Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sarvesh Devi And ORS
!"#$#%&'&()* +&#("!,('-+!(%#./!(01"$ //#,,!("
2#+'-'
!+3#'4#3&!($"4#+' #'/($#("'
) 51
2 6
!"
##$$%&"'(#) * '
& !"
# '$+( 2 67 '
$$,+ +##$+$+ -
.
# /) ""+ '$+( 0+/&$ &$
!+ - "(#+ 1
2- - # "$+(""& &+($) +$
&( 3+ " "
+$ &( +" " $,-+ # 45+ *+, -,+, (")"$/+,,++&(/61 ...7 /+, +! /)# 4 (-+ ""+ ""& ,$+, +!+, # 45+ *+, +$ &(&+ + &++ ""+ $ +
+$& (36#+$ 8$ +' ""& +$
&( "$+(#++- +$ +- # 4 " (/) +$+, -+( +, + """+
9#$"*+(+$ -9/) %&"'(#)+ ###$$ ""+ 9#$" 0+/&$ ( +& -+ , "&(
""+ - +-"& & ,$+, +!+,
5+ *+, &$+, + +$ &( 0 0+/&$ ##"++ !+ "$ /) "$+( " + + +, & :;% #! + " +$ &(
*
*+, + + ""+ - 9#$"
*$+ & + !+$$, *$+$+"*+*$+ & ,$+, +!+, # # +!
! +"$/+,1,61 ...7 <=$*+, )-+ ""+ ## + -+/> ?% # /)-) +
+ !+@>?
2
- +,*$+& /& .
#( - +$ &( +" " $,-+ # -"(+, (")"$/+,61 ...7 - -/+, +! /) # $ + ,$+, ( !) # -+ &/!+,
&$ - )"
& *$+ (")"$ $$ - & ,$+, +!+, # $ +$ &( $ $$ - &+ (&$+#$ ,+!&+ &+ +#6 # +$ &(+" " /$, +!+$$, #$$)9- +( ""+ + ( (+$) ((/ +$ &(
(+$)((/9+$ &( () #+$ &+, ( + 6
#"+ +"$$) # ""+ / "& & ,$+, +!+, # 4 0 #++ ! >(+ ? +
&( ++$ $( "& 5& +"+$ ,+ '$ + , # /&, +$ "+(+$"+$ A* !& 5+ A /+, %1 ;4
& *"+ ;72 %' $+" *+*$+ "
, $ )/ ( ,+ ""& # 7
"+ +> #"&+!+ "6 #! "+ + "#) #& *"+ ;'' @>% "+ + "#) &# ,+(@> "#) %1@>. 70 #++ !>(+ ?@6'*/+ *+, # /&, %1 ,+ $+"*+*$+ # " %1;4-,+
& *"+
;72 %' ( *! 8!+ #++ +!+,+ "
$$-# + "&,+5+ # 6 #! "#) %1$ )> +/+ @>.
0 #++ !>(+ ? +/*&/ *)!+*+, # 36#+$ 8$ +' - # /&, +,+$='
,+ #+($)*#+$ &( .74 ; 6 #! ='742
@>? 2
0 #++ !>(+ ?;*"
+
&(=8'* &,6#+$ -8$ +- # /&, "#)
#((# +$ &(6 #!
(@>?;2
- #&$ %'@>? 2 1@>?; - +) + ""+
.
#(*$+ + , +(+ +
0 /! "&( #! #$+" ,+ ",+# 5+ *+,
"$$" (+$ &+, +!+,+ + +"+, # "& ""+ /) + ,$+, +!+, "
$$ +( 0 + #&(#+ +!+,+,
+" +"
, + &++ ( "
$$ # /"&
"& ""+ /) + ,$+, +!+,0 /!!+ " +$$/$+ # 5+ *+, + "+,+$ "&+, +$ &( - #+( "+ /$+ ""+ +B&+9#$" & ,$+, +!+, # - +$ +!+,(")"$/+,61 ...7 &$+, + +$ &(
0 !+ " &" /) #++, +, "& ( ""+ ,&/& " 1# + ""+ +
+-+( / ! #+ -+/> ) "&( ""+ ""& ##" # + -+/> %(+"$+ - !+ " ,+ # % +">% -&##
( & ,( &-6A/$6+, '&#
= "&$ # ! &, / ( $$, ""+ 9 #$"
%1 /$ ,
) ! &, +>#$+
$)+$ ,+, %1 ! &&, $)+$ ,+, %1$ + " ! +"$+B&+-$$ +! !/ $$) +!$! + "
.6-! ,+!+, &, &$"+ + #$+ / $ # % ""& -+ ( + ""+ ""&
#&$ #$+"#" +,+ %1. -
@*%/ & $,-+ 6' 1 &( - ,+, !+$$, 8+, + ""+ -+ #$$+, &) +!+,+ " *$+ + '
-9 *(*! $,-+ +$-( ( # ##$+"+$,-+ # "#) =1 1 /+ ##$+"+#%1 -,+ #&$ %1@>. - + ##$+"+ (+
&/ &+ +&+ &++ ""+
- 36#+$ 8$ + /&
+ ,+!/+ "
+$ & $+!) && (+ &/ $ ($- - $+$/+"! ( "9
&/ +B&+ $$ ", +, ""+ ()-+=$*+, 0 & ( %1 + ( & *( *! 8!+ - "9 && (+ &/ & $+!) - ,"! # ##$+"+ ,++, %10 & $)+ $ ,+, %1+-$$>#$+ + %1+$ 0 #++*(*! 8!+- +$ ## + -+/> $+ " -+$< $)+$ ,+, %1- +-$$
.
>#$+ "/,& &/ "$+(A" ) &+" !+"+(1$+"+ +, " /#$" &# & ,( 6A/$*&#('& #
!"# $
% !&& % " ' 0 & %/& #$ + / $ #
;% -9 "+"&(" +"& /! ## " #//+$+++$""$&+ +$ &( *
*+, + + ""+ - 9#$"
*$+&+ !+$$,*$+$+"*+*$+ &
,$+, +!+, # # +! ! +"$/+,1,61 ...7 0 + +& "+ + !& #++C $-'&A" +B&+++ = "&$ ##$$2%&" '(#) #+(+$)"
$$, +(#&, - ,& ""+ + B&+-#! $+/+$+) %&"'(#) /-,$) /) 0+/&$ = "&$ ##$$ ( ? + &( ++$ $( &/(+ %1;4 & *"+ ;72 %'-,+
$$, ""+ 9#$"
+ $) /& ( +,++ %1 - +>#$+ /) "$+( = "&$ ##$$ ,& 0+/&$ -,$)" + +, ""+ 9#$"# ? *! 8!+ + -+ ""+
-! ""+ -"& & ,$+, +!+,
+,! +"$
;
= "&$ ##$$ ( ? =$*+, )-+ ""+ &/(+ + #" #+ &/ &$+ %1 + "-+
, +#" # +" + #+$
/&, + & +$ &( #+$ % #$) $ "&$ # 2"$+( &/(+ ""+ - &$) #! 6 ( ? =$*+, #
- +, + - - " +$ &( 5+ *+, -"(+, (")"$/+,,++&(/ 61 ...7 - +!/)5+ *+, + ,$+, (!) +, # -+ &/!+,
+"&$?
) "
& *$+ (")"$ $$ - & ,$+, +!+, 5+ *+, +$ &($ $$ - &+ (&$+#$,+!&+ &+0 +-+
+$ &(-9- +( /$, + !+$$, + ( (+$) +$ &( - 9 +(!+&
#+$ + &+,(
%">(++ +-+ #$+" " +(/& "$$- +(-" 6 +$ &(-9 #+$/) +( - # - (9- + &,,+ ""+ 9 #$" & ,$+, +!+,
+,! +"$ ">(++ " -"$$ /)
+(+ #+$ + &,,+ + -+ ""+ = "&$ # 2"$+( &/(+ ? *! 8!+ - +-+ - +$ &( ## #! >#+"& ( +$ &(/ + %+ &/(+ ? + &( ++$ $( > +/+ "#) %1;4
& *"+
;72 %' $+"*+*$+-$$#& *"+ ; '' "#) 1' "#) 8+!+,=+"" "#) %&"$+") "#) *&# ,+( #&(( " +$ = "&$ # 2"$+( $+ &# & ,( 6A/$*&#('& + ( !)"'
*
+
&/(+ ++ $ ( " %1+$ , ( ""+ "/ +" " !+ " "( " #! ""+ % +
& ,( 6A/$*&#('& $ $ & :
%+-$$$ $)+$ ,+,%1"/ ,& &/ "$+(A " -+, % + " ++ ) - " >#" "(( ( + & $+" *+ +(( +$) ""+ 6&(& (+$) #+/+$++""&#) (+ 9+ 9+&"
> ),+! ( +(#" , !+"+( & $+"*+ D &"
"+"&(" )>#" " ("
+"$$)-+ #(#+& +$ ,+, %1-+
$+"8$)+$ ,+, %1 & "/
,& ) &+" !+"+(%" $) "&B&+ >(+ !+ "-+ "$"&+) + +,< " %1 &$ $/"&++E (" &$$)% "& + ++ +"+ /+"++ / """ ,+ +(#$+"+"# !+ + $)+$ ,+, %1 "$+( ""/ +(+ ($) ,&
0 #&# $ ,+, %1+&"
)# " +#+(+$)++( #$+"++++!+,+ "+(+$
"= ,+, %1"+$)#!
"&( ""+ !+"+(+/$$ , " "(#+/& $)+ +,"/ (+,& "+, "$+(#++% - $ &, $ ,+, %1+!+$+ "+ +,( ""+ "$+(" $)+$ ,+, ( &$ / $ &"
#" +, + "$+(
//$ (+ ") ", + 0 "&$ / !+) + ,&+" $) $ ,( %1D$9+
9+ !+"+(/$,+"+$!$
B&+$+) (+ "(# $ ,+ !+
+ $) ( !/" %&"
"+"&(" & +"+) %1&((&"
( +,+ +"" $) + $ ,+,
&## /)", #+-,& / ( +,$ "&$ #+ ,+, &,
" ##"++ #$ +, !+ " % + +$$,$+)+ +(+)+ + +," /) 0+/&$ ""+ - -+ /) ? =$ *+, - +()"&$ / 9/) ##$$%&"'(#)+"
>(++ >"#/),+!+,&,,+ + -+ ""+ @!5+ *+, +!
+,! +"$ + ##-+/& "$+(A!+ " " %1-,+ &/B&, - -$)#! /& ( ?@6'*/+*+,
$#! "(#$+, +!+,+ "
$$$ ) # ,+5+ *+, &## !+ "$+( ""+ -"& & ,$+, +!+,
+, ! +"$ ! "$+(2-+ - " >#$+ $)+,++ %1 -& &( +$)/"&
&/ +$ &( " (+ & ( + +
#+$ ) $ -& "9 "" +,$) + +,(++ ###$ (+ +(+ * 2 6