← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4455/2017allowed

M/S Kundan Lal Vijay Kumar v. Indian Oil Corporation Ltd And ANR

2017-03-07Mr. Justice Krishna Murari5 pages



       

 !"!#$% & ' ( %)"*+#, #- ./!0 1*+2 & 3

/" #,!

# !.&4&

!#-!2!

,(%+25 ! #& 3 "4#,#  %$  6-%  7%%7 88 

&"# $8 %&+&9!#,&7!#:'7!,'+(,9

 & !#& %&"'!"'* 4&(,9

&

&8&"4#,# " 88 

/!,.

8,

, #+ &1<( ( !&2='! '!# "4 #&"'!4!&2(!"&+##!#: :# 1 24 #1 ='! ' .

& # 2&:, !#   -( = " &>+!&,  +4. # ""

&1 ,

!." ) , +2# " 4&

!#!#: ' , .&"'!4 !# '!& 4&

. ? .&##+ .

+&#@# '&4&

!#6"=5"!

===!#,!

#!. !#( "5# !#&2,

!#& '

, #  +4. ,, , +2# " # 4&

.&<8 #,8 = "+& '&2# !#,!# '"

!,.

!# '9# 4 !#&6"# "+52!

!#: '&>+!&,9 .!,, +2#

51 5&+ &1( ( '&"4#,# "=+.,5 #"

!#, "

4"+44.!"  ..4&,+

A '&# ""

&1

'&4&

!#,2"!



!#& .

!2,

''

, 24.!,=!

' .. ' &>+!"!

#,!

!#"&&+##!#: '5+"!#"" /!,.

8B,

5&+ &1( &;4!&1 B, 1"( !#&'

"5#!# !2

"..="$8  

     

      



 !  " !

! !

 #  $!

! !"!   !! " !"

 %&  ''  $



 () * +)#( ,!!    ,!!

-!

  

!!  !   !

 !   .  !

!   !

!&

'!  / !0  ,!

!,,, 



  

  !!"!-!

!"!!

!

!

(# )# +)#1   . !

-! !    ,!! !2 !

   "!     "  ,!

! ! !   " ! !  ! -!

  

  

 !2 !

  ! "  !

0  

,!

-!

3 

! !2 !

,! ! "! 0    !,!!



 " ! ! .!!!

 !4! !

!,!!

  

!0 

3  -

!"

 ! 

 - ! !  ! !! !!

!

-!    !.

  

 . "  -   !

  

!

!

    -   " ! !

.!!!

 (  5!    -! 

 ! !

! &

 '!   !0  6,!

!"!!

+)#(#78 +)#7#9   !

   !  !

  !

!   ! -!

   

  -! !!

!!!

  : ! ! !       !

   ,   !!

  ,    " .  !    ; 

! " !  . !  -! !!

 !

   <  -!, " !

-! ,! !        ! "    "   ! , !

 !!""! !

-!!! !

, 

! !

  !! !!"!0 



!.!0    -!

!!   ! ,"

/ ' .

8B !#,!

' &"4#,# &4&

!# '

A#  , !"!#  "

4 "+44.1  .. 4&,+ , .&"'!4  !#& =!

' !22,!

   & ' & "#"

&+ !

.!#&2

!#'

"# 5#+&#!"', ', +2# ""+52!

& # "4& 44&9, #"

#,'

95#&0 ,  ! 2 !# '&"4#,# &#

 %& "'!"' * 4&( ,9

" # !  # 5'

.   -

 +#". & ' &"4#,# " '

" 5# "A,  +&#!"' "#"='! ' &#  .

&.1"4 !!,!# '&,& 8B  '

"5#!#&2,51%&"'!"'* 4&(# '5 "!" & &, !.

5.=!

''!2( !#&!"

..1# ', .& ='2

'+ .

= ..

,'

""+52!

., .&'

". " # '5+"!#""!"!# ''

#,"+# '&!C,4&"#"  '

9 '

&, .

&#, +#". & " =.. +#".& '&"4#,# #,!#,

'& "#"&"

44!#: '"+44.1

#, +&

!.!#: '5+"!#"" ",!" .",!# '+& ,# !#,2# !#,!# '&,&##;+& 8B 

"!

2 1(=!

'+ # &!#:!# ',!"4+ ,>+"

!#

"(  2  ' !&2 4!#!#

' &,& ,

5&+ &1 (   !" 9!.

!9&+."#

+& .0+"

! '

9!#:5#4 "",=!

'+ :!9!#:  !& 44& +#!

!#&!&2"'= +"# ! = "!""+, !#&5&4 ""!#: '4&0+,! !

.&,& 8B !" "

., 4&!# !4..

=

9&1

!#9&#2# '&!

1!" 4 "" "

 & "# 5.#""

 !

 !" !# ' !# &"

  #

+& . 0+"

!  ='! ' !"

&# .12!""!#:!# '!" " # 9!=  59( !# !" ..=,  ' &,&

8B,

5&+ &1( !"'&51"

"!,5!#:9!.

!9

'&+."#

+& .0+"

! =!

' ,!&

'&"4#,# "=!..5

.!5&  !""+  "'= +" # !  2# !#!#: ' !&&:+.

&!

!" & !..:

.!

!" 22!

, 51 !#& !&2 !# 9!.

!#  :&2#

 # &, !#  5 =# !"  =9&( !

 =!.. 5 4# &"4#,# 4 "" #14&0+,! !

.&,& :

!#"

&:!9!#: !&44& +#!

!#& % & ' ( D%%7E "

#0   '

'&"4 A!#:)& "#,$ ") '

'& 4&

5.$ ")