High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2232/2015allowed

M/S Raja Ram Corn Products Punjab Pvt Ltd v. Suncity Projects Pvt Ltd

2015-05-29Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan9 pages

!" #"$%&%'()

& * +,',#-$!&-'* ./!0!# 11"22 '! 3",&-& 4-'$%!5,*"$!&/!0!# "&1'#"'!

( 6 0 470 4 ,"&"'!( ,-'""! 2%84"'%,#/$ !"89%!:8 ,3%.: / %' '#,,-'-1! 8#/$ !"&8

,!:" 11"22 '! , &:%&::1, 8#/$ !"8 ,,"&1'#"'!

;:"!:",!:""1,!",& 2$ 2'"9&1 1",+ 5." 229"#!&"" !:"*-#<+"'!= .","

",,"#!!:""1,!",,'! ;:"!:",!:"*-#<+"'!&:-2#.","1,!"#%'!:"#%<"&!= 70 48 11"22 '!: & %2"#!:%& 11" 2 < %'&!!:",#",# !"# >

8 1 &&"# .5 !:" 2" ,'"# ##%!%' 2 %&!,%$! -#<"8 : '#%< ,:89:",".5!:" 112%$ !%' %2"#.5!:" 11"22 '!1"!%!%'", ."

," !:" 29", -,! -'#", 4"$!%' ) !:" ,.%!, !%' '# '$%2% !%'$!8 ))?%'&:,!6!:",.%!, !%'$!8 ))?6 ,<, '!

%'!",%+1,!"$!%'%'!:" ,+ ,"@-%,%'<!:","&1'#"'!! -,'%&:

11,1,% !"&"$-,%!5 ,,"$/",5 & $,,"&12-&%'!","&! !!:"

, !" A ''- 2 ,+!:"# !" 9 ,#%"

!%22!:"

# !" ,"$/",59 &#%&+%&&"# :" $!&'"$"&& ,5 ,!:"1-,1&" #%&1& 2 1,"&"'! 11" 2 ,"!: ! #%&1-!" ,&"."!9""'!:"1 ,!%"&-!

!:"$22 ., !%' <,""+"'!# !"#

>8"'!","#%'!."!9""'

!:"1 ,!%"&!#"/"212! B8'#-&!,% 2," 8$ 2%'!8 : &"38: 2%8-'* .8+" &-,%'< .-! $,"&,?

&@5#&:","

,"8!:",.%!, 2,%.-' 28$'&%&!%'< '6.2",

-&!%$"7-2#%14%'<:"!#8,"&%#%'<,.%!, !,8'6.2", -&!%$"

40%.",: '"!# '#'6.2", -&!%$"%!! 2"!#8 9 &$'&!%!-!"#.5!:%&-,!%',.%!, !%' &"

!%!2"# &

:",.%!, 2,%.-' 21 &&"#!:" 9 ,#89:",".5%! 9 &:"2#!: !!:" 11"22 '!1"!%!%'",%&"'!%!2"#! , "%!!:"&"$-,%!5 +-'! &

$,,"& '#,"$/", -!-," +-'! & $,,"& 9%!: A%'!","&! ,+!:"# !" 9 ,#!%22!:"# !" ,"$/",5

,+!:","&1'#"'! !%& -,!:",&! !"#!: !,"&1'#"'! %2"#!:"

.*"$!%'&-'#",4"$!%' C !:",.%!, !%'$!8 ))? < %'&!!:"

& %# 9 ,#8 9:%$: ," &!%22 1"'#%'< ." ," !:" %&!,%$! -,!&8 : '#%< ,: !%&&! !"#.5!:" 11"22 '!1"!%!%'",!: !!#" " !!:"

+-'! 9 ,#"# ! !:" 11"22 '!1"!%!%'",8 !:" ,"&1'#"'!

+1 '5%&!, '& ",,%'<%!& &&"!&:","&1'#"'!+1 '5: & <%/"'2 !"&! #/",!%&"+"'!# !"# )

%'!:"6:",%.-'"68 9:","%'%!%&&"22%'<!, '& ",,%'<2" &%'<%!& &&"!&8&-$: &<,-1 :-&%'< .-%2#%'< #-25 $'&!,-$!"#8 &1," # /", > $,"& 9%!: 11,D%+ !"25

B) 1 ,!+"'!&%'!:"' +" ,%E, + ,-1 -&%'<811&%!" -'%,4!F /%",4$:284"$!, 8 '$:E-2 ,5 ' '#4-'$%!5 -&%'"&&"'!,"8.-%2! '#$'&!,-$!"#'

: '#%< ,:+. 2 #8G%, E1-,9%!:!! 2 ," 8?

""! 11,D%+ !"25"&1'#"'!%&: /%'<,"<%&!","#

%$"2$ !"# !"9 "2:%8.-!!:"1,1",!5%&&%!- !"#9%!:%'!:"*-,%&#%$!%'

!:%&-,! !%&&! !"#!: !% !:" 9 ,#1 &&"#%' /-, 11"22 '!1"!%!%'",%&-2!%+ !"25-1:"2#8%!9%22'!."& !%& %"# ' ,"1258 ,"&1'#"'! 11&"# !:" 112%$ !%' ' !:" <,-'# !: ! -'#", !:" <-%&" $2 %+%'< %'!",%+ +" &-,"&8 !:"

11"22 '!1"!%!%'", %& &""E%'< ! "D"$-!" !:" 9 ,#8 1 ,!%$-2 ,25 9:"' !:" .*"$!%' 1"!%!%' < %'&! !:" 9 ,# %& 1"'#%'< :" 1,"&"'! 112%$ !%'%&'!:%'<8.-! $-'!",.2 &!!!:".*"$!%' 1"!%!%' %2"#.5,"&1'#"'!-'#",4"$!%' C !:",.%!, !%'$!8

))?!&"! &%#"!:" ,.%!, 2 9 ,#81 &&"#.5!:",.%!, 2,%.-' 2 :" 11"22 '!1"!%!%'",9 '!&1",+ '"'!1,!"$!%'!"' ,$"!:"

9 ,#89:%$:%&'!1",+%&&%.2"-'#",2 9:" 11"22 '!1"!%!%'", : & %2"#! -2 %2!:,""$'#%!%'& 1,%+ $%"$ &"8. 2 '$"

$'/"'%"'$" '#%,,"1 , .2"%'*-,58! / %2!:","+"#5&-<:! ,%'

C !:"1,"&"'!1"!%!%' !9 &&! !"#!: !!:"1,1",!5 ,%E, + ,-1-&%'<4$%"!5%' '$:E-2 '#4-'$%!5 -&%'"&&"'!,"

!G%, E1-, ,"'!!:"&-.*"$!+ !!", !:" 9 ,#',!:"& +" ,"

9%!:%'!:"*-,%&#%$!%' !:%&-,! "&1'#"'!%& +-2!%$,,"

$+1 '5 '# 9"22 "&! .2%&:"# %' !:" .-&%'"&& ," 2 "&! !" ,*"$!& 9,!: &"/", 2 !:-& '# $,,"& ," -'#", "D"$-!%' :","

,"8%!$ ''!."& %#!: !,"&1'#"'!9-2##%&1&"

1,1",!5! /%#%!&2% .%2%!5 0" ,'"###%!%' 2 %&!,%$! -#<"8: '#%< ,:8#%&+%&&"# !:" 112%$ !%'8 %'!", 2% 8 ' !:" <,-'# !: ! 4"$!%' ) !:"

,.%!, !%'$!8 ))?%&2%+%!"#!!:"1,!"$!%' 1,1",!589:%$:%& &-.*"$!+ !!", !:%& ,.%!, !%' :","

,"8!:" 112%$ !%'%&'!

+ %'! %' .2"@- !:"!:",1,1",!%"&8 ,9:%$:!:","2%"

: &.""'

&-<:!"'$"8!:" 112%$ !%'9 &#%&+%&&"# &'!+ %'! %' .2" : /" :" ,# 2" ,'"# &"'%, $-'&"2 , !:"

11"22 '!1"!%!%'",82" ,'"#$-'&"2 ,!:","&1'#"'! '#: /"

2&$ ,"

-225<'"!:,-<:!:" %2" ',#",!&""9:"!:",!:","2%"

-'#",4"$!%') ,.%!, !%'$!8 ))?%&2%+%!"#'25!!:"1,1",!589:%$:%&&-.*"$! + !!", !:" 9 ,#8%!%&'"$"&& ,5!,"1,#-$"!:"& %#&"$!%'8 9:%$:," #& &-'#",( H) '!",%+ +" &-,"&8 "!$ .5 -,!I 1 ,!5 + 58 ."

,",#-,%'< ,.%!, 21,$""#%'<&, ! '5!%+" !",

!:"+ E%'< !:" ,.%!, 2 9 ,#.-!."

,"%!%&"'

,$"# %' $$,# '$"9%!:&"$!%' ?8 1125! $-,!I % ,!:" 11%'!+"'! <- ,#% ' , +%',, 1",&' -'&-'#+%'# ,!:"1-,1&"& ,.%!, 2 1,$""#%'<&J, %% , '%'!",%++" &-," 1,!"$!%'%',"&1"$!

'5 !:" 229%'<+ !!",&8' +"25(I !:"1,"&",/ !%'8%'!",%+$-&!#5,& 2" '5 <#&9:%$: ,"!:"&-.*"$!+ !!", !:" ,.%!, !%'

<,""+"'!J .&"$-,%'<!:" +-'!%'#%&1-!"%'!:" ,.%!, !%'J $ !:"#"!"'!%'81,"&",/ !%',%'&1"$!%' '5 1,1",!5,!:%'<9:%$:%&!:"&-.*"$!+ !!", #%&1-!"%' ,.%!, !%'8, &!9:%$: '5@-"&!%' + 5 ,%&" !:","%' '# -!:,%&%'< , '5 !:"

,"& %#1-,1&"& '51",&'!"'!",-1' '5 2 '#,.-%2#%'<%'!:"1&&"&&%' '51 ,!58, -!:,%&%'< '5 & +12"& ! ." ! E"' , '5 .&",/ !%'!."+ #"8,"D1",%+"'!!."!,%"#8 9:%$: + 5 ." '"$"&& ,5 , "D1"#%"'! , !:"

1-,1&" .! %'%'< -22%'

,+ !%',"/%#"'$"J # %'!",%+ %'*-'$!%' , !:" 11%'!+"'! ,"$"%/",J "&-$:!:",%'!",%++" &-," 1,!"$!%' &+ 5 11" ,!!:"$-,!!."*-&! '#$'/"'%"'!8 '# !:"-,!&: 22: /"!:"& +"19", ,+ E%'< ,#",& &%!: & ,!:"1-,1&" 8 '#%',"2 !%'!8 '51,$""#%'<&."

,"%!K 1",-& 2 !:"& %#&"$!%'%!&"2 &:9&!: !!:%&&"$!%'

$ '."%'/E"#."

,",#-,%'<!:" ,.%!, !%'1,$""#%'<&, !",

? !:" ,.%!, 2 9 ,#8 .-! ."

," %! %& "'

,$"# %' $$,# '$" 9%!:

4"$!%' ? !:",.%!, !%'$!8 ))?:","

,"8"/"'!:-<:!:"

.*"$!%'1"!%!%'%&1"'#%'<-'#",4"$!%' C !:",.%!, !%'$!8

))?8!:"1"!%!%'-'#",4"$!%') !:",.%!, !%'$!8 ))?%& + %'! %' .2"!&""E%'!",%+1,!"$!%' 98!:"@-"&!%'9-2# ,%&" &!9:"!:",,"2%" -'#", 4"$!%') !:",.%!, !%'$!8 ))?$ '."<, '!"#'25,"< ,#%'< !:"1,1",!589:%$:%&&-.*"$!+ !!", !:"#%&1-!"=1",-& 2

4"$!%') !:",.%!, !%'$!8 ))? &:9&!: !2 -&" %& 112%$ .2"'25!!:"&-.*"$!+ !!", !:" ,.%!, !%' <,""+"'!8 9:"," &-'#",2 -&".8!:",#",$ '."1 &&"# ,&"$-,%'<!:"

+-'!%'#%&1-!"%'!:" ,.%!, !%'2 -&".#"&'!! 2E 1,1",!589:%$:%&'25&-.*"$!+ !!", !:" ,.%!, !%' <,""+"'! 4%+%2 ,258-'#",2 -&""8&-$:!:",%'!",%++" &-," 1,!"$!%'

&+ 5 11" ,!!:"-,! &*-&! '#$'/"'%"'!$ '.",#","# 2 -&"" 2&#"&'!! 2E .-!!:"%'!",%++" &-,"'25 < %'&! 1,1",!589:%$:%&!:"&-.*"$!+ !!", !:" ,.%!, !%' <,""+"'! :","

,"8 + !:"/%"9!: !!:"2" ,'"###%!%' 2 %&!,%$! -#<"8 : '#%< ,:8",,"#%':2#%'<!: !',"2%"

$ '."<, '!"# < %'&!

!:"1,1",!589:%$:%&'!&-.*"$!+ !!", !:" ,.%!, !%' 9 ,# :" $!& ,"'!#%&1-!"# '!:%&$ &"8!:","9 & $22 ., !%' <,""+"'! ."!9""' !:" 1 ,!%"& # !"#

> ! #"/"21 .%<$:-'E 2 '# &!:"#%&1-!" ,&"."!9""'!:"

> 1 ,!%"&8 !:" ,.%!, 2 ,%.-' 2 9 & $'&!%!-!"# .5 !:%& -,! %' ,.%!, !%' &"

!%!2"# &

!%& 2& '!#%&1-!"#!: !!:"& %#,%.-' 2: #1 &&"#!:" 9 ,#9:",".5%! %&:"2#!: !!:"1,"&"'! 11"22 '!1"!%!%'",%&"'!%!2"#! , "%!!:"

&"$-,%!5 &

$,,"& '#,"$/", -!-," +-'! & $,,"& 9%!: A%'!","&! ,+!:"# !" 9 ,#!%22!:"# !" ,"$/",5 &1",!:"

%# /%! %2"#.5!:" 11"22 '!1"!%!%'",."

!:%&-,!8 !", , "%!%'<!:" +-'! &

$,,"&8!:","+ %'%'< +-'!$+"&! .-!& ?

$,,"& '!:"

%# /%! 11"22 '!1"!%!%'",8%!%&&! !"#!: !,"&1'#"'!: &!91,1",!%"&8 ' +"258 % ,%E, + ,-1-&%'<4$%"!59:","<,-1:-&%'< &$%"!5%&.-%2!/",> $,"& 2 '# '# %% 4-'$%!5 -&%'"&&"'!,"8&%!- !"#': '#%< ,: +. 2 #8G%, E1-, ! %& -,!:", &! !"# .5 !:" 11"22 '!1"!%!%'", !: ! ,%E, + ,-1-&%'<$'&%&!& C!9",&8" $:: /%'<

2 !&!: &.""' -,!:",&! !"#!: !!:"!9",& ," !/ ,5%'<&! <" $+12"!%' '#1:5&%$ 21&&"&&%' '!"/"' &%'<2" 2 !: & .""'<%/"'! '51",&'!%& -,!:",&! !"#!: !!9",& 8 C8C 8 '#

,"'" ,$+12"!%':"," ," .-!

2 !&%'

" $: !:"& %#!9",& '#!:"1,%$" $+12"!"# -,'%&:"# 2 !

&@ !%& .-!& 8C

1",&@ !&!:"& %# 2 !& ,"'!

-,'%&:"#8!:"/ 2-" " $: 2 !%&& 8

1",&@ ! '#!:"

$-,,"'!/ 2-" " $: 2 !%&&

2 $&:","

,"81, 5",9 & + #" ,,"&!, %'%'<!:","&1'#"'! ,+ 2%"' !%'<!:"& %#!9",&8 +"'!%'"# ./" '!:"$-'!", ##%!%' 2

%# /%! %2"#.5!:","&1'#"'!8 !:" /",+"'!&: /".""'#"'%"#!9 &&! !"#!: !!:"," ,"'25 &%D-'&2# 2 !&%'!:"& %#!9",&89:"," & 22!:", 2 !&&!#&2# &%'$"

B:""'!%,"1,*"$! > $,"& 2'<9%!:C!9",&&! '# +,!< <"#9%!: 'E0%+%!"#8 1%! 2-,!8-'%,E 8 "2:% !9 & -,!:",&! !"#!: !,"&1'#"'!: &<#$ &" '#%&2%E"25! &-$$""#%'.*"$!%'& 1",-& 2 !:" $!& '!%$"# ./" &:9& !: ! !

1,"&"'!8,"&1'#"'!: & 2% .%2%!5 '" ,25&C$,,"&-'#",!:"

,.%!, 2 9 ,# :" .*"$!%'& < %'&! !:" & %# 9 ,# ," &!%22 1"'#%'< ."

," !:" %&!,%$! -,!&8 : '#%< ,:8 !:" #"$%&%'

9:%$:9%22! E"!%+" :","

,"8-'#",4"$!%') !:",.%!, !%'

$!8 ))?8&+"+" &-,"& ,","@-%,"#!."! E"'!1,!"$!!:" %'!","&! !:" 11"22 '!1"!%!%'", , & !%& $!%' !:" +-'!

9 ,#"#%'!:"& %# 9 ,# + 2& !:"/%"9!: !% !:"&!"1& ," '! ! E"' ! &"$-," !:" 9 ,#"# +-'!8 !:"' !:" 11"22 '!1"!%!%'",9%22 $"#%

%$-2!5%'"D"$-!%'<!:" 9 ,#8% & +"%&-1:"2#.5!:"$-,!&

) :","

,"8 + !:"/%"9!: !!:",#",1 &&"#.5!:"

2" ,'"###%!%' 2 %&!,%$! -#<"8: '#%< ,:8# !"#>

%& '!&-&! %' .2"%'!:""5" 2 9:"& +"%& $$,#%'<25&"! &%#" :","&1'#"'!%&#%,"$!"#! -,'%&:!:"&"$-,%!5%'!:"&-+ & C$,,"&."

,"!:"2" ,'"###%!%' 2 %&!,%$! -#<"8: '#%< ,:8 9:","!:".*"$!%'&-'#",4"$!%' C !:",.%!, !%'$!8 ))?

,"1"'#%'<8!& !%& 5!:" 9 ,#!: !+ 5."-2!%+ !"25-1:"2# < %'&! !:"+8 9%!:%' 1",%# -, 9""E& ,+ !# 5 !:"

&"$-,%!5%&'! -,'%&:"#9%!:%' -,9""E&8!9", 8 ,%E, + ,-1 -&%'< 4$%"!58 4"$!, 8 '$:E-2 8 %& ,#","# ! ."

!! $:"#9"/",8&-$: !! $:+"'!&: 22."&-.*"$!!!:"" ,2%", "'$-+., '$"& '#!:"%'!","&!$," !"#%' /-, !:"!:%,#1",&'

," !:" # !" 1 &&%'< !:%& ,#", :" !! $:+"'! 9%22 $'!%'-"!%22!:" 9 ,#8% %' 225

%,+"#%' /-, 11"22 '!8%& & !%& %"# '&"@-"'!258!:"1,"&"'! 11" 2%& 229"# 70 4

)

&*E&