9($ ( . # <

= > ?

= (< ?")% >

=")% >

? 3$4")%6)$-("-$')"99$"4($$@')8 7-#3$-$)3")&$+$)#

&+9$)("#') -#3$"&A7'-$%4")% -'$ 4:.#3$ "&#( #3$&"($"-$#3"# 5'%$)#'

'&"#')%"#$%

B.'((7$%7)%$-1$&#')? #3$0")%&A7'('#')&#.<?

- (3-#./#3$&#/!.1#"#$ "-:")"(783##"&A7'-$ B ?"&-$( 4")%.

('#7"#$%6'#3')#3$-$5$)7$$(#"#$ 5'44"8$C"D'-","%.$3('4 '(#-'&#

7-8") -#")'&"4"-%$)')1$&#- E.7-8")3$("+$6"(

446$%,:)#'

'&"#')%"#$%>?

?.'((7$%7)%$-1$&#')> #3$&# 3$0")%&A7'('#')44$&#-

-(3-#./#3$44$&#-/!.5'%$"6"-% B%"#$%

?."(($(($%#3$&+9$)("#') #3$"&A7'-$%4")%F .

2E9$-"&-$ 88-'$5$%"8"')(##3$"6"-% #3$44$&#-.#3$ 4")%6)$-( '4$%,;$&#')(63'&36$-$-$ $--$%##3$4$"-)$%&7-#,$46.

63@$$9')8')5'$6#3$+"#$-'"494"&$%)-$&-%,:#3$9"-#'$(.5'%$ "6"-%(%"#$%

")%B <

"6"-%$%&+9$)("#') F 2E9$-(A7"-$:"-%G'%$")#3$-"6"-%%"#$% B

?.#3$4$"-)$% &7-#,$46"6"-%$%&+9$)("#')F . >2E9$-(A7"-$:"-% 0$"-)$%&7)($4 -#3$4")%6)$-((7,+'##$%#3"##3$"&A7'-$% 4")% ') #3$ 9-$($)# &"($ '( 4&"#$% &4($ # #3$ 4")% "&A7'-$% 5'%$ )#'

'&"#')%"#$%>

B3$"99$"4(9$-#"')')8#5"47"#') 4")% "&A7'-$%5'%$"

-$("'%)#'

'&"#')"-$9$)%')8')#3'(&7-#C3"#$5$- "+7)# &+9$)("#')'(%$#$-+')$% -#3"#"&A7'('#').#3$("+$+":,$ 8-")#$%##3$4")%6)$-(')#3$9-$($)#&"($"(6$44 0$"-)$%&7)($4 -#3$1#"#$%'%)#%'(97#$#3$ "&##3"##3$ "&A7'-$%4")%')#3$9-$($)#&"($'(4&"#$%&4($##3$4")%"&A7'-$%5'%$ )#'

'&"#')%"#$%>

B")%#3$"99$"4(9$-#"')')8#5"47"#') 4")% "&A7'-$%5'%$"

-$("'%)#'

'&"#')"-$9$)%')8')#3'(&7-# $"-%4$"-)$%&7)($4 -#3$9"-#'$(")%9$-7($%#3$-$4$5")# -$ $--$%-$&-% G'%$ )#'

'&"#') %"#$% B>

B. #3$ 4")% 9$-#"')')8 # -$5$)7$$(#"#$ C"D'-","%6"("&A7'-$%3$4")%"&A7'-$%')#3$9-$($)# &"($'(4&"#$%&4($##3$4")% -$5$)7$$(#"#$ C"D'-","%.63'&36"( "&A7'-$%5'%$)#'

'&"#')%"#$%>

BG'%$($9"-"#$;7%8+$)#9"(($% #%":')

H341')83")%")#3$-51#"#$

"-:")"")%")#3$-.#3'(&7-#3"("(($(($%#3$&+9$)("#')F .?

B2E 9$-(A7"-$:"-%9$-#"')')8#4")% -$5$)7$$(#"#$ C"D'-","%.63'&3 6"("&A7'-$%5'%$)#'

'&"#')%"#$%>

B(#3$4")%')A7$(#')'( 4&"#$%')#3$("+$"-$".#3$4")%6)$-(')#3$9-$($)#&"($%$($-5$#,$ 8-")#$%#3$("+$"+7)# &+9$)("#').'$. F .?

B2E9$-(A7"-$ :"-%-%$-$%"&&-%')84:3$4")%6)$-((3"44"4(,$$)#'#4$%#"44

B (#"#7#-:,$)$ '#("5"'4",4$##3$+7)%$-#3$&# 3$"99$"4("-$%'(9($% "&&-%')84:

";$(3')%"4!

7%8$

$&$+,$- .