Dr. Vijay Gotwal v. State Of Punjab And Others

   
        
        
        
     
 
 
 
  

     
 



    
 



    
 



    
 



   !

"#$%&'($)

*'"'"&+*!

*!,-,

'$'*&. -+#$/$+0&'1*!,

*,2&+0*+',


3

4   
       


3

4   
       


3

4   
       


3

4   
        !*,*+'

!*,*+'

!*,*+'

!*,*+'

!

 $+01- 05&6$'*.&!'1*2*'"'"&+*!

787878 787878 787878 787878                                     )*$0"+9,&+!*6&!0"+0"6$'*'1$''1*2*'"'"&+*!",$+

 &6'&!$+0'1*!*$.'*!1$0#&"+*0'1*2&,'9!$0-$'*6&-!,* "

*

 "+ -):&+$!%:*0"6"+*  *'"'"&+*!1$0$22*$!*0*$!)"*!

"+'1*."+$)%*$!*;$:"+$'"&+&.'1*$.&!*+&'"6*0

 6&-!,*"+

$%<-+*    $+0  '1*  !*,-)'  &.  (1"61  ($,  0*6)$!*0  &+ =

  22$!*+')% 2*'"'"&+*!0"0+&',*6-!*'1*!*>-","'* :$!?, 1*"+,'$+'2*'"'"&+1$,/**+.")*0!$","+9$9!"*5$+6* '1$''1**5$)-$'"&+&.'1*$+,(*!,6!"2',6&+0-6'*0/%$/$$!"0 +"5*!,"'%&.*$)'1 6"*+6*,($,"+5"&)$'"&+&.'1*2!&6*0-!* 2!*,6!"/*0/%'1* &,'!$0-$'* *0"6$) 0-6$'"&+*9-)$'"&+, $+0$,.!$:*0/%'1* *0"6$)
&-+6")&.+0"$  
$,*"+$ +-'3,1*))  2-'  .&!'1  /%  '1*  2*'"'"&+*!  ",  '1$'  '1*  !*,2&+0*+'3 +"5*!,"'%  1$,  !*,&!'*0  '&  *3*5$)-$'"&+  &.  '1*  $+,(*!  ,6!"2', (1*!*$,"'&-91''&1$5*/**+0&+*/%*;$:"+*!,:$+-$))% +

 ,-22&!'  &.  '1*  2!$%*!  :$0*  "+  '1*  "+,'$+'  2*'"'"&+  )*$!+*0 6&-+,*)(&-)0!*)%-2&+&!0*!,2$,,*0/%'1",
&-!'"+"0*+'"6$) ,"'-$'"&+,"

* "+
"5")!"' *'"'"&+ &, $+0@&. $+0  (1"61  1$5*  /**+  $22*+0*0  $)&+9  ("'1  '1*  2*'"'"&+  $' ++*;-!*, A$+0 @!*,2*6'"5*)% $5"+9  1*$!0  )*$!+*0  6&-+,*)  .&!  '1*  2*'"'"&+*!  $' )*+9'1$+01$5"+92*!-,*0'1*2)*$0"+9,&+!*6&!0 '1",
&-!'", +&'"+6)"+*0'&$66*2''1*2!$%*!:$0*"+'1*2*'"'"&+ +0&-/'*0)% ("'1!*9$!0'&'1*",,-*$,!*9$!0,*3 *5$)-$'"&+$,&22&,*0'&:$+-$)61*6?"+9 '1",
&-!'1$,2$,,*0 &!0*!,"+2!*5"&-,(!"'2*'"'"&+,)*$5"+9"''&'1*0",6!*'"&+&.'1* +"5*!,"'%$,'&(1*'1*!$+,(*!,6!"2',(&-)0/**5$)-$'*0$.!*,1 :$+-$))%&!/%($%&.*3*5$)-$'"&+ -!'1*!:&!* $''1*,'$9*&.

2$,,"+9&.'1*2!*5"&-,&!0*!, "'1$0/**+:$0*6)*$!/%'1",
&-!''1$''1*0"!*6'"&+,/*"+9",,-*0(&-)0+&'/*'!*$'*0$,$ 2!*6*0*+'$+0'1*,$:*$!*/*"+92$,,*0"+5"*(&.'1*-!9*+6% "+5&)5*0$,'1*+*;'/$'61&. <

6&-!,*",'&6&::*+6*

!

$+01- )*$!+*06&-+,*).&!'1*2*'"'"&+*!$22!",*, '1* 
&-!'  '1$'  '1*  +*;'  /$'61  .&!  <

 6&-!,*  1$,  $)!*$0% 6&::*+6*0( * .

    +$,2*6"."6>-*!%1$5"+9/**+ 2-' '1*)*$!+*06&-+,*)1$,$),&5*!%.$"!)%6&+6*0*0'1$''1* 2*'"'"&+*!  1$,  $)!*$0%  2$!'"6"2$'*0  "+  '(&  ,-22)*:*+'$!% *;$:"+$'"&+,("'1$+&/#*6'"5*'&":2!&5*1",!*,-)''1$'($, 0*6)$!*0&+=

 1*.$6',+&'"6*01*!*"+$/&5*(&-)06)*$!)%"+0"6$'* '1$''1*2*'"'"&+*!1$,$66*2'*0'1*:*'1&0&. *3*5$)-$'"&+"+ '*!:,&.!*,-)'0*6)$!*0&+=

$+0/%$6&+,6"&-,0*6","&+

1$,   *5*+  $22*$!*0  "+  '1*  ,-22)*:*+'$!% *;$:"+$'"&+, '& .$6")"'$'*$+":2!&5*:*+'"+1",,6&!* +  '1*  6&+,"0*!*0  5"*(  &.  '1", 
&-!'  '1*  2*'"'"&+*! 6$++&'/*2*!:"''*0'&9$"+":2*'-,.!&:'1*&!0*!,2$,,*0/% '1",
&-!'"+(!"'2*'"'"&+,.")*0*$!)"*!"+2&"+'&.'":*$+0$''1* 1$+0,&.,-61&6'&!,(1&:$% /* ,":")$!)% ,"'-$'*0  1&,* 2*'"'"&+,   (*!*  .")*0  /%  &6'&!,  2!"&!  '&  2$!'"6"2$'"+9  "+  '1* ,-22)*:*+'$!%  *;$:"+$'"&+   1*  2!*,*+'  2*'"'"&+*!  (&-)0  /* ,**+$,$.*+6*,"''*!

  
$-,*&.$6'"&+'&'1*2*'"'"&+*!1$0 $66!-*0"+'1*:&+'1&.-)%"',*).

*1$,61&,*+'&!*:$"+ >-"*'.&!$))'1",'":* 5*+'1*,-22)*:*+'$!%*;$:,.&!'1*  6&-!,*  &.  2-):&+$!%  :*0"6"+*  1$5*  6&::*+6*0  $+0  '1* 2*'"'"&+*!1$,$)!*$0%2$!'"6"2$'*0"+'1*,$:* '",'&&)$'*"+ '1*0$%'&$66*2''1*2!$%*!!$",*0"+'1",2*'"'"&+ +0*!,-616"!6-:,'$+6*, '1",
&-!'",&.'1*5"*( '1$''1*$00"'"&+$)2!$%*!:$0*/%'1*2*'"'"&+*!,**?"+9$(!"'&. 6*!'"&!$!"  .&!  >-$,1"+9  '1*  !*,-)'  &.  '1*  '1*&!%  2$2*!  0$'*0 =

  ++*;-!*    $))*9*0  '&  /*  "+  5"&)$'"&+  &.  '1* 2!&6*0-!*  2!*,6!"/*0  /%  '1*  &,'  !$0-$'*  *0"6$)  0-6$'"&+ *9-)$'"&+,+**0+&'/*9&+*"+'& *'"'"&+0",:",,*0 B       C B       C B       C B       C



  



  



  



       















&'*

&'*

&'*

&'*

1*'1*!,2*$?"+9<!*$,&+*0

*,< & 1*'1*!*2&!'$/)*

*,< &