High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2244/2015allowed

United India Insurance Company Ltd v. Manpreet Kaur And ORS

2019-07-24Mr. Justice Dr. Ravi Ranjan9 pages

! "# $"%#&

% !#

%'( %()*+,

- "+(. +.' +*/0'+)( 1. '+20((3'/0'+.(0*

!"#$ %#& ''((

)&!"#$ %#& # *# $#+ '#"# ,#- #%# '#"#. ////

!0 (1")23 & '' ( & '%" 4 & ''(( * 1 $ #2'

4! 2(4! ""

1 $#2'

)&1")2

"5 ""

",6,,78,9'

#:,#%78,6 4&## $$ "(

2 (!

)10& %%"# & (3! 4 5& $&& (! %&#("

)& & "5 1(#% & )( ) "

) #%& #%%"

) & $( " 4

" ;1' ! '#"#,*0 %#& (3!& &("& &$(

5#1(" ("%# 12#% ,<!87!888+* 45 4#%$#2' # (#)5 & =<->' 12# $ ($1( "%#2&"

#%% )#%&$(

2' ((& $1 ( ?

##%& "" 2#1

&#% $ 5& $&5#1(" $ 4%#$# ##%& "12 " 1"* &$(

* '@ 1 "#& % ("&$(

2' 1" #,..#%&##& $( $!,A::0& %%"#

&$3%#) #%$#2' ##% 7-!88!888+*# $$#1#%" &#% # B&

)&!5&# )" #17A4 & 2#% "!

2##& $1( " "& #688:78,6! B&

)&0 $ "$ "3 (#)5 & B& @& !&

)&0$(

#- &$(

' #3 " 2

)&5)# )# %#5#B $ B& @& 5##2##$4$(5& &

)& " 2

)& 5# #&2##$4$(&2##$4$(#%&"$ "5 )# ) & #%&2##$4$(#%&

)&C&&4 $&" # & B&

#1<68! &#( ) ) ##*79*@*7777 0& %%"# D&#%%"

)& $(E3$ 2 1""(4%#21"&

"" 4 '#"#, & ")( )2 "$#(( ""5 & &2##$4$(#%&"$ "%#2&5#) " 1(#%5& $&! #& &#$$1'

#%&2##$4$(%(("#5#&# " " 1

"21( '( ) #1 1 # & ' # &4 5 22"

(4 B #

# '

(! %# 2 1# $& )&&# '

(! 1"* B&

)& 1$$12 "#& 1 %1& " &$(

2' #& &

" "5 1(#% &!)( ) "$ ( "

)#% '#" #, 2 #% $(

#-*&

)&! F #.. "

688:78,65 (#")" #( $ #& B& !1" # 689* "97< #%"

(#" ( # " &$(

2' #& &"$ "

7A4 #% ) "5 G1 & ( "& 4 & 2#% (()"

" 5 B ((" 2 # " "# ) 5#B # $# $

%# $# 1$ )&&#1 " 1 ("

) "5 ) 7-!888+*'2#& '# 1$&$(

) 2 "!# $ 5 1"#& '#" '# &#%! '#"#,! !&" "#5#% & #%%"

) & $( $# " & $(

2 ' # 4 % ) & 5

4 2'

%#22 )$

'( 4# # !& ( #" "&

" 4#%&"$ " ( #&% $& & )5 7A4 & 2#% & " "&5 B (("2 #$(

2"& &#%%"

)& $( $1 ((4# #(" & (()" " &F & (#")"# ( )#1" 2'( ) '#"#,45 4#% ( '( )! 5

"& &#%%"

)& $(5 1"5 & ""

1 $# " & 2#% (()" "!&%#! % %#1"& &

"##B'( $"1#"

)#% '#"#,! 5#1(" &"14#% & 1 $ #2'

4! ! '#" #70 & $(

2 ' #3 #

"2 %4& '#"#,

'#" #7* 1 $ #2'

4 ( # $# " & $(

' # 4% )5 2 ) (2# ( & #% '#" #,& %1& "& &#1)&&#%%"

)& $(5 1"

&& 1 $#2'

4!&#5!&(

4#%& 1 $#2'

4 (( #(4 &$ % '#"& &" 5 &#("

) " %%$ "

)( $$ & 2#% " " 5 # )'( $# ##%& 1 $'#( $42 "$#"

# 5(( &## & $( $ "& 1( & (!#&

('( ) #%&'

!% 2"

%#((#5 ) 1 * D,C&& B&

)& ##%&

)&"

"# 688:78,6"1#& & ")( )"

)#%& $(! !$ )# *79@*7777 #" 4& '#"#,H 7C&&&$(

("%#$#2' #! % # #5& I "%#25&#2H 6C&&&$(

2' # #2

( & ' %#2H

9 C&& & '#" #, 5 # &

) "

)( $$ & 2#% (()" "! % #!5& %%$H

-C&&&$ )# *79*@*7777 #&

)

"% $ "'2 & 2#% (()" "H

. ( %E #"# 1''#& $(

2!&$(

#,* '@ 1 I "& (% C*,!$(

#-*&

)&I " C*7!

$& )* &% (" 4&'#( $1" #,<6& I&

I7!$ "$#'4#% ''( #& I&

" I6 '

%#2#&"#$12 !&'# 2#2'#5& $&& I&

'#"#,*

";1' !#&#&& "! ''" # &5 #I C*, " #1)&#$#"& ) # 0 3 #%&& $( I 7 ""1'( $#'4#%& 1 $'#( $4 I 6 $(# "& "$#& & (% & ""

( "$!$(

#,"" # "$ $#'4#%#" 4 " I: "$#'4#% "& " IA $(# "& ""

( "$ & (! % $# # #% & 2

( # $#"

$(1"

)& "$(" 4&'

" % %%#"

)#''#1 4#% & )#&2!"$ "" 1#, % #1#%&$(

&#("

)& &

"##B'( $"1# & ")( )"

)#% '#"#, & (! 5& ( "$ ) 1 #7! ##B & ) #% & "$ 7A4 "& 2#&(4 $#25 " .!888+*' 2#& " %$# )& ( 1"

('##1$2 $(1"

)

##% # ( 1'2#1"" 5'06'7(08''+.0*9 %(6 0'+*20 020'+ '+. +(0:

- - 5 &

(% ((4&("& &$(

5#1(" ("%#$#2' ##%

12#% ,<!87!888+* (#)5 & =<->' 12 $!& 1 $#2'

4& '%"&' ''

) & 1")2 " 5 " #% & ( " & $(

0 '#" & 3 & '%" $# *# # B ) & $2#%& "" 2#1) " 4& ( & %#

" $B)#1"#%&% $1 (2 I!& & "

( "$#1 (%#&'

"& '1 "&$#" #%& $ "$#1 (%#& ''(( * 1 $#2'

( & 1")2 "5 "#"

)#1" $#"" & ) & $(

2 #% & $(

* '#" & &"$ "5 2 ## $#$&&5 5#B )#

(45 )

!&%#!1"&& "#%%11'# '$ !98>#%&

$#2 &#1("& """ && -8>5& $&& "# 4& ( %1&1)" 4( "$#1 (& ,!88!888+*&

""1"&& "#%(# #%$# # 125& $& &I$ "

&'I#1 '+'6 +*/0'+)( 82'+;1.7*$0'+';5('+.

(0*:

# # 96

-:& &("& #(4 98!888+* # ) "1" 1$&& "& !%#(# #%$ ")1 $! 7!88!888+* & ""5& $&#1)&#& "# 5#%&"$

# #% # ( 'I #1 5'06' 7(08'<* )'*( */20' " $0'+'; 5(<* )'*(*/20' F1&!1"&& "#%%1 (I' ! 7-!888+*&

"" '( $#% ,-!888+*'

%#2& #! ( # 1 2 "& $(

#- )% &#%&"$ "$#1("#& $#1"

"'"%#&$ 4'1'#

& 1)"# & (%#%&$(

+$# * # $# & 2 # &#1(" "# B (("' # "!&%#!

.!888+*'2#& $#2& 5#)(4 " 4& ( & &#1(" & $2 & & ! ( # 1)" 4( "

$#1 ( %# & $# *# $# & &4 5#1(" (" %# 2# &

,!88!888+*5& $&& ""1"&& "#%(# #%$# # 12 #5! #% ''(( 1 2

#& $(

#- ) & "& )#%-74 #(4!$#1("#& B "'"!

((4 5#%&# ##%&# ('I#1"" 5'06'7(08'<*)'*(*/20': '' # $ 1#"' $1 4! '' & & 15#1("# #%21$&( $%#& & %&

)& # B #$# # "'"!&

( "4%#1"'" #%&"$ " )& 5 "#5!2 #"

1)&!

# # "2#&!&%#!&""1$ #%#' # (I' ! 1$& ! '&5'06'7(08'<*)'*(*/20':$ #(4 #&I#%,+9& #%& $#2#%&"$ "5& $&& ( "4 "# 4& 5& ($ ($1( )&$#2' # 2#1#5!5&&&% &5#1("

("%#%

($# # 12##5#1(" "

$1 "( #

#% 7!88!888+*5& $&& "" 4& (# &$(

%#$ ")1 $ $#$"! 24#'

#! "$

##% &# 1 #$&#%# ('I#1"" $0'+';5(<* )'*(*/20' 122 ?

)&& " 1"5& $&$#2' #$ ) "!

& %#

"& ""# #% "'( $&%#! 24$# "" 5!

#& )$#1("& ""1" 1$&& " 4 (

#% %1 (I' $#$"!&'I#1& % I"

,-!888+*!&%#!& ( &#1("#& ) " 7-!888+*

& &#1("& ) "#(4 ,-!888+* #5! & 2 2! "# # '' & 4& )&

) "1"& 1 *& "#%(# #% 1"$# (& 5& $& &#1(" ,-!888+* $$#"

)#& %#

""$

##%# ( 'I#1&1 !& 2#15#1("& # """

# % (# #%$# # 12 $#$"!&'I #1

!" # "$$$& &("& & &$ )# 1" 5& $&&$(

5#1(" ("%#$# # 12#% 98!888+*F 5#1(" '#1 ($# # 12!5& $&5#1("

(#& '#1 #%& "$ " $#"5#1(" %

($# # 12!5& $&5#1("

(#& $ #%" &#%& $& (" "&& "5#1(" (# #%'

$# # 12%#5& $& (25#1(" #%& # #"

1)& #%& "$ "5&#& (# & '

###%&'

2##& $1(

" & 1")2 & "" 4 & 'I #1 % $# ##%& 1")2#%# 1 #$&"" $0'+';5(<* )'*(*/20' &1 ! 24 5!$(

#9 "-5#1(" ("%#

($# # 12! "$(

#,5#1(" ("%# '#1 ($# #

"$(

#7 "65#1(" ("%#'

($# # 12 &IG1 #5& $& &

$# *#

) "

)& 2#% $#2#%&"$ " $#"" 4( "$#1 (%#&$(

+$# *# $# & &"$ " ) # &#1(" $# "" B (("( #15& $& & #''# " 4( "$#1 ( '' )%#& ''(( * 1 $ #2'

4$$#"

)#5&#2! !&$ $# "" 2 * B (("

' # '' # $#$24 5!&"$ $#1("

$# "" 2 * B (("' ## )&"$ "# 2 * B (("

#1 5(( $# )&& $" #%&2 2125 ) &

#%1

1" "# #"

",-8678,6!&"

#% " )688:78,6!&& $" %# 2 * B (("' #5 .!9<-+*' 2#& 24#'

#!#1"

) #%!& $#2#%&"$ "$

" .-88+*'2#& $$#"

)(4! 5 #% & %#

" "

$1 # " % ) $#"" 4& #1!&5 "#%& ( " 2#"

" 42 ) %#((#5 )$ ($1( #* 50 ('.*

82(+*'+'0.(.

, 1 ($#2

.-88J,7K <:!888+* 7 "" 98> #5 "

%11'# '$

6,!788+*0 98> #% & $#23 <:!888L 6,!7883K ,!8A!788+* 6

"1$ 0,+9&3 #5 "

' # I'

,!8A!788*7<!688K:,!A88+* 9 # ($#2

:,!A88+* - #2' # % 21( '( #% ,<

''( "

:,!A88J,<K,6!A7!688+* . # #% '#1 (!

( " %

$# # 12

7!88!888+*0 98!888+* $&'

(#$(

* '#"#,%# '#1 ($# # 12!$(

* '#" #7M6%#'

($# # 12 $(

* '#" # 9 " - %# %

$# # 123 < F1 (I'

,-!888+* : # #%

,-!888+*

'6 82(+*'+ #* =::4

> 24#'

#&$(

5#1(" ("%#& %#

2#1 && $" #% =A>' 12# $ ($1( "%#2 &"

#%% )#%&$(

2' # ((&"

#%'

)#%&5 " #5!&#&% ) #%& (! !#&& "

$1 " #!

- 2

$ & 1(!& '' ( "# *

# #& ((#5" #&I " ##5!&5#1(" ##" # $# %##7 # "%!

798<78,A

?((0*2('@+A>0('*+(.B&(*> ?((00(20'C6(B &(*>