Jai Singh v. State Of Haryana & ORS
!
"# $ !
!"# ! !$%
&
'# !
!"# ! !$%
(
'!)*!# !
!"# ! !$% +
))'# !
!"# ! !$% &
!# !
!"# ! !$%
, (
*# !
!"# ! !$% % &'% ((
() *
&'% (* ' ) - %./0 )11--23245%6722%./ )822-425%672 91$:
; )<2=-15%672 91$:;:=2-72; )!2=212=25%%452/22 )25%672 91$%2=2712/2 >>>> (
() *
+ 72441$2619=27==1 % 1951/22=2.4.%7%%1 -127== 6%7
,#-",.,#/0"
1$ % 9%74225.91 764 77%51/2
5.
1?.4$@ 2=.-42%.9521%742%1212% 3 2.4./1!6 5124475 2% 77%5%7%%1 2-21$ 1 .A 1 = 2 .72= %23 ./ 1 2--6%5 .72= 24 %=%51 1 -1:@ ; 1 1 -1 2%=2%& & (5 $64$,+( 9 :@ ;529-2%12.6=2%%51
=% 1 72 1 2 4475 2% . 31 %7 1= %7% 1 291 365 1 2 4475 2%77%52-21 -12%%23
, :@ ;5B7%1$4299 5 .%2 2$$2452.72=2%2-212%%524.72=%=% + & )65142%===.242'65 1 -12%=2% ( :@ ,;524%=% 14626$5 2.72= $9%./16 $4299
1295 1 -12%%23
5 1 2724==52/22=2%%1 12 44777% 124475 2%77%5 1 -12%%23 &
52-2%=%1$4299 194-922$$242-21%: $2;5142% 44777%51 -12%%23, (
52-2 =%1=2 1 2447 2%77%
1 2 447 2% 1 -1 2 % %235
,
+5 %7% 1 $4299 5 .
2 2$$24 2% 12-25 1 .9 1 $$442 1/5 ./ 1 2= 2712/277%51421 -12%%23(
+5 =%112447 2%77% 1 2$$442 = 72 2-2 1 2% =2% % 32 B7%5 1 -12%%23./1==5=.242'65 &
& 1 -1 2 % %23
,5 1 2724 ==5 =2%% 1 1 ==5 =.242 '6 7 172 3242%/=2%% ./1 447 77%512447519512$$241 3
%$% 9 ./ 1 == 365 1 2= 2712/2 $9%
9
(5<-2%714475 %7%1=22=. %=251 42%-1 1 -12%%23 5=2<- 2%7 $1 44758 <125%7%1=2311=1 1 44777%51 -12%%23 + 5%=% 1$4299 4-22$$24.-$9%12-25 .9 1 == =.242 '65 31 1 -1 2 % %23 +
+5 1 =2%% 1 72 1 447 <12 + 365 1 447 8 <12 2-2 1 -15 2 %%23 + (:@ ;5%=%1 $4299 4 12$$242%12-2.72=24%=%./1 == =.242 '65 1 1 -1 2 % %23
( :@ ;5 4-12--6%5 6$5.91!624 1/77%53171 1 -12%%231, 521%=%1 2%6$ &
1 2.6 77 4/ =2% %=24 %5 $764/ ./ 1 447 77%5 :@ ;5 ./ 1 2$$4422 1/77%:@ ;52%./1!624 1/ 77% :@ ;5 .- -627 1 2--6%19=51 51/24%=2<271244-12% 2@ 51 -11 -123$.91 ("12334-5.,#".4-56-3-3 , 2;
121279= 2&, 5 @1.!
./16 99777%5926 912=2712/2 77%5$791$42%2924427 4/%23% 9= 212.6 .=1$=5121 B2=2.2%2$$2-1 42%521 .7=7=$% @ 5 2%5 @ 5 2% 3171 2 42% $764/5 1 /2 & , .% 1 /2 + ++
1951 .=12711728122 =.51 42 1 <122 =.5 .%31174 = 9 4621951/9 .7=%$7% A 4/53112%74 =931$51$%7 91$2%121
A 45 1 .=121 42%.72=26%9=6=1
1 5=97:-;:6;91 B2.442- ==C2%:!- 42;75 ,:129917244%?1 C7?;5$63192@27%129 9 1 7A 4/2- 1212.67%%= 232=2% %-2912.6$74%27%
!
"
# #
$%
&
&
&
&
!
"# $ !
#
%
&
'
% # %#
( )
*
' (
+ * )
% "#
'* & ,
% -$
.
.;
142%7 491$24 .= 1271B2=2.2%2$$2-1/2 + ++5624122 $62$277 %2=-1712-7 462561 $ 42%5 1 4- 2 94%% ./ @ 5 1 12$$-:;9%==.=:;9712%7 462-$ .
$ & ! 424/51: $2;1./ =29512 =9126-742 : $2;5 1 4/1$%7 21 14%-%$%7 4625.
2412$$ 73%7 462-$:;51 .72= .B7%$2
19512- 1263924412 /-%72% 112.6@27%26-742 52 71512.6$ 74%27%532A %.=%6753125 67.-=%15 21 4 1= 2: $2;5 .-924427 4/%23 ("12334-5.,#".46-7 (
142%7 42$$2-912=2712/2 $%+5122- %512=91%7: $2;52 =2%./1 13$: $2;5142%447 77%5129= 42%1129@27% 52%57 16%742-24412% 5 1 .72= 12%.2 %4.2% $5 4-2$2<-2%%7.-=2% 271 9 1=5 .
4/ 29 1 447 77%5 2$4/ 2$$2-1%7 =2/6%752.72=2%% 7%./12= 2712/277%521 1$4299742= 1951
.=121%7 =2/6%752.72=2%% 7%./1 2=2712/277%59624%2-12.6%9= 25 .% 9 624%2- 1 74%2 71= 21 12 7A 71./1.9912.69%26-742 7 4%.%%1$4299 '(
#
## )'* '
+"* $
#
$
&# #, ,,-.// '(
$
&# #, ,,# )'* '
+"*###
$
-.// '(
& ,, 0
1 #, /
2 3## 4
1
/ #
#
#& # # #
,,-.// !'(
&
5/
$ ,, &
##& 5/ -.//'
"'6,$
&#
$ ,, $ &# # #
- .//'
)'( ,, #$
# # #&
-.//'
7'(
& 5/ -./8 9'( # -./8 +'( ,,
#, # #,#$ :#
-./8
*'( ,,& #
-./8'
' ( # & # #
-./8'
,48#-30-5"12334-5.,#".4-5 6-3-3
2;
1 $ 126 . 2.4 .- 91 2-.4 6%7 %$42/5 12 1 $ $%
1
.72=7%%17%9-1$ & 51 6%4/ 314239 4$%7 =$264/531 1 .6%7 .225192791$5.-1624% 77 9 1
77%5 31 .72= $ $%4/7%%52 71517%9-1.
$ & 1 5321$%-2.43653112%$%-2.412 .$427%7%51951$72742=12 1/ 3 1 4239 4 77 9 1 $ $% $%75313$ $%4/7%%52
61$42%517%9-151 $$2%$ & .;
12174297274 =72%17% 9-1$$2%$1/2 & 56241211 $42%27%%25; 2%2
42%
1956397:-;:&;9?1C7?5$6 3195 2 @27% 1295 1 2% 42% 31 1 2.6 6 %-2:;531.72=242-%1$2712/2
195311/32 7151 6%4/ %917== $ $916442-51./
< 42%%9244311 74 6%99
42% )65 24142% 72/-17429729
42%51 242%6%9 1.9916442-$$2/.%/77%52% $79 716%42%5211$ $%$%7 91$5 1 7 4%=2<1=2=2.49 4622%%2//17%9-1%23$ & 5624-1$ $%$%791$5 =2<7 462942%5%7.%2 =
< 2%5 9
42% %7.%2
42%51 72.7 %5 1 =2<- 2/.9-7 462195-6 7142%6%4/ .- 997 462! 424/199792/92/$62 $277 -2=-1B7 46291$42%5 1 7=$44/-972 >
>
?!
@ " #
-
## ( '
'
/ "
% * ""
)%) *
## ($
( % .1 7;
121$126. 2.4.-91 2-.46%7%$42/121%$ %42%21121 42%$731951= 2: $2;532=2%126. 2.4.-916%7 --65121%$ %42%521 %5/9244:;531174 2/%9 9
42%! 424/1$42%2
42%2%1% 9= 2: $2;532624%4/2%
"-5 , 4 8#-30 -5 "1233 4 -5 ., #".4-56-3-3 ;
$ 2491 2=2.2% @1.53171 %2391/2 + ++52%5428132 ,5812 +51 7=$-42%=2 -
+.--2+.325624 121%$ %42%2
< 2%
42%712.6B2=2.2%51
$5 2451.6 4/17 4%.2/624%$2$79 12.672-942% 195.
.6 4/2/$427-9 4275 $52/$ $%$62$25317177 %1 /2 + ++5 2=- 1 7 462- 7 12 77%5
-9725241.9912.626-742 72. 2-%1$ ;
$ 249174%271=%74512 122:; 942%53171 31 2=2.49$62$2 2<-$4272=-17 462?77%5-6 114%- 717 462$ & 521.72=%==.%2=-1 11B7 46291$42% 12%2272% 2%=9( 8224 )242$ 2712-= 126 . =2% 1 4239 4 2 14% 77% 9 2-=:;942%5 11212.651 3 =2%1 74%271=1$5 1 $512.6 2-=51 .
322 7=97=$4924 51$29 1$5$% 76%7.
%$42/-125 2; 121/34239 4 7791 $ $%$%75211 1 -11?$427- 7%1$%-2.477% .; 1 2-= 9 1 $ 42% 1 $174%271=52%53171 4%1 %23-912.6229= 2531./1
327%%2391$42%51 53299= 2/ 67 9 2/ 44-24/ 1 2 .- 12 31 1 2.6 7429722-%1$42%51$.7=- .2%761.97-27912.626-742 7;
1 $2592/5317177 %2=-1 B7 46277%52%1 $1/2 & 52$$2 .=2%421%$ %42%5.
2$$2.=2% 42=142% 12.-126%712.
2%% 7%%$42/51212%$2317177 %$1 /2 & 1 2=-17 462-B352142% 1<122 =..
3171213171.7=%$42/% 1 % 9 = 2 : $2; 195 1 2% $2 -9725 2% % =$3 1 42% 7 4 9 1 $5 7% 12 1 % 9 = 2 : $2;5 .72= 4/%23 %;
12311 $2712/22%% 7-6%753171 1 91-14/%$42/5121$12%.212-% 1$42%542)653112.69275.7= 6%9=12$$42%42-2%7$.<53171 $764/ @1. !,5 ! 2% !5 1 .7= 2-%
195712$ =$9 112.651 1 927 9 1 $ 2<- 1 $ %$ % 42% 425 1./1$27=$44/$$%9=7%-512 1 1/ 3 4239 4 77 9 1 $76 $ $% $%75 3131 7 462-1$42% $ & &52%51./1/ .72=4%761 .9912$$26-742 )5613 $79142%72-D%174297274 =12
< 1 %1= 2=2.49%6% 462! 424/ 1 7 4% . 2/7 462 9 72-942%./1$ $%$%791 $ 1 195 1 % 9 = 25 31./ 1 %$ %42%5.72=2-%12=2712/2531./4 2312.79% $1$2712/277%51 % 999=2/6792/55=2%%-2%91
$74%2 7% A 45 1 2% % 9 = 2 A %. $14%
3,. 29=2151 9%=13$5 2%5 31 1 2.6 .625 1 2= 2 %=% 1 =$ -%%2=22%2%299=% %27 71=2724912.%7%%51 52441 $%-2$$472:;592/5242%:;%$%9 9(
() *
:
9* ' ) :
$ !
<26-1 )5-56,/30;,
; )5-56-,1. ;