Harbhajan Singh Cheema v. P.S.I.D.C. & ORS






   
 



















 
 

  

 !"#
$ %"
&"'









(()) * + ,$-&
 
" 





.(  




/
 
 

  

,$-&









(()) * + $" 
 !"#
$ %"
&"'
 
" 





.(  






 
 

  

 !"#
$ %"
&"'









(()) * + ,$-&
 
 "





.(   




 
 
 

  

,$-&









(()) * +  !"#
$ %"
&"'
 
 "





.(       

  , 

 
$
0( 1
2

(())  -



 
 

 
 


(  
-

 
 
 
/
   
3&
3 %1
2

(  4,$-& -



 
 

 


(()) 
-

 
 
 
/
  
 

6"
 

' 
"))
(

(()


  

 
% 
"
7


  
7 
-
"
 


 

 1
"
7 



8

 

 


  1
"
7 




7" 
"
"
7 (()
)

"
  

,$-&
7 
% 
"
 

" !# %
&+ 1
7" !9
(()
!  %
/
 
)
!9
" ,$-&
%  
"
  
"
!
))7
 
'
"
!

'
!:

"
6 !+ )
7"
% 

"
%   %

"
( 4    
  

27

( 2
 

"
88

  "
(()
!  %
 
 
"
! )
% 
"
')
!#
: %
7 
"
  
'
"
( 4    
( 1 7" !9
 ! 
"
 )9
7 

8;
(
'





'
"

 )
"
)'
(

 
$
0( 1
) 
+ )
((  %

!")
 (()) 
+!'
"
7
 )
))! 
% ' 


88/
 


88
7 
  
 
!7
"
( 
 
!9 2 +

"
'1
"
(()) 
"

(+ "<!+9
!:
"
" 1 %  %
7""
,$-&
"
(+ "
"
'
!9
 2 %
"
'+ 1 
2
9 

"
'( 9
! %
(+
 
"
'' )
( + $ 
(+
 1
"
'
7
  

"
 !  
6"
)'

(
7

'  !)

"
! 

"
'()' 

" '( 9

27

"
( 2 

$+ 
&  
.%+)  
 
&'( 
1
 
 



8 
 


8 8 
+ "
+!'
"
'( 9
"
) 9
!
%  7"
0-.
2
   
 

 
 1
"   1
,$-&



:

"
=+
"
7 

27


 
+))
+
!9
 >!) $+( '
&+ 





     
6"
))! 
% ' 
7 


  
7"
" ( 2

"
&'( 
1
'+"
)1
  ,
&  1
 
3&
3 %1
) 
+ )
(( 
!")
,$-&
+!'
"

 ! 
7 


8
  %
+
 "
))! 
% ' 


88/1
"
 ! 
 !+ ) 7 
"

8;
(
7 
8 88/


/88


"

:
 

!+
"
"
(

"
( 2 
 $
 

88

6"
!# %
&+ 
+%"


"2
'  "
'
!:1

' 


( '!)

"
!1

+)
"2 ' 
"
7 
!9
: %
 
  
"
 '
 
  
 "
&))! 
% ' 
!




+ "
+!'
"
  
 ))' 1
 ))' 
" 
 ))' 1
 !+ )
%  

 ;
(
!+
"


:
 
  
"
  
?+
+!?+ 
( 
)'

" 

 ;
(
@2
" 71
"
!#
 
0( 1
7
 '  !)


7+)

)) %
+ 
"
( 2


" 



"
 %  
"2
!
'
+
6"
7 

! % =+
+ 
"
( 2 

.6

 1
"   1
"
( 2 
 $


"
$:
- + )
&'( 

$-&

7+)

(()9
 7 %

4! 
)+

"


88
 
"+
+ %
"
&+ 


' 
"
 
+ 
")) %
!9
7  %
  

"

;
(
 
 ;
(
 

8;
(
 
 ;
(

 1
  
" 
 ))' 
 
)
 ;
(
 
 ;
(

(

"
 7" 
 )9
8;
(
"
!
7  -
"2
" 
) 
+ )

"
( 
 
(( 
" ((
!:
 

"
27
"
" 


 
 
' 

" +!'
 
0( 1
2442
7"

(   %
 !"#
$ %"

&"'
7"
"
  
 
))! 
% ' 
  '  
(+ "

"
" 
 
2
9 

"
'' )
( +
" '( 9

"
 '
 
  

"
% ' 
 
   !7
"
( 
 4'()' 

"
'( 9
7+)

!

 91
 1
))! 
% ' 
7
!7
"
(()) 
  ,$-&

% 
"
(()!)9

"
"
)71
-
'

"
27
" "
&+ 

( 


"
#+%' 
  

&A,



 

)

<
.'
, "')
B
 
" 
*
,+ #!
$ - + )
2)(' 
& ( 
B
 
" 1



 

81
")
"
( 2 

$+ 
&  
.%+) 
 7+)

(()9

% 
"
% 
"
'( 9
7"
0-.
  (()!)9



$-&


27


  +))
+





   
$+( 1
-
'

"
27
" 


(( ( 
%


!# 
6"
(()) 
"))
!
 ) 

!#


(( ( 
%1


2

!  
" =+ %
&+ 
-

)
)
)7
"
2

"
&+ 
"
 '


  ( 
4(( 
"
2 1
"+%"1





"
(  1
2
"
+ )
 
+ )
" 

( 
))%)91
7""
"
!

! +%"
7"
"
'!

"
(+!)
()9

27


  +))
+
!9
 >!)
$+( '
&+ 



!"

#$%& $ '

 ( 

 )**  %+**,) "
&+  




"
7 

27

"

 
+))
+


- $.+ 

/. 0

* * 12 
% 
"
  
 
3 %
7"
% 

"
7 
"   1
-
'

"
27
"

+!
"
( 2
+!4$ $


88

( 2
%  

 ;
( !+
:( %

27
"
)1
 '
  1
'+"
)1
7

))  
"
 + 91
-
'

"
27
"
7 
"
  

" 

8;
(
2442
"
 ! 
7 


81
   
7 
8 88/


/88 1
  

( 1
)%)
 
#+  6"
!# %
&+ 
+%"


"2
' 
!:
"
'

"  ! 
2
"
% + 

"
?+
' 
'

!
! +(
!9
"
2
0 "

 >!)
0'!9
%"
&+ 

3





!  -

      5  6   7!)  %77!  *  '   

%0 


 

  ,8  '  1  

   *1
7" 

(  ()
"
!
)
7
%  %
' 
"
' 
-  
 

))
7"
"
  '  
(  ()

"
:

! 291 ( 


"
#+%' 

"+ 9, :

  &0;  

 ,  '   

 ,)      &   - #       

) #      77 7   #   & <&0$7$)  &   7 

  '     7   '     %   &   

 

  '&

  0 ! 0& !#  

77 &

$ & 0 !7 

  6 &

   



  7

 ' ( 0& !# !!

!

   & ' 

  # &0;

 

, '  

,) ' )  

7!  &

#  7 

 0 6   0  '

  0 !#=



0 !#  &   

,) 0

 

!&

7 

0'   &> &0;

 

, '  

, -     77 &

$   0 ! 0& ! & 0 

7 

   6&

   

# &!!

   &  '   

       #  >  &  

   0 ?

& -)  #  

 -  '     &

 #     0 ! 0& !  -! 67

&!  ' !

#

7  -!- 

  -  & %

!!

  0 !#

&

  # &!0    &   0 ! 0& ! ' !   

    !   #

 #   ) 

 -   &0 &7 ( 7 - 

 '  

, 0!   &  &  7 

&   

,  

 '

  #) 0 ! 0& ! 

&     7 

     6   $  7   !

  &  '

!!

  

,, ) #-)     

7!    -    7 # 

    &    7 

0 6  0 ! 0& !

   &            #  =

    #   ?

0$  &# ! &

7 

&   

,@   %)91
!"
7 

 ! 

7 
 

 

8
 
+(")
(()
)
!9
,$-&
  ))71

( 1

"
= 

' 
 
(()
)
!9
 !"#

$ %"
&"'
 
" !9
' !""# "$ 
  7#

  %&'%& ()& *+,-.

& (/,&01 &(./ %&'%& &)/ '

&1 &(./