← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18862/2025dismissed

Om Parkash Singh v. Financial Commissioner, Punjab

2025-07-10Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj8 pages



        CWP-18862-2025 

 ! ""# OM PARKASH SINGH  

 FINANCIAL COMMISSIONER, PUNJAB AND OTHERS  

 $  %&$  '( '  ) *****    

   !

" 

  ##### ( '  )+ , -./ $"%% & "

  ''('('' ')(*'('  '+('('*  ,- " .   $

 / "   .  

%

  %  0%%  " 1 % $

 

, 0" ,-% 

!" 

!

, &

/ " ,  "  0  

", ! % ' /

 $

% 

 ,"%! ! "  

 " " %-   "    ! 2   / %%& 3"  4" % -% .   / "   !%%  

 " " !  0" % /  "

  &" 

! 5&  &"

 ''(+'() % 

0   !

 %% " % & ,%      ,- 6

%

 "  %%& 7

 (+    % & "

  0%%  " 

  ,  "  % 



   ! %% "    0  &   !   %%-

'

 8 * 0

 ,- "    $

  9  %

 

   " ! . -%   "



!

0 "  "$

 

''('(''" .  $

/ "  



8 *% &"

 &"/

0 " &" , 

!" 

" , &  -    &   %%

 8 * 0

%

 ,  %,% " %%&!

"  " & !!

/  

&& & " 

!''('(''" 

!

   %,!

" .  

% $

  % .  

 4"   % 0 %      

  ')(*'(' 4"

 

  

 0 "

  !

 ,- "  

 ,!

 " 1 %

 ')(*'(' 0  %%-    ,- " 1 %

   " 

  '+('('* 2  "   0

 *

%

 " "  "

  " ! %   6

 

""   %, % - !/  %%&   % :

 ,

  ,-"$

0%%" 

 "

 4"

"

0" %0 "" ! 

, 

 ,-" 

""

0 - 0 " "  &   %%   "

 0

%

 ,  %,%  "  %%& !

  " & !" !

!

  &" %%&  )/

$

%!

" 

% % 

" "2

;,% $

" !<     ;

  ,"3/4 '543   " -

& &  



     " % 

 

 ! /  4"  " ! =  "

       



 

  

                             

          !    "

 #  $%&'( )*+,  

- ./   0    0 1                2 

   3(

4 > 7 " "  %

 $

% 

 ,"%! ! "

  "&

"

&"" 

   %

& 0 " " 0  

0%%" ,-"2

;,%

!7   " !    7   !



% !"

,-". 

 " " .   $

  "   ! "

0%%"



 

!"

     0

 ,- " .   $

 " % &"",

,-"8 ,4" % %

0%% " ,.  

%&  "



  "% 

 

 "   !

 

  /  4"      "

" , 

 ,

 "    "  %%& 4"  

8 *%0!

 ,

, !

!



/ 7 "% !

,-" 

* "

  

 8 * 0

  &  ,- " .  

%$

""& !

 ,

* - ""   %%'"$%0" " 

"  

%-   (" % 4"   " ,

6 ,- " 

"

  " ", % & % 

!

!"

 8    0 ,

&"

  4" % 0

&%-  4"  

 

% " ! " %$



 .3         5 

            

       

               

 0   6 5



  0       

        

 

 0 5     

       '7 0        

 %*          

 8       

   

    

          )     

  0

0    0   

0  

    

   



 



  0  0 

0 #9

   5      

*((&:%;<5<:5 ;8+85                    0     



    0           )            *(**               

 

)

 

              

 )        0     

0   

   <

  0         



  

*+ ('

*(*7 

0 5   6    

** (7 *(**  

 0   6 5

 

   

 50      

  

 =

 

    4 ? 4" %

 ,-"$

%!

" 

  ""

   -  &  %% "

0

%

, %,%!

  " & !" !

 + 7 !"

"" "

!"$

"

%

%-, ! 0 "

%&

 !

- %%&% -

-

%   !%  " 

!"

 "

  ( ! " %  % ,-"$

%!

" 

" !"2

;,% $

" !   & & " ! & 

 "   

 4"%% " " "%% &"

!".  

5 " !" $

0" ,-" 

",   !

"

0"

"  "

!

!

'?- ",  % & ,%!



/  , &>' - !&70 " 

=""2

;,% $

  "

,-".  

5 " !" $

 

"

,-"$

0" %"

% &"" 

 6 !"

>

 

   ,

%- !  0 "   " & 0

% , 

! 

"% 



 !/ 7 "   " 

"

 ! % & *- "

,-"$

  "% ;!

4"

" "  & & " 

"      !   " 

 " "

 8 * , - 0

% ,

 %,% 

 %- ,    

  - 

 "  % & ,%

 ,%!

"

 4" .  

 5 " ! "  $

 " !            !

""#$  %#&!

 ! " ,  04" =  " "

 .7  >     0        



  

 )        "    

?

         

 

0      

                

 7%%   5           

     "                      

        

    

                0              

    0     "     

           

 0 0         

    "     )     

 

          0 



=  5  

   "     

0



               

  0           



    

  4 ' 4"

"  

  ,"

   -,

-

 ,% & ,%!



/ 2 

%-,  

0"

"% !

"  !/  % - "   

 ,    "    &   "

% & ,%!

, &

/   "  !@         ' ( )**'+ ,-!

#./ 

  

#0$ 0"%,- ".  

5 " !" $

"" "

!.  $

 

,% &"%-   !0  0   ,%

%"   - %%&% -

   -" 4" =  " "

 .3 ) 

 

)   0 5



   0  

 

    1  

     )                

    @  '             A   



                 

0 ?





  0    ?

0 

  

B

      @  '   



0    "    0    

     

?              

   5 0             

  

    0  ?

 

* 4" 

!! %"

%-

" 

8 * = 

" , 

,

" %, % - !"

!

 

-

"!

!/  ) 4"  $

 " ! 1        ( )** '+ ,- A

#.#    &. "

,-"1 %$

"% " "  

; %

%

 " ,   %-

 " 



"" 

" &",   &%0" 0" %

& 

;

%, 6&

2   

%-  

" !"

 & 

0 "  

 %, % - !"

 " 



 

, 0 4"  

%0, 0%%%"

%-" "

!" 

!! %" ,&  ! 7!

"

&



 = 0

%

% "  $

  !  0 " " "

 ,- "

!! % > 1

     2      

   ,( '  )/  & +""#   C    B"" 6 &C 



DC8 B"" 

,%  DC8