Naresh Kr. Dhiman v. Shiv Kr. & ORS
!"# $#%&'&() #%#*+#,-.
!,#'/01*!, /&*!( 22#33!("
4#,'1' 5/&601*!,!($"/#,' #'2($#("'
! !
"!
,#'#(") ,!7&($#,5&(8/!(!.$6%!"#
,"/#!22#33!(" , 5$3!9/!.$6%!"#
,,#'2($#(" :::
!
"! #
22#33!(" ; !,#'/ 01*!, /&*!( /!' 2,# #,,#$ "/&'
!22#!32,!<&(8 ,#(/!(%#*#(" %*2#('!"&(!=!,$#$"/&* 6&$# !=!,$ $!"#$ > 2!''#$ +< 3#!,(#$ ", %%&$#("
3!&*',&+1(!3.01,19'/#",!/#,#&(!
"#,,# #,,#$"!'"/#?,&+1(!3? (!%%1(" &(71,&#''1
#,#$+</&*&(!*",6#/&%3#!%%&$#("(
!%"'!'(!,,!"#$&("/#%3!&*2#"&"&(!,#"/!"!22#33!(" =!' 2,%##$&(8 " /&' ,#'&$#(%# ,* "/# '&$# !&( !@!,.
/!(#'!,(*",%<%3# !7!7 3!"&(!+#!,&(8,#8&'",!"&(;
- ; ( !"!+1" /1,'A/#(/#=!'&( ,("
!%/#*&'"'/2(#!, !("!5%/3.%!,+#!,&(8,#8&'",!"&( ;; ;->B $,&6#(+<,#'2($#("C5/&601*!,!"!/&8/ '2##$&(!,!'/!($(#83&8#("*!((#,.&(6&3!"&( ",!
&%,13#'
%!*# ,*+#/&($!($'",1%9!8!&('""/#!22#33!("22#33!(" #33( "/#8,1($!($,#%#&6#$8,='&(71,&#'22#33!("?'+,"/#,51,#'/ 01*!, /&*!(!,,&6#$!""/#'2"!($"/#,2#,'('!3'8!"/#,#$ "/#,# #'2($#(" 3#$ ,* "/# '2" !3(8=&"/
#($&(8 6#/&%3#!'2#23#8,!"/#,#$"/#,#22#33!("=!''/& "#$" /3!
'2&"!3. 01,19'/#",! +< /&' +,"/#, 22#33!(" '1
#,#$ *13"&23# &(71,&#'( ,#/#!$.,&8/"'/13$#,!($3# "=,&'". ,!%"1,# /1*#,1'
!($,&8/"'%!2/&$$!"#$ D >=!',#8&'"#,#$ !8!&('"$,&6#, "/#
#($&(86#/&%3##2,"1($#,5#%"&(
, D
=!'2,#'#("#$!
"#,%*23#"&( &(6#'"&8!"&(!($ %/!,8#'/##"D -=!'2,#'#("#$!8!&('",#'2($#(" 3!&* 2#"&"&( =!' 2,# #,,#$ +< "/# !22#33!(" 1($#, 5#%"&('>>!($ "/#",4#/&%3#'%".B-- ,8,!("
%*2#('!"&(""/#"1(# 3!9/' 3!&*=!'%("#'"#$+<"/#,#'2($#("'#'2($#("' !($ 23#!$#$"/!"(!%%&$#("=&"/"/#
#($&(86#/&%3#/!$ "!9#(23!%#!($!22#33!("(#6#,,#%#&6#$!(<&(71,&#'"/#,#&( !3'# %!'#/!'+##(,#8&'"#,#$&(%331'&(=&"/"/#23&%#1,"/#,*,#. ,#'2($#(";$,&6#,=!'/3$&(8!6!3&$!($#
#%"&6#$,&6&(83&%#(%# !($
#($&(8 6#/&%3# =!' &('1,#$ =&"/ ,#'2($#(" #'2($#(" ;&('1,!(%#%*2!(<23#!$#$6&3!"&( "#,*'!($
%($&"&(' &('1,!(%#23&%<!'=#33!',#8&'",!"&( !3'#&( %331'&(=&"/"/#23&%# 33=&(8&''1#'=#,# ,!*#$+<"/#3#!,(#$,&+1(!3);
A/#"/#,"/#!%%&$#("&(E1#'"&(=/&%/"923!%#(
!"!+1"2*&("/#!,#! !("!
5%/3. /!('! !$. 01,19'/#",! 1($#, 3&%# 5"!"&(.&"</!(#'!,$1#",!'/!($(#83&8#("$,&6&(8 "/# %!, +#!,&(8 ,#8&'",!"&( ; ;->B +< ,#'2($#("!($&",#'13"#$&(&(71,&#'"%3!&*!("F
&''1#&'2,6#$&(!
&,*!"&6#.=/!"#D"#("
%*2#('!"&("/#2#"&"&(#,=13$+##("&"3#$"!($
,*=/*F
A/#"/#,"/#"#,*'!($%($&"&(' &('1,!(%#23&%< =#,# 6&3!"#$ +< ,#'2($#(" !($ &('1,!(%# %*2!(<&'("3&!+3#"&($#*(& <"/#%*2#('!"&(!'
!33#8#$F ;
#3&# "#,%('&$#,&(8"/##6&$#(%#(,#%,$.3#!,(#$,&+1(!3 %(%31$#$"/!"!%%&$#("&(=/&%/"/#!22#33!(",#%#&6#$&(71,&#'=!' %!1'#$$1#",!'/!($(#83&8#("$,&6&(8
#($&(86#/&%3#+< ,#'2($#("5!&$ &($&(8&'&( ,*#$"/!6#!""!&(#$ &(!3&"< "!3%*2#('!"&( .
. G;=!'!=!,$#$""/#!22#33!("!'
$#"!&3#$/#,#1($#,);
!&(!($'1
.G;
#$&%!3#D2#('#' >.
G;
'2&"!3&'!"&( .
G;
&'!+&3&"< -. G;
"!3 # # $
(%*# "/# !22#33!(" =!' !''#''#$ !' >. G;.
%('&$#,&(8/&*"+#!(1('9&33#$3!+1,#,&("/#!+'#(%# !(< 2'&"&6##6&$#(%#"2,6#/&'6%!"&(13"&23&#, =!'!223&#$.
9##2&(8&(6&#= "/#!8# !22#33!(""+# <#!,'H''
&(%*#=!'!''#''#$!' .>.G;!'"/#!22#33!("=!' 1($ '1
,*$&'!+&3&"<""/##D"#(" -I#=!'8,!("#$-I
"/#!*1("&#-. G; H#!,(#$%1('#3 ,"/#!22#33!("6#/#*#("3<!,81#'"/!"
!22#33!("=!',1((&(8+1'&(#'' 4%!+3#(#"=,9# #,#(%#&'
*!$#"'"!"#*#(" "/#!22#33!("+<=!< /&'!
&$!6&".D G "'1+*&""/!"/#=!'#!,(&(8 .G;2#,*("//#,# ,#.3''
&(%*#'/13$+#!''#''#$.!%%,$&(83<1,"/#,*,#.%*2#('!"&( (!%%1(" 2!&(!($'1
#,&(8'/13$+#&(%,#!'#$
#, %(",! 3#!,(#$ %1('#3 , "/# ,#'2($#(" =/&3# ,# 1"&(8!+6#'!&$23#!2,!<' ,12/3$&(8"/#&*218(#$!=!,$+< '1+*&""&(8 "/!" "/#,# &' ( '%2# =/!"'#6#, , !(< 1,"/#, #(/!(%#*#(" &( "/# !*1(" %*2#('!"&( !=!,$#$ " "/# !22#33!(" !6&(8/#!,$3#!,(#$%1('#3 ,"/#2!,"&#'!($8&(8 "/,18/!6!&3!+3#,#%,$.&"&'!22!,#(""/!""/#,#&'(#6&$#(%#( ,#%,$ #D%#2" '"!"#*#(" "/# !22#33!(" " 2,6# "/!" /# =!' ,1((&(8 +1'&(#'' 4 %!+3# (#"=,9 !($ #!,(&(8 .G;
"/#,# ,*$%1*#("'=/!"'#6#,/!6#+##(23!%#$(,#%,$ 5&*&3!,3<. "/#,# &' ( $%1*#("!,< #6&$#(%# " '/= &(%*#
.G;+#&(8#!,(#$+</&*!""/#"&*# !%%&$#("("/#'!&$ %&,%1*'"!(%#'. "/#,# &' ( &33#8!3&"< &( !''#''*#(" !22#33!("?'
&(%*#!'"/!" !(1('9&33#$3!+1,#,!'/!'+##($(#+<"/# 3#!,(#$,&+1(!3
#,1'!3 "/# ,#%,$ ,#6#!3' "/!" !22#33!(" '1'"!&(#$ *13"&23#&(71,&#'&(%31$&(8&(71,<( ,#/#!$.,&8/"'/13$#,!($3# "
=,&'". ,!%"1,# /1*#,1'!($,&8/"'%!2/&$ A ,51,#'/01*!,
/3!/!'2,6#$"/#'!&$ !%"#,#*!&(#$!$*&""#$&("/#/'2&"!3
,* " - A ,51,#'/01*!,/!'2&(#$ "/!"2!"&#("%!(("8+!%9"/&',&8&(!37+ ,!2#,&$ *("/'
A , &*3!1,&.5#(&,#$&%!3
&%#,.,"/2!#$&% 51,8#(.H
.'2&"!3.01,19'/#",!/!'2,6#$"/!"""!3$&'!+&3&"< '1
#,#$ +< "/# !22#33!(" =!' -I =/&%/ =!' $1# " *$#,!"# ,#'",&%"&6# *6#*#(" !" ,&8/" '/13$#, A /!$ #D!*&(#$ "/# !22#33!(" ( B !3(8=&"/ , 19#'/ 01*!,. 5#(&, #$&%!3
&%#,. H
'2&"!3. 01,19'/#",! 5/# /!'. /=#6#,. %3!,& &#$"/!"$&'!+&3&"< -I&'=&"/,# #,#(%#"2!,"&%13!,3&*+!($ ("E1!=/3#+$< 6#(& &"&'!%%#2"#$"/!"!22#33!("=!',1((&(8+1'&(#'' 4%!+3#(#"=,9"/#,#&'(#6&$#(%#"'/="/!"/#'1
#,#$ !(<3''$1#"$&'!+&3&"<&(%1,,#$$1#""/#!%%&$#(","/!"/#&' 1(!+3#"%!,,<('!&$6%!"&($1#""/&'$&'!+&3&"<=/&%/2#,"!&(' ",#'",&%"&6#*6#*#(" '/13$#,/1'.&"%!(("+#'!&$"/!"
!22#33!("'1
#,#$! 1(%"&(!3$&'!+&3&"</&8/#,"/!(-I/#,#&'( 8,1($ , #(/!(%#*#(" %*2#('!"&( !=!,$#$ +< 3#!,(#$ ,&+1(!3(!%%1(" $&'!+&3&"<'1
#,#$+<"/#!22#33!(" H#!,(#$%1('#3 ,"/#!22#33!("&'1(!+3#"2&("1"
> !(<#6&$#(%#"71'"& <#(/!(%#*#(" %*2#('!"&((!%%1("
*#$&%!3#D2#('#'./'2&"!3&'!"&(#"% =#6#,. !22#33!(" &' #("&"3#$ " #(/!(%#*#("
%*2#('!"&(!=!,$#$"=!,$'2!&(!($'1
,*
.G;" .G;#&'!3'#("&"3#$"3'' &(%*# ,!2#,&$ "/,## *("/'&# -. > D &(6&#= "/#'2#%& &%$#2'&"&(
A ,51,#'/01*!, 22#33!("&'."/1'.#("&"3#$"%*2#('!"&( .
.> G;
&('"#!$ .
. G;!'$#"!&3#$/#,#1($#,);
H'' &(%*#
!&(!($'1
#,&(8 .G;
#$&%!3#D2#('#' >.
G;
'2&"!3&'!"&( .
G;
&'!+&3&"< -. G;
"!3 # #% $ *1(" %*2#('!"&( !3,#!$< !=!,$#$ " "/# !22#33!("'/!33'"!($$#$1%"#$ ,*"/#!*1("%!3%13!"#$!'!+6# 22#33!("'/!33+##("&"3#$"&("#,#'"!""/#,!"# I2#,!((1* ("/##(/!(%#$!*1(" ,*"/#$!"# &3&(8 "/#2#"&"&("&33 ,#!3&@!"&( A&"/ "/# !+6#'!&$ *$& &%!"&( &( "/# !*1("
%*2#('!"&(.2,#'#("!22#!3&'$&'2'#$ &'("&)) #%#*+#,-.
*+,- ,"'