Naraji Devi v. U.H.B.V.N. Ltd & ORS
" #$%$ &
'' ( ''' $ $ & ) (** '
''(''
+'
, *
''' %- &" & % .
/+ .'
* * *
* *
0 '
1)
##$%##& '" (
) "
" *"
) +, #+ - +0
1
" +, #++$ ,0 3
" "
"
) /)
' 5 6" #++7
)
*" !
#
!
8 % "3
8 ()
"! ' .
48 ( '0
9
)
48 ( '
)
7+ +& #++#
" : '
")
(
3"
" : '
)" 2"'
2" ) " : ' "! 8 ;
)
") +7 #+++ +7 #++-
) " 2"'
2" )
: %' %"! 8 ;
)%' %;!
< :% ") 8
/
( ) 8
2
# +$ #++$ # 7+= '" (
8% "
"
"
# "$
% & '
# ( # $ # )* +*
, # #%%- , ##
$ "% # #%%- ,
"" +* -* # .
"%*
# /
0(" 0 +%
2 , 0("$ 3
%
, $ "
%*45
(# * $ )* 6 (
3 % (
"% *
$ )* 3 " 6 + &6 3 % (
"% *
$ )* ( " 6 + ,% +
* $ + )* -
, %$ " 6 + !"#"
, , 5"%* # , %
"
(
"%*
# /
0(" 0 +% 2 ,
6 - -
, "
#
6&6
6&6 , $
# # "
(
$%+% /
0(" +% 2 ,0 (5# 01+ % / 0 * .
%
,
"
# $ - "
#
9 :::555:::555:::
.
# "%*
# /
0(" 0 +% 2 ,
%
, (5 "$ 3
- %
+
"% %# "
+% 6 .
#
"%*
%% + # $
"%*
-%% $ %,% ,
, # %% " 0/
+% 2 ,
$ , ;
- %
< #
+ # "
+ #%%
"
# ,
"%*
, ( +
# "
" 6 !6 .
# "%*
%% +
6 :::555:::555:::
48 ( '
)
70 ) )
> ;
:3 ?
) <
"! 8 ;
)
4 2 (( #& #++$
# +$ #++$ #0
(
)
4 2 (( 6 #$-+%>+++ " ""
)
"
!
#
" /
"
>0 "
" 3 : 0=2 "
1)/> %26 6 0 .
'
% 68 $. (% * )
? %6 6 +4 "" # " # )%" 56
# $ )* % $ " # 6
&0( 06& '0
$ @@@@@@@@6666666
@@@@@@@@ *
+* ##
"" , "* " # )%" 5% "*
% # !8 07 "%
% %%-
* +
+* , # 6 999599959995999
%
+ %%*
## # ""
"
%* "* + ( < %* *
$
+
- - $
$ * , - *
+ 999599959995999 A
-%% + "+ # "
# - *
- * # + 9
# "
# * * -2
#
#*
, "
# "+ B *
$
%+% +
#- -
, , * 6 999599959995999 >
3
) !" "" #& +& #++&
!" =
) %21%/) %'62%
"
" *"
) -
"
) *"
! ) $ /)
+, #++$
4
,0
)
) & !"
)
*"
! '" )
(=
CD5
7
6 . $ $
1 )* /.% > ,
' : '" #+ >
)) ;4:?
< "
) )
+ ") +, #+ -
)) ;4:?
< "
! 3 1
%
+, #++$ ,0
-
< " "!
") +, #+ - +0
) % ,0
) )
!
4 " "!
")
)) )
+, #++$ ,0 ! " += +- #++,
1 '
8 67%70 1 '
8
) % ! " "
( '
'
)"
)!
!%
4 " "!
+= +- #++, 67%70
1 '
8 "
"!3
!"
# +$ #++$ #0
7+= '" (
4
"! "
"
" " 7+= '" (
)
"
"
4 " "!
" " !" " " "
4 "!
#
! "
"
"!
$
< " " "!
)
!
% +, #++$ ,0 ! "
6"
)!
5
%1 8 =$>
4 " "!
)
)! " ! "
8 =$> "
)"
4 " "! "
) ) ) "
")
!"
)"
( )
)
# +$ #++$ #0
7+= '" (
8
!
8
)
8 "! / 8 8 ) ) )" 2"'
2" : %'
)
)" 48 ( '
" 8
"
: %'
" )
""
8
4 2 (( >
) "
9
) ) > "!
!
") " "
) !"
)" '
48 ( '
6
""
)
)" "
# @ !
)
)
4 " "!
"
>0
"
"
4 " "!
) "
!"
)"
")
!
6 #$-+%>+++ " ""
) "
"
! ! "
&
< "
8 =$>
6" $ & "3 ' 8 6" ?"((
)
"!
6"
"
"
""
" !
!"
) "
""
/
" A "" B " ' " .0 "
!
4 " "!
)
/ ' C
) ""
!" =
/
8
( )
>
) >
/ ' C
4 "
)
>
)
4 " "! "
)
/
"
4 " "!
)
"
! " ' " .0
"" "
!
6" $ & "3 ' 8 6" ?"(( "
" -%% +
+%-4G EF #%* " -%% +
+% # -%
$ # # #
$ "%* -
" # " $%
,
" " 6
#
-%
$
$ "%*
%
$ "%
"
#
*
#
$
-
+26 #%* " -%% +
+%
# # #
"%* #
-
" # , * %*4 $
#
"% ,
"
# * #
$ -%% + ""%+% # $ "%* -
+ %%* 9
%
# # * $
$6 EF H *
$I
%
EF
%
$
#
"
"*
$ " +% +%
* "
#
%$
%
,
9 *
%$
%
/* $
" "
%
, %
+* " *6
,
< "
"!
") +0
)
!)
% 7+= '" (
+, #++$ ,0 " )! 8 =$>
=
C " "!
)
"!
)"
3") 4@! 8" '" "
$% !"&"'!(')*"&+&),,") -
.
/0 ' 12/3 4
"% " "
8 =$>
1 8 )" ,
4 " "!
!
1 '
8 += +- #++, 67%70
!!
) % ! " "
( '
'
)!
!%
) % ! "
" ! 1 8
) " "!
+= +- #++, 67%70
"
)
48 ( '
!
!"
" "
4 " "!
")
67%70
)"
) "
! ! 1 8
( "
#
(
)
48 ( '
7+ +& #++#
)
#0
# +$ #++$ 7+= '" (
8
)" 2"'
2"
'*" " > ;4:?
<
#& #++$
# +$ #++$
)
4 2 (( 6 #$-+%>+++ " ""
(
"
!
4 "" #& +& #++&
!" = 3)
"
) %21%/)
%'62%
"
) )
7+= '" (
+, #++$ ,0
! 6"
/)
)" !
(
,0
4
! ") +, #+ - +0
)) ;4:?
< "
")
% 1 '
8 += +- #++,
)
67%7
1 '
8
) % ! " "
( '
'
)"
)!
!%
+= +- #++, 67%70 "
" 3
3 % (
J "% *
$ )* - " 6
, , )>
2 %6
6
!0&&0 !57 -
'6 86 '56"7 2 &%0 #, " " !"
*","%" %"""% &"#" #,) $"" "8')"
!" 9$ #, " " !"
*","%" !"*"""% &"#" #,) $""')"+
9 ) ')" %'5 ')": ')"4 # * 6(5 !0 05787!
6 &6
+.
+$6
$ + $
"%*
, %0" * + #
# "$
##
(
(" * - ""
$ "
,
" 2 +* $6 %,+% # * " * + # # %
6 " - # 3 % (
J "% * $ )* - " 6
(
)" 48 ( '
8
7+= '" (
#0
> !"
!" = 3)
" ! %21%/)
%'62%
" )" 67%7
) % ! "
)"
)!
!%
! "
" " " 6"
7+= '" (
4
" !3)
1 1
4
'
8 67%7 )
!
" 6"
,0
)!
! " )!
6"
%1 8 =$>
>
)
!3 " 67%7
% 1 '
8 % ! "
)"
)! !%
!" ""
")
) 48 ( '
!"
!
"
" "
)
4 )
" "
# +$ #++$ #0 7+= '" (
>
"
>
"
")
)
!"
!
(
)
" " !"
)
!"
"
/ "
) 48 ( '
)
)"
8
)
!) " , +, #++$
7+= '" (
6"
-
6" )
9
48 ( '
!
) "!
8
)"
" #
# +$ #++$
!
8
8
) ) )" 2"'
2"
"!
"
)
""
%8 7+= '" ( " ! "
1 '
8 ! "
8"
5
# +$ #++$ #0
-
(
% "%
) "
7+= '" (
"
)
"
: '"
)
"
) ) 8 #++$ 6;'#&"' <$=6) 0#1#"%% !"+
./:3 :+
!
!
1 '
8
) 6" 7+= '" (
,
3") "
" C6 # "
- - ,
&6&6 #
< +
+* # )* '6C6 E5
+ % %*
-
#
+% *
# %- +
%
$ + #
% & '
# (
%
'6C6 E5
+
+* 3 % (
"% * $ # )* 6
-%%
%
"
+* 3 % (
$ ## # -" , %
#
% & '
# ( - " - #
6C6 E5'F6 "
% # #
6C6
-
%
$ + #
% & '
# ( 6
+ $ %
#
% & '
# ( + $
$ +*
, 9 $
6
%
# ( 6 ,
% * + "%
( / .
, # ) K+% " ( # #!#&" 6!+> -',"#"
'
-
+ " %* #%%-
%
""%
+ #
%
, *!6$ )(& " <!)+
./ 3 4
./3? :
/
.3:-
!&< >%+ /
.3 : -
+ %
*
9 $
+ ,$ "$ ##6 " %
+* 3 % (
- $ ,
9 $
%
# (
+ %
" +* "
,
%
#
% & '
# ( E5'F
+,
$ %* ## ,
# " 6 , "" %* - %
+ "+%6 #
# "
,
%
6'6
E5!
J 5DF "$%* 2 , " , " , +* " , # % "5
95, "* +
# % # 3 % (
'6C6
"
+* " 6
!6'6 - %
+
+%
%+% +
6 3
#
"
"
,
%
6'6 E5!F
E5DF +*
6
"
% %% + #
"
$ ,
+*
&6&6 E58F6 # %
%% + - "
# -
#
# " # #
"* # 6 "
"
# +$ %%- $
' : '" # ""*"&@% 8 1" ! '%" 2) &"' !" " $ % !"+ @2 .:
!
3") "
" $ , , %
#
%
""%+%* %* " "%* * %*
9"
#
+ ,$ #%* # 0$ "%*6
#
"%*
+
"% * + # " %,% " $ # $ "%* - -
"* " 6
#
"" # " K
+
-
# "%*
+* # 5"%* 0+ " #
"%*
# $ (" $ % * # " K
+
1)/> -
#* - %$ "%*
%
< %* ""% # "
- %
% + 9
" 6 "
,
86&6
9
5D
5!
"$%* <
"
" K
% # "
"$
%
"
+* 1)/>6
%% + 2 +* * - , -2
# # " # #
"* # 6 - "
%%-
+. +$
&
(
% 1 '
8 67%7 ) ! "
)
7+= '" (
#
,
,
8
!3 " " 6"
,0
)!
6"
%1 8 =$>
"
6" $ & "3 ' 8 6" ?"((
"
!
"
6"
"
" ""
" !
)
" ""
/
A "" B " " .0 "
!
")
!" = !)
)
! !"
/ ' C
"
>
) )
)
/ ' C
"
! "
% %1 8 =$>
" )! " 6"
,0
=
< " "
3") 4@! 8" '" " $% !"&"' !(')*"&/',3
%
4
"
3")
"
$
(
! 4@! 8" '" 8
)"
!
"
)"
"
)"
6"
C ! "
"
" ! "
)
(
")
>0
!"
#0
7+= '" (
)"
")
)
!
3") 4@! 8" '"
" " )"
#+
(
"
") +, #+ - +0 !
*"
)
!
- 5/)
8 +, #++$ ,0
*" !
)
$E
" .0
1* *
3 ''
7
& 7 89) 9
)% F% 9 F%