High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1170/2016dismissed

M/S Dhir International Pvt Ltd v. Jitender Lalwani And ORS

2016-04-12Mr. Justice Arun Monga12 pages

!!"#$#%&'(#) *+

,$*#(% !(% #%) - . /+0(1% ''!))% 2!($0$ # !%/!(.)3%# *!($ !$'%/!% $

#$ 4*! *!( !'( !($)")''!($567!))3!/ $!! *!80/15!% 9 7!(!!((!/ *! !'( !($(% 9 : 4*! *!( *!80/15!% $*0)/7!(!'( !/#% *!#1!$ 9

(!$!% &

(2#(!%/!(;05(#%+<!%#(/-" !3# *

(. )* (+/-" !+ ( *!''!))%

(%#);;*!(+<!%#(/-" !3# *

(2#860' +/-" !%/

( ;;*#%/(#+/-" !+ ( *!(!$'%/!% $ ===== !"

*!''!))% #$11(#!-!/ *!(/!(+3*!(!76 *!'! # #% #)!/0%/!(<!" #%> *!(7# ( #%%/%"#)# #%" +>>( $*( ?>>" @ *$7!!%))3!//0(#%1 *!'!%/!%"6 *!(7# ( #% '("!!/#%1$

(2;#%+ )!(%!/ <!%#( 0%$!) $$#$ !/ 76

(. )* (+/-" !+''!(#%1%7!*) *!''!))% +#%$0''( *#$"% !% #%$+*$(#$!/5%#)/(105!% $+3*#"*(!!%05!( !/ *!(!#%7!)3&A !$075# $ * $'!( *!)!$!1(!!5!% / !/> #%/0$ (#)'('!( 67!(#%1>>+ *$!A+ /612#*(+0(1%*-#%1

') (!5!$0(#%170 $B5! !($3# *"%$ (0" #%3$(!% !/0 %(!% +C+,A+ 7!'67)!%(7!(! *! * /6!"* ")!%/(5% *$05 D)"$$#% !(!$ (!!$!"0(# 63$)$ /!'$# !/76 *!''!))% + 7!(!0%/!/0'%!E'#(6(!()#!( !(5#% #% *!)!$!*!5% *)6(!% 3$ #%"(!$!76F !(!-!(6 *(!! 6!($%/# 3$#%")0$#-!'('!( 6 E+70 !E")0$#-!!)!" (#"# 6+3 !(+ 5#% !%%"!%/$!(-#"! E(%6 *!("*(1!$ ' <!' !57!(+G+ *!''!))% '#/ *!"% (" 0)( ! +G+,A'!(5% * ( *!

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

(/!(/ !/%/1-!)#7!( 6 *! '! # #%!(A''!))% #)! ''('(# ! '("!!/#%1$ ""(/#%1)6+ *! (7# ( (!% !(!/#% (!!(!%"!-#/!(/!(/ !/G: *#$0( %/ *!(!$'!" #-!")#5$3!(!#)!/ *!(!$'%/!% $#)!/%'')#" #%0%/!(<!" #%>> " (#$$0#%1/#(!" #% *!''!))% '6 *!((!($(!% +/51!$ %/5!$%!'(# $(0$!%/""0' #% *!'(!5#$!$( *!'!

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

% %/++D:+D,A%""0% $!(-#"! E'67)!3# *#% *!'!(#/ *(!!5% *$(5 *!/ ! '$$#%1 *!(/!( %/ 0( *!( /#(!" #% '6 *!5% *)6 (!

& :+D+GG,A3!*!!$") #%")0$!"%% 7! H!%#% "%$#/!( #%(3% (!1#$ ( #%)!$!/!!/-!% *!(3#$!+$'!( $07A$!" #%:

<!" #%> *!!3" + *!(7# ()(#70%)"0)/% !% !( #% *!'')#" #%0%/!($07A$!" #% 0%)!$$ *!0( #%/$ * "#("05$ %"!$ !E#$ 3*#"* 56 % (!%/!( *! (!5!/6 '(-#/!/ 0%/!( <!" #%>>" !#""#0$%/+ *0$+0(1!$ *#$0( ($! #%1A $#/! *!(/!(

(%#);;*!(+)!(%!/<!%#(0%$!)$$#$ !/76 (2#86 0' /-" !%/ ( ;;*#%/(#+/-" !+''!(#%1%7!*) *! (!$'%/!% $$075# $ * %')#%%/$#5')!)%101!+<!" #%>!%-#$1!$ *(!! $# 0 #%$ ( 11(#!-!/ '( 6 #%-H! *! 80(#$/#" #% *!

(#%"#')0( +# 7!(! *!(7# ( #%+## /0(#%1 *!(7# ( #%%/###

7!(! *!3(/#$!%("!/ ($!!H#%1#% !(#5(!)#!+ %'')#" #% 0%/!(<!" #%>>" 3$#)!/*!''#% 5!% *!(7# ( (#$ / !/G:+3*(!"0$!/*#5$!)-#/!(/!(/ !/DC%//0(#%1 *!#% !((!1%05+'! # #%0%/!(<!" #%>+$% #"!/7-!+3$#)!/% GC*!'(-#$#%$$07A$!" #%:

<!" #%>>>" *$% '($'!" #-!!!" %/$*))% '')6 *!'!%/#%1'("!!/#%1$%$0''( *#$"% !% #%+(!)#!/0'% *!/!"#$#%(!%/!(!/76 *!#1*0( !)*##% '()*'+ ),-.'/0 1(-2)(/

*3)'

452010 60 -)*'

'+ *0(217()* $218 28*"

:6 &"

/!"#/!/% :3*!(!$#5#)(B0!$ #%3$(#$!/%/# 3$%$3!(!/#% *! #(5 #-! * #% $0"* $# 0 #%+ *! '! # #% 0%/!( <!" #% > #$ 5#% #%7)!/07 +<!" #%"%!($'3!(% *!(7# ()(#70%) ((7# ( ( 5H!#% !(#5(/!($+70 # 30)/'!( !%)6/0(#%1 *! !E#$ !%"! *!(7# ()(#70%)7!#%10%" #%)<#5#)(-#!3#$ H!%76

*! #-#$#% !%"* #1* 0( !)*# #% 60 4'+15

1275 527'*()+5 (3 452010 60

8'* 57-*(2*);

(3"

/!"#/!/%GCD*!''!))% $(!')6#%1*#/!%/$#"H 7!(! *!(7# ( (%/$3!))$ *#$0( *!63% -#/ *!#( )#7#)# 6#%%!36( *! *!(*!6(!!%86#%1 *!'(!5#$!$(5(! *%$!-!%6!($3# *0 '6#%1%6$#%1)!'!%%6+3*!(!$!-!(6/6#$ #%"0((#%1)$$ *!(!$'%/!% $,)!$$($-!(6'$$#7)! !5' #$7!#%1 5/! '(!-!% *!(7# ( (('("!!/#%1$3# * *!5 !(76#)#%1%! '')#" #%( *! *!(%/+ *0$+0(1!$ *#$0( (/#$5#$$) *! ''!) *-!*!(/ *!)!(%!/"0%$!)( *!'( #!$%/''(#$!/ *!''!(7H%/ *!-#!3 * *!(!#$%5!(# +50"*)!$$$07$ %"!#% *!$075#$$#% (#%( *!(!$% * <!" #%>")!()6$'!"#6 !E#$ !%"! *(!!$# 0 #%$ ( *!$H!7(!-# 6+<!" #%>#$(!'(/0"!/ *!(!#%7!)3&A

" !

! $

(

$ "

! % $"

$ $

& +!

(

$ +-

% !('(! #%1 *!(!5!% #%!/'(-#$#%$+ *!)!(%!/<#%1)! 0/1!!)*##1*0( 1-! *!))3#%1#%/#%1$+3*#"*(!/ *0$&A + /+

0 )+1

0 2 . 1

0 + 3

$ 2.

1 $

$4 $ 2. 0

$ %

$ $

0 )+ $ $

% 0

0 +) 30 0 79:: ;$< ;=, #)>>> ??!@78- >

4 0

: 1 $A

0 % , #)>>B !0+?? +C

#& 2+C.

/=+

+B> 1 0 +-

1 0 0 +- $

0 +- ( 1 @ 1 0 +- 0

$ (

& & '

$ 1 $

$ $ 2(

. 2

0 0

7 0

$ 1 & &

0 4

0 $

+ , 0 +-$

1 / 0 +- 1

1 $

130

$ $ 0 +-

0 %

= 1 1

)B>+)>>? 2

544

(

7 ?+ '

7 C 4

1 D 54!

$ )B>+)>>?

1 4

06< =$< 9 ; #)>>?

!7 )C? 0! B

0 ++

( 8

4 8

0 ++ !

$ % *

$ 0 +-

#& 2B 0

0 .

2 0 +-

2+)

0 @ 4 ( %

$ & .

2+C 0 $

(

$ 1

, 0

2 $

10 & #& $ !

0 -

0 B 3 $ $

1 E 0 +-

3 1

$ $

* 0

0 ? $

$< &%

( $

< & 0 < & ( $ 0 ?

1 $

0 !

$ 0 !

0 ! ! ! !

5% #%1(!!5!% 3# * *!$075#$$#% (#%-#$AA-#$ '')#"7#)# 6 *!%!3" $# $*))"5!#% ("!3!:C *!5 !($3*#"*(!)(!/6'!%/#%1/80/#" #%*!''#% 5!% *! %!3 (7# ( ( !( *! (!"0$) *! '(!-#0$ (7# ( ( #$ / !/ >C+3*!(!$ *!(!)!-% / ! *!%!3" #$:C*!(!#$ )$%("!#% *!$075#$$#% (#%-#$AA-#$#%"(!$!/ *!(!% $ *!''!))% */7!!%'6#%1 *!(!% $'!( *!!$") #%")0$!%/%

'6#%1%)6(!% *!( !+C+,A%/ *!)$ '65!% 3$ *!( ! G+CG+,A*!/#(!" #%1#-!%0%/!(<!" #%>(!/ *0$&A J '

CBC->CF& +>>B B-+F& $ (

+ B-CB>F& +))>+

3 : .

;!!'#%1 #% -#!3 *! (!5!% #%!/ " $ %/ "#("05$ %"!$+5 *!-#!3 * *!(!5!% #%!//#(!" #%"% #%!/ #% *!(/!(#$'!(!" +)!1)%/80$ ##!/%/*$7!!%'$$!/ !( H#%1 #% "%$#/!( #% )) *! " ($ $ % #"!/ 7-! ""(/#%1)6+ *! #5'01%!/(/!(#$0'*!)/ *!''!)#$/#$5#$$!/ 3!-!(+ *!''!))% $*))7! )#7!( 6 H! *!')!-#$AA -#$%%A(!1#$ ( #% *!)!$!/!!/7!(! *!(7# ( (+70 % #% *#$ 0( 82)+ (-"

! 2'>50-