← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1088/2016dismissed

Sonia Kuruvilla v. Simon Chaudhary

2017-11-03Mr. Justice S.P. Bangarh11 pages

 

     

  

 !!"#$#%&'() *+%#,-*-.#// 

*+#0%1-21*3    &'  45

 ++6+          

   +6+7     !

                   "

#    $%&'$&('$)   *+ *+ 

* #

 +   $'    ,  $-)% *   + #

    '/&$$&('$(  *          

    

*"

*  #

+*+  0*       12 3

*+ 

*+ 

  #

  #4    '/&$$&('$(      

    

   #     

     0 

 



 

#6! 75       # # #8

9-(:  ( ;

5 # # #  *  

* 

# 8   

  + * 

   

 

      

  ;

    +  <

           + # "

 

* #



*+ #

  

= +('$: 8

9$:%>  ? ;

0 

*+

*  

   



   #!   +$/+ 

* +



*

!      8 





!   #

 

+ #  *

 

*  

  #"

  

 

 *+ "

 #  8

  8

9-(:  ( ;

0 

*+

*  <0 9?/:')&'%&('$:

  #  *  *+   

:(:?')?%-/'):?0   

    

  @ 

#    # 

+  

   $( ,#    *+  

    #+ "*  ,   :(A #8 



  

 +      

+ *##*+  ( B    #*+  *+  /$'+ #



* #+##*

   

  *  

 +  #+

*   #+

 ,A++ #0 

 

+ *##*+ #+##*



* ,#* ('$(

* 

*        * 0   * 

! *  +  * 0 

 $'&'$&('$:



*    *+     #+      

*      

+  

##    #  #

   #    #*+

*

 0  

 ;          *  

*  #  #  8 <0 #

,#   #*

 8 0     

 *

*           

           $    $



+ *   5 

 

*   

+5



+  #

 

##

+  #*+

    #  8  9 2                       

*+ 25 

 # 

 

+ ##*+  #+  **   8    * 

 

  # 

;

  +  **  +

  





* #    +   

  

   8 

    

*+ 

* *   

*3      

*

    

+#  *+ #+##*



*

* * 0 *      

*  + #  #+* 

  0  <0    @    # ,#   # *  0 *+   

+ *##*+   



#* $'6@7 , $-)% 

* #  "

 



 

  *  

#   * 8     $'6@7$-)% # 8 + * #     #  "

#

*+ 

  B     

   2 

   +# 

  ##

+ 

*      

*+ 

    

  +      8               + +           

         #*  #     +   #  @$C;

6   

    ##

  

$?;



:;

*+3 #+ #

#4#

! 75

  + #+* #

 ) 0  2     

  *;     *

 + # + #

 

+#   * #

 >    

+

    *    @  $'6@7 , $-)%  *   D

     

       

 

     

   

          

     

 E * 

   

     + #

 D *  E #  * #  "

 #&  

  

          *              +   D 

  E ##+ #      *

#*    +     0   *    #     

#+# &   

     D     E   +#+*    +#    #     +      *    "+         *    E   +  D #    "

+E       #& +         

#  *    &

##  #+ ##*

  <

        D#  

+E  

* + #  

  * 

 * 

 *+  F;     +   

+  #  

+          *

 *+    0 

+#  *  #

      #                 

  #

3 



*+    +* 

 

 #    

# #  *5   *  #    #  ; # +5    

* ;  #    #  #   #          +              *  +4   *+;   #    $'6@7, $-)% 0     #      

*@ $ # 

@#  # #

* +

;  #*   1; ;3

#

*  

#     +  *+    #+      *  *      

 8  ;

 #

              #  #     

*     #+  ##*

  ;   +   #   8  #     *    +         #  6G@ *    /:7  8      

@#

        ;

  #       *+

# 



   # *  <0 6G@ */?7     *

    +

 <0  *+  

 

 #5 *;* 

*



*

 <0   * &# #  # <

#

 *+*



* #

+ 

6

 *+ >

+ # 7  #

+ +



* * 

*8  <0   

  

+"   *8 #+    *  #

  

  * 

 #5      +  

 + + + 

*  *+  <0  

       + #*

*

+8         <0   

*  

  

* +

   +  # *+    <0     #

*    9+ #

 ,#      * #

 9+ *  

*  + *

*+ 25 

*

 

@# #  #  + 





!  + #+ #0   

*   #+* + ; 

**+;   ! # 0 #    #  !   *#  +  *

6+ 7

* 

;  * 

   

 #     +   +     *      

*    #+   +           #        +      *+      

       # 0 

#    



# # #  ? ;

* ;

 

*  ( ;

  

  



# #*

#*  *

B *     # # # #+ "

    3 #   9+ 

 

 #    



  #"

     #  

  ( ;

6G@:/7 0 +  +* *

   #

 *            *          *

*"  

*     #  

+   

  @   *   

 # "

+*

 #0#

*; #     *  *+;        $'6@7$-)% 

 *      : 5 # 

#

 *

    #

*

  +  +  

  @ *

 &* 

 

   +  @ #+   ++  #

# *1 

  3 *



# "

+       

 

 

#   # *        *     + #



    *

 *   

 *  + 

+



# *

*+ *

 

  ;         +           #      +;  $'6@7 , $-)% 

   # 

* 



+ 

 *   #  * #  "

 #   +0 #  

*+   

 #



* +#  6+6+

 .!0;!*(*27) +



 



 !

 "

 !